Daniels v. Roanoke Glass Shop Inc., No. 7:2012cv00465 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 10/9/12. (eot)
Download PDF
CLERKS OFFI L. DI . CE JS. ST COURI AT ROANOKE, VA FIED L I TH E UNITED STATES DI N STRICT CO URT FO R TH E W ESTER N D I STR I T O F V I G I A C R M R O A N O K E DI I O N V SI C H A R LE S H EZ EK IA H D A N IEL S, JR . , 22T 29 2 1 22 JULI C. A BY: DE L ERK . L ER C i lA ct on N o.7: v00465 vi i 12c Pl nti , ai ff M EM O M N D U M O PI IO N N V. ROANOKE G LASS SH OP, NC. l , By:Sam ue G . is l W l on Unied Stat Di t ctJudge t es s ri De e f ndant . Plitf, a lsHe e ihDa il, r, Vign actz np o e dn pr s a di o ma anif Ch re z ka nes J.a r ii iie r c e ig o e n nf r pau i ,f l t sci la ton ag ns hi f m e e pl er Roa pers ied hi vi c i ai t s or r m oy , noke Gl s Shop,l as nc. co ai ng a mpl ni bouthi empl m e a tr i ton.Da el cai t tRoa s oy nt nd e m nai ni s l ms ha noke Gls as t r i t d hi f beng lt t wor butt tot re oye sc e m na e m or i ae o k, ha he mpl e omm it d wor ei r tonsa te s nfaci nd t tt r a e o he non- pe fe m otves f hi t m i ton.D a e sdoesnota l t ha he e r t r s cii d i or s er na i ni l lege he j iditona bassofhi cl ms a t c tdic r n plusbl f r lcli t r if urs ci l i s ai , nd he our s ens o a i e ede a am o ele . Co s q e ty tec u t s se Da es c mp an wi o t rj dc . n e u n l,h o r dimis s nil' o lit t u p eu ie h Fe r Rul ofCi lPr e ze8a ( rqukesaihor a pl nsae toft cli deal e vi oc dlr ()2) e s t nd ai ttmen he am s s ngt tt pla i e il t r if' Fe R.Ci P.8()2 .Plrua t 28U. C. howi ha he e der s ntted o ele ' d. v. a() zs nt o S. j 1 1 ()2 ( (i, c u's alit n t 'dimisa i o mapau rsc mpliti içal 9 5 e ()B)i a o l h lû a y i ' s s n nf r ) t a me pe i o an f tç i fs t sat a c ai upon whi r le m a be g a t d. The c t o te lm ch e i f y r ne ' ' our consr spr s com pl nt tue o e ai s lbealy,i i tl ssrnge sa r t nf mal e di drfedbylwyes' Seet. i r l mposng ûes ti nt tnda ds ha or pla ngs at a r. ' d o (nt na quottonmaksa cttonomit ) Ev siltac antmus conti s fcin i er l ai r nd iai ted . en tl,û ompli t an ufi e t f c ua m ater a e ed a t ue,t i t t a cl m ofr i ft ti pl usbl on is f c '' A s r t a t l t , cc pt s r o s a e ai ele ha s a i e t a e.' hc of v.I l556U. 662,678( qba, S. 2009)( i BelAt.Co p. Twombl 550U. 5 570 quotng l l r v. v, S. 44, . ( 0 ); e as At e tnv D. Ofkeo Ma pr 5 7F.d6 2, 81 2 ( C. r 2 0 ) 20 7) s e lo h ro . C. t f y , 6 3 7 6 -8 D. Ci. 0 9 (tWhiepr s c antjmus behedt ls srnge sa r t fr pladi l)... tg l o e ompli s t l o e s ti nt tndads han o mal e ngs, e n apr s c pl i tm us pl a f t m a t rt tpe m ist co tt i e m or t n t ve o e om a nan t e d ac ual te ha r t he ur o nf r e ha he meeposi lt ofmiconduc.'(ntr lquottonmaksa ciai omit . r sbiiy s t' i ena ) ai r nd ttons ted) Da el alege t tot re oy sofRoanokeGl sled t hi bos a ni s l s ha he mpl ee as i o s s boutDa el out ni s o j ao ya dh te a dta ti lde e tal t hstr n to Healg sh ha a f e lus n ard, n h t h s e v nu l o i emiain. l e e d y e m e tng w ih hi e pl rt di c st st ton b t tt ale ha as m e di notc s , ei t s m oye o s us he iua i ut ha he l ged r s nt d ea e hi pay w a c , hi i ur nc be ft we e d e H i alega i gi no hi ofa s s ut and s ns a e ne is r eni d. s l tons ve nt dic ni e f r lcl m f r i 1 tal a pl us bl one. Ra he , he c tonl i a e t s er bl ede a ai or elef e one a i e t r t our y s bl o c udet tDa el i un ppy wih hi f me empl err gar ng t c tonsofhi oncl ha ni s s ha t s or r oy e di he ondii s e pl e and hi t m i ton. W hie t pl di r e do noti pos a e tng sanda d m oym nt s er na i l he ea ng ul s m e n xac i t r on Dani l ,he m us of e s e f t d on whi h Roa es t f r om oo hol c noke G l s c d bas a a we o on a s oul e n ns r r whihtec u t o d b s aj d me t c r igy tec u t ldimisDa il' o an c h o r c ul a e u g n .Ac o dn l,h o r wi s s nes c mplit l ) u i 1 wi o t rj dc p rua t o2 U.. j 1 5e ()B)i frfi r t saeagam. t u p eu ie u s n t 8 SC. 91 ()2 ( (i o al e o tt h EN TER : c obe 9,201 O t r 2. * , '. ',. '' . .' v' ., U NI TED STA TES D I STRI J DG E CT U lM or ove , tefd rl o rsaec u t o l tdj rs ito .çl e p seso yt t o ra t rzd e r h e ea c ut r o rs fi e uidcin ç- y o s s nl ha p we uhoie mi -h b ( eUntdSae)Co si to o asaue whc i n tt b e p n e b j iil e re l it b peu d y t ie tts ntt in r ttt, ih s o o e x a d d y udca d ce . ts o e rs me h u t t c u el so tieti I tdj rs ito a dteb r e o etbihngtec nrl r ssu o t p ry ha a a s i usd hs i e u idcin n h u d n f sa ls i h o ta' et p n he at e mi y asrigjrs ito . Kp k n nv Guada Liels Co o Am.51 U.. 7 , 7 (9 4 (i to so te ) set u idcin' k o e . rin f n . . f , 1 S 3 5 3 7 1 9 ) ct in mi d . n ' a t 2