Hairston v. New River Valley Regional Jail et al, No. 7:2012cv00460 - Document 11 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/19/2012. (tvt)

Download PDF
C ERKS OFFI U,. DS O URT CE S ST. AT R- OKE,V A FI LED I TH E U NI N TED STA TES D I STR I T C O UR T C FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A RO AN O K E D I ISI N V O JAM ES JERR Y H AIR STO N , CA SE N O .7: V 00460 12C 021 1b 2 1 22 BJ L+T. / , *K U . ; R Pl ntif ai f , M EM O R AND U M O PI I N N O VS. N EW RIV ER V A LL EY R EG IO NA L JA I , L By: G l E.C onrad en C hi fUnie St e D it i tJudge e t d at s s r c c K , Dee fndants. t) J m esJ r y H a r t a Vigi a i a e pr e di pr K , ie t s c vi r g s a ton a er i son, r ni nm t oc e ng o f l d hi i l i ht c i . p ru n t 4 U. C.j1 8 , le igta j io fcash v s be tdhi t o eco iga d u s a t o 2 S. 9 3 algn h t al fiil a e u j ce m o v rr wdn n i de t m e c lc r a de ed hi a es t a pr ry pur has d l w book, n vi a i n of na qua e di a a e nd ni m cc s o ope l c e a i ol to hi c tt i nalr g s A fe r e ofHais on' co pl i ,t c ts m a iy dim i s s s ons iuto i ht . tr evi w r t s m a nt he our um rl s s e t a tonwihoutprj cef fiu et saeacam. he ci t eudi or alr o tt li Hart ni ic reae a teNe Rie ValyRe in l al ih j i' i Du i iso s n ac rtd t h w v r le go a J i (te al) n bl û ' n, Vigna Hart nalg st ttej i i o rr wd d tet ie fcl isa eif se wi fis r ii. iso le e ha h al s veco e ;h olt a ite r n e td t le i h a d de ii bl ve m i ' nd s i ofur ne one s al srk m us s r e 54 o m or m e i one nd i uni ntfa e r n' a tnk i ; m l il t ev r e nn housng uni, t ts rk i o t n c a i t d w ih bl od, r f i t and ha it s f e ont m na e t o hai, ood,a ot s t nc ; nd her ubs a es ofk i sdo notcl a t s pa a e s t al e n he e r t howe a l vat y a e i t hous ng unisw ih s fc e r nd a or r as n he i t t ufi i nt fe u n y;al fi il d n tp o i eimae wi ce nnggo e o a e u t ce nn r q e c j io tcas o o r v d n ts t la i lv s r d q ae la ig h p o ucs ar o n d sa e s ra çn a ty'h o g tej i a dnos lvesi t ej i' r d t; ib r e ie s s p e d s mp n l'tr u h h al n ie e l n h als r ; do m sar t ea o bl ' I a e who ha be n s nt nce t t o t t ve yea si prs r el unr s na e.' nm t s ve e e e d o w o i r n i on r i i a c rtda t j i frt s lnghypei ,be a eVigi aDe rme tof eman nc r eae t he al o he e e t rods c us r ni pat n Coredins(t r o ç VDOC' fcltesaeoverr ed.I r s et Haison' giva a ut ' a iii r ) cowd n epons o rt s re nce bo t s c n iins aj i o fca rs o d dta tej i me i s e t nb t eVDOC a t e he e o dto , al fiil e p n e h t h al t n p ci y h o nd h Vigi aDe t tofHe lh(t r ni parmen at I VADH' i 201 ' n 2. ) Hart nas c mpli ta j io f ash v n t r v d da p o raef lo u c r iso lo o ans h t al fkil a e o p o i e p r p it ol w p ae frsrousij i herc ve i ave cec lsonbeor hi i re ai J i ofiil di o ei n ures e ei d n hil olii f e s ncac r ton. al fcas d no pe f m anyhe lh s r e ng onHar t n,d d no obti hi m e c lr c dsuntlJ y 1 t ror at c e ni iso i t an s di a e or i ul , 201 a i e hi c pl nt a tG r a ed a e s a ot d hi a 2, nd gnor d s om ai s bou i ni t r a r m he s bdom e ' W he H a r t n.' n i son fl d a k m er nc m e c lr ues f m ' i Se e be 201 c pl i ng ofe m c a i pa n ie n t e ge y di a eq t or ' n pt m r 2, om a ni xc i tng i a s e lng a ound hi abdo e he di notr c ve a i m e a e m e ca a t nto nd w li r s m n, d e ei ny m di t di l t e i n. Fial, iso c mpan t a a trh sfmiyc mp idwi al e u ai n t p ya n l Hartn o lis h t fe i a l o le t i rg lto s o a y hj p b ih rt s n Hartn a1w b o a tej i, fiil teefie t d lv rt eb o t u ls e o e d iso a o k th al o fcas h r ald o eie h o k o H a r t U li a e y, f c al r t ne t book t t publs . is on. tm t l ofi i s e ur d he o he iher Asd f n a t i t i a to , iso n me o l t ji,heVDOC, n t eVADH. ee d n s n h s cin Hart n a s ny he alt ad h Hart ns e c mpe s tr a p ntv d ma e a dij n tv rle, r e igta t iso e ks o n aoy nd u iie n g s n n u ci e eif o d rn h t he of e ng housng a e be cl ed. f ndi i r as os 11 Tosaeaca eofa tonunde j1 apl nifmus etbls t thehasbe n tt us ci r 983, aitf t sa ih ha e de i ofr ght gua a e d by t Co tt i o l w soft Unie St t a t tt s prved i s r nt e he ns iuton r a he t d a es nd ha hi de i ton r ule f om c nduc c m it d by a pe s a tng unde col ofs a e l . W e t prva i es t d r o t om te r on c i r or t t aw s v. ki , 7U. 42( 988) Thec ti r q rdt dimisa ato o cam fldbya At ns 48 S. 1 . our s e uie o s s ny cin r li ie pr s r a i ta go r e a e iy o ofi i li t c tde e m i st tt ac i orc ai i one ga ns ve nm nt l ntt r fc a f he our t r ne ha he ton lm i f i ous m a i i ,orf ist s a e a c ai on whi h r le m ay be gr nt d. 28 U . C. s rvol , lc ous al o tt l m c e if a e S. j1 5A( ( ) 91 b)1. 2 Th j i i no at ro 'a di teeo en ta n bet s i u d rj 1 8 .P e a v. e al s t û s n' n s h r fr o me a l o u t n e 9 3 r v l pe Re 203F. 821 2000W L 20591 a *1( hCi.2000)(mpubls d)( i W ilv. no, 3d , , t 4t r t ihe quotng l M ihianDe tofStt Polce 491U. 58,71( 98 ) The eor,t c t s s e al c g p' ae i , S. 1 9). r f e he our dimis s l camsa an ttej i, n e j1 5 b)1 , slg l fi oo s1 li g is h alu d r 91 A( ( ) a e al rv lu . y Haisonas hasnoacina ej1 3cam a ns t ohe dee nt heha na rt lo to bl 98 li gai t he t r fnda s s med: t VDOC a t VADH.l i wels tl t tasaec no bes dunderj 1 he nd he t s l eted ha tt nn t ue 983. W il491 l, U. a 71(iNl ihe aStt norisofi asa tngi t rofkilc pa te aet rons S. t ûg et r ae t tcil ci n hei t a a ciis r pes ' t rj 1 ' .Thi r ea iskoSttsorg r me ale iist tar c i rd û ms mde 983.) s ul pple t ae ' t ove n nt ntte ha e onsdee ar oft St t f El ve h Am e he a e' or e nt ndme pur e .'J. a 70.Thus t VDOC a t VADH,a nt pos s' -, t ds , he nd he s a nce o t Commonwe 1h ofVigi a c tbes dt rj1 a t co tmus ge is f he at r ni, anno ue mde 983, nd he ur t dimisHart scamsa i tt m unde j1 5A( ( ) asl lyfi ous s s ison' li gans he r 91 b)1, egal rvol . Be a s Hartnn me n d fn a t i t slws twh aes be tt s i u d r c u e iso n s o ee d n s n hi a ui o r u j c o ut n e j1 8 ,hec u t l sl rl ds s tee tr a to wi u p eudc .Ana p o rae 9 3 t o r wil l mma i imis h nie cin t t rj ie y ho p r p it or rw ili s t sday. de l s ue hi The Cl r i di e t t s nd c esoft sm e or ndum o ni a a c pa ng e k s r c ed o e opi hi m a pi on nd c om nyi or rt pl i if de o a ntf . EN TER : Th s tq 4 day ofoct r 2012. i obe , Chi fU nied St t D i ti tJ e t a es sr c udge 1 Haison alo f l t alege f ssatng an ac i r t s ais o l act t i tonabl Ei h Am endmentcl m conce ng e ght ai rni t al on to h c a lng s b c u eh d sn tale f css gg si t the pe s nal h s hej ic diins e h le e , e a s e oe o lge a t u e tng ha , ro ly, a s fr d o i lk l t s fe,a ys ro o sg f n ij r fo t s c dii s Se Sh k v. ufe e , r s iey o u fr n eius r inika t n u y r m he e on ton . e a ka Smih 71F.d 1 2,1 6( t Ci.1 95 . t, 3 6 6 4h r 9 ) 3

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.