Makdessi v. Fleming et al, No. 7:2013cv00079 - Document 24 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 06/11/2013. (kab)

Download PDF
* rdFp<; oFF4 J. DI rnlr c;l B. SK l ATROANOKE, VA FI LED I TH E U NI N TED STA TES DI STRI T C O UR T C FO R T H E W ESTERN DI STR I T O F V I G I I C R N A ROANOKE DI SI W ON A D I ED D I R AM EZ M A K D ESSI B E , J 1 12 1 UN 23 JUtl C. A BK u, . , DEP 'iLERK ,. 2 CL ERK CA SE N O .7: 3CV 00079 1 Pl ntff ai i , M EM O M ND U M O PI O N NI HAROLD CLARKE, AL , :I By: Gln E. nr d e Co a Chi f Unied St esD i t i Judge e t at s r ct Defnda t) e nts. Pl ntf Adi Eddi Rn zM a s i pr e ngpr K a t f mapa i i t s ai if b e me kdesi s oce di o nd q or upers n hi prs ne cvirg sa tont r42U. C.j 1 io r i l iht ci mde S. 983.Thecour notfe M a s t thi i tal t iid kdesi ha s nii compl i f ie t sa ea a tona ec am , c us he di notsae f c sc e ni c ant al d o tt ny c i bl l i be a e d t t a t onc r ng onduc t by t i vi lde e nt i vi a i ofhi rght . M a he ndi dua f nda s n ol ton si s kdes ihass i t d a n e d s ubm t e n m nde co pl nt a t co tr ce l die t d t c e k t a t m ai , nd he ur e nty r c e he l r o tempts r i eofpr e soft tn nde e vc oc s ha me d c pli on t de e nt na e t r i .1 M a s ihasalo fl dt motonst thesyl om a nt he f nda s m d he en kde s s ie wo i ha t es a t me g n yr q sl)f ro d ro p oe to '( No .1 & 1 ) Afe rviw o te s û r e c e uets o r e f r tci n'ECF s 4 5 . tr e e f h e r c r ,h c u t e e te emoi n f ritro uo yij n tv r l f e o d te o r d nis h s to s o n el c tr n u cie ei . e I hi c pli , a n s om a nt M kdes ial st ti N ove s lege ha n mber201 tle ofi r fom Red Oni n 2, lr e fce s r o SaePrs n wh r h sp e iu j1 8 a to aos , r al we t c met t ep o e tv tt io , ee i r vo s 9 3 cin r e wee lo d o o o h r tcie c t t twhe ehe i now ho ed a Ke n M ount i Co tona Ce e a i r t iton usody mi r s us t e an aeci l nt r nd, n e ala i f t tpro l ws t we ealowe t ha uf hi be nd hi ba k d pie knowl dge ofhi or ha i r a ui, r l d o ndc f m hi s c es t e s s o l e ij r I h sc re t to , a d si se t ta h f asf rh slf a Ke n h u d r nu y. n i u rn moins M k e s a s rs h t e e r o i ie t e M ot n,ba e on sa e e sva i ofi i sha m a a mii s d tt m nt rous tcal ve de bouthi prorlws tandt sne s i a ui hi w ca e. H e a l gest tOfi rPhilps t d hi s c i y ofi r c d sr p s a c M a s if s le ha tce li ol m e m t ice s oul ti e r h kde s or 1 Bas on M akdes isom isi ofot def ndant fom t am e d com pl nt t courtwil ed s' s on her e s r he nde ai , he l dim ist acton ast t om it def s s he i o he ted endant ,on t pr umpton t M akdes ihassa ed no cl m he s he es i hat s tt ai w ihest pur ue agai tt . s o s ns hem s ctrt r s ns t tofk er i si a i hi ca m ofs xuala s ta c edhi ofl ng a e liy ea o ; ha t s nve tg tng s li e s aul c us m yi nd t d hi heco d ge outofs gr ga i i he c ng hi so y;a t tt as it wa de ol m ul t e e ton f ha ed s t r nd ha he s sant r n s d hewoul lmi t nlmbe ofl lm aera sM ak s coul pos e si hi s g e i c l ai d i t he ' r ega t il des i d s s n s e r gaton el. M akde s a kst c t o is a o de t thebepr ec e fom ha a s e a t ea sa s i s he our t s ue n r r ha ot t d r r s m nt nd hr t nd t tofi i l pr ec hi lga doc nt a hi a lt t a e st cours ha fc a s ot t s e l ume s nd s biiy o cc s he t. Asap ei n r ij n to tmp rrl af r a e ta r iayrme yp i r otilt e r l ay nu cin e o aiy fods n x ro dn r e d ro t ra,h mi pa t se n tep ei n r ijmcinmu td mo taet t ( )G ei l eyt s c e do ry e kig h r l a y nt to s e nsrt ha: 1 û s i l o u c e n mi h k t emeis'( )l ei lk l t s fe i paa l h nni tea s n eo p ei n r rle, ( ) h rt, 2 ç s iey o u fr ae rbe a n h b e c f r lmi ay eif' 3 ' h ' ûh baa eo e ute tpsi h sfv r'a d( )û nij ci ni i t p bi itr s. Se û e lnc f q i s i n i a o , n 4 ç nun to s n he u lc n ee t' e t i ' a ' W i e v. t alRe ouresDee eCouncl l ,555U. 7,1 S. .365,374( ntr Naur s c fns i.nc. S. 29 Ct 2008) A . s howi ofa t tong pos i lt ' hn i i ufi e ,be a et sanda d r quie a s ng t' sr sbiiy'of nn s ns fcint c us he t r e r s howi ng t tha m i tlkel ' I Ea h oft s f f c or m us bes tsi d bef r i e l or ha r s li y.' d. c he e our a t s t a ife o e nt rocut y ill tver le i wa r nt d- Re Tr t AboutOba a. l c v. EC, 7 F.d 3 2 3 7( t n'nc i ei f s ra e z al uh l m n . F 5 5 3 4 , 4 4h Ci. r 2009) va ae bve e nd bv.c r.grnt 1 S.Ct 2371( 0) rafimedi pa t , c td r ma ed e t a ed, 30 . 201 , e fr n r. r ma d db , 0 F.d3 5(t Ci. 01 ) e n e y 6 7 3 5 4h r2 0 . M a s if l t de kde s ais o monsr t t twiho i e l ut y r le , i lkel t s f r ta e ha t ut nt roc or e if he s i y o ufe ir pa a eha m .He sa esno f c ss re r bl r tt a t uggesi t thehasbee de i d ofa es t hi l ga tng ha n prve cc s o s e l m a e i sort a e s oft cou t . l e t r co d i ca est the r ce l pa tc pa e i a t ral o cc s he r s nde d, he e r ndi t ha e nty ri i t d n t o- y be h t i w ih co ta nt d c m s la s s i hi . M or ove ,M a s if ist w da nc ral t ur - ppoi e ot e s itng m e r kde s a l o demonsr t t t a lge pa ta t ofr t la i t ke a ns hi by Ke n M ount i ofi al ta e hat he le d s c s ea iton a n gai t m e an fci s have pl e hi ,ora e lke y t pl ce hi , tr s ofir pa a e ha m wihoutc t nt r nto ac d m r i l o a m a i k r e r bl r t our i e ve i n. 2 Tempor y r tai ng or sar is onl r el , when t movantpr der e s ued y ar y ar esr ni he ovest hewils f hat l ufer ijr irle i no ga tdb fr t a ves pat c l ben tfe a ha eo ru t t r po nuy f eifs t rne eoe he d re ry oud oiid nd v ppotniy o es nd. See Fed.R.Ci P.65. Such an or woul onl l tuntls h tme asa hearng on a pr i i r v. der d y as i uc i i elm na y ij ci nc l bear n d.Asi i ce rfo t o te t tM a sii n e tte t ap ei n r nun to oud ra ge t s la r m he u s tha kde s s ot n ild o r lmia y ij c in,h c ur fnd noba i u nwhiht grnthm atmp a yr sr i ngo de . nun to te o t i s ss po c o a i e orr e tani r r 2 A ss a e he com pl ns prm arl t tK e n M ount i ofi i sha m a ve ba c m e s t t d, ai i iy ha e a n t c al ve de r l om nt a bouthi l ws t Hedoesnotaleget ta s a ui. l ha nyone a Ke n M ount i hasca e ort e t ne t e an us d hr a e d hi wih a physc hn m. On t s a lga i ,M a s f ist de onsr t a lke i m t ny ial r he e le tons kdes i a l o m ta e ny i lhood t thewils f ir par bl hn m i t a e e oft r quese r lef An a o it or r ha l ufer re a e r n he bs nc he e t d e i . ppr pra e de wilis ett d y d n i ghsmo in fri tro u oyijlcier l f l su ls a , e y n i to s o ne lc tr nl tv ei . i n e The Cl r i diece t s nd c e oft sme or ndlm o ni n a a ompa ng e k s r td o e opi s hi m a l pi o nd cc nyi o de t pl i if r r o a ntf . ENTER:Ths tl d yo J n , 01 i a f u e 2 3. ChifUnie St t sDititJ e t d a e src udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.