Rodriguez v. Federal Bureau of Prisons, No. 7:2013cv00047 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 03/05/2013. (kab)

Download PDF
OAFRK: OFFI U,,DI rnlRT CE S ST.. l AT RCz'C kF 'A 3 % t(5 , *ë ' i-'' ' :' ': ' I TH E U NI N TED STA TES DI STR I CO UR T CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI GI A CT R NI R O A NO K E DI I O N V SI JUA N R O D R I UEZ , G MA2 A JUtl B A K D 21 23 )u'CEK ., LR i, è . . DE UTY CLERK CA SE N O .7: 3CV 00047 1 Pl nt f , ai i f M E M O M ND U M O PI I N N O V. FEDE R AI,BU REA U O F PR ISO N S, ET M z . , By: G l n E.C onr e ad ChifUnie St e Dit c Judge e t d at s srit Def endant s. J n Rod i z,a f de ali a e pr ee ng pr K ,brngst sci la ton,s e ng ua r gue e r nm t oc di o i hi vi c i e ki . r mbm s m e f rt val ofpe s lpr pe t ie sl tbyprs n ofi i l .Upon r vi w of ei e nt o he ue r ona o ry tm os io fc a s e e t r cor , t c ttndst tt a ton mus be s ma iy dimis d asl ga l fi o . he e d he our i ha he c i t um rl s s e e ly 'vol us1 r I Rodrgue alege t ti Aprl201 whe Fe r Btr uofPrs (ç ' ofiil i z l s ha n i 2, n deal lea ions GBOP' fcas ) ta serdhm fo t Fe ea Co rcin l n ttto CTC1'Gime ,nW e tVigna t rn fre i ' m he d r l re to a I siuin r ' l r i s r ii,o ) ano he BOP prs f c lt FCIGim e ofk i sl thi pe s lpr pe t ie s Rod i z t r ion a iiy, l r t al os s r ona o ry t m . rgue fld a admi s tvet tc am a i tt BOP, s ki t r c r$680. f t l tie . ie n nika i or l i gans he ee ng o e ove 00 or he os t ms2 On Nove mber1 201 t Be kl Le Ce e is d al te ,i c tng t ta tr 9, 2, he c ey gal nt r s ue e tr ndi a i ha fe i s i t o B OP ofk i l f m d i a opra e t oferRodrguez a s tl e unde 31 U . C. nve tga i n, t a s ot t ppr i t o f i e tem nt r S. j37 i t nmot of$70. b%edont de e itdvaueoft l tpr pe t W he 23 n he mt 50, he pr cae l he os o ry. n Ro rg e a k dfrr c nsd rto o t eo fr t ea e c so db isNo e e 1 , 1 d iu z s e o e o ie ain f h fe ,h g n y to y t v mb r 9 21 2 dec son. ii 1 The cour i r r t dim isany acton orcl m fl by aprs t s equied o s s i ai ied ioneragai ta govern ent ns m al entt orof i i t cour de e m i t acton orcl m i f i ous m alci ,orf l t sat acl m iy fcer f he t t r nes he i ai s rvol , i ous ais o t e ai onwhih rle ma beg a e 28U. C. 1 5 b ( ) c e if y rntd. S. j 91 A( ) 1. 2RO rgtza srsta tels i msweewo t moeta $ ,0 , u b c u eh o l h s d il set h th ott e e r rh r h n 15 0 b t e a s e ny a r c it f s le , o y a ke f $ 0. i hi t t am. e ep s or ome tms he nl s d or 68 00 n s or cli Rodrg zbrngst cvi a tonagans t BOP a t t kllyLega Ce e,' iue i Ms i l ci i the nd he i le Bec l ntr' s e ngr i bure e f hi l tpr ry ie s pt tveda a s a cou tc t .Rodrgue e ki em s m nt or s os ope t tm , mii m ge , nd r oss i z i now i a c r td i aBOP prs n f c lt i Ge gi s nc r e ae n io a iiy n or a. 1 1 I i no c e rfom Rod i e sc pli wha s t cam hei e t fl Hi t s t la r rgu z' om a nt t or of li ntnds o ie. s al ga i , le tons howe r m a i e de t tt sc ti no t pr pe ve f rRodrgue s ve , ke t vi nt ha hi our s t he o r nue o i z' lws t r r es ofhi t or oft c e. Theaci ofwhih Rodrgue c a ui, ega dl s s he y he as tons c i z ompl i oc ur e ans c r d i W es Vigi a,a t Bec ey Le Ce e i l t i t tsa e wlie Rodrgu z hi s l n t r ni nd he kl gal nt r s ocaed n ha t t , ll i e m ef i c r nty i Ge gi . Forpr t c am ss h asRodrgue brngsher ,ve woul 1e i a s ure l n or a opery l i uc i z i e nue di n dititc t n W es Vigni whe et pr ry l soc u r d a t de e nte ii sr sde src our i t r i a, r he ope t os c r e nd he f nda ntte e i , o i Ge r i, eeRo rg e no r sd s S e2 U. C. 1 91e .Th c u t o l ta fr r n o ga wh r d iu z w e i e . e 8 S. j 3 () e o r c u d rnse t c eunde 28U. C.j 1 t ac t r ve woul bea oprae. Howe r t he as r S. 631 o our whe e nue d ppr it ve ,he c u t n no fn ta s c ata se wo l b tnt itr s o j sie'a rq ie f rta fr o r c n t id h t u h rn fr ud e t he ne et f u tc y s e ur d o rnse i ' u d rj 1 31 be a eRo rgu z salg t nsd n tsaea ygo ndfr u iil eif n e 6 , c us d i e ' le ai o o tt n r u o j dca rle . o Rodr g s i t hi c pl i on a f m de i ned t as i ti a e w ho w i h t i uez ubm ted s om a nt or sg o s s nm t s s o p ru acv l ih sp ru n t 4 U. C. 1 3f rc nsiu in l oain c mmitdb sae u s e ii rg t u s a t o 2 S. j 98 o o t to a vilto s o te y tt t p io o t as S eW e t At n , 7U.. 2( 9 8 (i dngt tj1 3cam rq rs rs n fkil. e s v. kis 48 S 4 1 8 ) fn i ha 98 li e uie s howi t tc ng ha onduc c t omm itd by aperon a tngund c o ofsae 1w de i d pl i ifof te s ci er ol r t t a prve antf rg sgu a ee byt Consiutonorlwsoft Unie Stts.Rodrgue nn sfde a iht arnt d he tt i a he td ae ) i z me e r l e iisa dee t,howeve.Fedealofiil cn tbes dunde 1 1 be us t do ntte s fndans r r fcas nno ue r 983, ca e hey n t c u d rc lro saelw.Ha w v. tg r l, 5 U. 8 0 8 4- ( 9 2 .Th r fr , o a t n e oo f tt a do Fiz e ad 4 7 S. 0 , 1 20 1 8 ) ee o e Rodrgu ha noc us ofa tont rj1 i ez s a e ci mde 983. 2 I Bie v. i Un n wnNa dAg n s 4 3U. 3 8( 9 )t eUntd Sae n v ns Sx k o me e t, 0 S. 8 1 71,h ie tts Su e Cou tceaedarme smia t j 1 t al i vi l t s f dn gesf pr me r r t e dy, i lr o 983,o low ndi duas o ue or ma or de i tonsofc tt i lrght c ed by t aci nsofof il ac i unde col of prva i onsiutona i s aus he to sca s tng r or fd rllw.Hal . it n 2 5F.d20 2 4 (t Ci. 0 0 .F d rla e is s c a t e ea a l v Cl o , 3 3 2, 0 4h r 2 0 ) e ea g nce , u h s he n BOP a dteBe k e Le a Ce tr a eno s be t os i u d rBie .F. IC. . e e, 0 n h c ly g l n e, r t u j c t ut n e v ns D.. v M v r 51 U.. 71 4 6( 9 4 .Alo ap io o t a' n gie tls ofa imae sp o e t d e n t S 4 , 8 1 9 ) s , rs n f ls e lg n o s n n t ' r p ry o s o ki gv rs t a yc nsi in lcam.Da il v. ila , 7 U. 3 7 3 2( 98 ) Be a s ie ie o n o tmto a li nes W l ms 4 4 S. 2 , 3 1 6 . c u e i Rod i zdoesnoti ntf a f r lofk i lasa de e ntorde rgue de iy ny ede a t a f nda mons t t ta kae ha nyone pur el l tordesr d hi pr pe t , heha saed no a tona eBi nscli . pos y os toye s o ry s tt c i bl ve am 3 Fi l Rod i z ha no c us ofa ton i a c t s d on hi dis tsac i wih naly, rgue s a e c i n ny our ba e s s aif ton t t s tlme ofe e t Mm t rj37 Thi s to auhorz sfdealta ncyhe dst he ete nt fr d o mde 23. s ecin t ie e r Ige a o s tl ,f rno mor t n $1 e te o t e ha 000, a msi vi t neglge eofgove nme a empl yee s' cli nvol ng he i nc r nt l o s' i l ng ios ofaprs r spr rybyt neglge ofaBOP ofi r' Andr wsv. t d ncudi : s l ione ' ope t he i nce fce .' e Unie St es 441F. 220,225n.5( hCi. 4)(br t o ohe loundsbyA1v.Fedea at , 3d 4t r 200 a ocaed n t r i rl Bu e uo P io , 5 U. 21 2 0 21( 0 8) c us t erme yu d rj3 2 l o sn t r a f rs ns 5 2 S. 4, 2 - 2 0 ).Be a e h e d n e 7 3 ç e o d 3 RO rg e me to s woBOPatr egi hsc mgan wh p riiae i ters lto o diu z nin t t n J n i o lit o at p td n h e ouin f o s c hi tr cam u e j37 Heh nocam a ams t s i vi asu rBi n , c us h f l t s o t li nd r 23. as li g t he e ndl du l nde ve s be a e e ais o s a ef t demonsr tng t teiheroft ha any per onali vem e i t ale de i i of t t ac s ta i ha t hem d s nvol nt n he lged prvaton hi pr rt s ope y. 3 alw aj d ca s i'j= h we e , d i u zc n o a kac u toatro rv ret e lo u iil ut'# . o v r Ro rg e n n t s o r t l r e e s h , e s tlm e ar dy ofe e t hi . e te nt lea frd o m 4 Fort r as saed,t cou tc ude t tRodrgue sco pl ntsaesnof malor he e ons t t he r oncl s ha i z' m ai t t ac lg l a i f r u iil eifi a yc u t T r fr ,h itr sso j sied n t e ur e a b ss o j d ca rle n n o r. heeo e t e n ee t f u tc o o r q ie ta se rn tec s t e j 1 31fri r p rve u .l se d tec u t l rl ds se r n f rig h a e md r 6 o mp o e n e n t a ,h o r sl iy imis s mma tea to 5p ru n t j 1 5 b ( ) a lg lyfioo .Th Clr i d rce t sndc pis h cin, u s a t o 91 A( )1, s e al rv lus e ek s ie td o e o e oft sme or ndlm opi on a a ompa ng or rt pli if hi m a l ni nd cc nyi de o antf . v,) tp ENTER:Thi D s da ofM a c 201 y r h, 3. Chi fUnied St t Diti tJ e t aes src udge 4 W hiet eFe e a Tor Cl msAc (TTCA' a t rz r c vey a ans teUnie Stt sf r l h d r 1 t ai tC ' uho ies e o r g i t h t d ae o ) smed piain c ue b ten gie t cin o fd rl mpo e s Ro rg e i l cu e fo o e rv to s a sd y h e lg n a t s f e ea e ly e, d iu z sye ld d rm o pur ui an FTCA r m edy f hi pr t l scl m . See Al v.Feder Bur ofPrs 552 U . s ng e or s opery os ai i al eau lons, S. 21 ,2 ( 008 ( oli t tt FTCA e e i c diida 28U. C.j2 0() r g r ngdee tonof 4 41 2 ) h dng ha he xc pton o fe t S. 68 c , e a di t n i pr t by Eany of i ofcusom sorexci orany ot rl enf c entom cer' ext opery t fcer t se he aw or em ,' endst l s of o os es p o ry b BOP o f as; a c v. ie Sx e ,1 6Fe C1 11 ,1 8n. ( d. . 01 CAl ( 5 r pe t y fkil) Se ry Untd tt s 0 d. . 6 1 1 Fe Cl 2 2) i 5 2 U. a 2 n. e plie t tte Gd nitai r me y' o d dby31U. C. 3 3 i t eo y S. t 28 71 x an d ha h a mi sr tve e d pr vie S. j 72 s h nl r ifa t rz db Co e sfrp io r wh ep op ryi wr ng ul deane ') ele uho ie y ngrs o rs nes os r e t s o f ly ti d. . ' 5 se Sea cy, l 6Fe Cla 1 7 1 (umma i dimisngc s up fndngta ta fru e e r 0 d. . t 1 - 8 s rl s si a e on i i h t r nse nd r y j 1 31wa un ra td, ca ep io rst r cam f deane p op rywa wiho tme i) 6 s war ne be us rs ne ' o t li or t i d r e t s t u rt. 4

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.