Berry v. Gorman, No. 7:2012cv00500 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 11/27/2012. (rkc)
Download PDF
CL e OFFZ E t.%, sT. ERK' l r$ Cour A ROANOG , T VA FI LED N0V 27 2 1 22 I TH E UNI N TED STATESDISTRI COURT CT FO R T H E W ESTER N D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R O A N O K E DI I O N V SI RE G IN A LD R .B ER R Y , J A C. ULI DUDLEY CLERK B Y: ' ) . Ci lA ct on N o.7: vi i 12cv00500 Pl nt f ai i f, M EM O M N D UM O PI I N N O V. M ICH AE L G O R M A N AND G EN E M L ELE C TRI CO M PA N Y C By:Sam ue G .W is l l on Unied St es D itri Judge t at s ct D ef endant s. Pl ntf R e na d Be r brngst sac i npr s a i tdef nda sM i ha lGor a a ai if gi l r y i hi t o / e ga ns e nt c e m n nd Ge r lEl c r c Com pa A lho h Be r sc pl i i by no m ea c e r Be r pr um a y ne a e t i ny. t ug r y' om a nt s ns l a , r y es bl i e t ale a de a ofpe i be f t i vi a i oft Em pl e Re ie entI om e nt nds o l ge ni l ns on ne is n ol ton he oye tr m nc Se urt Ac of1 4 (( SA',Pu L. 93- 88Stt 8 (odii a a ndedi c iy t 97 6 ERl ' b. No. 406, a. 29 c fed s me ) n s atrds ci of5U. C.18U. C.26U. C.29U. C.a 42U. C..Be a eBer s c tee e tons S. , S. , S. , S. , nd S. ) c us ry' c ompli f ist ari a eapl usbl cai f r lef t c tdimis shi c am ss s e ant al o tcult a i e l m or ei , he our s s e s l i ua pont a dwi o t rj dc .Th c u t rn sBe r la et fl a a nd dc mpan t tme t t e n t u p eu ie e o r ga t ry e v o ie n me e o lit ha es h h pl di rquie nt stfrhi Rul 8()oft Fe rlRulsofCi lPr e ewihi t ry ea ng e rme s e o t n e a he dea e vi oc dur t n hit da f o t e r oft sor r ys r m he nt y hi de . 1. Ber sc npli i c tst thei s ngf ( a ofeane pensonbe tt (i ry' ol ant ndiae ha s ui or t l r d i niis scl deni pr e t d u rERI a EB SA ' a f d a l e t pr d pe i doc e sunde t ot c e nde SA nd ' nd or t iur o ovi e ns on um nt f r he tmelnestbyERI a EBSA. ( '.Compl 1 ECF No.1 .Exc ptf hi prye f i i e SA nd ' Pls ' ., ) e or s a r or F - r le r t e s a e e s a e t sl t t lo Bery' a l ga i . Addii l Be r na e e i f ' hes t t m nt r he tm o a f r s le tons tonaly, ry m s G o ' an a a i vi lde e l m s n ndi dua f ndant buthi c pl i f l t pr de a i o m a i n a t ho , s om a nt ais o ovi ny nf r to s o w G o m a c d be la e r n oul i bl . I I. Unde Rul 8()2)oft Fe rlRulsofCi lPr ed e apla ngmus c ai a r e a( he dea e vi oc ur , e di t ont n C hol a pl i s a e e oft c a m s t ' nd a n t t m nt he l i howi t t pl a ri e il t r le ' Fe R. s t ng hat he e de s ntted o e i f ' d. Ci P.8( ( .Att pla ngsa t c tmu ta e acai ntsfcua algainsa v. a)2) he e di tge,he our s cc pt l ma ' a t l le to s tt butpl ntfsmus pl de rl e, ai if t ea noughf t t t acs o s nudgel t i camsa r st lnefo l her li c os he i r m c e va et pl i e' a t ca m mus bedim is d i i i notiplusbl on isf ce' onc i bl o ausbl,' nd he li t s se f t s s a i e t a .' BelAt.Co'.v.Twombl 550U. 5 57 ( l l l p v, S. 44, 0 2007) M orove ,at . e r lhought c r i rquie he ou ts e rd t lb rlyc n tu /s d c me t, iks nv. ad , 51U. 8 , 4 ( 0 ) t sd e n t o i eal o sr err e o u ns Erc o P rus 5 S. 9 9 20 7 ,hi o s o r quiet c tt i e a obvi f iur t a lgef ct s ti f rh apl usbl cam f e r he our o gnor n ous al e o le a s e tng o t a i e li 0r rle.M il v. e nvil Couny,58 F.Supp. 480, ( S. 2008)(ii W elrv. eif ls Gr e le t 6 2d 487 D. C. ctng le De tofSoc.Sevs,901F. 387( hCi.1 0).Eve whe apli ifhaspadt f lflng p' r . 2d 4t r 99 ) n n antf i he ul ii f e, he dit i tc t et ns di c e i t di m i st c a m ss s e t s rc our r ai s r ton o s s he l i ua pont . Se M a l r v. . e e la d U S. Dit Co tfrt S.DitofI ,490U. 296,307(1 9) Unie Aut W oker v. son s. ur o he s. owa S. 98 ; td o r s Gat F sias I c, 3F.d9 2 9 5 0 ( t Ci. 9 )( imisngpli ifscamss as n e; e tv l. n .4 3 0 , 0 - 6 4h r 1 95 ds s i ant f li u po t) seas Gre v. t Stts 57F. 1 1 W L 361 ,a *1( h Ci.1 (a e e lo ir Unied ae , 3d 066, 995 271 t 4t r 995) tbl de ii ( rcu im) Fizgeadv.Fis E.Se hSte tTe nt Cor , 1F. 362,363 4 cson) pe ra ; t rl rt vent re na s p.22 3d -6 ( Ci. 2d r 2000) . 1 1 hi pr or elef r y t t ha n s ayerf r i , Be r s a est the s e t o add 5 ye r pe i n t t t a e ks d t a s ns o o he ot l ye r s a s hown by Ge r lEl ti ' nd t o r c ve$1 000 f re c m on h ofde e be tt ne a ecrc'a d e ei t 0, o a h t nid neis snc r ie ntageelgi lt ofSe e rl 20117( ' Compl 1 ECFNo.1 . i e etrme i biiy ptmbe , . P1s. 1 ., ) Ra he t n r ctng a f c ua a lgatonsa i te t rdef nda ,Be z ha at c d t t r ha e ii ny a t l le i gans ihe e nt r. s ta he o y hi c m pl i tva i e pl e - el t doc e sofno s f e de s g fc nce. I f c , s o a n r ous m oym ntr a ed um nt el- vi nt i ni i a n at B e r d snota l ge an f c sen ilng hi t r le . ordo a oft c pl nt sa l ga i r y oe le y a t tti m o ei f N ny he om ai ' le tons putt de e he f ndan so no i ast t potnta ca msa i tt .Ac or ngl t c t t n tce o he e il li gans hem c di y, he our dim is Be r sc am sagans bot def nda s Thec tg a t Be r l vet fl a s s es ry' l i i t h e nt . our r n s ry ea o ie n am e d c pl i w ihi t r y da f om t e r oft s o d . nde om a nt t n hi t ys r he nt y hi r er 1 11. F rt ra o ssae ,h c u t imissBer ' c mplitwi u p eu ie wi o he e s n ttd te o r d s se ry s o an t t rj d c , t ho h l vet fl a a nded c ea o ie n me ompli wihi t ry da fo t e r oft so de . a nt t n hit ys r m he nty hi r r EN TER : ove be 27, 2. N m r 201 UN I TED STA TES D I STRI J DGE CT U