Prater v. Clarke, No. 7:2013cv00072 - Document 16 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 4/29/2013. (tvt)

Download PDF
% raFRK' OFFI t. Dl r lr S CE Js. sm n l ATROANOKE, VA FI ED L APR 29 2 1 23 I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRICT COURT FO R TH E W E ST ER N D I STR ICT O F V I G I I R N A R O A N O K E D IV ISIO N J A . ULI BY; Ci lActon No.#: v00072 vi i 13c K I A .PR A TE R , M : 2254 M EM OM NDUM OPI O N NI Pet t oner, ii V. H ARO LD W .CLARK E, By:Sam uelG .W is l on U nie St e Di t c Judge t d at s s ri t R es pondent. Thi i apeii purua t 28U. C.j225 byKi A. ae,c le ngt Vigi a s s tton s nt o S. 4 m Prtr halngi he r ni De rmentofCoreci 'comput i n oft s r i eofhi sa es nt nc Ther s nde ha pa t r tons ato he e v c s tt e e e. e po nt s move t dimisf non-xha ton.Thec t tst t28U. C.j2241, j2254,i t d o s s or e usi our noe ha S. not s he a opra evehil f Pr t ' c le ppr it c e or aers hal nge.But i any e nt Pr t rhasnote use hi sa e ,n ve , a e xha t d s t t - c trme e ,a t c tdimis shi peii wiho prj c our e dis nd he our s se s tton t ut eudie. 1. Pr tri a i t c i dwihi t Vigni De rmt ofCoreci (ç ae s n nmae onfne t n he r i a pa t nt r tons < VDOC') ' a i c r nty c i d a t Parc He y Co r to Uni # I M ay of201 whiei nd s ur e l onfne t he tik nr reci nal t 28. n 2, l n f de a c t e r l usody,Pr t rfl apeii n f rwrtofha sc pusi t Cic tCour ofTa e l a e itd tto o i bea or n he r ui t z wel Cot y,Vigi a, aii varouscai s i udi t cai t tt Vig ni De t ntof mt r ni r sng i l m , ncl ng he l m ha he r i a parme Core tonsi pr pe l cacult d tmet bec e t d t hi sat s nt nc The Cic tCo t r c i m o ry l a e i o r die o s t e e e e. r ui ur f t tecam t b u tmeya das wih u mei.( i lOr e 3 4, No. - ) The omd h li o e n i l n lo t o t rt Fna d r - ECF 15. Cicui Co ta s not d t t t t e e Pr t rco e d he s ul r ceve<1 mont a 8 r t ur lo e ha , o he xt nt a e nt nde ho d e i 1 4 hs nd d y o ce iba e u o hsp iri ac rto i Vigni j is . . n a dto h st a s f r dt s d p n i ro nc r eain n r i a al, . a u i f i i me c mp tto rc r ( ul)n t cz u tl u htmea h ( s rt me t Vign ac so y' o uain e od wo d o oc l ni s c i s e wa j eu d o r ii u t d . r ' LERK (4. t4 5) Th Cic i Co r te rj ce h so h rcamsa dt e ida ddimis d' i L a - . e ru t u th n ee td i t e li n ç n e n s se 'h s d peii (d.a 6. tton. I t ) Pr t ra aed t t Su e Cour ofVigi a butf ie t fl atm ey pe ii f a e ppe l o he pr me t r ni , al d o ie i l tton or a pe l a dt S p e Co r o Vign arj ce h srq e tf ra e tnso of i . p a, n he u r me u t f r ii ee td i e u s o n x e in tme ( pons 4,6,ECFNo.1 -1) Res e 5 . II . The r ponde c a m sPr t rha f ie t de onsr e t the ha e es nt l i a e s a l d o m tat ha s xhaus e hi s a e td s tt- c trme e .Thecour ag e sa dimis hi peii wiho prj c our e dis t r e nd s ses s tton t ut eudie. Th c u t o e t a j2 41 n tj2 5 i t ea p o raev hcet atc t ee e ui n e o r n ts h t 2 , o 2 4,s h p r p it e il o ta k h x c to o P ae ' s n e c .S eUntdS ae v. tl, 9 F.d6 , 7 -8 ( t Ci. 0 4 .l a y f rtrs e tn e : ie tts Lit 3 2 3 71 6 9 0 4h r 2 0 ) n n e e nt Pr t rm us e us hi s a e c t e e esby r i i hi c r ntc a m i t V i g ni ve , a e t xha t s t t - our r m di a s ng s ur e l i n he r i a Supr me Cour i a c da ewih t St t sesa ihe p oc dtr . SeeW ai i v. ke , e t n c or nc t he ae' t bls d r e les nwrght Sy s 433U. 72( 977) I rs et t r ponde ' moint dimis Pr trha fl wiht s S. 1 . n e pons o he es nts to o s s, ae s ied t hi co tt Supr ur he eme Cour ofVigi a' de a ofhi r ques f ra e e i oftmet fl hi t r ni s nil s e t o n xt nson i o ie s pe ii f a tton or ppea oft Cic tCour' dimi s lofhi saeha aspe ii Buta t i ey l he r ui ts s s a s tt be tton. n mtm l p tto f ra p a, n ta d e n t o lw etb ih dp o e l ea di rjce b t sae eiin o p e lo e h t o s o f lo sa ls e r c dz n s ee td y he tt r c to t tgr md,doesnots tc a e usi s l ast de a i bas upo a our n ha ot ufi e s xha ton o ong he ni l s ed n n ade t a i pe quae nd nde ndentsaegr tt ound,a e as ngofc us a prj c Se O' 1v. bsnt howi a e nd eudie. e De1 Nehelnd,95F.d 1 4,1 -43(t Ci.1 . t ra 3 21 240 4h r 996) Ne t l s , heCic tCo t whih r l d a atm ePr t rwa i f der lcusody,di verhe e s t r ui ur, c u e t i ae s n e a t d notpum or t r e on t quesi ofwhe he Pr t rw o d be en il t a c edi off ur e n t o ul he ton t r a e ul tted o r t o t e m on hs a e ghtda f l i a a tupon hi r tun t ac uals a e c t y. Co e nty, t nd i ys olow ng n udi s e t ' o t t t us od ns que l Pr t rsilm a ha a unde a t sae- our r dy.Buthec nno pr valo t tcam i a e tl y ve n f uled t t c t eme a t e i n ha li n 2 f r ha suntlhehase use i bypr pe l pr s n i i t t Supr m eCour of ede al bea i xha t d t o ry e e tng t o he e t V igi i .1 r na 11 1. Fort r as sa e t c rt s is sPr t rspe ii f wrtofha sc us he e ons tt d, he ou dim s e a e ' tton or i bea om wih u p eu ie t o t rj dc . ENTE R :A prl29,2013. i A UN I TED STATES D I STRI J G E CT UD S-heexha tonr quie e c pr oe c iy be we n t sae a f r ls tm sonl i t f usi e r m nt an om t om t t e he tt nd ede a yse yf saeco t a ual haveam e ngf opporu t t ove s et rown ope ai . l i t r o e tt urs ct ly ani ul tniy o r e hei r tons t s he efr rq ie ta a p tin r se ig fdea h b a rve ma mo e t% a pefn tl jt e urd h t eio e e kn e rl a e s e iw ke r h t ru coy amt t ough t saecour s t ,a habe r vi i t f de a co t wilbea lbl onl ale hr he tt t ysem nd as e ew n he e r l urs l vaia e y tr t sae cou t ha be n ( ovi d a f l a f r o t t t rvi e rir sae cou t he tt rs ve e pr de ul nd ai pporuniy o e ew a le tt r p o e dn s.' Wh r q eto sc n enn e h usinaie tep tto rb astebzd no r c e ig l l ee u sin o c rig x a to rs ,h eiine e r h l e f r de monsrtng t tsaer medi have i f c , n e used.' tai ha tt e es , n a t bee xha t ' Malr v S t 2 F. 9 , 9 (t Ci. 9 4 (i in o te ) l y . mi 7 3d 91 9 4 4h r 1 9 ) càto s mitd . o h,

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.