Bender v. Insight Health Corp. et al, No. 7:2013cv00157 - Document 9 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 5/10/2013. (eot)

Download PDF
ctEe s OFFI U.. CE 8 D< rn 1 RT ATROAROKE, A V FI LED m t l2 2 1 23 I T H E U N I D STA TE S D I N TE STR I T C O U RT C FO R TH E W E ST ER N D I STR ICT O F V I G I I R N A R OANO KE DI SI VI ON R O B ER T D A N A BE N D ER , J AQ ULI BK D , JFQ* P CL C i lA ct on N o.7: v00157 vi i 13c Pl nt f ai i f, V. I SI H T H EA LT H C O R P.eta . N G l, D ef endant s. O DE SSA M .SH U C K , Ci lA c i N o.7: v00158 vi t on 13c Pl ntf ai it V. I SI T H EALTH CORP.e a . N GH t 1, De e f ndant . s RO SE M .W H I TE, Ci lAdi N o.7: v00159 vi on 13c Pl nt f , ai i f M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI V. I GH T H EALTH CORP.eta1, NSI . De e f ndant . s By:Sam ue G.W is n l lo U nied St es Di tri Judge t at s ct Thepl i if i t s t e s pa a ec vi a tonso i na l fld t i cli i t antfs n he e hr e e r t i l c i rgi ly ie her a ms n he Cic tCour f t CiyofRoa agans l ihtHe lhCor CtHC' ,HC physca , rui tor he t noke i t nsg at p. l ' l ) iins and I age Gui Pai M anagem ent. Jus as i W i e v.l ghtH ealh Corp. 7: m ded n t n nMat nsi t , 13cv00142 ( . Va.May 1 201 ,hepli if'sae-our c ant al t tt dee nt a td W D. 0, 3)t antfs tt c t ompli s lege ha he fnda s ce ne i nty,f a e l a i vi a i oft V ig ni Cons erPr e i A c by ob a ni glge l r udul nty, nd n ol ton he r i a um ot cton t t i ng c a naedmehyl e s oneac tt (n ij tbl se oi c ontmi t t prdniol eae a neca e tr d ommonl usdt tea s lng y e o r t weli a pan)fom t Ne Enga Compoundi Ce er(C nd i r he w lnd ng nt C NECC' a a nitrngivi ' nd dmi se i t a ) ij cin t a c u e f n a me i gts Afe t eplitfsfldterc mpansi saec u t ne to s h t a s d u g l n n ii. tr h an if ie h i o lit n tt o r, I r movedt a tonst f de a c tba e on t c am s pur td r ai t NECC' HC t he ci o e r l our s d he l i ' pore elton o S o i Cha e 11ba pt y i t DititofM asac e t.Ea h pl i tf hasfl d a ngo ng pt r nknz c n he src s hus ts c a n if ie m oton t r m a hi orhe c us ofaci n t sa tc t e c a gui t tI Sr mova i o e nd s ra e to o tt our, a h r ng ha HC' e l p tto wa j idcin l d fce t Fal gt t t e ag e t ec u t h uda ti fo ei n s m s ito al e in . ii ha,h y r u ,h o r s o l bsan r m i y n e rii r ltd- j rs ito o s o l rma dt ea t n o e utbeg o n s I S xecsng eae t u idcin, r h u d e n h ci n q ia l r u d . HC' o o code e f ndan s Dr J M ahi, . t , . ohn t s Dr Robe tO' i n, nd l a Gui d Pan M a ge nt ha r Bre a m ge de i na me , ve j ne i t pl ntfs motons Asi W i at v.nsa Heat Cor ,hecour asume oi d n he ai if ' i . n na e l iht 1h p.t t s s wi o td cdn ta iha r ltd t j rs ito o r h s matr b t e s n ilyfrt e t u e i ig h t t s eae -o u idcin ve t e e tes u, se tal o h h r as t cour sa e i W i a e, hec ta t nsfom he rngt e ma tr purua tt t e ons he t tt d n ng t t our bsai r a i hes te s s n o he m a t r a t nton pr so i 28 U .S. j1 c ( 1al as r m a t m on e t bl nda o y bse i ovii n n quia e C. 334()2) rd lo e nds he g omd p rua tt 28U. C. l 5 ( ) Ac o d n l,h c u t rn steplitfs moi n t rt s us n o S. j 4 2 b . c r i gy te o r ga t h an if' to s o r and. em ENTER:M a 10,201 y 3. zA -v''-y- ' . /' V M T .,r )' f) 'y - ., . ' . . z' . . > . UNI TED STATES DI STRI J CT UDGE 1 1n iainsaeta tesaec ut ltmeyaj iaeteematr, ln wi Wig t v I ih A1idcto r h th tt o rwili l dudc t h s tes ao g t n ae .nsg t h Heat Co p.. l a e t t çc r c i r i no whe cltgai wo dmovet fse t butwhehe i ca be 1h r n ny ven ,he tore t nquiy s t r ii ton ul he a ts, t rt n . t l aj dctdi saec u t t 1. Po rPln Enm'Cai Reo tn .LLC v Ma a o 4 4B. 2 0 i y du iae n tt o r a al' we a t t t sno s r ld. me ' . ng n , 8 R. 9 , 297 ( M d.201 .Pl ntfs'cou elr pr e e durngor lar ntt t pa teshad c D. 2) ai if ns e es ntd i a gume hat he ri onducedalngt t e hy c n ee ewihtesaej d ea dh dfr ltdapa i whc tec u t udueW i aea tela c s t o frnc t h tt u g n a omuae ln n ih h o r wo l s na t s h e d ae o a e st lgala f t lis a woul c oldaet r s oft c e f dic l The atdavisand ddr s he e nd acua sues nd d ons i t he e t he as s or s ovey. fi t ohe tl si teec s ss o ta tes ep o e dig weemovn q c ya ta t saej d eh dma e t rii n h s ae h w h th ot r c e n s r ig uikl nd h the tt u g a d ng ce rhsitnint mo etec ssfm ada dha e e e trdp ril u r jd me tnan mb ro te la i n e t o v h a e o r n d v n nee at s mmay u g n i u e f h m. o a I fc,ta p as+a teo l tigi e i tmeyaj dcto o temei it sd tl t fd rlc u t n a ti p e r th ny hn mp dng i l du iain n h rt s hi eoz o e ea o r. s r 2

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.