Makdessi v. Ayers et al, No. 7:2013cv00079 - Document 84 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/15/2014. (kab)

Download PDF
D -QKB OFFI U, , S'.- l F CE S DI F rnlr AT ROANCFE VA A ( I TH E U NI N TED ST ATES DI STRI T C O UR T C FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STR I T O F V I G I I C R N A R O AN O K E D I I O N V SI A DI ED D I R AM EZ M A K D ESSI B E ' 0rT 1 2 1 24 JULI C. LE% CL A ( ERK BK DEPU CL ERK Ca e N o.7: CV 00079 s 13 Pl ntf, ai if M EM O M N D UM O PI I N N O HAROLD CLARKE, AL , :I By:GlnE. n a e Co rd Chi Unie Stt Diti tJ ef t d a es src udge Dee nts. fnda t) Pl ntf Adi Eddi Ra e M a s ha fld a pl a ng t the tte : GM oton f ai if b e m z kdes i s ie e di ha il s l i or Em e g nc Or r of Pr t c i .,l M a s ias e t t tbei cufe t t ba ca e hi r e y de o e ton , kde s s rs ha ng f d o he ck us s m s de pan a t tnume o tme a Ri rNorh Co rci lCe e (û houl r i nd ha r us i s t ve t re tona ntr < RNCC',ofkes ' t r ) ha c f hi t t fontorc f d hi t t ba wih t paisofc f . Heco pl nst t ve ufed m o he ' r ufe m o he ck t wo r uf s m ai ha o S p e e 1 , 01 RNCC o tcas( p . b a dt J h Do s rijze hss o d r n e tmb r 8 2 4, f il Ca t Fe s n wo o n e ) ent d i h ule i r a wrs by c fng hi t t bac du i a s kedown ofhi cel e afe he as d f nd it ufi m o he k rng ha s l, ven tr ke or s i c fng a s e t m m e c l r or . M a pec al uf i nd how d he di a ec ds kdes i a s c pl i t t w hie o he s l o om a ns ha l t r i t pl c t i lgalm ae il t ough an X-a m a hi t ofi r t e up a s a t e nma es a ed her e tra s hr r y c ne, he tce s or nd c ter d M a s isll l' a t d hi t ti he wo d s nd hi l alwor hom e he woul notbe kde s' ûegas' nd ol m ha f ul e s eg k , d r a it d a ns. M a s ialege t tOfi erAye s a defnda i hi pe ng lws twho etla e gai t kde s l s ha tc r, e nt n s ndi a ui i no a K- ofk e a RNCC,br t hi dog t t s ke s w 9 t r t ough s o he ha down a a l d i t ba k at nd lowe t o r Makdessi v. Ayers et al Doc. 84 Ma kdes it i i dae hi . M akde s sa e t he s d be ta f r e t ea t r Vigi at s o ntmi t m s i t t s hat houl r nse r d o se n r ni o a o df rh rs o le ij t a dr tlain. v i u te h ud r nu' n eaito y 1 l t he ng ofhi m oton, M akdess ls sCas No.7: n he adi s i i it e 13CV00079 whi s ch eeksdam ages f or ij re t hi s ule a Ke nMo t nCorcina Ce tr nu is o s ho d r t e unai reto l ne. Dockets.Justia.com Th c t'c n tu sM a d siss b s in a a mo in s e ig itro u o y ijmcie e out o sr e k e s' u miso s to e kn n el c tr nt tv rle die tng t pecfe ofi as t ta fr hi a y fom wesen Vigi a. t( eif rci ms iid fcil o r nse m wa r tr r ni tA1 p ei n r ij n to ma n v ris et p e e ta ij r o h t whc n te nt emo i g rlmi ay nu cin y e e su o r v n n n u y r a' ih o ve h v n m pa t c e wa c ed by t wr cl med i t unde l ng a ton.' Om e W ord ry ont nds s aus he ong ai n he ryi c i ' ga l Trve v.TW A,111F. 1 1 ( h Ci.1 ) I r Mir of Anttus Lii ,333F. 51 a l 3d 4, 6 4t r 997 ; n e cos t ir t ta. 3d 7, 5 6( t Ci. 0 3 . 2 4h r 2 0 ) M a s i doe no a l ge t t t pot ntal hn m he s ks t pr vent t ough an kde s s t le ha he e i r ee o e hr itro u o yij n to aie fo tep s wr n sh ha came a ans o t asi Ca eNo. n elc t r n u cin rs s r m h a t o g e s li d g i t fkil n s 7:3CV00079. Rat r M a s ia l esanew s tofca msagans t e ne def nda s t t 1 he , kde s leg e li i t hr e w e nt- ha RN CC ofi a sc f d hi t t ba m e s d up hi l ga matra s a alowe adogt ba k fcil ufe m o he ck, s e s e l e i l , nd l d o r a hi . The ef e, l hi moton f i t roc or r i mus be de e i t spe ng c e, t m r or whie s i or n e l ut y elef t nid n hi ndi as 2 t c t w il di e t t c e k t fl t m oton as a ne a s pa a e c vi ac i he our l r c he l r o ie he i w nd e r t i l ton. An a opraeor wilis t sda ppr it der l s ue hi y. The Clr i die t d t s nd a c oft sor rt t pl n ifand t co elofr co d ek s rce o e opy hi de o he aitf o uns e r f t de e or he f ndan s t. ENTER :Ths I N d yo Oco e, 01 i G a f tb r2 4. E Chi fUnie St t Diti tJ e td aes src udge 2 M akdess s a e t t he wilpur ue t e cl m s i a s a e ci lacton, unl s t cour i t t s ha l s hes ai n epar t vi i es he t alows hi t a end t pe ng cas Thi a i whi i r l m o m he ndi e. s cton, ch s eady t be s o chedul f t i ,concer ed or ral ns eve st toccur e i November2012 a anot prs nt ha rd n t her ion.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.