Goode v. White et al, No. 7:2012cv00532 - Document 10 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 11/27/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
k,tà/ : t FCtî L , DI y ... .. ts' ) Fi) lS. BT.. . , eu . . J ' , A: ROANOKE, VA FI LED N0V 27 2 1 22 I TH E U N I N TED STA TE S D I STR I T C O U R T C FO R TH E W E STER N DISTR I T O F V I G I I C R N A ROANO KE DI I O N V SI D EZA CH TR E R A D EL L G O O D E , 'I A C lL! ' -PJ .- ' rek W =$ 1 *' C i lA ct on N o.7: vi i 12cv00532 Pl ntif, ai f M EM O M N DU M O PI I N N O SG T .W H I e al, TE t . By:Sam uelG . is W l on Uni St esD i t ctJudge ted at s ri D ef ndant . e s Pli ifDe c r Radel Goode, Vigni i t pr ee ngpr s brngst s a ntf za hte l a r i a nma e oc di o e, i hi a tonpurua t 42U. C.j1 cai ngt tt dee nt,nlre wiht Lynchbu g ci s nt o S. 983 l mi ha he fnda s zs s t he r Adul Dee i Ce e (t t tnton ntr $LADC',s ddei rt i ferncebymitke ygi nghi t ' howe lbeae ndif e ) sa nl vi m he wr m edi a i on a s ngl oc s on w hie he w a hous a t LA D C i Lync ong c ton i e ca i l s ed t he n hbur g, V igi a. The c tfndst tGoode' com pl n f ist s a e a pl us bl cl i f r le a r ni our i ha s ai t a l o t t a i e a m or e i f nd dimissiwihoutprj c purua t 28U. C.j1 A. s se t t eudie s nt o S. 915 1. A c or ng t G oode' com pl i ,o Oc o r 1 2011 t nur e on dut ga hi c di o s a nt n t be 6, , he s y ve m m e ca i n t tw asac ualy f a he i a e by t na e ofRonni G oode. Goode t ok t di to ha t l or not r nm t he m e o he pil, c hede ci a mus l r a r a ts ot rpils, a alege t thebe ame ls whih s rbes s ce elxe s nd dome he lll' nd l s ha ' c ve y di y a a r ul. G oode sat t the t n r m e be e t the di nott ke m e c ne, r zz s es t t es ha he e m r d ha d a di i e e a i otcsf hi knee . Goodeas f r$1 000 i dn a . xc pt ntbi i or s s ks o 00, n m ges II. Se ton 1 5A r qui e t c t o c c i 91 e r s he our t onduc a i tals r e ng ofa pr s r s t n nii c e ni i one ' c pl ntt hi ...s e r e s f om a gove m e a e iy o ofi erore pl om ai i ch w e ks edr s r m nt l ntt r tc m oyee ofa g ovenune ale iy'a dimisi i i i ( )Srvolus malci ,orf l t sat acai upon nt ntt ' nd s s t f t s 1 t i o , i ous ais o t e l m f whihrle maybegrntdi' ( d e ksmoneayrle fom adefnda whoi i c eif a e 'or 2) t e s tr eif r e nt s mmune fo s hr i .'28U. C.j191 A() b) A prs ofkilsdelbert i fee t t r m uc elef' S. 5 a-( . ion t a' i ae ndifrnce o he s i m e ca nee ofa prs rm a c tt e an Ei h A m e erous di l ds i one y onsiut ght ndm e vi a i Se e c. nt ol ton. es . , Eselev. mbl 429U. 97 ( 976 .Thedei rt i fee esandadr quiesmor t n t l Ga e, S. 1 ) lbeae ndifrnc t r e r e ha m e e ne i nc a t or t n or na y l c ofdue ca e f t pr s r s i e e t o s f t ' r glge e, nd s e ha di r a k m r or he i one ' nt r s s r a e y. ' W hilyv. ber, U. 31 31 ( 986) te Al s 475 S. 2, 9 1 . ( prs ofi a c nno bef la eunde t Eiht Ame A1 ion tcil a t ound ibl r he g h ndme f nt or de ng a i a e hum a c tons ofc i m e unl s t ofi i lkno s of nyi n nm t ne ondii onfne nt e s he f c a w a di r r a exc s ve rs t i a e he lh ors f t t of i i lm us bot nd s ega ds n es i i k o nm t a t a e y; he f c a t h be a ar off t f om whi h t i e e e co d be dr w n t ta s t nta r s w e ac s r c he nf r nc ul a ha ubs a i l ik ofs rousha m e s s a he m us a s dr w t i e enc ei r xit , nd t l o a he nf r e. Fame v. e n,511U. 825,837( 994) Hee Goode' algai f lfrs t r r Brnna S. 1 . r, s le tons al a hor of a l gi a Ei t A m e entvi a i Eve he r c ni est tt nur e adm i s e e t le ng n gh h ndm ol ton. n e og z ha he s nit r d he m e c ton by m i t ke. The nur e di notac ualy ç a t i er nc ' ha s a i s e e di a i sa s d t l t w he nf e e' t t he dm nit r d dr t m e ca i n i pr ry. Goode a l gesnot ng m or t n or nar l k ofdue ca e,a he di to m ope l le hi e ha di y ac r nd t e or t c t ildi m i shi co pl nt her f e he our w l s s s m ai . 111. Fort r a ons s a e a he e s t t d bove t c t ildi m i sG oode' c pl i pur ua t 28 , he our w l s s s om a nt s nt o U. C.j 1 5A( bec ei fist saeacam u n whihrlefma begrntd.TheCl k S. 91 b) aus t al o tt li po c ei y a e er oft Cour i die t d t s nd a ce tfed c oft sM e o andum O pi on a a c pa ng he ts rce o e r ii opy hi m r ni nd c om nyi Or rt t pl i if de o he a ntf . A .-2 x - .e .ee .. . J--p S-. ENTER :N ovem ber27,2012. z e A <> ./ , , e* r .e 2 : . . . ' 1+ * ' p' . e eA . p e z' f., ' . a ' .# . . ..# ' e .- x' x e. '' . / , ' zd e e . * I TED STA TES DISTR I JUD GE CT