Arledge v. VanOver et al, No. 7:2012cv00486 - Document 8 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 11/2/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I T C O UR T C FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R O AN O K E D I ISIO N V JA RED AR LED G E, CA SE N O .7: 2C V 00486 1 * # 222 1 12 XlW c k .K B .. . .; .. , , . , QRX r . . :. ' .. Pl nt f , ai i f M EM O M N D U M O PI I N N O VS. By: Jam esC .Turk Se orU nied St e D i t i Judge ni t at s s r ct HENRY VAN OVER, AL. c , Deendants. f t) J r d Are a e l dge,aVigi ai aepr e ng pr K ,fl t scvi rg sa tonpur ua r ni nm t oce di o ied hi i l i ht ci s nt t 42U. C.j1 ,ale ngt tvai i viuas a tonsc us dhi t rc vea o S. 983 lgi ha rous ndi d l' ci a e m o e ei n un e s bl s nt nce.Upon r vi oft r c d,Upon r vi w oft r or t c r tnds z a ona e e e e ew he e or e e he ec d, he ou t i t tt co antmus bec tu d asape ii f awrtofha asco pus pur ua t 28 ha he mpli t onsr e tton or i be r , s nt o U. C. 2 5 , n s S. j 2 4 a d ummai d s se wi u p eu iefrfi r t e h us saec u t rl imis d t t rj dc o al e o x a t tt o r y ho u r n e es l e n di . I Are ma st f lowi al ga i .Diki on Count Cic tCour J l dge ke he o l ng le tons c ns y r ui t udgeHe y nr Van Ove s d havee us hi effom Ared sc ebe a eheha a c lc ofi e e t r houl xc ed ms l r l ge' as c us d onfit ntr s, ba e o t f tt Are sc i kil Va Oversgr ndf he yea sa J s d n he ac hat l dge' ousns led n ' a at r r go. udgeVan Ove i pos d atn- a s ntnceo Are ,a unr a ona y s ve es nt nc be a ei wa r m e e ye r e e n l dge n e s bl e r e e e c us t s Aredge st is tmei toubl .'Compl 2- Buddy W al n,t pu i de e rwho l ' t rt i n r e' f . 3. le he blc f nde r pr s nt d A redge a s had a c lc ofi e e t s nc W alen w a t Com m onw e lh' e ee e l , lo onf i t nt r s , i e l s he at s Atone a tet o t c u is til o kligtej dg ' g a d ah r W alnas tr y th i f he o sn 'ra f r il h u e s rn f te . le lo me n pr d i f e i a s s a e t Ar e by f lng t m o f rJ ovi ed ne f ctve s i t nc o l dge aii o ve o udge Van O ve ' r us la r s ec a nd l Rul 4oft Rul Gov r ng#22 4 c s a t rz st i c r t s e he es e ni 5 aes uho ie h s ou t o umma i ds s a rl imis y habeascor acton i i i clarfom t f oft pl ng t pettoneri note il t r i . pus i f t s e r he ace he eadi hat ii s ntted o elef frfii t o j c t t s ne ea u a o a l.Th Co n at sAtone wh o al o b e t o he e tnc s re s n be e mmo we l ng h' t r y o p osc tdAre g , o hNe ry k e a o ttec nlcso itr s t a t ej dg a dt e r e u e ld e J s wber , n w b u h o tit f n ee t h t h u e n h publc de e erha i t sca e,bu di not ng t a l vi t t pr e . i f nd d n hi s t d hi o le a e he obl m Are g s e t j d e tep bi d fn e , n tepr s c tr Asr le, ldg s e s ld e u s he u g ,h u lc ee d r a d h o e uo . eif Are e e k ane sne cn he rngb f r adfee t u g , t adfee p bi d f n e, n a w e tn ig ai eo e ifrn j d e wih ifrnt u lc e e d r a d r duc i i hi s nt nc .2 e ton n s e e e 1 1 A diti tc ti notc taned by altga ' syl ofpl di o r que tf r le a src our s onsr i ii nts t e ea ng r e s or ei f nd ma lbealyco tueaci lrght c anta aha speii purua t j2254.Ha i y i r l nsr vi i s ompli s bea tton, s nt o mln v. arn,66 F. 29,30 ( hCi.1 ) dee newhehe ana toni pr ry W re 4 2d 4t r 981.To tnni t r ci s opel c i rd aha scor peii rquii e ha tonofsaec tr dispt s ntt j onsdee bea pus tton e rng x usi tt our eme e z ua o r 2254(9,rt rt naci lrg sco an unde j 1 3, c ur mus c i rwhehe t 1 ahe ha vi iht mplit r 98 a o t t onsde t r he ( or 'oft ltga ' cl i c e nst f c o dur ton oft ltga t s c i m e . Pr i e i e' he ii nt s a m onc r he a t r a i c he ii n ' onfne nt e s r v.Rodrcue 41lU. 475( 973) Toddv. s r le 7l F. 7 ( hCi.1 3) i z, S. 1 ; Ba kevil, 2 2d 0 4t r 98 . Aredge s c ai salege t tt de enda t 'confi t ofi e es ,a t pr ec or s l ' l m l ha he f ns lc s nt r t nd he os ut ' fi et o j c o t b sso tos c nlcs c usdAre g t b wr n f lysn e c d al o be t n he a i f h e o tit, a e ld e o e o g ul e tn e . ur Be a et c c us he ompli t co e t t lng h ofAredge sco i menti t Vigni prs ant hus nt ss he e t l ' nfne n he r i a ion s tm, scai aeno cog z bl unde j1 a hi s er me i t brngaha a yse hi l ms r t nia e r 983, nd s ol e dy s o i be s peii unde 28U. C.j2254.Pr s r s a.Theef e,hec tc udest tAre s tton r S. eie, upr r or t our oncl ha ldge' c ai s a e a o i t y co tued a ape ii f a wr tofha s c pus unde 28 U . C . l m r ppr pr a el nsr s tton or i bea or r S. j2254. 2 Aredge alo demandsasr i : wrte r i l s elef itn eprmandsagai tal t eedef ns I hr endant , and an s i tga i and dici i y ac i by t Vigi aSt eBa agai tal t eedef nves i ton s plnar ton he r ni at r ns I hr endant . Are i s ldge s her advied t s dici i y ac i agai ta t neysar noti tgat t ough af alcour eby s hat uch s plnar tons ns tor e ns i ed hr eder t acton. i Pr dedt tane yconsnl j225 peiinme t t t es dr rme sf ovi ha wl t ed 4 tto es he hr hol equie nt or ha asa tons unde t s s ton, he c tc n a e st pe ii scl i s on t m e is be c i r hi ec i t our a ddr s he tton' a m he rt . Hai sv. r , U. 519( 972) ne Kener404 S. 1 .Unde 28U. C.j225 1 howe ,afdealc t r S. 449, ver e r our c nnotgr ntaha spe ii unl st pe ii ne hase use t r disa ia ei t a a bea tton es he tto r xha t d he eme e va lbl n he c t oft sa ei whih pe ii nerwa c ctd. O' lva v. r kel 526 U. 838, ours he tt n c tto s onvi e Suli n Boe c , S. 8 ( 999) l t peii rha f ie t e us saec trme e ,hefderlcou tmus 42 1 . f he ttone s ald o xha t tt our e dis t e a r t ds s t j2 5 peio wih u p eu iet alw hi t rt r t saec u t Slvo v imis he 2 4 t in t o t rj d c o l t o m o eu n o tt o r. a tn . Smih,404U. 53( 971 . t S. 1 ) Not ng i Are ss bm iso s esst heha pr s nt d hi c r c am st t hi n ldge' u s ins ugg t hat s e e e s urent l i o he SuprmeCour ofVigi aa rquiedfre usi ofsaecour rme esunde j225 . e t r ni s e r o xha ton tt t e di r 4*) M or ove ,sa ec t e or a lbl onlnei caet tAre wass nt nc i Febr l e r t t our r c ds vaia e i ndi t ha l dge e e ed n ua' y 201 a t thi c i nala a i c r n l pe ngbe or t Cour ofAppea sofVigi a. 2 nd ha s rmi ppe l s ur e ty ndi f e he t l r ni l hi a ali uns c s ul Aredgema t n a a t t Supr m eCour ofVigni a f s ppe s uc es f , l y he ppe l o he e t r i a nd, t r a tr pur ue saecour ha a c puspr ee ngs i wa r nt d. Be us Are cla l he e fe , s tt t be s or oc di , f r a e ca e l dge e ry hasnote use a lbl sa eco tr medisa t stme,hi c t a notgr ntr lefo hi xha t d vaia e tt ur e e t hi i t s our m y a ei n s c n lc o itr s camsa dmus s mmai d s s tep tto wi o t eu iet alw o fit f nee t li n t u rl imis h eiin t u prj d c o l y h o Ar e t pur ue hi cl m s fr ti sat co t Sl t n,s a. A n a o i t or rw ilent r l dge o s s ai i s n t e ur . av o upr ppr pr a e de l e t sda The Cl r i die t d t s nd c e oft sm e or ndum o ni and a c pa ng hi y. e k s r c e o e opi s hi m a pi on c om nyi or rt pl i i f de o a ntf . EN TER : Thi l - d-a o No e e, 01 . s x d y f v mb r2 2 - Seni nied St esD i t ct or t at sri 3 ge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
