Wolters v. U.S. Dept.of Justice et al, No. 7:2013cv00009 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 1/17/2013. (tvt)

Download PDF
CL ERKSOFFI 0. OI GOUX CE S. SX AT M NVILE, L VA Fl I T EU IE S A E DSRC C U T N H NT D T T S IT IT O R FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R O A NO K E DI I O N V SI J 1 f A a w uu B K E A ND R EW W O L TER S, Pl ntf ai if, ,cuERx , L C i lA c i N o.7: 3- vvi t on 1 c 00009 M EM O R AND U M O PI NIO N U . DEPT .O F JU STI S. CE,e aI, t . De e f ndant . s By: H on.Jaclson L .K i t ser Se orUnie St t sDit c Judge ni t d a e srit Andr w W ole s af de ali epr e i pr K ,fl d aci lrght co pl i e t r , e r nmat oc ed ng o ie vi i s m ant . plr ua t Bi nsv.Si UnknownN a d Age sofFede a Blr a ofNa c tc , U . 388 zs nt o ve x me nt r l ze u r o i s 403 S. ( 9 ) wi j rs ito v se i 2 U.. j1 31 Plitf na sa d fn a t t Uni d 1 71 , t u idcin e td n 8 SC. 3 . anif me s e e d n s he t h e St t s D e m e ofJ tc Erc Hol r t Ator y G e r loft U nie St t s a C . ae pm nt us i e; i de , he t ne ne a he t d a e ; nd Zyc W a den oft Unie Stt sPe t nta y i Le Count Vigi a Pli ifdi no pa h, r he t d a e nie i r n e y, r ni . antf d t y t $ 5 fln fea da k t p o e dL fr p u rs Se 28U. C. j 1 4 a,1 5. he 3 0 iig e n s s o r c e q o ma a pei. e S. j 91 () 91 lpr vi l wa ne pl i ift thehad a las t e no ha asci lc e ousy r d antf ha t e t hr e n- be vi ompli so ant r a a spr vi l dimi s asfi ous a ma i ous o f rf ii t sae ac am upo whih ppe l e ousy s s ed rvol , s lci , r o a lng o t t l i n c r i ma beg a e elef y r ntd.W olesv.Hol r No.7:2-vtr de, 1 c 00056,si op. t1( . Va J y3, lp a W D. . ul 2 2 ( ingW otr v F d rlBu e uof io s No 1 - 0 7 si o a 12( t Ci. a . 01 ) ct i l s . e ea ra Prs n , . 0 3 71 , lp p. t - 5h r J n e 1 , 01 )(p a ds se a fio o s; otr v F d r l ra o P io , 0 -v 08 7, 1 2 1 a pe l imis d s rv l u ) W le s . e ea Bu e u f rs ns No. 8 c - 3 si o a 1( . La J y5 2 0 (cindimis dwi p eu iea fi lu a df rfiig l p. t W D. . ul , 01 ) a to s s e t rj dc s rvoo s n o aln p h t saeacai upo whihrle ma begane ;W olesv.Hune , 1: c 0 o tt l m n c eif y r td) tr tr No. 07-v-2290,si lp o . t ( Co o Ma . , 0 9 ( imisn a to wi p eu ief rfii t saeacam p a 4 D. l . r 2 2 0 ) d s sig ci n t rj dc o al o tt li h ng uponwhihr i ma beg a edl.SeeHe l v.Kelr 681F. 538( h Ci.201 c elef y r nt ) nsee le, 3d 4t r 2) ( ohi tngadititc tdimislfom bengc i r asrkewhiet dimis ma be pr bii src our s sa r i onsdeed ti l he s sal y a ld) I a co da wiht t eesrkespr sonof28U. C.j 1 5g) pli ifwa ppeae . n c r nce t he hr -ti ovii S. 91 ( , antf s a s d t thene d t s dvie ha ede o ubmi t $350. flng f eore t bls a i mi ntt ea ofs rous t he 00 ii e sa ih n m ne hr t e i physc hn m t pr e wih ac vi s tonc he a umult t e lsrkes'pur ua t 28 ial r o oce d t i l ui e cc aes hr e tti , s nt o ' U. C. 1 5 g .W otr v. d r l le u o Prs nsNo 1 - 0 7 si o a 2. S. j 91 ( ) les Fe ea Bt a f in , . 0 3 71 , l p. t r p Afe r viwi pli if sa l tonsa tr e e ng antf legai boutpa te nt,i i cea t tpl i ifdoe no s ve s t s l r ha antf s t e tbiht t ei c re tyu d ra i n n d n e ofa ys ro sp y ia ij r .P an if sa ls ha h s u rn l n e ny mmie t a g r n eiu h sc ln u y litf fl d t s a ton whie i a ce a e i Pe yl ni a c ie hi c i l nc r r t d n nns va a nd annots how a i m i ntda n m ne ngeri n Pe yl ni a utpa teve st toc r d i Vigi a. See e. , hly v. l t 1 F.d nns va a bo s nt ha cure n r ni m a.As e Diworh, 47 3 71 71 ( t Ci.1 Cç lgai t tt prs ne ha fce i ne da ri t pa ta e 5, 7 8h r 998) Ale tons ha he io r s a d mmi nt nge n he s r i u fce tt tig rt e e e to t j1 5g . .' .P an iffist r lt a yalg dy ns fiin o rg e hg) xc pi n o 91 ( ) . .) litf al o eae n l e l ' e poorm e c ca ei Pe ms va at W a de Zych,ErcHol r ort De rme ofJ tc dial r n r yl ni o r n i de , he pa t nt usi e. Se FDI v.M e r 51 U. 471 484- ( 994)(e u i t fndaBi nsrmedya ns a e C ye, 0 S. , 86 1 rf sng o i ve e gai t fd rl g n y ; o l v De to So . r s, 6U. 65 , 6 n. ( 9 8 (e u igt p r t e e a a e c ) M nel . p' f c Se v .43 S. 8 6 3 7 1 7 ) r f sn o e mi r s o d a s peira ab ssf rs pe vs r la ii ) Ac o dn l Ids s t ea to e o n e t u ro s a i o u r io y ib ly . c r igy, imis h cin t wi u p eudc frplitf' fiu et pa tetln fea t t o fl gt c mplit t t rj ie o an ifs alr o y h iig e the i f ii he o an . ho me n Se e. ,Dupr ev. l r 28 F. 1 1 ( t Ci. e. g. e Pame , 4 3d 234, 237 11h r 2002)(eaoni t tt flngfei r s ng ha he ii e s dueupo flngacviaci whe L f mapa rspr sonsdonota yt pli ifa t t n ii i l ton n q or upe i ovii ppl o antf nd ha t c ti no r quie t pe mi pl ntf a opport t t pa t flng f ei pli tf i he our s t e r d o r t ai if n tmiy o y he ii e f a n if s i lgi et pr ee t f mapa i) nei bl o oc d q or upers. TheCl r i diece t s nd c e oft sM e a l Opi o a t a compa ng e k s r t d o e opi s hi mor ndtm ni n nd he c nyi Or rt pli if de o antf . ENTER:T i 1 - dyo Jnay2 1. hs a faur,03 S ni U nied St es Di t i J or t at s rct udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.