Arledge v. VanOver et al, No. 7:2012cv00486 - Document 8 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 11/2/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I T C O UR T C FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R O AN O K E D I ISIO N V JA RED AR LED G E, CA SE N O .7: 2C V 00486 1 * # 222 1 12 XlW c k .K B .. . .; .. , , . , QRX r . . :. ' .. Pl nt f , ai i f M EM O M N D U M O PI I N N O VS. By: Jam esC .Turk Se orU nied St e D i t i Judge ni t at s s r ct HENRY VAN OVER, AL. c , Deendants. f t) J r d Are a e l dge,aVigi ai aepr e ng pr K ,fl t scvi rg sa tonpur ua r ni nm t oce di o ied hi i l i ht ci s nt t 42U. C.j1 ,ale ngt tvai i viuas a tonsc us dhi t rc vea o S. 983 lgi ha rous ndi d l' ci a e m o e ei n un e s bl s nt nce.Upon r vi oft r c d,Upon r vi w oft r or t c r tnds z a ona e e e e ew he e or e e he ec d, he ou t i t tt co antmus bec tu d asape ii f awrtofha asco pus pur ua t 28 ha he mpli t onsr e tton or i be r , s nt o U. C. 2 5 , n s S. j 2 4 a d ummai d s se wi u p eu iefrfi r t e h us saec u t rl imis d t t rj dc o al e o x a t tt o r y ho u r n e es l e n di . I Are ma st f lowi al ga i .Diki on Count Cic tCour J l dge ke he o l ng le tons c ns y r ui t udgeHe y nr Van Ove s d havee us hi effom Ared sc ebe a eheha a c lc ofi e e t r houl xc ed ms l r l ge' as c us d onfit ntr s, ba e o t f tt Are sc i kil Va Oversgr ndf he yea sa J s d n he ac hat l dge' ousns led n ' a at r r go. udgeVan Ove i pos d atn- a s ntnceo Are ,a unr a ona y s ve es nt nc be a ei wa r m e e ye r e e n l dge n e s bl e r e e e c us t s Aredge st is tmei toubl .'Compl 2- Buddy W al n,t pu i de e rwho l ' t rt i n r e' f . 3. le he blc f nde r pr s nt d A redge a s had a c lc ofi e e t s nc W alen w a t Com m onw e lh' e ee e l , lo onf i t nt r s , i e l s he at s Atone a tet o t c u is til o kligtej dg ' g a d ah r W alnas tr y th i f he o sn 'ra f r il h u e s rn f te . le lo me n pr d i f e i a s s a e t Ar e by f lng t m o f rJ ovi ed ne f ctve s i t nc o l dge aii o ve o udge Van O ve ' r us la r s ec a nd l Rul 4oft Rul Gov r ng#22 4 c s a t rz st i c r t s e he es e ni 5 aes uho ie h s ou t o umma i ds s a rl imis y habeascor acton i i i clarfom t f oft pl ng t pettoneri note il t r i . pus i f t s e r he ace he eadi hat ii s ntted o elef frfii t o j c t t s ne ea u a o a l.Th Co n at sAtone wh o al o b e t o he e tnc s re s n be e mmo we l ng h' t r y o p osc tdAre g , o hNe ry k e a o ttec nlcso itr s t a t ej dg a dt e r e u e ld e J s wber , n w b u h o tit f n ee t h t h u e n h publc de e erha i t sca e,bu di not ng t a l vi t t pr e . i f nd d n hi s t d hi o le a e he obl m Are g s e t j d e tep bi d fn e , n tepr s c tr Asr le, ldg s e s ld e u s he u g ,h u lc ee d r a d h o e uo . eif Are e e k ane sne cn he rngb f r adfee t u g , t adfee p bi d f n e, n a w e tn ig ai eo e ifrn j d e wih ifrnt u lc e e d r a d r duc i i hi s nt nc .2 e ton n s e e e 1 1 A diti tc ti notc taned by altga ' syl ofpl di o r que tf r le a src our s onsr i ii nts t e ea ng r e s or ei f nd ma lbealyco tueaci lrght c anta aha speii purua t j2254.Ha i y i r l nsr vi i s ompli s bea tton, s nt o mln v. arn,66 F. 29,30 ( hCi.1 ) dee newhehe ana toni pr ry W re 4 2d 4t r 981.To tnni t r ci s opel c i rd aha scor peii rquii e ha tonofsaec tr dispt s ntt j onsdee bea pus tton e rng x usi tt our eme e z ua o r 2254(9,rt rt naci lrg sco an unde j 1 3, c ur mus c i rwhehe t 1 ahe ha vi iht mplit r 98 a o t t onsde t r he ( or 'oft ltga ' cl i c e nst f c o dur ton oft ltga t s c i m e . Pr i e i e' he ii nt s a m onc r he a t r a i c he ii n ' onfne nt e s r v.Rodrcue 41lU. 475( 973) Toddv. s r le 7l F. 7 ( hCi.1 3) i z, S. 1 ; Ba kevil, 2 2d 0 4t r 98 . Aredge s c ai salege t tt de enda t 'confi t ofi e es ,a t pr ec or s l ' l m l ha he f ns lc s nt r t nd he os ut ' fi et o j c o t b sso tos c nlcs c usdAre g t b wr n f lysn e c d al o be t n he a i f h e o tit, a e ld e o e o g ul e tn e . ur Be a et c c us he ompli t co e t t lng h ofAredge sco i menti t Vigni prs ant hus nt ss he e t l ' nfne n he r i a ion s tm, scai aeno cog z bl unde j1 a hi s er me i t brngaha a yse hi l ms r t nia e r 983, nd s ol e dy s o i be s peii unde 28U. C.j2254.Pr s r s a.Theef e,hec tc udest tAre s tton r S. eie, upr r or t our oncl ha ldge' c ai s a e a o i t y co tued a ape ii f a wr tofha s c pus unde 28 U . C . l m r ppr pr a el nsr s tton or i bea or r S. j2254. 2 Aredge alo demandsasr i : wrte r i l s elef itn eprmandsagai tal t eedef ns I hr endant , and an s i tga i and dici i y ac i by t Vigi aSt eBa agai tal t eedef nves i ton s plnar ton he r ni at r ns I hr endant . Are i s ldge s her advied t s dici i y ac i agai ta t neysar noti tgat t ough af alcour eby s hat uch s plnar tons ns tor e ns i ed hr eder t acton. i Pr dedt tane yconsnl j225 peiinme t t t es dr rme sf ovi ha wl t ed 4 tto es he hr hol equie nt or ha asa tons unde t s s ton, he c tc n a e st pe ii scl i s on t m e is be c i r hi ec i t our a ddr s he tton' a m he rt . Hai sv. r , U. 519( 972) ne Kener404 S. 1 .Unde 28U. C.j225 1 howe ,afdealc t r S. 449, ver e r our c nnotgr ntaha spe ii unl st pe ii ne hase use t r disa ia ei t a a bea tton es he tto r xha t d he eme e va lbl n he c t oft sa ei whih pe ii nerwa c ctd. O' lva v. r kel 526 U. 838, ours he tt n c tto s onvi e Suli n Boe c , S. 8 ( 999) l t peii rha f ie t e us saec trme e ,hefderlcou tmus 42 1 . f he ttone s ald o xha t tt our e dis t e a r t ds s t j2 5 peio wih u p eu iet alw hi t rt r t saec u t Slvo v imis he 2 4 t in t o t rj d c o l t o m o eu n o tt o r. a tn . Smih,404U. 53( 971 . t S. 1 ) Not ng i Are ss bm iso s esst heha pr s nt d hi c r c am st t hi n ldge' u s ins ugg t hat s e e e s urent l i o he SuprmeCour ofVigi aa rquiedfre usi ofsaecour rme esunde j225 . e t r ni s e r o xha ton tt t e di r 4*) M or ove ,sa ec t e or a lbl onlnei caet tAre wass nt nc i Febr l e r t t our r c ds vaia e i ndi t ha l dge e e ed n ua' y 201 a t thi c i nala a i c r n l pe ngbe or t Cour ofAppea sofVigi a. 2 nd ha s rmi ppe l s ur e ty ndi f e he t l r ni l hi a ali uns c s ul Aredgema t n a a t t Supr m eCour ofVigni a f s ppe s uc es f , l y he ppe l o he e t r i a nd, t r a tr pur ue saecour ha a c puspr ee ngs i wa r nt d. Be us Are cla l he e fe , s tt t be s or oc di , f r a e ca e l dge e ry hasnote use a lbl sa eco tr medisa t stme,hi c t a notgr ntr lefo hi xha t d vaia e tt ur e e t hi i t s our m y a ei n s c n lc o itr s camsa dmus s mmai d s s tep tto wi o t eu iet alw o fit f nee t li n t u rl imis h eiin t u prj d c o l y h o Ar e t pur ue hi cl m s fr ti sat co t Sl t n,s a. A n a o i t or rw ilent r l dge o s s ai i s n t e ur . av o upr ppr pr a e de l e t sda The Cl r i die t d t s nd c e oft sm e or ndum o ni and a c pa ng hi y. e k s r c e o e opi s hi m a pi on c om nyi or rt pl i i f de o a ntf . EN TER : Thi l - d-a o No e e, 01 . s x d y f v mb r2 2 - Seni nied St esD i t ct or t at sri 3 ge