Barbour v. Arlington Virginia Commonwealth Attorney, No. 7:2013cv00085 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 03/01/2013. (kab)

Download PDF
r FRKSOFFI U, DIX COURT d CE S. S AT FO.RC KE, ? , ) VA t . . . / r. . . ' MA2 q 1 23 1 I TH E UN I N TED STA TES DI STR I T CO UR T C FO R T H E W ESTERN DI STRI T O F V I G I I C R N A R O A NO K E D I I O N V SI K ENN ETH EDW A R D BA R BO U R , JULI C ' ! , A ) ' CLCRK BY: DEP CL ERK CA SE N O .7: 3C V 00085 1 Pl ntf , ai if M EM OR ANDUM O PI ON NI V. A RI I G TO N V I G I I ,N R N A COM M ONW EALTH ATTORNEY, By: Jam es C .T urk Se or U nied St t sD i t i tJudge ni t a e sr c D ef endant. Pli ifKe t Ba bo , Vigi a i t pr e ngpr K , i t scvi rght a ntf nneh r ur a r ni nma e oce di o brngs hi i l i s c antunde 42U. C.j1 ompli r S. 983.Babotral s nmongot t ngs t ofkil a Re r t lege , her hi ,hat t as t d O ni St t Pr s t e tdi f e t pe ofm a ldif r nty, ha t y onl a l w i ge i a e on a e i on r a fer nt y s i f e e l t t he y lo ndi nt nm t s t malfv ltespe mo t ,h tteVigni De a t n o Co rcin (: o i ie etr r n h ta h r i a p rme t f re to s û VDOC' r q ie ' e u rs ) ofi a st hol $25 i ea h i t stus a ountf hi r e e,a t tt e o Loa 'ha fcil o d n c nma e' r t cc or s elas nd ha ç dc M ns' ve c us hi t i trade of$68. Ba bours kst ha a lde sca ele andt ob ai a ed m o nc t bt 50. r ee o ve l bt nc ld o tn ac es t a1 hi tus a cot f nds antf di nots i pa m e oft $350flng f e,b c s o l s r t c mt u .Pli if d ubm t y nt he ii e ut move t pr ee L f mapa rs See28U. C.jj1 4() 1 s o oc d q or upe i. S. 91 a , 915.Afe r viwi t tr e e ng he r cor t c tde est motont pr ee wihoutpr ymen oft f ea sz a iy e d, he our ni he i o oc d t epa t he e nd lmm rl dimis t a tonunde 28U. C.j 1 5( . s ses he ci r S. 91 g) Pl ntf ha ha a las tle non- be c vi c ai if s d t e t ir e ha as i l ompl i sora a spr vi l ant ppe l e ousy dim is d a fi ousorf f ii t saea cai upon whih r le ma begr nt See e. , s s e s rvol or a lng o t t l m c ei f y a ed. , 2. Bab u v. r i aDe t o Con. t 1 7:9c - 0 91( . Va Ap . , 0 ) Ba b u v r o . Vigni p . f r e a. 0 -v 0 0 W D. . r 8 20 9 , r o r . r , . Stnf d. ta.7: c 00077( . Va. . 2009) Bar lv. r ni De t ofCor. a or e l, 09-vW D. Apr 7, ; bot Vici a p . r r, 7: c 00083( . Va.Apr 6, ) I ac or nc wiht t e -ti spr vii of28 09-vW D. . 2009 . n c da e t he hr esrke o son U. C.j1915() t c tprviusy a s dpli ift thene dt s tt $350. S. g ,he our e o l dvie antf ha ede o ubmi he 00 flng f eoresa ih a i i ntt e tofs rousphysc ha m t pr e wih a cvi s t ii e t bls n mm ne hr a ei ial r o oc ed t i l ui. Se , ..Bab u v Ke fe Co s aisa VDOC', 7:9 c - 01 4 ( . Va M a 1 , e eg, r o r . ef e mmis re t s No. 0 -v 0 5 W D. . y 2 20) 0 9. Afe r vi ng pl ntf s s isons i t s ci la ton,i i c e rt tpli if doe tr e ewi ai if ubm s i n hi vi c i t s l a ha a ntf s n talg a f csidc tn t a tecru tn e o wh c h c mp ansp a ehi u d ra y o le e ny a t n iai g h t h ic msa c s f ih e o li lc m n e n i ne tt ra o a y sro s p y ia ij r wi i t e me nig o 2 U. C.j1 5 g . mmi n h e t f n ei u h sc l nu y t n h a n f 8 S. h 91 ( ) Ba e on t f egoi a t co ai ,t c ttndst tpli iff ist de onsr t a sd he or ng nd he mpl nt he our i ha antf a l o m tae ny i mi nt da r of s rous physca hn m a pl i if has not pa d t $35 00 flng f m ne nge ei i l r nd antf i he 0. ii ee des t bei pr vi usy a s ofha ngt e srke .Acc di y, he c tde e pli ifs pie ng e o l dvied vi hr e ti s or ngl t our ni s a ntf moint p o e dt f r p u e i a d ds se tec mplitwi o tp eu ief rfit et to o r c e q o ma a p rs n imis s h o an t u rj dc o alr o h l pa t flng f e a t tm e offlng t c pl i . Se e. ,D upr e v.Pa m e ,28 F. 1 y he ii e t he i ii he om a nt e, a. e l r 4 3d 234, 1 3 ( 1h Ci. 0 2 (e s nn t a t c u ti n tr q ie t p r tpanifa o p ru iy 2 7 1 t r 2 0 ) r a o ig h t he o r s o e urd o emi litf n p o tnt t pa t flng f a trde ng la t pr e L f ma pa i) Mor ve,t co t o y he ii ee fe nyi e ve o oce d q or upers. eo r he ur ce tfe t ta a a of t s or r woul no be tke i good f t pur ua t 28 U . C. rii s ha n ppe l hi de d t a n n aih, s nt o S. j 1 5()3) 91 a( . TheCl k i die t d t s nd c e oft sM e or ndlm Opi on a t ac ompanyi er s r c e o e opi s hi m a l ni nd he c ng Or rt pl i if de o antf . ENTER:Thi I d yo Mac , 2013. s A a f rh .' .. ' . , 2 5 1 Unie St t sDitit or t d a e src g e

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.