Hudson v. Botetourt County Jail, No. 7:2012cv00466 - Document 6 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 10/3/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
rdFRTSAT CE U.S. ST. OFFI Di COURT ROANOKE:VA FI I LEC I TH E U N I N TED STA TE S D I STR I T C O U R T C FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI GI A CT R NI R O A N O K E D I SI N VI O JO H N M ICH A EL H U D SO N , OCI 23 2 1 ' j 22 f' JULC BY A C . ; DeP L ,CLERK CLERK C i lA ct on N o.7: v00466 vi i 12c Pl nt f ai i f, M EM O M N D U M O PI I N N O V. BO TET O U R T C O U N TY JA I L, De e f ndant s. By:Sam ue G .W is n l lo U nie St e D i t i Judge t d at s s r ct Thi i a a i purua t 42U. C.j1 3byJ m M ihae Huds aVigni i t s s n cton s nt o S. 98 ol c l on, r i a nmae pr e i oc ed ngpr s a i tt Bott t t y J l Thee iey ofHuds sc am i a f lows o e, gans he e our Comt ai. ntr t on' l i s s o l : t e il fme c l e vc s t j id co s i Ic u dtxmya m wh n lg t u .I d()b dta t r n a o dia s r ie- he al o tr ad o l i r e e o t ha a a r f k wrc t tc us dt eij r ' Bywa o r d e s Hu s ns e d ma e a da ij n to o d rng e k ha a e h nu y. ' y f e r s, d o e ks a g s n n nu cin r ei m e ca team e a t dimi s lofhi c i i lc r .Bec us Huds hasf l t saea ca m di l r t nt nd he s s a s rm na ha ges a e on aied o tt li t rle a ns apa t a na et s tunde j 1 t c tdimis Huds sco an wihout o eif gai t ry me bl o ui r 983,he our s ses on' mplit t P eu ie rj d c . A compl ntm us a l e ç noug f t t sa eacl m t r le t ti plusbl on is ai t leg t e h ac s o tt ai o e if ha s a i e t fce' Ginatnov. ol on,5 F. 298,302(t Ci. a .' a a J ms 21 3d 4h r 2008)(uoi BelAt. . q tng l lCop v. Two l , 5 U. 5 4 5 0( 0 :.Tosaeac u eo a to u d rj 1 8 , p an ifmu t mb y 5 0 S. 4 , 7 20 7 tt a s f cin n e 9 3 a litf s aleg f t i c tng t tpli ifha be n de i d ofrght g r nt e by t Consiu i n or l e ac s ndia i ha a ntf s e prve i s ua a e d he tt to lwsoft Unie St esa t tt sde i ton r s t fom co a he t d at nd ha hi prva i e uled r nduc c t omm itd by ape s te r on aci unde c orofsaelw.W es v. ki ,487U. 42, ( 988) Thoug t fmii tng r ol tt a t At ns S. 48 1 . h he n lar nle ofpl a ng a e g e ty r a d f pr s pl i if ,s e Be ls e di r r a l el xe oï o e a ntf s e aude tv. w ofH a pt n,775 t Ci m o F. 1 1 2d 274, 277-78( h Ci.1985) diti c t aer quiedt rviw prs rc ai s 4t r , srct ours r e r o e e ione ompl nt andm us et rtdentf c z bl cli so dim ist c t ihe s iy ogni a e am r s s he ompl nt...i t compl i ... i ai f he ant fist saeacli uponwhihr ifma begrntd. j1 A( . al o tt am c ele y a e ' 915 b) ' Hee Hu s nh salg dan ns e i ij r t hi am t t nu n me j i d co h s r , d o a le e o p ct nu y o s r ha a n a d al o t r a k de lne t tea f rs euns cii r a on.Huds ofe sno f t r ar ngt naur or ci d o r t o om pe fed e s on f r acs eg di he t e e tn o hi alg dij r ,hete t n r q ie , ra yo h rd t i o h sc ni e n o xe t f s l e n u y t r ame t e urd o n t e eal f i o fn me t r e s me ia c r.Eve i Hu s nh do frdt s f cs h h ss e aj i, ihi n t t ro ' dcl ae n f d o a fee ho e a t, e a u d alwh c s o a t s n' pe s b e t os i u d rj 1 8 .Se W il M ih. p'o Stt Poie 4 U. 5 , ( 9 9 u j c t ut n e 9 3 e l v. c De t f ae l , 91 S. 8 71 1 8 ) c ( () c mmo u a e t tnn te s n' o sn ticud tes v r in,a d saue e lyn Cln o n s g ,he e p ro d e o n l e h o e eg (n ) tt ts mpo ig 1 t ( d)aeodi rl c t e t e udei.)(ntm a quottonmakso te ( i he wor r r naiy onsnld o xcl t' i e l ai ' r mitd) quotng W i o v. haTrb , 42U. 6 3, 6 ( 9 9 ) Prv lv Re o, 3F.d 8 ( t Ci. 0 0 l n Oma i e 4 s S. 5 6 7 1 7 ); e a . n 20 3 214 h r 2 0 ) (a l d cso )(fimi t edsrc c u tsj 1 1 A ds sa o teg o dta aj ii t o tbe e iin afr ng h itit o r' 9 5 imis l n h r un h t al s i t n aûe s n' a dte eo eno n n bl t s i u d rj 1 8 ) An e e i tej iwee p ro ' n h r f r t me a e o ut n e 9 3 . d, v n f h al r ' n na et s tunde j 1 i or t pr t tagove n ntle iyi la ef a me bl o ui r 983,n der o ove ha r me a ntt s ibl or c tt i vi ain u rj 1 apli ifmus s t tt e iy' polc wa the onsiutonal olto nde 983, antf t how ha he ntt s iy s û t movi f c oft consiutonalvi aton. SeePol Cn v.v. ng or e he tt i ol i ' ' k t Dods 454 U. 31 326 on, S. 2, ( 9 ) Hu s nh sn ts mu ha me to e aj ipoiy, c ls l k da yj ip lc t 1 81. d o a o o c s n in d al l mu h e s i e n al o iy o c n hi aleg d deni ofme ca ca e.Acc di y,hec t l dim isHuds sc pli s l e al di l r or ngl t our wil s s on' om ant wih u p eudc p ru n t j 1 1 A. t o t rj ie u s a t o 9 5 Thece k i diecedt s nd ac oft smemor ndum opi on a t a ompa ng lr s r t o e opy hi a ni nd he cc nyi o de t t pl i if r r o he a ntf . . .? . EN TER :O c obe 3,201 t r 2. < .. .. p g e a UN I TED STA TES D I STRI J DG E CT U 2