Smith v. Ely et al, No. 7:2013cv00329 - Document 15 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 08/27/2013. (kab)

Download PDF
r F>*:OFFI U, DI r.lI d CE S, ST, n RT ATROANOKE: A V FI6D L I TH E U N I N TED STATE S D I STR I C O U RT CT FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STR I O F VI G I A CT R NI ROANOKE DI I ON V SI AL 2 2 1 C 13 JULI C A W: s C O R EY JERM A I E SM I H , N T X CLERK w ax CA SE N O .7: 3CV 00329 1 Pl ntf , ai i f V. M EM O M ND U M O PI I N N O LT. ELY, AL. c , By:Ja sC. k me Tur Seni U ni e St t D i t i tJudge or t d a es s r c De e f ndants. t) Thi matri b f r t e c u to plitf s( to f rij n to , whc t e c u t s te s eo e h o r n anif G in o nu cin' ih h o r mo ' co t ue as a m o i f pr lm i y i l tve r le .1 Pli tf Cor y J r ne Smih, a ns r s ton or e i nar n- i e i f unc a n if e e mai t Vigi a i t pr e ng nr #q fld t sci lrg sa i purua t 42 U. C.j 1 r ni nma e oce di o , ie hi vi iht ct on s nt o S. 983, - alegi t tt de e l ng ha he f ndan prs n ofi a sus d e e sve f ce agans hi on J y 18 201 t i o fcil e xc s i or i t m ul , 2. The c t has r c nty a t m pt d s r i e o t de e n pr s n of i a s t ough notc of our e e l te e e v c n he f nda t i o fci l hr ie wa ve ,a de e i r nd f ndan sha no ye w aved s r c o r s nde t t compl i . I hi cure t ve t t i e vie r e po d o he ant n s r nt m o i n, Smih de to t mands a co t or r die tng defnda s t t desr y or tm pe wih' ur de r c i e nt ç o to not a r t' c rai vi o f age r a e t t a l ged e e s ve f r e i i nt A f e r vi w o t r o d, e t n de oot el t d o he le xc s i o c nc de . t r e e f he ec r t c t c udes t t Sm ih ha f ie t de he our oncl ha t s al d o monsr t t t t vi o pr e vai n is ta e ha he de es r to s ue warn sap ei n r ij n to a dd nishsmo in ra t rlmi ay n u cin n e e i to . Asap ei n r ij n to tmpoa i a f r sa e ta r ia yrme yp irt tilt e r l a y nu cin e r rl fo d n x ro dn r e d ro o ra, h mi y pa t s e ng t prlmi r ij ton mus de nsrt t t ()S i lkel t s ce d o ry e ki he ei nay n unci t mo tae ha : 1 t s i y o uc e n he t me is'( ' i lkey t s frirparbl har i t absnc ofprlmi yr lef'() he rt,' 2) s s i l o ufe re a e m n he e e he ei nar ei , 3 ' th b ln eo e ute tp i hi f v r'a d ( )ç n ij n to i i t p bi itr s. S e s e aa c f q iis i s n s a o , n 4 ç nu cin s n he u lc n ee t' e t ' a ' W i e v.NaurlRe ouresDee e Counci.I ,555 U. 7,21 ( ntr ta s c fns l nc. S. 2008) A s wi ofa . ho ng 1 By s a e or , t cour w il addr s pl ntf s ot pendi motons r r ng epar t der he t l es ai if her ng i , ega di am endment dicover a appoi m entofcouns . , s y, nd nt el l tong pos i lt 'ofha m i i ufi e ,be us t sa r r quiesa s tr s sbiiy' r s ns fcint ca e he t nda d e r howi t thn m i ng ha r s ûi l ' I Ea h o te ef u f co smu tb s tsidb fr itro u o yij n tv rle i 'key. d. c f h s o r a tr s e aife eo e ne lc t r nu cie eif s l ' warntd. Re lTr h AboutObn .l v.FEC,575 F.d 3 3 (t Ci.2009 ,vac td ra e a ut ma nc. 3 42, 47 4h r ) ae by.rma e nded by,c r.grntd,1 S.Ct 2371( 0) r afr d i p-r.rmande by,607 e t a e 30 . 201 , e fime n at e d F. 355( h Ci. 0) 3d 4t r 201 . Sm ih as e t t tt r quesed vi o f a i i r m ey r l va ' t hi e s i t s rs ha he e t de ootge s û e l e e nt' o s xce sve ext f r e cams a d é e d t b p e e te t qt c u t' He alg s ta ih a miitain o c li n s e o e rs n gd o he o r. n ' l e h t t e d nsrto e t her ...i ve y welknown f desr ng ortm pe i wih t e de e.' Smih doesnotct e s r l or toyi n rng t he vi nc ' t ie a i t nce i whi a co t has de e mi d t t t def nda prs ofi i l o t r ny nsa n ch ur t r ne ha he e nt ion fc a s r hei c la ole gues ha pum os uly desr ve ef l toyed or t mpe e wih vi o f a r lt t i t n r d t de oot ge e aed o nma e ltga i ii ton. Sm ih' va t s gue a conc us y sa e t a e i ufi intt s nd l or t t men s r ns fce o uppor a fndi t t t i ng ha ha m t t vi f agehe s eksi e t rlkel ori mi nt Ashe t f ist s tsy t of r o he deo oot e s ihe i y m ne . hus a l o a if wo tefu f co su d rt eW itrts,h c u t e ishi ç to f rijmcin' to tfrh r h o r a tr n e h n e e tt e o r d n e s ç in o n t to 'wi u u te mo h ds u so . l t itrs o j sie h we e,t c u twilr q s t tp io o t asma e ic s in n he n ee t f u tc , o v r he o r l e ue t ha rs n fkil k e r efor t pr s r t r que t d vi o f a t i a trt sc eha be f l r s ve ve y f t o e e ve he e se de oot ge mtl fe hi as s en uly e ol d. An a o it or rwili s t sda ppr pra e de l s ue hi y. The Clr i die t d t s nd c es of t s m e o andt opi on a a ompa ng ek s rce o e opi hi m r l m ni nd cc nyi or rt pl i i fa t t def nda s i ca e oft Of i e oft Ator y Ge r lofV igi a de o a ntf nd o he e nt , n r he f c he t ne ne a r ni , Prs rLii a i Uni. ione tg ton t E E T i %Z a o Au ut2 1. NT R: hs y f g s, 0 3 / i .. . M y Se ni 2 J. ' nie Stt DititJ t d a es src udg

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.