Dingess v. Virginia Department of Corrections, No. 7:2012cv00630 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 12/31/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
CL SAT CE U.S.Dt COURT EAK' OFFI 3T. RQANOKQ VA FI LED I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI I CT RG NIA ROANOK E DI I ON V SI DEC 3 1 2 1 22 s. . ) u .E . u A LL EN R A Y D IN G E SS, Ci lAc i N o.7: 2c vi ton 1 v00630 Pl nt f ai i f, M EM O R AN DU M O PI NION V. V I G I IA D EPA R TM E N T of R N C O R R E C T IO N S, By:Sam uelG .W ison l Uni ed St es D i ri Judge t at st ct D efendant . Thsi a i o mapa pe i, os , ci nf rd ma e p rua t o42U. C. 1 8 by i s n nf r u rs pr e a to o n g s u s n t S. 5 9 3 pli it Ale Ra Di s,agans t Vigi aDe rme ofCore tonscl mi t t antfl ln y nge s i t he r ni pa t nt r ci ai ng hathe Depa t nthe dhi a t Norol Ciy J i i e ry20 t ry- i da pas hi r las da e. rme l m t he f k t a l n a l 05 hit sx ys t s ee e t Be a s teVignaDe rme to Co r cinsi n ta' es n' u j c t s i u e j 9 3 c u e h r ii pa t n f re t s o ' ro 's b e t o ut nd r 1 8 o p a be a eDi s ' nd c us nge s compl i a a son isf cet bewelbe ant ppe r t a o l yond t a ia et ye r he pplc bl wo- a saut lmiatons t c t uas edimisspu s ntt 28U. C.j1 A. tt e i t i ,he our s pont s se rua o S. 915 1. D i s ' om pl i r i esa sng e c a m f dn age a i tt V i gi a D e r m e of nge s c a nt a s i l l i or m s ga ns he r ni pa t nt Co r ctons. c di t hi co pli t Di s ,who i c r nty i a ce a e wih t re i Ac or ng o s m a n , nge s s ur e l nc r r t d t he V igi a D e rm e ofCo r c i ,washe d 36 da pa thi r l as da e i e r y 2005 o a r ni pa t nt r e tons l ys s s e e e t n a l n prvi s ntnc ofi ionme att Norol CiyJ i,i Norol Vigi a(nt Ease e ous e e e mprs nt he f k t al n f k, r ni i he tm Ditito Vigna . n e ssae t t ed dn tfl agiv n ee rirbe a ehej s lane src f r ii) Dig s tts ha h i o ie re a c ale c us u t e r d t theha be n hed a t ji pathi r e edaedurnghi prviusi aceai Henoe ha d e l t he al s s elas t i s e o nc r rton. ts t the be i d a t tm e t he w a pa thi r l as da e butdi notpur ue i be us he di ha leve t he i hat s s s ee e t d s t ca e d notw a t be ' c e ofm a ng a f l e aleg i n. nt o ' us d ac ki a s l ato ' ' / I l. 28 U . C.1 5 di e t dit i tc t t s r n prs rc pl i s a i t S. 91 A r c s s rc ours o c ee i one om a nt ga ns g n e ale ii so ofk er ore oye oft ee ii sa dim isa cli st ta e over m nt ntte r t s mpl es hos ntte nd s s ny am ha r f i ous m a i i ,f i t sa e a c ai upon whi h r le m a be g a ed,ors e m o t r rvol , lc ous a l o t t l m c ei f y r nt e k ne a y r leffom a de e ei r f ndan who i i munefom s h r le He e Di ss ksda t sm r uc e if r , nges ee mage fom a sr gove nm e a e iy t ti i r ntl ntt ha s mmunefom t i r he mposton ofda a son ac am ba r d by t ii m ge l i re he sauelmiain . c r ig y t ec u t s se tes i wih u p eu ie ttt i tto s Ac o dn l ,h o r dimis s h ut t o t rj dc . Fi s , he V i g ni D e rm e tofCor e tonsha 11 h A m e rtt r i a pa t n r ci s t ndm e i m uniy a i no nt m t nd s t a e tt s be tt s i i a a to frd ma e u d rj 9 3. t o g s mee t is s c a n n i u j c o ut n n ci n o a g s n e 1 8 Alh u h o ni e , u h s y t l algoveni unis ha be nde ds bl unde j1 3,M onelv.De t ntofSoc. r . oc r ng t, ve e eme ua e r 98 l p' me Sevs ofN. 436U. 658,690( )sae aenots bl u 51 See W ilv.Mih.De tof Y, S. 1978 tts r ua e nder 983. l c p' Stt Polc 491U. 58,71( 989)( di t tsaesaenots bl underj1 be a eof ae ie, S. 1 hol ng ha tt r ua e 983 c us t saue'lng geandbe us saesha Elve hAme he ttt s a ua ca e tt ve e nt ndmen i t mmuniy) Li wie, tts t . ke s sae a nce aenots bl unde 51 a t Vigi aDe rmentofCorecinsa is ge is r ua e r 983, nd he r ni pa t r to nd t consiue pa t ha El nt Amendme i tt nt rs ve eve h nt mmuniyand a enotpe s nsf pur e of t r r o or pos s j1 8 .Yo tv Yo nc 8 2F.d7 1 9W L 1 25 5 a 1(t Ci. c 7 1 8 ) Rhe v. . 9 3 s . u , 9 2 5, 98 5 1 , t 4 h r De . , 9 9 ; a Va De t o Cor.2002W L31 734, t1( . Va. t 23, p'. f r, 398 a W D. Oc. 2002);Hae v. De t OfCor ly Va. p . r, a 5( D. Fe 6,2002) He e Di s na sonl t Vigi aDe rme o Cor tons t E. Va. b. . r , nge s me y he r ni pa t nt f reci a a de e an . s f nd t Se nd, nge s compl i s co Di s ' ant howst tt saut lm ia i ha r on hi cai . o ha he t t e i ttons s un s lm N f rlsaut o lmiainsa i i j1 acins. is v. r a 471U. 261 266 edea tt e f i tto pples n 983 to W lon Gaci, S. , ( 985)Ac or ngl j1 a to aeg r dbyt saesaut oflmiai a i bl f 1 c di y, 983 cins r ovene he tt tt e i ttons pplca e or ge rlpe s ij yaci i t saewheet alge vi ai occ . ns v. ur nea ronalnur tons n he tt r he le d oltons ur Owe Ok e, 488U. 235,239- ( 98 . r ni ha at ye rsaut oflmiai frge rlpero l S. 40 1 9) Vigi a s wo- a tt e i ttons o nea, s na ij ycams Va. nur li . CodeAmn.j8. - a)Unde t eprncpls apl ntf brngi aci l 01243( . r hes i i e , ai if i ng vi rght a tonunde 51 i Vigi amus dos wihi t ye sfom t tmehi a ton i s ci r 983 n r ni t o t n wo ar r he i s ci a cue .d Thea cr lofac us ofa tonunde 51 f saut oflmiai pur esi cr sI c ua a e ci r 983 or tt e i ttons pos s bae o fd rllw. sm v. ad m M d Ho s o Cor , 4F.d9 , 5( t Ci.1 9 ) s d n e ea a Na i W r e . u e f r. 6 3 51 95 4h r 9 5 ( ba ) A c us ofaci unde 51 a r stwhe t pli ifpose s ss t e fcs en nc . a e ton r 983 ccue t n he antf s s e ufkint a t a utt ha m donet hi t tr s bl i r wilr vea hi c us ofa ton. l He e bo he r o m ha ea ona e nquiy l e l s a e c i ' d. r , ' D i s ' w n aleg t o r ve lt the be i ve i e l 2005 t tt D e rm e ofCor e tons nge s o l a i ns e a ha le d n ary ha he pa t nt rci wa hol ng hi be s di m yond hi a o it r l s dae. s ppr prae eea e t Cons que l hepos e s s fcintf t e nty, s s ed ufi e acs a boutt ha m do t hi t ta r s bl i uiywoul ha r ve e hi c us ofa ton. he r ne o m ha ea ona e nq r d ve e ald s a e c i H i c r nts t t r f e c s ur e ui, he e or , omesne ry 6yea spas t a i a et yea saut lmiatons l al r t he pplc bl wo- r t t e i t i . 1 11. I ac or nc wih t me o a um o ni e e e o t sda t cou t a s e n c da e t he m r nd pi on ntr d n hi y, he r su pont d s se Dig s' o lit t o t rj ie imis s n e s c mp an wih u p eudc . EN TER :D e e be 31 201 c m r , 2. s SA M U EL G . I / W LSON UNI TED STA TES DISTR I J D GE CT U ' SNa i c n ld d,nsre iga if r A sm o cu e i ce nn n n o mapapeip io e c mpan, dsrc c ut yc nie asaue u rs rsn r o lita itit o rma o sd r ttt lm iatonsdee es s ewhe t fceoft c pli pli y r al t exit eoft tdefns See64 i ti fns ua pont n he a he om ant anl eve s he senc ha e e. F. a 9533d t 54.