Joyner v. Swiney et al, No. 7:2013cv00227 - Document 24 (W.D. Va. 2013)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 6/27/2013. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CL SOFFI U. DI COURT ERK' CE s. ST. A D NVIL V T L E,A FI L + n U 27 j IN TH E U N ITED STATE S D ISTR ICT CO U R T FO R TH E W ESTER N D ISTR ICT O F V I G IN I R A R O A N O K E D I ISIO N V JULI A BY: CH W ST O PH ER LEE JO Y N ER , Pl ntf ai if, By: a ER M EM O M N DU M O PI I N N O W A LTER SW I EY ,e al, N t . D ef endant s. E :Y r C i lA c i N o.7: 3- v- 227 vi t on 1 c 00 V. U L ,c R H on.Jac t on L . i e ls K sr Seni U nied St es Di ri Judge or t at st ct Clrso rLeeJ lit phe oyne ,aVigi a i t pr edi pr s fl d am o i r si a r r ni nma e oce ng o e, ie ton eque tng p ei n r ijmcint o d rhi ta frt ad fe e t rs ni Vign a Plitf ag e t a rlmiay n t to o r e s rnse o ifrn p io n r ii . anif r u s h t hef r frhi lf whiei a c rtda t Re Oni Stt Prs (t eas o s ie l nc r eae t he d on ae ion d ROSP' be a ehewa ' c us ) s alege y a t c d by de enda s w ho a e c r c i l dl ta ke f nt , r or e tonals a fa RO SP,on M a c 1 201 a by tf t r h 8, 3, nd non- f nda son Aprl28,201 whiei ROSP' C- l ng. de e nt i 3, l n S buidi A p ei nayij nci ni a t x ro d n r a d atcr me y. M u fv. rn, 5 rlmi r nu to s n s ta r i ay nd r si e d ' na Gee 5 3 e ' U. 6 4, 9 9 ( 0 ) A mo n mu te tb ihf u ee n sb f r ap ei nayij n to S. 7 68 - 0 20 8 . va t s sa ls o r lme t eo e rlmi r n u ci n ma is 1 hei lkel t s ce dont mert;2)hei lkeyt s fri pa a eha m i t y sue: ) s i y o uc e he is s i l o ufe ae r bl r n he a e eo p ei n r r l f 3 t baa c o e ute tp i h sfv r a d4 a ij n to i bsnc f rlmiay ei ; ) he ln e f q iis i s n i a o ; n ) n nu cin s e i t ep b i itr s.W itrv Nat a Re . f Co n isn .5 5U. 7 2 ( 0 ) Plitf n h u lc n ee t n e . tr l s De . u clI c, 5 S. , 0 2 08 . anif l i nota l d t de o t a e o y a t sbiiy' ofi r pa a e ha m be us t ts anda d i s lowe o m ns r t nl l i lt ' re r bl r pos ca e ha t r s tn o sse twi ( lc a a trz to o ij n tv rle a a e ta r iayr me yt a ma d c n itn t t h r ceiain f n u ci e eif s n xr o dn r e d h t y i h he onl be a r d upo ac e rs y wa de n l a howi t tt pl ntf i e il dt s h r i . l a 23. ng ha he ai if s ntte o uc elef' d. t ' Joyner v. Swiney et al A mo a tmu tas etbls ar lto s pb t e teij r came i temoi nf r v n s lo sa ih eain hi ewe n h nu y li d n h to o Doc. 24 p ei n r ij n v r l fa dtec n u tgvigrs t ac mp an .Ome aW o l Trv l . r l ay n u die ei n h o d c i n ie o o lit mi e g rd a e v TW A,111F.d 1 1 ( hCi.1 .Co e nl a ij to i no a l ei t s 3 4, 6 4t r 997) nsque ty, n nuncin s t vaiabl n hi ac i t r m e t a l ged a t c by non- f nda s on A pr l28,201 bec us pl ntf s ton o e dy he le ta k de e nt i 3 a e ai if Dockets.Justia.com G . Am e d Compl i s ksr le onl a t t M a c 18 201 i de . Se l r M i r oh nde ant ee e if y s o he r h , 3,nci nt e n e c os Antt s Lii ,333F. 51 5 ( h Ci. inzt tc. 3d 7, 26 4t r 2003)(ttngt twihoutane bewe nt sai ha t xus t e he ij r alg di temo inf rap ei n r ij n to a dt c n u td srbe i a nu y le e n h to o r l ay n u cin n he o d c e ci d n mi c mpan ,h c u t h ul n t o i e tefco sfrp ei n r ijmcierle o litt e o r s o d o c nsd r h a t r o r l ay nt tv eig. mi Pl ntf f ist esa ih t thei lkey t s ee on t m e is A prs ra lgi ai if al o t bls ha s i l o ucc d he rt . ione le ng e e sv f remu to j ciey s o t t d fn a ttn lce u n c s aya dwa t npan xc s ie o c s b e tv l h w ha a e e d n t fitd n e e s r n n o i i a ds fei g' W hi e v Ales 4 5U. 3 2 3 0( 9 6 .De pt p an ifsalg to sta n u frn . ' t y . b r, 7 S. 1 , 2 1 8 ) s ie litf le ain h t l de e n ss ve el be thi ,media sa fas e s pl ntf a oxi ael t ry m i esa tr f nda t e r y a m c l t f s s ed ai if ppr m t y hit nut fe t al ge a t k a di notdic ra ta he le d tac nd d s ove ny r uma,s li ordicol a i a pli ifdi we lng, s or ton, nd antf d noteompl n t m e ca sa fa ai o di l t f bouta hi butpa n i hi rg pevi . nyt ng i n s i ht l s Pli ifalo f ist e t ih ir par bl ha bec us hei c r nty s gr t i a antf s al o sabls re a e nn a e s ure l e egaed n dif r n buidi a RO SP t n wher t a l ge M a c 1 201 oc ur e Fu t nnor f e e t l ng t ha e he le d r h 8, 3, c r d. r he e, pl ntf m e el s c a es a ta unkno n pos i lt ofhar . Se Si m onsv. ,47 F. ai i f r y pe ul t bou n w s biiy m e m Poe 3d 1 7 ,1 8 ( t Ci.1 9 )(1 f tr o c n e tla tr a o ij r i i u fce tt j siy 3 0 3 2 4h r 9 5 tA) ' u e r o j ct lh e t f nu y s ns fiin o u tf g u r ijmcierle ) Emmo sv M c uc i 8 4F.d3 , 5 ( t Ci.1 8 )(ttn v r a n t tv eif'; n . La hl 7 2 51 3 4 6h r 9 9 saig eb l n, tr asc usn fa f rplitf slf n t n ifi e n o ac nsiu in l ih) Plitf as h e t a i g e r o an if ie o a n rng me t f o t to a rg t. anif lo t f ist esab ih how a or rb e on s c ai a uns tnta e f r f rhe st a l o t ls n de as d pe ul tve nd ubsa it d ea s u t r he publc' i e e twhe t ti e es i s r d by de e rng t core tona ofi a sa utt i s ntr s n ha nt r t s e ve f r i o r c i l fcil bo he a oprae s ofwhe et hous a s ii prs r Se eg. Be lv. olih,441U. 5 ppr i tne s r o e pecfc ione . es . , l W fs S. 20, 5 0n.3 5 8n2 ( 9 9 (x anigta manann s c rt a do d ra o rtn 4 2 , 4 .9 1 7 ) e pli n h t itiig e u iy n r e nd peaig i tt in i ma ge bl f hi a econsde a i pe ulary wihi t pr nc a nsiuto n na a e as on r i r tons c i l t n he ovi e nd pr e sona e rieofc r tonsofkil) M o e r prs r dono ha a rg t be ofs i l xpe ts oreci t as . r ove, ione s t ve ny iht o hous di apa tc arfciiy.Se e2.Mea hum v. no,427U. 215( 97 . e n riul a lt e, . , c Fa S. 1 6) Ba ed on pl ntf salega i a t pr s ntsa usoft ca e pl ntf f ist s ai if l tons nd he e e tt he s , ai if a l o e tbls t tt balnceofe te tpsi hi f r Def nda sha notye r pondedt t sa ih ha he a quii s i n s avo . e nt ve t es o he Am e d Compl i ,a or rng a unne es my ta f rwoul t y bur c r c i nde ant nd de i n c s r nse d mdul den ore tonal o fcas Ac o dngy p an iffist s tsyt ee n sfrap ei n r ij n to , n I fiil. c r i l, litf al o aif he lme t o rlmiay n u ci n a d d n hi r q e t f rap ei n r ijmcina da e i e tayh a ig. e y s e u ss o r l a y nt to n n v d nir e rn mi TheCl r i diecedt s nd c e oft sM e a l Opi o a t a ompa ng ek s r t o e opi s hi mor ndtm ni n nd he cc nyi Or rt pli if de o antf . EN TER :Thi c da ofJ y une, 2013. t Se orU nle t t s i t i tJ e n t d a e sr c udg
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
