Smith v. Ely et al, No. 7:2013cv00329 - Document 52 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 10/25/2013. (tvt)

Download PDF
r;pRx' oFFl u. Dl cour s cE s, sm ATROANOKE, A v FI LED I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W E STER N D I STR I O F VI G I A CT R NI ROANOKE DI I ON V SI COREY JERM AI SM I , NE TH 22 25 2 3 T 11 J AG. ULI BY: DE CASE NO.7: 13CV00329 Pl ntf , ai if V. M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N NI LT. ELY, AL. c , By:J me C. k a s Tur Se orUnie St e Dit c Judge ni t d at s srit Dee fndants. t) Cor y J r ane Sm ih,a Vigi a i ae pr e ng pr K ,fld t sci lrght a ton e em i t r ni nm t oce di o ie hi vi i s c i p ru n t 4 U. C.j1 8 ,algng ta t e d fnd n p io saf u e e c si fr e u s a t o 2 S. 9 3 le i h t h ee a t rs n tf s d x e sve oc a ns hi a orde edhi m e c te t e . Defnda GlndaM e , anur e, sfl a gai t m nd/ ni m dial r am nt e nt e ade 1 s ha ed m oton t dim i s t whi h pl i if ha r s nde w ih a to l uns o a l ga i a i o s s, o c a ntf s e po d t ddii na , w m le tons nd m'um e . Ot r de enda s r pr s nt d by s r t couns l ha fl d an a we . Upon g nt he f nt , e e e e epa a e e , ve ie ns r r vi w oft r or howe r t c tc ude t t Smih' c pli m us be s ma iy e e he ec d, ve , he our oncl s ha t s om a nt t um zl dim is d,be a e he f ie t exha ta lbl a i sr tve r medis asr quie t r42 s se c us a ld o us vaia e dm nita i e e , e r d mde U. C. 1 9 ea . S. j 9 7 () The f t , a n i t lg m os f vor bl t Sm ih,a e t s On J y 1 201 i t ac s t ke n he i ht t a a e o t r he e. ul 8, 2, n he pr s ofta pori hi t Re Oni Stt Prs c r to ofk e s fom W ale Ri oce s r ns tng m o d on a e ion, oreci ns t r r lns dge St e Prs n be hi a s ke hi wih a e e toni bet W hen Nur e M ea c at io at m nd hoc d m t n l cr c l. s de ame t o pefr a imae me ia s re i o lm a Re Onin s lo e a h sij isa d si , ro m n n t d c l c e nng n l t d o , he o k d t i nure n ad i éi) Nrllv ( l)r. W ec ml)t Re Onin' ( No 1 1 a 0) M e d dd n t çrl Nl ie , ))( Atl i ) ( ) lo e o d o . ECF . - , t1 . ' ae i o pr de Smih wih any team e . Durng Smih' i a e ovi t t r t nt i t s nt ke xnmi ton by Dr M ilron J y 26, na i . le ul 1 sm ih s t ometm esr er t t def i ef s o he endantasNur e Tat Becaus t def s e. e he endantr e st her el ef r o s f asGlnda M eade,t cour wilus t snam e. e he t l e hi RK 2013,M e de t d Smih t puti a sc calr ques i he wa ed team e f hi ba k. M ilr a ol t o n ik l e t f nt r t nt or s c le lo e a t eijlis b tp o ie n te t n . Smi camsta,oh rt a M orn h h s o k d t h nt e , u r vd d o rame t r t li h t te h n ti, e a h r eve no team e tf rt bur and a lr e,pai 'ltkeoi ' sa l edl f me wher t ec i d r t n o he ns ag nf û l d'ha leg y or d u e he blr w e e. l ns r W he Sm ih fld t sa i he s n t ie hi cton, ubmit at ii St t men ,'i ca i t the ha ted t fed a e t' ndi tng ha ver d l x a td (i)a mi srt rme isi t ef lo n f s in a d ( d atc e c pisof G h use h s d nitai e de n h o lwig a h o n ha ) ta h d o e e ve giva e de nsrtng c ein. ( No.2. Hi s si ,i l ng hi s n re nc s mo tai omplto ' ECF ' ) s ubmisons ncudi s wor l fs vi' ( No.3) i cae t ton Augus 7,201 Smih fld an i or lc ant ' tda t' ECF a , ndi t ha t 2, t ie nf ma ompli , sai t theha be n ç s ule (ndls ke wiht bet'onJ y 18,201 herceveda ttng ha d e ç a td a hoc d t he l' ul as 2; e i r c itwihn t d y ,b tn v rrc ie a rs o s . ( No. a 5) On De e r 1 e ep t i wo a s u e e e ev d e p n e ECF 2, t . c mbe , 201 Sm ih fld a s cond i or c pli ta 2, t ie e nf mal om a n boutt J y 18 i i ta r c ve a r s e he ul ncden nd e ei d e pons d td De e e 2 ,201 ( .2. S t t e fld a r g lrg iva c o J n a y 9 201 , ae c mb r 0 2. J ) mih h n ie e ua re n e n a u r , 3 # wh c wa rj ce a t i l fld;hsitk d cso wa u hedo a pe l (d 3 4) ih s ee td s mtmey ie t i n a e e iin s p l n p a. I . - . 11 Th Prs n Liiain Re o m Ac ( k ',n n oh rt n s p o d si 4 U. C. e io tg to f r t t A' mo g te hig , r vie n 2 S. TL1 ) j 1 9 ea t a ap io e c n o b ig acvla to c n en n prs n c n iinst i heh s 9 7 () h t rs n r n n t rn ii cin o c r i g io o d to mtl a frte h u t d a alb ea miitai rme is Po trv. s l,5 4 U. 51 ,5 4 ( 0 2 . is x a se v ia l d n sr t e de . re Nu se 3 S. 6 2 2 0 ) ve Thi e us i r uie ent a i t l l i a e s t , w he he t y i ve ge r l s xha ton eq r m pples o û l nm t uis a t r he nvol ne a c r lm sa es or pa tc a e s s . ..whehe t y al ge e es i f c or s icl tnc riulr piode , t r he le xc sve or e ome o he t r wr 'a e n i t f m ofr le t i t s e i hi l ws ti notav l bl t ough t ong,' nd ve f he or ei f he nma e e ks n s a ui s aia e hr he Prs s gre nc pr e ngs I Faiur t f l t r quie pr dtr oft prs s ion' i va e oce di . d. l e o olow he e r d oce les he ion' admi sr tve r m e pr e s i udi tm e lmis or t e us al lvel of a rita i nitai e dy oc s , ncl ng i i t, o xha t 1 e s dmilsr tve r viw i nott ope e usi 'a wilba a i t sj 1 a ton.W oodf dv. o,5 e e s û r xha ton' nd l r n nmae' 983 ci pr or Nz 48 U. 81 9 ( 0 6 . lW l r filet e h u ti a p rn fo tef c o tec mp an , t S. , 0 2 0 ) i hee alr o x a s s p ae t r m h a e f h o lit' he l t ' c tma s our y umm a iy dimi st c rl s s he ompl i on t tgr md. Ande s v.XYZ Coae tonal ant ha ot r on ci He 1hSevc s Ic, 0 F.d67 6 2 (t Ci. 0 5 . at r ie .n .4 7 3 4, 8 4 h r 2 0 ) Asid c td i S t ss b s in ,Op rtn P o e t e (1 ' 8 6. i t e wrte n iae n mi u miso s eaig r c dz ç ) 6 1 s h itn h' r OP' a i sr tve r m e es pr e e t t i aes i t Vigi a De rm e of Core tons dm nita i e di oc dur ha nm t n he r ni pa t nt rci (G < VDOC' mus f l t c y wih j1 ( .An i t mus frtatmptt r s vehi ' t olow o ompl t 997ea) ) nmae t is te o e ol s is si or ly by compltng a i or lc sue nf mal e i n nf ma ompli tf m f whih her c vesa r ept As a n or or c e ei ec i . t f m is l sa e ,i t i ae doesnotr c ve a r s he or t e f tt s f he nm t e ei e pons t hi i or lc e o s nf ma ompli wihi ant t n 1 da ,he m a f l a r ul r greva e,usng hi r ce pt a e de e t t he a t m pt t 5 ys y ie eg a i nc i s e i s vi nc ha te ed he i or lcompl ntpr es .A r gul rpi va m us be tld wihi 30 da oft oc ure e. nf ma ai oc s e a e nce t ie t n ys he c r nc I t itk o fc rrj cst eg iv n ea n t i l fld,h imaet e h s5d y t a p a f he n a e fie ee t h re a c s o tmey ie t e n t h n a a s o p e l t ti a decson t t r ona om buds a whos de ii n i fna . ha nt ke ii o he egi l m n, e c so s i l Smih saes t t hi s t t t ha s ubmitd doc e t ton de te um n a i monsr t hi exha ton of ta es s usi ad i sr tver m e esast t c am sr ie i hi c m nitai e di o he l i a s d n s ompli . The e docl e s howe ,do ant s lm nt, ver nots uppor t sconcus y a s ri I t a Smih' docl e t cea l i caet thedi not t hi l or s e ton. nse d, t s lm n s l ry ndi t ha d c ompl wih t tme lmis of OP 866.. He frt fld a i o m a co pl nton Aug t 7, y t he i i t 1 is ie n nf r l m ai us 201 nea l t e wee a t t i i nt whih di notla s fc e tm ef hi t r c ve 2, ry hr e ks fer he nc de , c d e ve ufi i nt i or m o e ei a r po e a fl a tmel gre nc wihi 30 daysoft J y 1 201 i de . M or over es ns nd ie i y iva e t n he ul 8, 2 nci nt e , ofk e s f llet r s ndt t Augus 7,201 i or c pli di notpr ve Smih fom t r ' aitr o e po o he t 2 nf mal om a nt d e nt t r flng a tm ey gre nc usng t r ept Ye ,Sm ih f ie t t ke a f t r se i t ii i l iva e, i he ec i . t t a ld o a ny urhe t p n he g iva e pr dm e untlDec mbe of201 a di no fl hi r a g iva e untlne ry re nc oce i e r 2 nd d t ie s egulr re nc i al sx mont afe t i i ntofwhi h he c i hs tr he nc de c ompl i l s doi Sm ih de i d ofi i soft ans. n o ng, t prve fcal he o rt t t i si t hi c ppo tmiy o nve tga e s ompl i spr ant ompty a tkea opra ea i Sm ih' afi vi l nd a ppr i t cton. t s fda t a doc e a i do noti c t t theeve fld a i or c nd um ntton ndia e ha r ie n nf mal ompli ta r gul gre nc a n nd e ar iva e c e ni hi co ai a t M e de' al ge f lze t pr de me c l team e f hi onc r ng s mpl nt bou a s le d ailr o ovi dia r t nt or s ij e o J y 1 , 01 , n tee fe. nmi s n ul 8 2 2 a d h r a tr Be aus i i cea fom Sm ih' s n afi vi a o he s c e ts l r r t s wor fda t nd t r ubmi so t tdi notfl an s i ns ha d ie 6, . i onnalc pli a g i va wihi t tm e lmis ofOP 866. ast t cli r ie i nf om a nt nd re nce t n he i i t 1 o he a ms a s d n t sac in,t c tfndst the di notpr pe l e us a ia e a i sr tver m e esand hi to he our i ha d o ry xha t va lbl dm nita i e di i bare underj1 s rd 997e()fom brngi t slws t On t sgr a r i ng hi a ui. hi ound,hec twilsl rl t our l zmmaiy dimi st aci n a d s isa 1pe ng motonsa moot An a opra eor rwile e t s s s he to nd im s 1 ndi i s . ppr it de l nt r hi da y. The Cl r i di e t d t s nd c e of t s m e or ndlm o ni n a a com pa ng ek s rce o e opi s hi m a l pi o nd c nyi or rt pli if de o antf . ENTER:Ths R. d yo Oco e, 01 i 9 a f tb r2 3. Z J Se Unie St t sDititJ e n' t d a e src udg 4

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.