Hines v. Mathena et al, No. 7:2013cv00288 - Document 21 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 10/21/2013. (tvt)

Download PDF
CL : IFFI t. . sT. ERK' JE Js Dl CDUr AT DANVILE.V L A Fl L . I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI M A CT RGI ROANOKE DI SI VI ON GREGORY S.HI NES, Pl ntf, ai if ) ) ) ) ) W ARDEN RANDALL M ATHENA,e aI,) t . Dee nt. fnda s ) 21 f , J AC U ULI , BY; D P CL C i lActon N o. 1 c 00288 vi i 7: 3- v- M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI By: H on. ls L.Kie Jacton sr Se orUnie St t sDit i tJudge ni td a e src Gr gor S.Hi s aVigi ai t pr e ng pr K ,fl aCompl i puruan t 42 e y nt , r ni nmae oc edi o ied ant s t o U. C. 1 8 wi j rs cinv se i 2 U.. j1 31a d j1 4 Plit falg st a S. j 9 3 t u idito e td n 8 SC. 3 n 3 3. ani le e h t h f Dee d n s wh aeo fcaso teVig naDe rme to Co rcin (û fn a t, o r fiil f h r i i pat n f re to s i VDOC', i ltdd ' v oae ue ) pr e sg r nt e by t Fo te h Am e oc s ua a e d he ure nt ndmen oft Unie St t sConsiuton by t he t d a e tt i i r sng Pli ifss c iy c a sfc ton a de r asngt r t Pl ntf e r good c uc nc ea i antf e urt l s iia i nd c e i he a e ai if a ns ond t c edi afe co uci ahe rng. Pli tf bele st the i beng t a ry cls ii d,s d r t tr nd tng ai a n if ive ha s i mf il a sfe houl notbe hous a a m or s c e pr s a i e il d t dn ag . ed t e em i on, nd s ntte o m es Pl ntf f ist s a e a c a m upon w hi h r le m ay be gr nt d. Pl i ifha no ai i f a l o t t l i c e if a e a ntf s co tt i rghtt behous d i a pa tc a prs orpl c d i as cii s c liy nsiutonal i o e n ny riulr ion a e n pe fc e trt ca sfc to , n c so il ls iiainsd n t r aeamao d su to i ap io e ' lsiiai n a d u td a ca sfc to o o c e t j r ir pin n rs n rs e vio me t Sa dnv. n e , 5U.. 7 , 8 - 7( 9 5 ; e c u v. a , 27U. 2 5 n r n n. n i Co n r 51 S 4 2 4 6 8 1 9 ) M a h m F no 4 S. 1 ( 976) Nordoesa i ras i s urt casiiai c tt ea ç t ca a sgniia ' 1 . n nce e n ec iy l sfc ton onsiut n ç ypi l nd i fc nt' a ha ds p i r l tont t o di r i de sofprs lf Se e. ,M ood v. caet 429 r hi n e ai o he r na y nci nt ion ie. e. g. y Da t U. 7 , 8n9( 9 6 .Plitf sca stc to a ditrfcl yta frd e n te c e a S. 8 8 . 1 7 ) an if lsi ai n n n e-a it rnse o s o x e d i i s nt nc i s h a e r m ewa a t gi rs t t pr t to oft Fo te h Am e e e e n uc n xte y s o ve ie o he o eci n he ure nt ndme ' nts DuePr es Clus byisownfr e.Se Beveaiv. t 1 F. 5 503(t Ci.1 oc s a e t oc e rt Smih, 20 3d 00, 4h r 997) ( di t ta nitai s r gai f sxmont wihvemi huma wat ,l d hol ng ha dmi srtve eg e ton or i hs t r n; n se' oode f t l ; oiet unbe r bl he t col f a a e a ; d ood;dit c ohi lne ,a be ng;l rpe i i c l;no ry l t ng, i ns nd ddi onge rods n e l f> RK o sder cr a i noeduc tonalorr lgi s r c ;a l sf wa no s aypi last ut i e e ton; ai ei ous e vies nd es ood s t o t ca o î esg fc nthads p) Furher e, ai ifdoesnotha albe t i e e ti t rt he mpos iniia r hi . t mor Pl ntf ve i ry ntr s n he ae a c u sg o c n u tc e i.De lsov. o s n, 28F. u p. 3 5( D. . 0 0 ; e . c r e o d o d c r dt b aj J hn o 1 S p zd 1 E. Va 2 0 ) se ec, wit Hems 45 U.. 6 ( 9 3 .Alh u hP an ifas g n rlyc mp ansa o t ..He t v. l , 9 S 4 0 1 8 ) t o g litf lo e eal o li b u prs of a s f l est f l t rown polcisorpr e es s h f l esdo notn ion fcil ' aiur o olow hei ie oc dur , uc aiur mount t c n t uina v oain .S eUn td Sae v. c rs 4 0U. 7 ( 9 ) Ricov. t . o o si to l i lto s e ie tts Ca ee , 4 S. 41 1 78, c i Cn y t . ofFara 907F. 1 1 (t Ci.1 )( di t ti sae1 g a t mor pr ed a ifx, 2d 459, 469 4h r 990 hol ng ha f tt aw r ns e oc ur l rg st n t Consiuton r q r ,a sae' f ilr t a deby t tl w i no af r ldue i ht ha he tt i e uies tt s a lze o bi ha a s t ede a p o e sis e .Ac o dn l,heCo liti ds s e . r c s su ) c r igy t mp an s imis d 1 TheClr i die d t s nd c esoft sM e o a e k s r de o e opi hi m r ndum Opi o a t ac ompa ng ni n nd he c nyi Or rt t pa tes de o he ri . ENTER:Th' da ofOc obe ,201 y t r 3. ( Se rUnie St t sDititJ ni t d a e src udge 1 Pl ntf' moto t amendt Compl nt whi s ekst a i viua c pact a insa ns detnda t a ai ifs in o he ai , ch e o dd ndi d l a iy cto gai t f n s nd u aeterle s u h i d ne a ftl.S t e2.F ma v Da i, 71U..1 8 1 2(9 2 (iigF d R. v pd t h eif o g t s e id s ui e . . , o n . vs 3 S 7 , 8 1 6 ) ct e . Ci. e n P.1 ()2) 5a(). 2

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.