Showalter v. Director et al, No. 7:2013cv00039 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 1/31/2013. (tvt)

Download PDF
t G p- IN T H E U NITED STA TES DISTR IC T CO UR T FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI T O F V I G I I C R N A RO ANOKE DI SI VI ON M A R K TO DD SH O W A LT ER , Pl nt f , ai i f OFFI t. . SI COUW CE JS DI AT R- OKE. VA FI LED J 3 12 1 Ad 03 JULA I L ERK BK ... D g Ci lA ct on N o.7: vi i 13cv00:39 M EM O M N D U M O PI O N NI DI RECTOR,VI RGI A NI D EPA RTM ENT O F CO RR ECTI N S e al, O / . D ef endant s. By: Sam ue G.W is l lon U nied St esD i t ctJudge t at s ri Pl n ifM a k Todd Showaler aVigi ai aepr e di aitf r t , r ni nm t oc e ngpr s brngst sa ton o e, i hi c i plrua t 42U. C.j1 3agans eghte dee nt,e c ofwho i a s itdwiht zs nt o S. 98 i t i e n fnda s a h m s s ocae t he V i g ni D e r m e ofCor e t o . Show a t r ss xt ni pa c pl i a l ges a o r i a pa t nt r c i ns le ' i y- ne ge om a nt le , m ng o h rij re , c n pr c t pos nhi f o t a S o l rh src nl d so ee wa meey t e n uis a o s ia y o io s o d h t h wat a e e ty ic v r d s r l e a s he t c nc hi t thi f waspoione t e kilng hi by sa vai c me o onvi e m ha s ood s d, her by li m tr ton. A c pl i m us alege te om a nt t l t nough f c st s a e a c ai t r le t ti pl us bl o is a t o t t l m o e i f ha s a i e n t fc ' Giraa v.J hns 521F.d298 302( hCi.2008 (uoi BelAt.Com. a e. artno o on, ' 3 , 4t r ) q tng l l v. Two v,550U. 544,570( $.Thefmiirnzesofpla ngaegeal rlxe fïpr mbl S. 2007 a la l e di r r ty ea d o o s pl i if , e antfs howe r a ltga swih m e iorouscam ss d notbe symi byt c ca ve , nd ii nt t rt i li houl t ed e hni l r quie nt.SeeBe udetv. t ofHn on, F. 1 1 -78( h Ci.1 .Stl, e rme s a t Ciy mnt 775 2d 274, 277 4t r 985) il t r l xai oft pl adi r l i notwihoutlmis A c r mus , tam i m um,bea e t he e a ton he e ng ues s t i t . ou t t a ni bl o d s e n fom t c i c r r he ompl i t pa tesbeng s d andt a l ed c ant he ri i ue he leg onduc on whih ea h c am t c c li r ss Though r a et. elxed, he sa r sild ndsge r c r nc a i doe notr quie t t nda d tl ema ne al ohe e e, nd t s e r c u t toc n meu q e to sn v rs u r l p e e tdt t m. 1 . t1 8 Hee o rs t o j p u sin e e q a ey rs n e o he ' d a 27 . r , t ' S o le' ln h a dd sone c mplitma e i dfkult d tnniet ep e ie h watrs e gty n ij itd o an k s t it t o ee n h r cs consiutona orsaut y cai she i e t r s ,t s ii de e nt a ns who he tt i l t t or l m ntnds o aie he pecfc f nda s gai t m i e t r s t m ,a t alege c ntnds o aie he nd he l d onduc on whi h e h c am r ss t c ac l i e t . W eet tno e h,t sc tha dimis purua t 28U. C.j1 5A( ( ) a r ha t noug hi our s s sed, s nt o S. 91 b)1, t l s t e ofShowatrsprviusa tons'Secin 1 ( ofTil 28pr de t taprs r eat hre le ' e o ci . to 915g) te ovi s ha ione ma notbrng ac vi a ton wihou pr pa m e oft r quie $350. flngf e y i i l ci t t e y nt he e r d 00 ii e i t prs rha ,on 3ormor proroc sons whie i a ce a e o deai d i f he ione s e i ca i , l nc r r t d r t ne n a f ciiy,br ny a lt ought a a ton or a pe l i a co tof t U nied St t t t w a n ci p a n ur he t a es ha s dim i s on t g o s s ed he r unds t t i i fi ous m alci ,or f is t s a e a c a m ha t s r vol , i ous al o tt li upon whih r le may be gr e unl s t prs ne i unde i i ntda r c ei f antd, e s he io r s r mm ne nge o s ro p y ia ij r f eius h sc ln u y. Show a t ha neihe pa d t flng f e, s ler s t r i he ii e nor hown t the i t ha s t ri m i ntdange ofs r o unde m ne r e i us p ysc ln t y' j1 5 g .Ac o dngy t ec u t imis shsc mplitwi o t rj dc . h ia ijl . 91 ( ) c r i l ,h o r ds s e i o an t u p eu ie r ' h l Showatrwihest brng a ac i i t sc t hemus fl as ta pli satm e toft f le s o i n ton n hi our, t ie hor nd an t e n he cai s owi t t( hei e ildt rle a ( t thei unde i ne da rofs rous l m h ng ha 1) s ntte o eif nd 2) ha s r mmi nt nge ei p y ia ij r wiho l e u hfcu ls p o torn e h scam pa i l. h sc lnu y, t ny no g a t a u p r t e d r i li lusbe2 ENT ER :J nua y 31 201 a r , 3. Z . yF UN I TED STATES D I STRI J D GE CT U 1SeeShowalerv. J h s n No. 08v2 6( . Va Oc. 9 2 0 . ho le v. slma , . t o n o , 7: c 7 W D. . t2 , 01 ) S watr Mu se n No , 79 c 00 3( . Va Jme2 ,1 9 ) S watrv Co sin No. :6 v 01 7( . Va Fe r ay8 1 9 ) :9 v 29 W D. . t 8 9 9 ' ho le . mmiso , 79 c 0 2 W D. . b u r , 9 6. , Showale hasfld a l s ffe ci la tonsi t sc ta t cour ha t i wa nedhi a tr ie t ea t iten vi ci n hi our, nd he t s w ce r m bouthi pa tr of s te n a u i a dfiolu liain S eS o le v Jb , :l v 0 3 , t 2( . Va J l 1 , 01 )(ic sn b sve n rv o s ig to . e h watr . a e 71 c 0 3 3 a n. W D. . uy 3 2 1 dsusig t tel 4p g c mplitS owatrfldi ta c s) h 9 -a e o an h le i n h t ae. e 2Showalerha i ude wih hi compl ntamoton, pls a to2 U.. j45 ,o t t esg ds t s ncl d t s ai i t u n t 8 SC. 5 frhe md rine ' r rc a.A dititu g ç h l dsu lf hmsl i a ypo edigi whc hsi rilymih rao a l b eusl src jd e < al iq aiy i efn n rc e n n ih i mpat i g te s n by e s at q eto e ' 28U.. j4 5a .Aj d emu t lodsu l yhmslE eeh h sap ro a ba o p eu ie u sin d. ' SC. 5 () u g s as iq ai i eft r e a esn l is r rj dc f wh c n enn ap ry, rp ro a k o e g of ip tde ie tayfcsc n eni tepo e dn ' j4 5b() o cr ig at o es n l n wld e ds ue vd nir at o c r ng h rc e ig. 5 ()1. ' Hee S o lrsaljto so pat ly peudc,ndba altm fo ticutsI o dsoiin o hs r, h wat ' leain f ri i , rj iea is lse rm hs o r' yir ip st s f i e at o cams tlu iil ulg ao eamo t e e c nsi eav l b ssfraba o p rilymoin' Li k v li . t l dca r l s ln l s n v r o tmt ai ai o is r at l to . t v . l n d at ' e UntdSae , 0U. 5 , 4 (9 4 .Ac odigy,h c ut id nogo n frrc a a d ne t moin. i tts 51 S. 40 5 4 1 9 ) c r n l te o r fn s ru ds o eusl nd e ishe t e o 2

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.