Woods v. Zych et al, No. 7:2013cv00327 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 7/22/2013. (tvt)

Download PDF
e . :. Iyu. :. 1 t e .: 1:- < A f N iv ToA iK ?A Flr: k JUL 22 2 1 03 I TH E UN I N TED STA TES DI RI T CO UR T ST C FO R TH E W E STER N DI STRI T O F V I I I C RG N A R O A N O K E D I SI N VI O M ARSHANE W OODS, JULI . A BY; E LEM M C i lA c i N o.7: 3c vi ton 1 v00327 Pet toner, ii M EM O M N D UM O PI I N N O V. W A RD EN ZY CH e al, t . By:Sam ue G . is l W l on U nie St e Di t i tJudge t d at s s r c R e po nt . s nde s Pe ii ne M ar ha W oods a f de ali a e pr e ngrr s ,brngst sac i n tt o r s ne , e r nm t oc edi o e i hi t o ptrua t 28U. C.j2241.W oods whowa c ce i t Unie SttsDititCour f ls nt o S. , s onvitd n he td ae src t or t Ea t r Di t i tofTe m e s e oft o dr g tafi ki c i e ,c ai st the i a t ly he s e n sr c r se w u r fc ng rm s l m ha s c ua l i nnoce oft e ofe esa t tt Ease n DititofTe s eel ke venuet ty hi .He nt hos f ns nd ha he t r src nne s ac d o r m ag e t t sac n e u nc h s ud me to c n ito i vod teUntd Sae d e n t a r u s ha a o s q e e i j g n f o vcin s i,h ie tt s o s o h ve G u h rt t e e ueav i j d me t'a hema rs r t j2 41f rr le.Th c u t ç t o iy o x c t o d u g n , nd a ' y e o to 2 o eif e o r c udesot r s a dim is shi peii oncl he wie nd s s e s tton. 1. A j r i t eEatr Ditit Te n se f t W o d g l o c n piigt po ss u y n h sen src of n e s e omd o s uiy f o s rn o se s t wih t i e t diti e 5kiogr m so m or ofpowde c ane i vi a i of21U. C. t he nt nt o srbut l n r e r oc i , n olton S. j8 6a po s sigwi itn t d srb t 5 g n o mo eo c c ieba e i v oaino 4 nd se sn t ne t o itiu e 0 rms r r f o an s ,n i lto f h Woods v. Zych et al Doc. 3 18U. C.j841a( ) andi Fe u r 2005,hec ts tnc dW oodst lf i ionme t S. ()1, n br ay t our ene e o ie mprs n . TheCour ofAppeasf t Si h Cic tafimed W oods sconviton and s nt nce Unied t l or he xt r ui fr ' ci e e , t Stt v. oods 1 F. x524( hCi.2006) W oodsc le aes W , 87 App' 6t r . halngedt lgaiyofhi he e lt s c c i a s t nce i a m oton t vac t ,s tas de orc r ts nt nc ptr uantt 28 onvi ton nd en e n i o a e e i , or ec e e e ls o Dockets.Justia.com U. C. 2 5 fldi t eEa tr Ditito Te n se , c t a c u t imis d W o d v S. j 2 5 ie n h sen src f n e s e whih h t o r d s se . o s . Unie Stt , 2: v00068,201 W L 1 td aesNo. 07c 0 303443( D. nn. a . ,201 . E. Te M r 31 0) lI . Or naiy, peii ptrua t 28U. C.j2255, 28U. C.j2241,st di rl a tton ls nt o S. not S. i he a opr a e ve cl f cha l ngi a c ppr i t hi e or le ng onvi to o t i pos ton ofa s nt nc ,lt j a m oton c i n r he m ii e e e m ess j purua t j2255i Gnade t andi feci 'f t epur es l r J ne,226F. 328, s nt o s ç quae i nef tve'or hos pos . n e o s 3d 333-34( h Ci.2000) A peii ptrua t j2255i çna uaea i fci 't 4t r . tton ls nt o s t deq t nd nefe tve'o i c alng tei sto o asn e c o l wh n( )s tld1w et bih dt elg l yo te h l e h mpo iin f e tn e ny e 1 et a sa ls e h e ai f h e e t c n ito o s ne ea t t i o e ; 2 a trtep io e h sc mpee h sa p a a d o v ci n r e tnc t he i mp s d ( ) fe h rs n r a o ltd i p e l n me frtj2255moton,ac ngei s tntvelw r ndest c is i ha n ubsa i a e r he onduc frwhiht prs rwa to c he ione s c n ce n lng rci n l a ()t ep io e c n o stsyteg tke pngpr vso so o vitd o o e rmia; nd 3 h rs n r n n t aif h ae e i o iin f j2255be us t ne r ei no oneofco tt i 1w ma rtoa tvel a ia et ca e he w ul s t nsiutonala de er ci y pplc bl o c eson colae a r viw .I W oodsspe ii n do noti c t a r pe ti whi h hi c e as lt r l e e d. ' tto es ndi a e ny es c n c s as meest sa r t rI r J s a t qualf f co i rtonunde j22 .I r J , t he tnda d mde n e ones o s o iy or nsdeai r 41 n e ones 226F. 328,332( hCi.2000) Specfc ly,t s ondee ntoft t trquiest t 3d 4t r . iial he ec lme he es e r ha ts tntve 1w c nge s h t tt c tubsa i a ha d uc ha he onduc ofwhih t prs rwasc ced i de m e t c he ione onvi t s e d no t beci nal' J- Thi saeme ha notbee e e dt i l s nt i cac ai t o rmi . ., s tt nt s '4 n xtnde o ncude e encng lultons ma epts a t oteS n e cn Gud ln s UntdS ae v. tio d 61 F.d2 0 28 ( t d t u n t h e tn ig ieie . ie tts Pet r . 2 3 7 , 4 4h r f Ci. 01 )( ligta d c-a ino e c a pisi t c n e t fh bi l fe d r o so s r 2 0 hodn h tç t ln c n e p le n he o tx o a ma o fn e prviin au onl whe e t c le t e i biiy se fom f t i y r he hal nge o lgi lt t ms r acual nnoce e oft pr cae c i , nc he edi t rmes and 1Se Unied St esv. Li l. 2 F.d 6 (t Ci. 00 )( $ )atc o t ee e u in o () e t at t e 39 3 7l 4 h r 2 4 (( ta k n h x c to f a t An s ntn ea no ao laea atc o ()c n cin .. (s p o ry b o htu r28U. C. t e c nd t o ltr l ta k n a o vito . ij r pe l r ug nde S. A. j22 1' .G ha e speiin u e j2 mus, ve , efldi t dsrc i whiht p io ri 4 .) W b a tto nd r 241 thowe r b ie n he itit n c he rs ne s ' c nfne ' l r J e , 6F. 328 33 (t Ci. 00 ( ii 28U. C. 2 ( ). o i d. n e on s 22 3d , 2 4 h r 20 ) ctng ' S. j 241 a) n tfo telg l lsii aino t ep e iaec i s' s eas Untd Sae v. oe 5 1 o r m h e a ca sfc to f h r dc t rme . e lo ie tt s Po l, 3 l; F.d26 26 n. (t Ci. 00 )tTo rh Cic i p e e e t sl e s n t x e d dt er a h 3 3, 7 7 4 h r 2 8 ç u t rut rc d n ha i wie o e tn e h e c k o t es vng ca s t t o ep tto esc alngn o l t i s n e c .)(iigI r J n s f h a i s lu e o h s eiin r h le i g ny her e tn e' ctn n e o e , ' 2 6F.da 3 3 4 .Cla l,h r h sb e noc a g i te1w ma igi n w lg lo 2 3 t 3 -3 ) e ry te e a e n h n e n h a kn t o e a t c piet pos es wih t i e t diti ec i ba eort pos e swih i e t ons r o s s t he nt nt o srbut ocane s o s s t nt nt o diti e 50gï orm or ofcoc i bas srbut ams e a ne e.Ac z ngl t cou tfndst W oodsf ist co di y, he r i hat al o me t h I r J ne sa d r t s o t a j2 5 i ia e u t t ts t lg l yo hi e t e n e o s tn ad o h w h t 2 5 s n d q ae o et he e ai f s t 2 c ci a hi cli c nnotbea e sdt rj2241 onviton, nd s ams n ddr se mde . 111. Fort r a onssaed he ei t c tdim is W oods spe ii . he e s tt r n, he our s s es ' ttpn. A . Ent J y 22, er: ul 2013. z . V. (. t UN I TED STA TES DI STRI J D GE CT U 2Th c ur de ln st c nsr eW oo ' peii a a922 mo in.Fis,j2 5mo insmus e o t cie o o tu dss tton s 55 to rt 25 to t beb o h i t c ur whih i os dt s ne e Se 2 U. C. 2 ;s eas S i v. e se r ug t n he o t c mp e he e tnc . e 8 S. j 255 e lo wan Prs ly, 430U. 37 378( 97 ) S c d, o sha ar a y fld aj2 mo in i teEa tr Ditito S. 2, 1 7 . e on W od s le d ie 255 to n h se n src f Te e s e l o d rt fl as c si j22 mo in i t dititc r h mus r c i pr - i nn s e . n r e o ie uc e sve 55 to n he src ou q e t e eve eflng a ho iain fo t ea pr praec ur o a e l.Se j2 (9.Be a eW o sha n t ut rz to r m h p o it o t f pp as e 2551 c us od s o demonsr t d t t Unied St t Cour ofAppeal f t Si h Cic thasis hi pr f lng t a e hat he t aes t s or he xt r ui s ued m e-ii a hoiaint s mias on o sc e sv j225 moton tedititc r h snojrs itont ut rzto o ub t ec d r u c sie 5 i ,h src out a uidci o c ie t eme isofhi j225 cams Ac o di y, h c ur do sno fn t a ta f roface ry onsd r h rt s 5 li . c r ngl t e o t e t id h t rnse la l sc siej225 moint t sne igc u tut r t i ee t o j sieo udca e o my. u cesv 5 to o he e tncn o r frhes he ntrss f utc rj iil c no Ther or t scour declnest consr andt a f W oods' pe ii ef e, hi t i o tue r ns er s tton.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.