Gleason v. Pearson, No. 7:2012cv00619 - Document 40 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 05/14/2013. (kab)

Download PDF
' RKS Op/) it.,f.-tT =(: )1 / S 'Ji , /. .. . qt 7 . I TH E U N I N TED STA TES D I STRI COU RT CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF V I N I CT RGI A RO AN O KE DI I ON V SI - . ' . $ .? . N MAt 1t/2 1 23 e JULA C . I ; ,, : v oyp . cue- FY ; <w , R OBER T CH AR LES GLEA SON , R . J , Ci lAci No.7: 2CV0061 vi ton 1 9 Pe ii r ttone , M EM O M ND U M O PI O N NI EDD I L.PEAR SON ,W a den, E r Sus ISt e Pr son, sex at i By:Hon.Gl n E. e Conr d a ChifUnie St t sDititJ e t d a e src udge Res ponde . nt Co r r t t die tve ofRobe tCha l Gl s J . ade t r i m a e J t n P. nta y o he r c i s r res ea on, r, a h ow n t , onaha Shel Es co me e pr e ngsi t scour by flng amotonf a nt ntofc ms l don, q. m nc d oc edi n hi t ii i or ppoi me ot e . Cii 1 U. C.j3599,Shedo r quetda or ra ni hi efandohe st rpr s nt tng 8 S. l n e se n de ppoitng ms l t r o e ee Gla oni a f dea ha scor pr e di und 28U. C.j225 Byme a e s n ny e rl bea pus oc e ngs er S. 4. morndum opi ona or re ee J nua y1 201 t cou tde edt moton,hol ngt tj3599does ni nd de ntrd a r 0, 3,he r ni he i di ha notma t t a nt e ofc nda e he ppoi m nt ouns li aca ei whi h ade t r i eexpr s l de lne e n s n c a h ow nmat e sy c i s t puruef de a ha a c pusr le . The c tf t rc ude t tShe don f ie t o s e r l be s or e if our urhe oncl d ha l al d o e t bls unde e si Unie St t Supr m eCour pr ce nt a e ilm e tt i e ve sa ih, r xitng td aes e t e de , ny ntte n o ntr ne a ans Gla o ' wih s Th c u tsj d me twa atr db t Unt dS ae Co r o g i t e s n s s e . e o r' u g n s fbme y he ie tts u t f Appea s f t Fourh Cic t t Supr m e Cour de ed Shel s s e nta i a i f a l or he t r ui, he e t ni don' ubs que pplc ton or say ofe uto a G l as w a e ut o J ua y 1 201 Shel hasnow fl d a t xec i n, nd e on s xec ed n an r 6, 3. don ie ( i t a ntc elnuncpr t ,'n whi h he s e t bec û on o ppoi ouns mot o unc'i c e ks o ompe aed f rltgai hi ns t o ii tng s uns e s ulm oton. The r ponde oppos st m o i n. Fort r s t tf l , he ucc s f i es nt e he t o he ea ons ha olow t m oton w ilbe de ed. i l ni The t r i em k nunc pr t ,' t Fo t Cic tr e l e a ned,C ie a l m e ns i o unc ' as he ur h r ui ec nty xpl i s t r ly a now l f t n.'' Gl mev.W imedHe t r 699 F. 380,383( hCi.201 ( i or he '' yr l alhcae, 3d 4t r 2) quotng JL K ER U î T M a s mc u v. a k, 7F.d 1 7 ,1 7 n2( t Ci.1 9 $. il ep r os o a od r k v h k Frn 98 2 0 2 0 5 . 4h r 9 3 d- u p e f n re -h e e e nunc pr t i t c r c m i t kesorom i sonsi t r co d s t tt r cor pr pery nt r d o unc s o or e t s a s i n he e r o ha he e d o l rfedst e nt t ta lvt plce. 1 ( el he ve s ha dual ook a ' d.empha i i orgi l. Suc a oderi no ' ss n i na) hn r ç may t beus d t r toa vel r c d a e ntt tne rocc r d ort ha t r o dr lctaf c t t e o e r di y e or n ve ha ve ure o ve he ec r efe a t ha ne re sed. I (ii Expa t Bus r 72F.1 20- ( hCi.1 ) Thedocrne' ve xit ' d. ctng ' re kik, 4, 21 4t r 896). ti s i row co i s...aewi l r og ze 'andtthepa s oftmehasnotatrdt s r na nfne r dey ec ni d,' lj sage i r lee he pumos andlmiai oft srrl us devie.' J1*s as Romer Rodrcue v. e i ttons hi aey- ed c ' -, ee lo (, o- i z Gonz ls ae , 488F.d 67 677(t Ci. 3 2, 5h r 2007)(l t ... vetadii lya idnuncpr t t co rc dcours ha r tonal pple o unc o re t lmie t sofer s na yce ialorohe r or ke pi eror.) Ce .La e s Penson, i td ype ror, mel lrc t r ec d e ng r s' ; nt borr ' i ' W elae& AnnuiyFundsv. ife,1 F. 642, ( hCi.1 (1 weha r mi t fr t Grfe 98 3d 644 7t r 999) $ As ve e nded he diti tc t tm eandagan,heonl pr rofi o ant pr t or ri t c r tamit src ours i i t y ope fce f mc o unc de s o orec sake i t rc ds ic tbeusdt rwrt hit y.) n he e or ;t nnno e o e ie sor ' . ' l lg oft lm ied pur e ofn pr t or r , he co tc udest t She don' n i ht he i t pos unc o unc de s t ur oncl ha l s m oton m us be de ed. W he t s c tc ude t tt r w a no a hort f She do t i t ni n hi our oncl d ha he e s ut iy or l n o i e v nea i tGla on' wihesa bea ne unde 1 U. C.j3599, t c tdi not ntr e gans e s s s nd ppoitd r 8 S. * he our d fnd, n c r c i oft tve y r lng,t tShe do w asnone he e se il d t c pe a i i i ontadi ton ha r u i ha l n t l s ntte o om ns ton unde j359 I ed,a at ne i note il t c r 9. nde n tor y s ntted o ompe ai t rj3599unl st ns ton mde es he at tonwyi a ntdunde t saut Se 1 U. C. 3599()1 (s s ppoi e r he tt e. e 8 S. j g( ) lcompe ain s lbepai ns to hal d * Secton 3599 tguar eesf r habeaspettoner on dea h r t rghtt f aly f i t ant ede al ii s t ow he i o eder l unded couns .' el' Rya v. nz ls 1 S. . 96 7 2 ( 3)(mp ssa e ) l t sc s Gla o pli y a dcla l n Go ae , 33 Ct 6 , 0 201 e ha i dd d . n hi a e, e s n anl n e ry el ed nott pur ue af alhabeascor pe ii ect o s eder pus tton. t a t ne a nt d unde t ss e i a ar t ofnotmor t n $1 pe hotrf i c t o tor ys ppoi e r hi ubs cton t a e e ha 25 r l or n- our a o to -o r tme. .' ; s nil v W ikn , 8 F. p' 2 5 2 7n. ( t Ci. 0 8 nd u- fc u ti . .) Ro e fed . l is 2 0 Ap x 7 , 7 1 4h r 2 0 ) ' ( i t tj3599( klmisc notng ha g) di t ompe atont a ntdc eli c pialc es'. Th ,t r ns i o ppoi e ouns n a t as ') us hee i no mit keoromi son i t r or t twoul per tt e r ofa or ra ntngShedon s sa s i n he ec d ha d mi he nty n de ppoi i l nuncpr t . Suc a o de woul r wrt hit y a t , i e r . SeeGl m e 699F. o unc h n r r d e ie sor nd, hus be n ror vl , 3d a 384(i ca et docrneofnuncpr t ma onl bee o dt core tmit sor t s us he ti Be o unc y y mplye o rc sake om isonsi t r or s t tt r or pr ry r fecst e nt t tacua l t k plc t s i n he ec d o ha he ec d ope l e l t he ve s ha t ly oo a e, he dititcour' a tm ptt m odiy isea le or f rt trttmeunde t g s ofnuncpr t src ts te o f t ri r der o he i s i r he uie o unc wa er .) s ror' . ' Fort r a ons s a e Shel s m oto t a ntc he e s t t d, don' i n o ppoi ouns lnunc pr t wilbe de ed. e o unc l ni The Clr i die t d t s c rii c esoft so de t a1 co elofr co d. e k s r c e o end e tfed opi hi r r o 1 uns e r ENTER: s I d yo Ma , 2013. Thi 4# a f y Chi fU nie St t sD i t i tJ e t d a e s rc udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.