McLean v. Kiser et al, No. 7:2012cv00495 - Document 12 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 11/13/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
CLERKS OFFI U S. ST. CE DI COURT AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W E STER N D I STR I O F VI G I I CT R N A ROANOKE DI I ON V SI N0V 13 2 1 02 J A ULi :Y: CLERK . QUENTI M CLEAN, N C .! 8 F : C i lAc i N o.7: 2c vi t on 1 v00495 Pl nt f , ai i f M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N N O M r.K i e etal, sr . Dee f ndant . s By: Sam ue G . is l W l on U nied St e D i t i Judge t at s s r ct Pl nifQue i M cLe aVigi ai t pr e ngpr se brngst sa to aitf ntn an, r ni nmae oce di o , i hi cin purua t 42U. C.j 1 a ns anumbe ofe o sa Re Oni Stt Prs algi s nt o S. 983 gai t r mplyee t d on ae ion, le ng voain o hsEih ha F u te t Ame d n rg t.M c va se sa ij n to od rn ilto s f i g t nd o re n h n me t ih s le n e k n n u cin r e ig t tt de e nt pr de hi w ih ne cl hi be ng,a s ha he f nda s ovi m t w ot ng, ddi nd hoes t tt de e nt sop ; ha he f nda s t i e f rng w ih hi r c ea i a s e prvieg ;a t tt g r i n c os pr m iy' t nt r e i t s e r ton nd how r i l es nd ha he ua ds l l e oxi t ' o i hi be c os l m onio e m l ey t r d. F d rlc u t h v d s s e wi p eudc , u s a tt 28U. C.j1 5 e( )B)i , e ea o rs a e imis d t rj ie p ru n o h S. 91 ()2 ( (i ) a las t e ofM c aa ' pr i prs rc anslSeci 1 5( ofTil 28prvi s t e t hre te n s evous ione omplit. ton 91 g) te o de t taprs rm a notbrng a cvi ac i wihoutpr pay e oft r r $350. flng f e ha ione y i i l ton t e m nt he equied 00 ii e i t prs rhas on 3 ormor proroc sons whiei r r t d orde aned i f he ione , e i ca i , l nca ce a e ti n a f iiy, oug a a ton ora ny aclt br ht n c i ppea i ac toft Unie St t st twa l n our he t d a e ha s di m i s d on t g o s se he r undst ti i f i ous m a i i ,orf ist s a e a c ai ha t s rvol , lc ous a l o tt l m upon w hi r le m a be gr nt d,unl st prs r i unde i m i ntdange ch e i f y a e es he i one s r m ne r o sro sp ysc lnu y f e iu h ia ij r . 'Se M cLe v. Fa s No 2:9 v 2 ( D. .u e2 1 9 )(imisdwi peu c frfi r t sae e an u t . 9 c 6 5 E. Va J n , 9 9 ds se t rj die o al e o tt h u acam)Mcaa v. li , . 9 c 3 ( D. .uy2 ,1 9 )(imis dwi peu c frfi r t sae li ; len Bol No 729 v 41 W. Va J l 6 9 9 ds se t rjdie o al e o tt ng h u acam) Mca-nv. tdSttsNo 20 c 4 7( D. . e t 1 , 0 6 (imisdwi peudc frfi et li ; -e Uni ae , . :6 v 4 E. Va S p. 2 2 0 ) ds se t rj ie o al o la e h ur saeacam) Th c u t oe t tnM cza v UntdSae, 6 F.d3 (t Ci. 0 ,heUntdSae tt li . e o r n ts ha i te n . i tts 5 6 3 91 4h r20 9)t i tts e e Cour ofAppe sf t FourhCicui satd t tM cLe n wasnotat e srke . Howeve ,a trt c t t al or he t r t t e ha a hr e-ti r r fe he our a fr e t dititc tsdim is ofM c e n' ca ef f l et saea cam , c nr ei hi t r srke. fim d he src our' s sal t a s s or aiur o tt li M Lea ec ved s hid ti Asnoe b tedse ti ta c s,dg ie ta temao i a re ta Mc a h sa latwop e iu srk s td y h isn n h t a e d qv n h th j rt ge s h t Le n a t e st rvo s tie , l y M c a n s ul heeaAe bedee e at eesrke .'Si t n, cLe hashadm uli ecam sdim is d ont s lea ho d r r m d hr -ti r' nce he M an tpl li s se hi b ss S e ea, lenv Ralf, . 1 c 2 ( . Va Ma 2 201 . Le nv. ae No 71 c 43 a i. e . ..Mcaa . tifNo 7:2 v 27 W D. . y 9, 2)Mc a Pe s, . :2 v 2 , ( . Va Se t 1 , 01 ) W D. . p. 7 2 2 . M cLe n hasneihe pad t flng f nors a t r i he ii ee, hown t the i tunde i ne da rofs rous ha s ç r mmi nt nge ei p ysc l nu y' j1 5 g .Ac o dn l,hec u t e isM c a smo int p o e d i h ia ij r . 91 ( ) c r igy t o r d n e Le n' to o r c e n ' fr o mapa pe i p ru n t 28U. C.j1 5 g , n d s se h sc mpan wih u p eu ie u rs u s a t o S. 91 ( ) a d imis s i o lit t o t rj d c . The Cl r i diec ed t s nd a c r ii d c oft sm e or ek s r t o e e tf e opy hi m andum opi on a t ni nd he a com pa ng or rt t pl i if c nyi de o he a ntf . ENTER:Nove r1 201 mbe 3, 2. ym hy' . ; z.. . ' ' r z) ,. . Z . . x' > * . -'' UN I TED STATES D I STRI J DG E CT U