Doss v. Colvin, No. 7:2013cv00241 - Document 18 (W.D. Va. 2014)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 3/3/2014. (ssm)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CL S OFFI t.S. DI . e ERK' CE J ST COUR7 AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED MA 232 1 24 I THE UN I N TED STA TES DI STRI COU RT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI CT OF VI STRI RGW I A RO AN OK E D I I ON V SI jo BY: . P ELD G ERT S.D OSS, Ci lA c i n N o. 7: 3CV00241 vi to 1 Pl i tf , a n if M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N NI CAROLYN W . COLVI Ac i N, tng Com m i s one ofSoc alSe urt si r i c iy, By: H on.Gl n E. e Conr d a Chi Unie St t D it i tJ ef t d a es s rc udge D e e nt f nda . Pl i ifhasf l d t s a ton c le ng t fna dec son oft Com m i sonerofSoc al a ntf ie hi c i ha l ngi he i l i i he si i Se trt de ngpl n ilsc ai f s em e a s cu iy i om ebe isunde he Soci lSec r t c ziy nyi ai tf' l m or uppl nt l e r t nc neft rt a u iy Ac,asa nd 42 U. C.j 1 q sq. J idito oft sc ti ptrua t 42 U. C.j t me ed, S. 381 t e urs cin hi our s ls nt o S. 1 3()3)whihi or ae j205()oft Soca Se trt t42U. C. 405( .Thi c t 38 c ( , c nc ports g he il cliyAc, S. j g) s our' s r vi w i lm ied t a de e m i ton as t whe he t r i s t n i l e de e t s e e si t o t r na i o t r he e s ubs a t a vi nc o uppo tt r he Com m i s one ' c l i t t a ntf f ie t m e tt c s i rs onc us on ha pl i if a l d o e he ondii f e il m e esabls d by tons or ntte nt t i he a ptr uan t t A c . l s h s t ntale de e e s s t fna de s on oft Com m i s one nd zs t o he t f uc ubs a i vi nc xi t , he i l ci i he si r mus beatr d. La v.Celbrz ,368F. 640( h Ci.1 6) Sttd b ity,s tni t fime ws e e ze 2d 4t r 96 . ae rel ubsa tal e de eha be de i ass hr e nte de e co i i t r c da awhol , m i be vi nc s en fned uc elva vi nc , nsderng he e or s e as ght f ound ade t t s qua e o uppo t c l i b a r as bl m i Ri ha ds v. r e , U . 38 r a onc us on y e ona e nd. c r on Pe al s 402 S. 9, 401( 971. 1 ) The pl i i f El er S. s w a bor on J y 1 1 65, nd e nt l r ac d t e g h a ntf , dg t Dos , s n ul 9, 9 a ve ualy e he he i ht gr de i s hool M r Dos ha wor pr m a iy a a c t c i l bor r A tt a i s r tve a n c . . s s ked i r l s ons nz ton a e . he dm nit a i hear ng,avocatonalexpert es ii t pl ntf hasal o been em pl i i t tfed hat ai if s oyed asa t obacco f m w or , ar ker pantr gr i e, ounds e r a c rpantr TR 5 .Whiet r ulr' ofpl ntf spa twor i ke pe , nd a i e .( 4) l he eg aiy t ai if s ks s b e tt s queton,ta pe r t tMr Dos l te ge i ganf a tviyi 2007or2008. u j c o ome si i p as ha . s as nga d n i ul ci t n u ERK ( TR32- . On J 1 2009,M r Dos fl a ap i to f s pplme a s cziy i ome 33) une 5, . s ied n plcain or u e ntl e lrt nc be is Pl ntf a l d t the be m e di a e f a 1f m sofs t ntal nf le pl e neft . ai i f lege ha ca s bl d or l or ubs a i gai u m oym nt o J n r 1 2 0 d e t p n raii,crh ss s eea ij re ,c r ni pan,b e ti g n a uay , 0 7 u o a c e t s ir o i, k lt l n u is h o c i r ah n t pr e /mphys ma,a he tts ( 1 ) r Dos now manti t theha r i d oblmse e nd paii. TR 81.M . s i ans ha s emane di a ed t t pr s ttm e. s bl o he e en i Pl ntf s a i to f s e e a s c iy i om e be ft w as de e upo i ta ai if pplca i n or uppl m nt l e urt nc ne is ni d n nii l c i r ton a r onsde a i onsde a i nd ec i r ton.Het n r q t d a r ceve ad no hea i a r vi w he e uese nd e i d vo rng nd e e be or a A dm i s r tve La J f e n ni t a i w udge. I a opi on da e M a c 22,201 t La J n n ni td r h 2, he w udge al o s dee m i t tM r Dos i no dia e TheLa J tr ned ha . s s t s bld. w udgef oundt tpl ntf s f r fom avare y ha ai if ufe s r it ofphysca i r nt ,nc udi sauspos rg n es ge y; ge r tvec i l mpaime s i l ng t t t i ht nkl ur r de ne ai hange oft rght s he i a e; r hrts oft l f w rs ;l t p f m or li pi em e ' s or ofc r hos sa pa r tts nkl a t ii he e t it ef hi e a m ng nt hi t y ir i nd nc ea ii ; , c r i lsr n;c oni obsr ci pul r die s andhepaii C.( 1 .Forpur e of e vca tai hr c tu tve monay s a e; tts TR 4) pos s hi c a m f s e e a i om e be is t La J s l i or uppl m nt l nc neft , he w udger e t tM r Dos hasno pas r l va ul d ha . s t e e nt wor ( 1 .TheLa J deemi t tpli ifrt nss tce f tonalc pa iyfr k. TR 9) w udge tr ned ha antf eai ufi int unci a ct o alm ied r nge ofs de a yw or ac i tes The La J e as e s d pl n if sr i lf to l i t a e nt r k tvii . w udg s s e ai tf es dua unc i na c pa t a f l w s a ciy s olo : Afe c r ulc i r i oft e tr r c d,hi Adm i sr tveLa J tr a ef onsde aton he n ie e or t s nita i w udgetnds i t t c a m a hast r s dua f tona ca c t t pe f hat he l i nt he e i l unc i l pa iy o r onn s nt r w or as ede a y k defne i 20CFR 41 967( , t t f l nge e i . cai tc nlf i dn 6. a)wih he olowi xc ptons The l man a it or c r 1 pounds fe ary 0 r quen l a 20 po ty nd unds oc asonaly,c n sand and wal 2 c i l a t k hour i a 8- t w or y,a st 6 hour i a 8s n n hotr kda nd i s n n hour w o kda The c ai ant r y. lm c nno r or c a lng,c n onl occ s ona l c i br m psa s a r , nd ca onl n tpe f m r w i a y a i ly lm a nd t is a n y pe f m o a i baancng,kne lng,soo ng,a c ouc ng. He c n pe f m ror cc sonal l i e i t pi nd r hi a ror f equent butnotcontnuous handlng and over r , i , i head reachi w ih hi l thand and ng t s ef s de . e ha no a tona m a pultve lm ia i w ih e t re r m iy. H e houl r H s ddii l ni a i i t tons t ihe xt e t cannotr ii y oper e f contol w ih hi rghtl epettvel at oot r s t s i owerextem iy,and cnnnot r t ope a e c r s con i r t ont ol tnuous y w ih hi l tha l t s ef nd. H e ca m ot ha conc nt a ed r ve e rt e xpos et t m pe a u eexte e , e shum i t polut n s ori t nt . ec nnot ur o e r t r r m s exc s diy, l a t , ni a s H n ha exposlet haz r ve tr o a dousm ac ne y orunpr t c e he g s c nnotc i b l dde s hi r o e t d i ht , n lm a r , r pe ,o s afol ,a c l wor o vi ai s f c . o s r c f ds nd amot k n br tng ura es ( 1 .Gi s harsdualuncina ca ct a a trc i rngpl ntf' a , ai TR 7) ven uc e i f to l pa iy, nd fe onsdei ai ifs ge educ ton, a pr orw or expe i e a wel a t s i ony f om avo to e r , he La J nd i k renc , s l s e tm r ca i nal xpe t t w udge f ound t t ha M r Dos r t i s fci ntfm c i lca ciy t pe f . s e a ns uf i e t tona pa t o r onn s ve a s cii s nt r w or r es e r l pe tc ede a y k ol e si i sgnika numbe i t nai le my.( 1 20) xitng n i t nt r n he tona cono TR 9- .Acc di y,t La J or ngl he w udge uli aey c l tm tl oncuded t tM r Dos i notdia ed,a t the i note ild t s e e al ha . s s s bl nd ha s ntte o upplm nt s cziyi omebe is Se 20C. R. 41 920( .TheLa J ' opi onwasa e ast e trt nc neft. e F. j 6. g) w udges ni doptd he fna de s on of heCom m i s o r heSoc al c liyA dm i s r ton' Appe l Cot c lH a ng i l ci i t s i ne byt i Se trt nit a i s a s m i. vi e xhaused a 1a ia e a i s r tve r m e e ,M r Dos ha no a t l va l bl dm nit a i e di s . s s w ppea ed t t sco t l o hi ur . W hie pl i if m a be di a e f r c r a n f m s of em pl e t t c uc a f c ua l a ntf y s bl d o e t i or oym n , he r i l a t l dee na i i whehe pli ifwa dia e f a l o ofs t nta ganf le o tnni ton s t r antf s s bld or 1 f nns ubsa il i u mpl yment Se . e 42U. C.j 1 () Theeaef ee nt ofpr whihmus bec i r i ma ngs h S. 382ca. r r our lme s oof c t onsdeed n ki uc a a lss Theeee n saes mmaie a flo :( )o j ci eme ia fcsa dciia n nay i. s lme t r u rz d s olws 1 b e tv dc l a t n l c l n fndi ;2)t opi o a c usonsofr ai physca ;3)s j ci e de ofphysca i ngs ( he nins nd oncl i te tng iins ( ub e tve vi nce il ma f tto ofi ime s asdesrbedt o hacama 'tsi ,a ( t cli nts niesains mpar nt, ci hrug li nt e tmony' nd 4) he ama ' s ed ain, ai lhitr r sd ls lsa a Vie v. nc 438F. 11 115 6 (t uc to voc tona so y,eiua kil, nd ge. tk Fi h, 2d 57, 9-0 4h Ci.1 ) Undewo v. biof,298F. 850,851( hCi.1 . r 971; r od Ri c f 2d 4t r 962) A fe a r vi w of t r c d i t s ca e,t c ur i c t a ne t conc ude t t t tr e e he e or n hi s he o t s ons r i d o l ha he Com m i s one ' fna de i i n i s s i r s i l c s o s uppored b s t ntale de . M r D os s f r d a s ver t y ubs a i vi nce . s uf e e e e c us ij yt hi rghta ei a a omobiea cde i 1 r h n ur o s i nkl n n ut l c i nt n 989.Hi a ewa rbuitwiht s nkl s e l t he i e ton of a r pl tng,a co pr s i s r w s Si e t ts ge y,pl i ifha e r e d ns ri od, a i nd m e sve c e . nc ha ur r a ntf s xpe i nce pr e svepan a l soff ton i hi rghtl re r miy. He a s expe i nc pan a ogr s i i nd os unc i n s i owe xte t lo re es i nd rsd aso arttrc f ij r i h s eth ule.M oer c n l, . s h sd v lpe c r n c e iu l f oao u fnu y n i lfs o d r r e e ty MrDo s a e eo d h o i obs r tvepul ona y di ea e, ppa e l a s i t d w ih c ga e t a e He ha a s be n t e t d t uc i m r s s a r nty s oc a e t i r te bus . s lo e r a e f de ne atve die epr es i t l or ge r i s as oc s n he owerbac M r Dos a s hasahit y ofpanc e ttsa k. . s lo sor r a ii nd he tts, houg t r i no i c ton t tt s co tonsa f tpli ifsc pa iy f r ul r pa ii t h he e s ndia i ha he e ndii fec antf a ct or eg a wo k a tviy.l s r,f t mos pa t pl n ifscai f dia lt i f unde on ava i t of r c i t n ho t or he t r, aitf l m or s biiy s o d rey m us ul ke e ali pa r ent ,a r c nto e ofb ea hi pr e s c os l t m im s nd e e ns t r t ng obl m . The m edi alr or i t s c s i s e ha lm ied,as i a c ec d n hi a e s om w t i t t ppea s t tM r D os ha not r ha . s s r ce ve r gul r a t nton. N ot bl none o pl ntf s t e tng or e m i ng phys c ans ha e i d e a te i a y, f ai if r a i xa ni ii ve s gese t thei dia e f a 1 or sofwor TheSocilSecziyAdmi sr tona r ngedf ug t d ha s s bld or 1 f m k. a l t r nitai ra or a c ula i m e c e m i ton by D r W ila H .Hum phres D r Hum phrese ons t tve di al xa na i . li m i . . i xmni d M r ne . Dos o J nua y31 2011 l e m sofpl n if sm us ul kel t l unc i Dr H um phrespr sn a r , . nt r ai t f c os e a f ton, . i oduce d c i c fndi asf l w s lni al i ngs olo : N ECK :Ra ofm oton i m idl r duce N o J . o brzt . o t nde nes . nge i s ly e d. VD N t sN e r s i BA CK : ng ofm oton i m idl r duc d w ih m id dor alkyphos s The e i no Ra e i s l y e e t l s i. r s s i i N o pa a r e a m us l s m .The e i t r s t pa pa i oft coloss. r ve t br l c e pas r s ende nes o l ton he pa a pi r s nous m us e i t l ba r gi The sr ghtl g r i e i nega i t 90 cl s n he um r e on. tai e a s s tve o de e s s ti gr e itng. J NT RAN G E OF M OTI : oi r ngeofm o i oft uppe e r m ii i f l OI ON J nt a ton he r xte tes s ul i bot s des ebows sihtyrduc d i s oft M CP a I j n swih n h houl r, l , lg l e e n ome he nd P oit t mids n va t ike igo s meo t e ej it.M idyr d c di lf wrs. l y o il hc nn f o f h s on s ll e u e n e t it Lo re rmiyj ntrngeofmoto i midl rduce i bot hi , t nnoma we xte t oi a in s l y e d n h ps wihi r l lm isoft knee and m ode a e y r uc d rghta e.The e i m ode a e s i t he s r t l ed e i nkl r s r t ynovi l a t ckeni i t s r on.Ther i a vertcal20 cm s al t m i r ghttb-i hi ng n hi egi es i car ong he d i i tb r on t tpr e t t a ei rghta ej n a t t me almalolz egi ha oc eds o he ntror i nkl oit nd o he di le a r on.Ther i apunct e 2 cm s dit t t rghtt a i t l er r ghtankl egi es at car s al o he i ibul n he at al i e rgin. ei s mids e o Ther s ome l ynovilt c ni ofs oft I j nt. a hike ng ome he P oi s ( 333) Dr Hlmphre lse t f lwi dig e a f to lase s nt TR . . z is itd he olo ng a nos s nd uncina s sme : D I GN O SES: A 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. CO PD ,m id. l Chr c l m ba s r i oni u r t a n. Postal tcDJ l f wrs,rgh a e tr lma i D, e t it i t nkl . Chr ni ce vi alsr i o c r c t a n. Panc e tts by hit y wih i e te ta r a ii , sor t nt nnit n bdom i lpai na n He tts by hi t y w ihoute de e o he tc f ilr pa ii , s or t vi nc f pa i a lze. Ba e o o j ciefn i so t i e au to , h e a n ewo l b l tdt s d n b e tv idng f hs v lain t e x mie ud e i e o mi st i 6 hotr i a 8 hou w or y, o s a ng a w a ki 2 hour i an 8- l itng ls n n - r kda t t ndi nd l ng sn hot r w or y,t lf i 25 1 oc asonaly a 1 l feq ty. H e w o d be lm ied kda o i tng bs c i l nd 0 bs r uen l ul i t t occasi clm bi kneelng and no crawlng. o onal i ng, i i ( 334) TR . I ques i ng t voc tona ex r, he Adm i s r tveLa J e a ed Dr H um phr e ' n toni he a i l pe t t nit a i w udg dopt . is f to la s s m e . The La J ge c l ed t tM r D os i ca bl ofa lm ied r nge of unc i na s e s nt w ud onc ud ha . s s pa e i t a s nt r wor a tviy. n r s ns t a c pr he i hypo he i al ede a y k c i t I e po e o om e nsve t tc ques i a voc tona e r ton, a i l xpe t t tfe a t a i sr tve hea i t tM r Dos c d be e es ii d t he dm ni ta i r ng ha . s oul xpec e t peronn s ve a s cii td o f e r l pe fc, uns led s den a y wor r e e s i i s g t a num beri t na i kil e t r k ol s xitng n i nik nt n he tonale ono y. c m The c tbe ivest tt La J our le ha he w udge sr la e on Dr Hum phres r por a t La ' e inc . i ' e q nd he w J e' a s s en ofpl ntf sphys c lm ia i f pum os soft hy t tc que ton,a e udg s s es m t ai i f i al i t tons or e he po he i al s i r bot r as bl a c it ntwih t evi nc ofr c d. Furhe m o e i a h e ona e nd ons s e t he de e e or t r r , t ppea st t co t ha r o he ur t t t voca i le r ' eva ua i oft voc tona f ct s a t as u pto unde w hi h t he tona xpe ts l ton he a i l a or , nd he s m i ns r c he expertdelber ed,ar al o cons sentw ih t evi i at e s it t he dence devel oped i M r.Doss' case.l s t t n s n hor, he c tc l our oncudes t t t La J e' opi on de ng e tte e t i s ha he w udg s ni nyi n ilm n s uppore by s t nta td ubsa il e de e.l f l t tt Co isone ' tna de son mus bea fr e vi nc t olows ha he mm s i rs i l cii t fim d. On a alt t sc t pli ifdoesnott ke is wih t Admi sr tve La J ppe o hi oul antf a s ue t he nita i w udge' s tea m en of hi cas l t a M r D os pr s n s a l ga i ns a o f r ne m e c e de , r t t s e. ns e d, . s e e t le to , nd f e s w di al vi nce s g sigt a hi c n iinh sg e tywo sn dsn etetmeo teLa J d esa j dc to ug e tn h t s o d to a ral re e ic h i f h w u g ' du iain. I hi m e or nd , r D os s a est thi he ttsa pa r a ii ha w or e d, nd t the n s m a um M . s t t ha s pa ii nd nc e tts ve s ne a ha i now a ca da e f a lve ta pl nt He a s not st t whie he does no have a hi t y of s ndi t or i r r ns a . l o e ha , l t s or m e a he t t e t e ,he i no bei tea e by a m e a he t s ci i t Fur he mor ,M r nt l alh r a m nt s w ng r t d nt l alh pe als . t r e . Dos r porst tonDe e be 11 201 heu r ntg lbldde slge y.Ac r ngt pl ntf, s e t ha c m r , 2, nde we al a r tr r co di o ai if t szge ydi notg we l a hi lve wa pt t ed.Hes est the i now f r e t r ceve he tr r d o l, nd s i r s mcur ot ha s ocd o e i pe i c m e c lca e t ha tui dr i d f o hi som ac Fi ly,M r Dos i c t t tt rodi di a r o ve l d a ne r m s t h. na l . s ndi a es ha he pr bl m si hi rghta e ha w or e d,a t ta o t pa di s c a i tha now pr c i d o e n si nkl ve s ne nd ha n r ho e c pe i ls s es r be addii lm e tr s a m e c ton f pa n c r . tona asle nd di a i or i ontol W ih t e e i o t a epr e s i a a st t c tha a 1oft ne m e ca t he xc pton f he nkl oblm ,t ppe r o he our t t l he w di l conc r i ntfe by pl ntf de o d a s epoi afe t A dm i sr tve La J e ns de ii d ai i f vel pe t om nt t r he ni ta i w udge i s d s ue hero ni on M a c 22,201 pi on rh 2.A sf t a e c to i i t ue t tM r D os hasi ntfe or he nkl ondii n, t s r ha . s de ii d m e ca t e t e w hi h oc ur e pr o t t da eoft La J e' o ni W hienots s yl d, di l r a m nt c c r d i r o he t he w udg s pi on. l ot e t c tc i r t ne s i s ons o f r d by pl i ifi o he our ons de s he w ubm s i fe e a ntf n pposton t t Com m i s one ' ii o he si rs moin f rs mma yj d me t t c nsi t amoinf rrma do h sc s f rc nsd rto o to o u r u g n ,o o t ue t to o e n f i a e o o i eain f ne a a to m edi a e de . w nd ddii nal c l vi nce 6 l Bor r v. c er777F. 95 ( hCi.1 ,heUniedSttsCour ofAp asf n des He kl , 2d 4 4t r 985)t t ae t pe l or t Fo t Cic tsl m a i e t s a r t rwhi h am o i n f r m a m us be c i r d he ur h r ui lm r z d he t nda ds mde c t o or e nd t ons de e as f l s: olow A rviwi c t yrma aSoca Sec iyc s t t g e e ng our ma e nd il urt a e o he commisoner o t si ) n he ba i ofne l di co r d e denc i f l pr r qui ie a e m e . The e de em us ss w y s ve e vi e f otr e e st s r t vi nc t be ' e e ntt t de e m i ton of di a lt a t tm e t a i a i w a fr t ' l va o he t r na i r s biiy t he i he pplc ton s i s flda dn t rl c multv . Mic el . h i e, 9 F.d1 5, 8 ( t Ci. ie n o meey u ai e' th lv Sc wek r6 9 2 8 1 8 4h r ' 1 .l mus bemaeilt t e entt tt g mmisone 'lde son' g 983) t t tra o he xt ha he co si rs cii ' ht mi r as bl ha be n dif r nt'ha t ne e de e be n bef r he . Ki v. e ona y ve e f e e ' d he w vi nc e oe r ng Caia 599F. 597, ( hCi. 979) Si v. ni , F. 26, ( hCi. lfno, 2d 599 4t r 1 ; ms Ha s 631 2d 28 4t r 1 .Theemus beg c ef t cama ' fiur t s tt e de 980) r t ood aus or he li nts al e o ubmi he vi nce whent cam wasbeor t ( he li f e he Commisonel42U. C. 405( , ndt cama si r, S. j g)a he li nt m us pr e tt t r a ng c t' tl as age r s i oft na ur 'oft t es n o he em ndi our ' e t ne al how ng he t e ' he a ne e de . K i 599 F. a 59 w vi nce ng, 2d t 9. 777 F. a 955. 2d t The c r fndsno l ou t i t good c us ' f r m a ofM r D os ' ca e.A s not d a a e ' or e nd . ss s e bove m os of , t t c ii a de opm e s i pl i if s m e ca pi t e occ r d s e i e a t r t da e of t he rtc l vel nt n a ntf di l c ur ur e om tm f e he t he Com m i sone stna dec s on. Thus i c nnotbe s i t tt e c i r tonsa e r l va t t s i r' i l i i ,t a a d ha hes ons de a i r e e nt o he d tr n to o d sb l yd rn t ep ro o tmea j dc td b t La J g .F rh r r , ee miain f ia ii u i g h e id f i du iae y he w ud e u temo e t t t e e t tt r i ne e de edoc ntngte t e ofM r Dos ' rg a ec ton, o he xt nt ha he e s w vi nc ume i r am nt . ss i ht nkl ondii t c ttnds not ng t twoul s he our i hi ha d ugge tt tpl i if w a i a bl ofpe f m i t lm ie s ha a ntf s nc pa e r or ng he i t d r nge o s de a y w or r e e s o by t La J a f e nt r k ol s nvi i ned he w udge. A c or ngl t r i no r s t c di y, he e s ea on o beleve t tt Com m i soner s de i i w oul ha be n dif r ntha a ne e de e be n i ha he s i ' c s on d ve e f e e d ny w vi nc e bef et La J or he w udgedurnghe consd r tonoft ea e.Cons que l t c tfndsnoca e i r ie ai he s e nty,he our i us f r m a B o der v. e kl r s a l s cic s a es t a opra e c s f M r D os or e nd. r s H c e , upr . n uch r um t nc , he ppr i t our e or . s i t f l a new applcaton f s em ent s l t i s o ie i i or uppl al ectriy ncom e beneft i w hi al of hi is, n ch l s l s a ng difc t e and m or r c ntm e ca pr e sca be c i r ong t ndi f i uli s e ee di l obl m n ons de ed. l afi m i t Co m i s one ' f na de i i t cou tdoe nots n tr ng he m s i r s i l c son, he r s ugge tt tM r D os i s ha . ss f e ofa l n, s om f t w e knes , ndf tgue.l e t m e ca r c d confr st tpl i if r e 1 pai di c or , a s a ai nde d, he di l e or i m ha a ntf s fee av r sro ij r t hsrg ta kl, t c niu n s mpo whc h v p e itby u frd ey eius n uy o i ih n e wih o t i g y tms ih a e r dca l n wo s ne ove tm e M or ove ,ts e st tM r Dos ha now de l pe ne m e c ldif uli s re d r i . e r i e m ha . s s ve o d w di a fk te lnr l t d t hi m us ul ke e aldys unc i H o e r i m us ag n be no e t no doc orha l ea e o s c os l t f ton. w ve , t t ai t d hat t s s esed t tpl i if i t t ly di a e f a lf m s of wor a tviy. I ed,D r Hum phr e ugg t ha a ntf s o a l s bl d or l or k c i t nde . is s c t c ly f pe ii a l ound t t a l as asofJ nua y 31 2011 M r D os c d e ge i a lm ie r nge of ha , t e t a r , , . s oul nga n i t d a s de a y w or a i t e . The cour be i ves t t t s co ula i r por s a as s t nta e nt r k ctvii s t le ha hi ns t tve e t t nds ubs a i l e d ei s vi enc n uppor oft La J t he w udge' a s s e o pl i if sr i ua fm c i c pa iy. s s es m nt f a ntf ' es d l t ton a c t I mu t erc g ie ta t ei bl yt d wo kwi u a ys b e tv ds o o t o s t s b e o nz d h t h na it o o r t t n u j cie ic mf r d e i ho n t ftef e d r cama t oal d sbld.Cr i v Ch tr7 F.d5 5 5 4 9 (t Ci. 9 6 . o o is lr n e a li n ttl ia e ag . ae, 6 3 8 , 9 - 5 4 h r 1 9 ) y On ea an,t p e r t t ec u th th Ad n srtv L wl d ec n iee al fh s j cie c g i ia p as o h o r ta te miitaie a u g o sd r d lo t e ube tv fco sra o a l s p o td b teme ia r c r i a j iaigplitf scam f rb n ft. a tr e s n by u p re y h dc l e od n dudc tn an if li o e eis I d,a pr vi l no ed,ta a st t c tt tt La J ge ga pl ntf t bene i of ndee s e ousy t i ppe r o he our ha he w ud ve ai if he ft a 1 doubti f m ul tng t hypot tc quesi f t voc tona e r ' c i r ton. l n or a i he he i al ton or he a i l xpe ts ons de a i f l st tal f ce s oft Com m i s o r sfnalde i i n a e s olow ha 1 a t he s i ne ' i c s o r uppored by s t nta e de e. t ubs a i l vi nc The c t a i no e t t M r D os m a w i h t c i r flng a ne cl i f our ga n t s ha . s y s o onsde ii w a m or s e e a s c iy i uppl m nt l e urt ncom e be ks A ss tf t a net . e orh bove i a , t ppea st tpl ntf c r ha ai ifs ondii has ton dr m a i a l w o s ne s nc t i s nce oft Co m i s one ' fnaldec s on. M o e r w he a tc ly r e d i e he s ua he m s i r s i ii r ove , n heal i t ag of5 M r Dos wil ape s n t el a oa hi a nc d a 'f pup os tans he e 0, . s l be r o t dos y ppr c ng dva e ge' or es oft medial cai lgui i s.Se ge , C. R. 41 969.Att ttme, vena s ng he c vo tona delne e, n.20 F. j 6. ha i e sumi 8 t the silpos es est ca c t t do s de a y exe ton, e 20109 ofAppendi 1 t Subpa t ha tl s s he pa iy o e nt r ri Rul . x o r P oft Adm i sr tveRe ultonsPa t404 wildie tadee mi ton ofdia e i hi c s he nita i g ai r l rc tr na i s bld n s a e. A s a ge r lr l ,r s uto o c nfi t i t e de e i a m aterw ihi t pr vi e of ne a u e e ol i n f o lc s n he vi nc s t t n he o nc t Com m i s one e n i t c t i r ol t c lc s dif r nty.R i ha ds v.Pe a e , he s i r ve f he our m ght es ve he onfi t f e e l c r on rls s a; rhem v. nc 495F. 396( hCi.1 .Fort rms sae t c r fndst upr Oppel i Fi h, 2d 4t r 974) he e ons ttd,he ou ti he Com m i s one ' r ol i oft pe tne c l c s i t r c d i t s ca e t be s s i rs es uton he ri nt onti t n he e or n hi s o uppor e b td y s t nta e de e.A cc di y, he fna de i i n oft Co m i s o m us be a fnned.La s ubs a i l vi nc or ngl t i l c s o he m s i ner t fi w v. lb e z , u .Ana p o rae u g n a dod rwil ee trdt i d y Cee rz e s ma p r p it j d me t n r e l b n ee hs a . The c e k i die t d t s nd c r ii c e oft s o ni t a lco elofr co d. l r s r c e o e e tfed opi s hi pi on o l uns e r EXTER t i 3 xf d yo rh, 201 hs a rvac 4. 1. -7 t Chi fU nie St t s D it i tJ e t d a e s rc udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
