Jackson v. Robinson et al, No. 7:2013cv00341 - Document 58 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 3/28/2014. (tvt)

Download PDF
e p*- OFRCE u s nl cot a sm m I THE UM TED S ATESDI TRI COURT N T S CT A x viiv T l A FE V CW ID L FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A MA2 28 2 1 24 ROANOKE DI I ON V SI JU c. LEM cLE DU DONALD CORNELI JACKSON, US Pl nt f , ai if V. A . A V I R O BI SO N ,e al, D D N t . D ef endant . s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ci lAci No.7:3-v- 09#IWYCL RK vi ton 1 c 0 E M E M O M N D UM O PI I N N O By: H on. ls L.Kier Jacton s Se or Unied St e Di t c Judge ni t at s s ri t Dona d Co nelusJ cks a Vigi a i epr e ngpr K ,fl ac vi rg saci l r i a on, r ni nmat oce di o ied i l i ht ton p ru n t 4 U. C. 1 3a dteReii u La dUs a dl si inaie Pes n Ac u s a t o 2 S. j 98 n h lgo s n e n n tmto l d ro s t z (C PA',42U. C.jj2000c e s g.a g ngt tDefnda svi ae t rght t $ RLUI ' ) S. c, t e , r ui ha e nt oltd he i s o r lgi usfe e i o r edom , pr es ,a e lpr eci Pl i ifnn e a de e nt A . vi due oc s nd qua ot ton. antf m s s f nda s Da d Ro i s n,h Ch e o Co rcin f r h VignaDe a t n o Co r cins(t b n o t e if f re to s o t e r ii p rme t f re to < VDOC'; nd ' Li a ) She r t VDOC Food Se v c Ditcin;Cha lneDavi,aVDOC Reg ona Admi sr t r a , he r ie ei a re s i l nita o As it nt Lm'yT.Edm onds t f m e W a de oft Bucki m Core tonalCe e ssa ; I ' , he or r r n he ngha rci ntr (< (BKCC';Vigi aHuntt FoodOperto DiecorofBKCC (ole tvel kno ast ' r ni ) ,he ains r t c lci y wn he ç re to a Dee d n s); n Na e rA. b s a ,h f nne p y iina BKCC.Prs nl d rcin l fn a t' a d s e Mo a h r t e o r h sca t co ee t y bef r t c ti Dr M obas rsmoton t dim is t whih Pli tf r po o e he our s . ha ' i o s s , o c a n if es nded,ma ngt ki he m o i n r pe f di poston. A fe r e i t r co d,Ig a D r M o s r sm o i n t t o i or s ii t r evi w ng he e r r nt . ba ha ' t o o di r s . s ni s The ge a t nltofPl i if s a ton i t tV DO C saf ha a l ge y notr s ve how ner l h s a ntf c i s ha t f s le dl e ol d t pr pa e amedi ly- e c i m e f di be i I lm i i t st ti fe ofpor a l o e r cal pr s rbed nu or a tc, sn c nma e ha s r e k nd ow i s t Pl i ifa s co pl i t tt Cor ec i lD e e n sde e hi a kos rdi t n al. a ntf l o m a ns ha he r tona f nda t ni d m he e of e e t ot rBK CC i a esa do no gi hi s t i ntc l i s W hie t s c ai s a e f r d o he nm t nd t ve m ufk e a or e . l he e l m r r l va t t c e e nt o he onduc oft Core tona Def nda s Pl i ifdoe notsa eacli upon t he r c i l e nt , antf s tt am whih r le may begr nt d ag ns Dr M obas r1 c ei f a e ai t . ha . Tosaeacli unde j 1 a i tDr M o s r Pl ntf mus afr tvey s tt am r 983 gans . ba ha, ai if t fimai l how t tD r M oba ha pe s ly pa tci t i a alege de i ton ofPl i if s rght . Se ha . s r r ona l r i pa ed n n l d pr va i a ntf ' i s e. eg, e t At n , 8 U. 4 48(98 ) W rg tv Coln , 6 F.d 8 ( t Ci.1 8 ) ..W s v. kis 4 7 S. 2, 1 8 ; ih . lis 7 6 2 41 4h r 9 5 . Forexn e Pli ifwoul ha t s w Dr M o s wasdelbe ael i if r ntt as ro mpl , a ntf d ve o ho . ba har i r t y nd fe e o e i us m e c lne d t e t bls avi a i oft Ei h Amendme f i de t me c c r di a e o sa ih olton he ght nt or na qua e di al a e. See e. , tlev. mbl 429U. 97( 976) p c.Esel Gn e, S. 1 . l t m or t 1 pa soft Compl i a a e n he e han 00 ge he ant nd m ndme ,Pli ifm e i nsDr nt a ntf nto . M oba ha i onl Cli V, ild,t t mpor r M e ca St r f rt Tr am e of s r n y a m tte tcon e a y di l anda ds o he e t nt Di be e ,oraLa k ofTr ti t De rm e . Pli ifi ntfe Dr M oba ha ' va i us a ts c us n he pa t nt' antf de ii s . ' s rs ro r s nsbiii sa t prs a alo s esswa t tdi tci aes m e ca c ec dbe e po i lte t he ion nd s ugg t ys ha abei nm t ' di l ar oul i pr d.Howe r Pl ntf wholy f ist de c i a ac orom iso by Dr M o s rt t m ove ve , ai if l a l o s rbe ny t sin . ba ha ha vi a e af de a rgh ofr i o fee , duepr e s o e lpr t c i 2 Alho h olt d e r l i t elgi us r dom oc s , r qua o e ton. t ug Pl i tf f l d copi ofgreva st tbe rt r pons or sgna lr ofnur e a ot r a n i f ie es i nce ha a he es es i tzes s s nd he m edi alpe s m el none oft doc l e sbe D r M obas r s r s c r or , he lm nt ar . ha ' e pons ors g t e,a e i na ur nd 1Deer i ng wheherac pli saesaplusbl cam f r le i $ contxts ii t s t tr uie t t m ni t om ant tt a i e li or eif s t a e -pecfc a k ha eq r s he rviwigc u toda o is u iile p re c a c mmo sn e' Asco v.q a, 56U. 6 2 6 87 e e n o r t rw n t j dca x ein e nd o n e s . h r h lb l5 S. 6 , 7 -9 ' (0 9 .Th s ac u tce nn ac mplitu d rRul 1 ( )6 c nietf pe dn t taen tette t a 2 0 ) u , o r sre ig o an n e e 2 b() a d ni la igsha r o ni d o n y l as s umpton oftut bec us t co ito nomo et n lbesandconcuso .l AlhoughIlbe al c t e i r h a e hey nss f r ha a l l ins d. t i r ly onsru poK c mplit, ie v Ken r40 U. 51 , 2021( 9 2)1d no a t sa imaesa v ct, u so t r o ansHan s . r e, 4 S. 9 5 - 1 7 , o t c a n n t' d o ae s a p ne de o ng sautr a consi i lcamsnotce ry r s d i ac velpi t t o y nd tmtona li la l aie n ompli . Se Br v. rol,1 F. 241, ant e ock Car l 07 3d 2 3(t Ci.1 9 )( ti, .c nc rig ; a et . t o Ha tn, 7 F.d 1 7 ,1 7 ( hCi.1 8 )s e 4 4h r 9 7 Lulg J, o urn l Beudt v Ciy f mno 7 5 2 2 4 2 8 4t r 9 5; e as God nv Leke 5 4F.d1 47 1 5 (t Ci. 9 )(e o nzngta adsrc c u tsn t x ce t lo ro . e , 7 2 1 , 1 1 4h r 1 78 rc g ii h t itit o r i o e petd o as meter l o a v ct frapoK plitf su h oe f d o ae o r anig. 2Fore mpl, Pli ifc xa e antf ompl nsa utas ve m onh dea t s eade itf ar i e ai bo e n- t ly o e nts or outne xami tonand nai cea nga alo adea t s a e docorf rar tnea l ni nd s ly o ee n ye t o ou i nnuale e m .N eihe compl nti plc t Dr ye xa t r ai m iaes . M oba ha ,who algedl e nedPli ifse a r fr e hi t t f lt e doco Furhe mo e Pli if s r le y xami antf' ye nd ee r d m o he aciiy ye tr. t r r , antf f l t de c i a ohe r ato hi bewee Dr M obas a de a- r oreyeca epr de sorVDOC f ais o s rbe ny t r el ins p t n . har nd ntlca e - r ovi r ood s r ce saf who de i orpr pa eBKCC' me . e vi s t f sgn e r S nus 2 s r ior la lt underj 1 ma no beprdiae ont t or ofr pondea s ror upe vs y ibiiy 983 y t e c td he he y es t upei , e n i Pl i ifhad de c i d s m es pe vs y r a i hi bewe Dr M obas rand a ve f antf s rbe o u r ior eltons p t en . ha ny ot rme c lsaf M o l v.Dep' ofSoc Se v .436U. 658, n. ( 978) M orove , he dia tf. nel t . r s, S. 663 7 1 . e r Pl i ifsr la on mer l l a concuso t tDr M o s i o a e Pl i ifsrgh s' antf e ince e abe s nd l i ns ha . ba har û l t d antf i t ' vi a f ded by t Cons iuton a RLU I i nots fc e t s a e an a tona e c a m . See Be l f or he tt i nd PA s uf i i nt o t t c i bl l i l At. p. Twombl 55 U. 5 555( lCor v. y, 0 S. 44, 2007)(e ogni ngapli ifsba i f r le r c zi antf ss or eif r quie mor t nlbesa c ncuso ) Fi ly,Pli ifsdis tsa tonwihhow Dr e r s e ha a l nd o l ins. nal antf saifci t . M o a h rmo io e a dte tdPlitf sd a ee o ûuflld ( ijo lg t n . .a d d t b s a n trd n r ae an if ib ts r t lile j h s biai . (n q u y f o t p o d a q aeme ia a ssa c t e c a de eyimae)a E o r vie de u t dc l s itn e o a h n v r n t g t BKCCI'sas n t 'i lo o s sc e t sae a Ei h Ame uf i nt o t t n ght ndme cai .Se ea. Ese l 429U . a 1 06 nt l m es . , tle, S. t 05- (e o nii gcamso me ia map a tc a n gi e t ig o i aen tc g ia l i a rc g zn li f dc l lr cie nd e lg n d a n ss r o o nz be n j1 3p o e dn ) W ra tv Co l s 7 6F. 8 , 4 (t Ci. 9 5 (e o niiga 98 r c e ig ; ih . li , 6 2d 41 8 9 4h r 1 8 ) rc g zn n n i t sdia e ntwih m e ca pe s nma e' s gr eme t di l r onnelove t c s ofteam e doe notsae a r he our e r t nt s tt j1 cli .Ac or ngl 1grntDr Mobas rsmoi t dimisa dimist cams 983 am) c di y, a . ha ' ton o s s nd s s he li a ns Dr M o s rwihprj c gai t . ba ha t eudie. ENTER: hiN nd yo Mac , 01 T s a f rh 2 4. ' e & . Se orUnie St t Diti J td aes srct udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.