Harris v. SWVRJA Abingdon Facility, No. 7:2012cv00446 - Document 8 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/19/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' OF CEu.. r . tv S FI : U! * ! ATRoANoe , VA FI LED 02T 1! 2 1 22 I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W E STER N D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A ROANOKE DI I ON V SI CLY D E AL LE N H A R R IS, ,'!J. * u:...z % é. .t1 ' 2 1CC. * .V . .$ ' - i CA SE N O .7: V00446 12C Pl ntf ai if, M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI VS. SW VR JA AB I G D O N , N By: G l E.C onrad en Chi Unied St e D i t i tJudge ef t at s s r c Defendant . Cl A le H a s a V i gi a i a e pr ee ng pr K , i e t s c vi r ght a ton yde l n ni , r ni nm t oc di o t l d hi i l i s c i . purua tt 42 U. C.j1 3,ale ngt thehasnotr eveda opraemedialteame i s n o S. 98 lgi ha ec i ppr it c r t nt n j i,nvilto o h sc n ttto a rg t.Afe rviw o Harssc mplit t c u t ali oain f i o si in l ih s tr e e f ri' o an,he o r u s mmai ds s e t ea to wih u p eu ief rfit et saeacam. u rl imis s h ci n t o t rj dc o alt o tt li y r I H a rs i i a c a ed a t Sout e t r V i g ni Regi lJ i Aut iy f c lt i r i s nc r er t t he hw s e n r i a ona a l hort a iiy n Abn d n(û ej i'. Harsalg st a hep tn likc ls'o t we k o mo ebeo e ig o çh al' 1 ri l e h t u i t c al'f r wo e s r r f r t ) e s ge tng a a t i n ppoi m e w ih t doc oron J 1 201 H a t d t doc ort the w a û n a nt nt t he t une 3, 2. nis ol he t ha sl i 1 ofpana ...houghtma be( lha brkenhi)pi l e. W he heas f a x-a ot i nd t y he d o l s ns oos ' ' n ked or n ry, t doc ors i no, ihouteve c ki H a r s a pr crbe pai m e ca i f hi . Ha rs he t a d wt n hec ng r i , nd es i d n di ton or m ri tl d agre nce sa i t tt docorhad no pr ry e m i d hi a a ki t be s e by ie i va , t tng ha he t t ope l xa ne m nd s ng o en a outi docor butnoonearng a outi c ulai f Ha s Thej i doco ltr n sde t , ra ed n sde ons tton or ni . al tr ae or r d a x- a and t tr ulsw e e nonna . de e n r y es es t r l Ha rsalo fl asc c l r ques,satng t the ha s t on hi ha a i a r i ri s ied ik a l e t t i ha d po s s nds nd s fa d t y m i htbe ca r . W he nur ese m i d Ha r s i t m e c luni o J y 24,201 he g nce ous n s xn ne r i n he di a t n ul 2, 1 Har i f ualalega i appeari hi com pl ntand i t grevancesa t rs' act l tons n s ai n he i tached t hi ve fed o s rii sae nt( Nos 1& 7) ttme ECF . . t yl he aughe s i t s sw e e notc nce , nd t d H a rs t doc or û d, a d he pot r a r a ol r i he t s won' c c i.' H a r s t he k t' r i tl d mor g i va e t havet s sche ked f rc nce ,wih no r pons ie e re nc s o he pot c o a r t es e. Th o yd fnd n Harsna si t l vl Abng o 'ji.Harsd e n tsae e nl ee a t ri me s he k sW uA- i d n'al ri o s o tt t r le he s eks i t sac i he e i f e n hi ton. 11 Tosaeaca eofa tonunde j1 apl ntf mus esabls t theha be n tt us ci r 983, ai if t t ih ha s e de i d ofrght gua a ee by t Consiuton orlwsoft Unie St esa t tt s prve i s r nt d he tt i a he t d at nd ha hi de i t o r uled f o c prva i n es t r m onduc c m it d by a pe s n ac i t de col of sa e l w . W es t om te r o tng m r or t t a t v. ki ,48 U. 42( 988) Theco ti rquie t dimisa a tonorcli fldbya At ns 7 S. 1 . ur s e r d o s s ny ci am ie prs ionera i tagove m e a en iyorofii li t c tdee mi st tt a ton orc am gans m nt l tt fc a f he our tr ne ha he c i li i fi ous m alci ,orf ist s a e a c a m o whi h r le m a be gr ed. 28 U . C . s r vol , i ous al o t t l i n c ei f y ant S. j191 A( ( ) 5 b)1 . S algoveni bodi ... nbes ddiecl unde j1 3f moneay,de aat y, l Loc r ng es ca ue r ty r 98 or tr clr or o ij n tv rle whee. .h a to t a i alg dt beu c n t ui n li e nso r nu cie eif r . t e cin h t s l e o n o si to a mplme t r e t e ut a polcy s a em e ,or na ,r ul ton,orde i i ofi i ly a xec es i t t nt di nce eg a i c s on tc a l dopt d and e pr omul td by t tbod sofi e s' M one lv.Ne Yor Civ De . SocilSe vce , gae ha y' fc r . ' l w k t pt of a r i s 436 U. 6 8 6 0( 9 8 .Top o et a ag ve n n a e t y s c a alc l al i l bef r S. 5 , 9 1 7 ) r v h t o r me tl ni , u h s o a j i,s i l o t a co tt i lvi a i c mitd by ise oye s pl n ifm us s nsiutona oltons om te t mpl e , aitf t how t tt entt spolc ha he iy' iy w asd he m ovi f c oft co tt i lvi a i ' Pol Co v v.D ods n,454 U . 31 t t ng or e he ns iutona ol ton. ' k unt o S. 2, 3 (981 . 26 1 ) Ha i fist l k aj ip lc t a yo t ealg dd p i ai n .Ac o dngy p an if n s al o i al o iy o n f h l e e rv to s c r i l, litf n e fist saeacam uponwhihr le ma beg a eda i tt j i, teon1 defnda he al o tt li c eif y r nt gans he al2 h y e nt s si ti a to .Th r f r,hec u t ld s s t c mp an wi o t eu c .An ue n h s ci n ee o e t o r wil imis he o lit t u prj die h a opr a e or rw ili s t s da ppr i t de l s ue hi y. Fo tera o ssae ,h c u t imis sHarssc mplitwi u p eudc , u s n r h e s n ttd t e o r d s se ri' o an t t rj ie p rua t ho t j 1 1 A() 1,o f i et saeadam.TheClr i drde t sndc p e o t i o 9 5 b ( ) fr al o tt ur i ek s ie d o e o is f h s m e or ndum opi on a ac om pa ng or rt pl i if m a ni nd c nyi de o a ntf . c ENTER: Thi s h /, Xw ' : da ofOc obe , 2. y t r 201 4 , ,A . ' - /) .-t. Z , i (' ik l ? ' ! s 1 ., . : . / . . x. . . . / z -1 .. , Chi fUnied St t sDititJ e t a e src udge 2 Ha rssalg ton as fi t saea y a to bej 1 83cam a ans a yj i o fca. ri' le ai s lo a lo tt n cina l 9 li g i t n al fiil Har i f l t alege f t i ca i t a ofhi medi condii pr enta s i m edi ne f rs ais o l ac s ndi tng hat ny s cal tons es erous cal ed or difr n te t n t a wha t j i' me c lsa fha p o d dt hi ort a o fcasha a t wih fee t r ame t h n t he als dia tf s r vie o m, h t fiil ve ced t dei r t idifr n et hi n e .S eEsel v. mbl, 9 U. 97 1 2( 976 (idi ta t sae lbeae n fe e c o s e ds e t le Ga e 42 S. , 0 1 ) fn ng h t o tt Ei h Amendm e cl m ,i e mus s ght nt ai nmat t how pr s ofi alsdelbe at i fer i on fci ' i r e ndif ence t i ae' s i o nm t s erous me c l e ) W rg tv. lns 76 F. 8 , 49( t Ci.1 5 (idi ta i t sdia r e nt dia ne d ; ih Coli , 6 2d 41 8 4h r 98 ) fn ng h t nmae' s g e me w ih medi per onnelr di di t cal s egar ng agnosi a cour e ofteat e doesnoti i et Ei h s nd s r m nt mplcat he ght Ame me t.Ev n i Ha rsc ul s w t tt a lsme c lsa fha a tdne ie ty wihr g r t nd n) e f ri o d ho ha hej i' dia tf s ce glg n l t e a d o hi teat e ,of i al neglgentactonsdo notgi rs t any consiutonalcl m ac i s r m nt fci s' i i ve ie o tt i ai tonabl unde e r j 1 3.Esel, up a. 98 t le s r 3
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
