Hairston v. New River Valley Regional Jail et al, No. 7:2012cv00460 - Document 11 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/19/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
C ERKS OFFI U,. DS O URT CE S ST. AT R- OKE,V A FI LED I TH E U NI N TED STA TES D I STR I T C O UR T C FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A RO AN O K E D I ISI N V O JAM ES JERR Y H AIR STO N , CA SE N O .7: V 00460 12C 021 1b 2 1 22 BJ L+T. / , *K U . ; R Pl ntif ai f , M EM O R AND U M O PI I N N O VS. N EW RIV ER V A LL EY R EG IO NA L JA I , L By: G l E.C onrad en C hi fUnie St e D it i tJudge e t d at s s r c c K , Dee fndants. t) J m esJ r y H a r t a Vigi a i a e pr e di pr K , ie t s c vi r g s a ton a er i son, r ni nm t oc e ng o f l d hi i l i ht c i . p ru n t 4 U. C.j1 8 , le igta j io fcash v s be tdhi t o eco iga d u s a t o 2 S. 9 3 algn h t al fiil a e u j ce m o v rr wdn n i de t m e c lc r a de ed hi a es t a pr ry pur has d l w book, n vi a i n of na qua e di a a e nd ni m cc s o ope l c e a i ol to hi c tt i nalr g s A fe r e ofHais on' co pl i ,t c ts m a iy dim i s s s ons iuto i ht . tr evi w r t s m a nt he our um rl s s e t a tonwihoutprj cef fiu et saeacam. he ci t eudi or alr o tt li Hart ni ic reae a teNe Rie ValyRe in l al ih j i' i Du i iso s n ac rtd t h w v r le go a J i (te al) n bl û ' n, Vigna Hart nalg st ttej i i o rr wd d tet ie fcl isa eif se wi fis r ii. iso le e ha h al s veco e ;h olt a ite r n e td t le i h a d de ii bl ve m i ' nd s i ofur ne one s al srk m us s r e 54 o m or m e i one nd i uni ntfa e r n' a tnk i ; m l il t ev r e nn housng uni, t ts rk i o t n c a i t d w ih bl od, r f i t and ha it s f e ont m na e t o hai, ood,a ot s t nc ; nd her ubs a es ofk i sdo notcl a t s pa a e s t al e n he e r t howe a l vat y a e i t hous ng unisw ih s fc e r nd a or r as n he i t t ufi i nt fe u n y;al fi il d n tp o i eimae wi ce nnggo e o a e u t ce nn r q e c j io tcas o o r v d n ts t la i lv s r d q ae la ig h p o ucs ar o n d sa e s ra çn a ty'h o g tej i a dnos lvesi t ej i' r d t; ib r e ie s s p e d s mp n l'tr u h h al n ie e l n h als r ; do m sar t ea o bl ' I a e who ha be n s nt nce t t o t t ve yea si prs r el unr s na e.' nm t s ve e e e d o w o i r n i on r i i a c rtda t j i frt s lnghypei ,be a eVigi aDe rme tof eman nc r eae t he al o he e e t rods c us r ni pat n Coredins(t r o ç VDOC' fcltesaeoverr ed.I r s et Haison' giva a ut ' a iii r ) cowd n epons o rt s re nce bo t s c n iins aj i o fca rs o d dta tej i me i s e t nb t eVDOC a t e he e o dto , al fiil e p n e h t h al t n p ci y h o nd h Vigi aDe t tofHe lh(t r ni parmen at I VADH' i 201 ' n 2. ) Hart nas c mpli ta j io f ash v n t r v d da p o raef lo u c r iso lo o ans h t al fkil a e o p o i e p r p it ol w p ae frsrousij i herc ve i ave cec lsonbeor hi i re ai J i ofiil di o ei n ures e ei d n hil olii f e s ncac r ton. al fcas d no pe f m anyhe lh s r e ng onHar t n,d d no obti hi m e c lr c dsuntlJ y 1 t ror at c e ni iso i t an s di a e or i ul , 201 a i e hi c pl nt a tG r a ed a e s a ot d hi a 2, nd gnor d s om ai s bou i ni t r a r m he s bdom e ' W he H a r t n.' n i son fl d a k m er nc m e c lr ues f m ' i Se e be 201 c pl i ng ofe m c a i pa n ie n t e ge y di a eq t or ' n pt m r 2, om a ni xc i tng i a s e lng a ound hi abdo e he di notr c ve a i m e a e m e ca a t nto nd w li r s m n, d e ei ny m di t di l t e i n. Fial, iso c mpan t a a trh sfmiyc mp idwi al e u ai n t p ya n l Hartn o lis h t fe i a l o le t i rg lto s o a y hj p b ih rt s n Hartn a1w b o a tej i, fiil teefie t d lv rt eb o t u ls e o e d iso a o k th al o fcas h r ald o eie h o k o H a r t U li a e y, f c al r t ne t book t t publs . is on. tm t l ofi i s e ur d he o he iher Asd f n a t i t i a to , iso n me o l t ji,heVDOC, n t eVADH. ee d n s n h s cin Hart n a s ny he alt ad h Hart ns e c mpe s tr a p ntv d ma e a dij n tv rle, r e igta t iso e ks o n aoy nd u iie n g s n n u ci e eif o d rn h t he of e ng housng a e be cl ed. f ndi i r as os 11 Tosaeaca eofa tonunde j1 apl nifmus etbls t thehasbe n tt us ci r 983, aitf t sa ih ha e de i ofr ght gua a e d by t Co tt i o l w soft Unie St t a t tt s prved i s r nt e he ns iuton r a he t d a es nd ha hi de i ton r ule f om c nduc c m it d by a pe s a tng unde col ofs a e l . W e t prva i es t d r o t om te r on c i r or t t aw s v. ki , 7U. 42( 988) Thec ti r q rdt dimisa ato o cam fldbya At ns 48 S. 1 . our s e uie o s s ny cin r li ie pr s r a i ta go r e a e iy o ofi i li t c tde e m i st tt ac i orc ai i one ga ns ve nm nt l ntt r fc a f he our t r ne ha he ton lm i f i ous m a i i ,orf ist s a e a c ai on whi h r le m ay be gr nt d. 28 U . C. s rvol , lc ous al o tt l m c e if a e S. j1 5A( ( ) 91 b)1. 2 Th j i i no at ro 'a di teeo en ta n bet s i u d rj 1 8 .P e a v. e al s t û s n' n s h r fr o me a l o u t n e 9 3 r v l pe Re 203F. 821 2000W L 20591 a *1( hCi.2000)(mpubls d)( i W ilv. no, 3d , , t 4t r t ihe quotng l M ihianDe tofStt Polce 491U. 58,71( 98 ) The eor,t c t s s e al c g p' ae i , S. 1 9). r f e he our dimis s l camsa an ttej i, n e j1 5 b)1 , slg l fi oo s1 li g is h alu d r 91 A( ( ) a e al rv lu . y Haisonas hasnoacina ej1 3cam a ns t ohe dee nt heha na rt lo to bl 98 li gai t he t r fnda s s med: t VDOC a t VADH.l i wels tl t tasaec no bes dunderj 1 he nd he t s l eted ha tt nn t ue 983. W il491 l, U. a 71(iNl ihe aStt norisofi asa tngi t rofkilc pa te aet rons S. t ûg et r ae t tcil ci n hei t a a ciis r pes ' t rj 1 ' .Thi r ea iskoSttsorg r me ale iist tar c i rd û ms mde 983.) s ul pple t ae ' t ove n nt ntte ha e onsdee ar oft St t f El ve h Am e he a e' or e nt ndme pur e .'J. a 70.Thus t VDOC a t VADH,a nt pos s' -, t ds , he nd he s a nce o t Commonwe 1h ofVigi a c tbes dt rj1 a t co tmus ge is f he at r ni, anno ue mde 983, nd he ur t dimisHart scamsa i tt m unde j1 5A( ( ) asl lyfi ous s s ison' li gans he r 91 b)1, egal rvol . Be a s Hartnn me n d fn a t i t slws twh aes be tt s i u d r c u e iso n s o ee d n s n hi a ui o r u j c o ut n e j1 8 ,hec u t l sl rl ds s tee tr a to wi u p eudc .Ana p o rae 9 3 t o r wil l mma i imis h nie cin t t rj ie y ho p r p it or rw ili s t sday. de l s ue hi The Cl r i di e t t s nd c esoft sm e or ndum o ni a a c pa ng e k s r c ed o e opi hi m a pi on nd c om nyi or rt pl i if de o a ntf . EN TER : Th s tq 4 day ofoct r 2012. i obe , Chi fU nied St t D i ti tJ e t a es sr c udge 1 Haison alo f l t alege f ssatng an ac i r t s ais o l act t i tonabl Ei h Am endmentcl m conce ng e ght ai rni t al on to h c a lng s b c u eh d sn tale f css gg si t the pe s nal h s hej ic diins e h le e , e a s e oe o lge a t u e tng ha , ro ly, a s fr d o i lk l t s fe,a ys ro o sg f n ij r fo t s c dii s Se Sh k v. ufe e , r s iey o u fr n eius r inika t n u y r m he e on ton . e a ka Smih 71F.d 1 2,1 6( t Ci.1 95 . t, 3 6 6 4h r 9 ) 3