Harris v. SWVRJA Abingdon Facility, No. 7:2012cv00446 - Document 8 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/19/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
CLERK' OF CEu.. r . tv S FI : U! * ! ATRoANoe , VA FI LED 02T 1! 2 1 22 I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W E STER N D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A ROANOKE DI I ON V SI CLY D E AL LE N H A R R IS, ,'!J. * u:...z % é. .t1 ' 2 1CC. * .V . .$ ' - i CA SE N O .7: V00446 12C Pl ntf ai if, M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI VS. SW VR JA AB I G D O N , N By: G l E.C onrad en Chi Unied St e D i t i tJudge ef t at s s r c Defendant . Cl A le H a s a V i gi a i a e pr ee ng pr K , i e t s c vi r ght a ton yde l n ni , r ni nm t oc di o t l d hi i l i s c i . purua tt 42 U. C.j1 3,ale ngt thehasnotr eveda opraemedialteame i s n o S. 98 lgi ha ec i ppr it c r t nt n j i,nvilto o h sc n ttto a rg t.Afe rviw o Harssc mplit t c u t ali oain f i o si in l ih s tr e e f ri' o an,he o r u s mmai ds s e t ea to wih u p eu ief rfit et saeacam. u rl imis s h ci n t o t rj dc o alt o tt li y r I H a rs i i a c a ed a t Sout e t r V i g ni Regi lJ i Aut iy f c lt i r i s nc r er t t he hw s e n r i a ona a l hort a iiy n Abn d n(û ej i'. Harsalg st a hep tn likc ls'o t we k o mo ebeo e ig o çh al' 1 ri l e h t u i t c al'f r wo e s r r f r t ) e s ge tng a a t i n ppoi m e w ih t doc oron J 1 201 H a t d t doc ort the w a û n a nt nt t he t une 3, 2. nis ol he t ha sl i 1 ofpana ...houghtma be( lha brkenhi)pi l e. W he heas f a x-a ot i nd t y he d o l s ns oos ' ' n ked or n ry, t doc ors i no, ihouteve c ki H a r s a pr crbe pai m e ca i f hi . Ha rs he t a d wt n hec ng r i , nd es i d n di ton or m ri tl d agre nce sa i t tt docorhad no pr ry e m i d hi a a ki t be s e by ie i va , t tng ha he t t ope l xa ne m nd s ng o en a outi docor butnoonearng a outi c ulai f Ha s Thej i doco ltr n sde t , ra ed n sde ons tton or ni . al tr ae or r d a x- a and t tr ulsw e e nonna . de e n r y es es t r l Ha rsalo fl asc c l r ques,satng t the ha s t on hi ha a i a r i ri s ied ik a l e t t i ha d po s s nds nd s fa d t y m i htbe ca r . W he nur ese m i d Ha r s i t m e c luni o J y 24,201 he g nce ous n s xn ne r i n he di a t n ul 2, 1 Har i f ualalega i appeari hi com pl ntand i t grevancesa t rs' act l tons n s ai n he i tached t hi ve fed o s rii sae nt( Nos 1& 7) ttme ECF . . t yl he aughe s i t s sw e e notc nce , nd t d H a rs t doc or û d, a d he pot r a r a ol r i he t s won' c c i.' H a r s t he k t' r i tl d mor g i va e t havet s sche ked f rc nce ,wih no r pons ie e re nc s o he pot c o a r t es e. Th o yd fnd n Harsna si t l vl Abng o 'ji.Harsd e n tsae e nl ee a t ri me s he k sW uA- i d n'al ri o s o tt t r le he s eks i t sac i he e i f e n hi ton. 11 Tosaeaca eofa tonunde j1 apl ntf mus esabls t theha be n tt us ci r 983, ai if t t ih ha s e de i d ofrght gua a ee by t Consiuton orlwsoft Unie St esa t tt s prve i s r nt d he tt i a he t d at nd ha hi de i t o r uled f o c prva i n es t r m onduc c m it d by a pe s n ac i t de col of sa e l w . W es t om te r o tng m r or t t a t v. ki ,48 U. 42( 988) Theco ti rquie t dimisa a tonorcli fldbya At ns 7 S. 1 . ur s e r d o s s ny ci am ie prs ionera i tagove m e a en iyorofii li t c tdee mi st tt a ton orc am gans m nt l tt fc a f he our tr ne ha he c i li i fi ous m alci ,orf ist s a e a c a m o whi h r le m a be gr ed. 28 U . C . s r vol , i ous al o t t l i n c ei f y ant S. j191 A( ( ) 5 b)1 . S algoveni bodi ... nbes ddiecl unde j1 3f moneay,de aat y, l Loc r ng es ca ue r ty r 98 or tr clr or o ij n tv rle whee. .h a to t a i alg dt beu c n t ui n li e nso r nu cie eif r . t e cin h t s l e o n o si to a mplme t r e t e ut a polcy s a em e ,or na ,r ul ton,orde i i ofi i ly a xec es i t t nt di nce eg a i c s on tc a l dopt d and e pr omul td by t tbod sofi e s' M one lv.Ne Yor Civ De . SocilSe vce , gae ha y' fc r . ' l w k t pt of a r i s 436 U. 6 8 6 0( 9 8 .Top o et a ag ve n n a e t y s c a alc l al i l bef r S. 5 , 9 1 7 ) r v h t o r me tl ni , u h s o a j i,s i l o t a co tt i lvi a i c mitd by ise oye s pl n ifm us s nsiutona oltons om te t mpl e , aitf t how t tt entt spolc ha he iy' iy w asd he m ovi f c oft co tt i lvi a i ' Pol Co v v.D ods n,454 U . 31 t t ng or e he ns iutona ol ton. ' k unt o S. 2, 3 (981 . 26 1 ) Ha i fist l k aj ip lc t a yo t ealg dd p i ai n .Ac o dngy p an if n s al o i al o iy o n f h l e e rv to s c r i l, litf n e fist saeacam uponwhihr le ma beg a eda i tt j i, teon1 defnda he al o tt li c eif y r nt gans he al2 h y e nt s si ti a to .Th r f r,hec u t ld s s t c mp an wi o t eu c .An ue n h s ci n ee o e t o r wil imis he o lit t u prj die h a opr a e or rw ili s t s da ppr i t de l s ue hi y. Fo tera o ssae ,h c u t imis sHarssc mplitwi u p eudc , u s n r h e s n ttd t e o r d s se ri' o an t t rj ie p rua t ho t j 1 1 A() 1,o f i et saeadam.TheClr i drde t sndc p e o t i o 9 5 b ( ) fr al o tt ur i ek s ie d o e o is f h s m e or ndum opi on a ac om pa ng or rt pl i if m a ni nd c nyi de o a ntf . c ENTER: Thi s h /, Xw ' : da ofOc obe , 2. y t r 201 4 , ,A . ' - /) .-t. Z , i (' ik l ? ' ! s 1 ., . : . / . . x. . . . / z -1 .. , Chi fUnied St t sDititJ e t a e src udge 2 Ha rssalg ton as fi t saea y a to bej 1 83cam a ans a yj i o fca. ri' le ai s lo a lo tt n cina l 9 li g i t n al fiil Har i f l t alege f t i ca i t a ofhi medi condii pr enta s i m edi ne f rs ais o l ac s ndi tng hat ny s cal tons es erous cal ed or difr n te t n t a wha t j i' me c lsa fha p o d dt hi ort a o fcasha a t wih fee t r ame t h n t he als dia tf s r vie o m, h t fiil ve ced t dei r t idifr n et hi n e .S eEsel v. mbl, 9 U. 97 1 2( 976 (idi ta t sae lbeae n fe e c o s e ds e t le Ga e 42 S. , 0 1 ) fn ng h t o tt Ei h Amendm e cl m ,i e mus s ght nt ai nmat t how pr s ofi alsdelbe at i fer i on fci ' i r e ndif ence t i ae' s i o nm t s erous me c l e ) W rg tv. lns 76 F. 8 , 49( t Ci.1 5 (idi ta i t sdia r e nt dia ne d ; ih Coli , 6 2d 41 8 4h r 98 ) fn ng h t nmae' s g e me w ih medi per onnelr di di t cal s egar ng agnosi a cour e ofteat e doesnoti i et Ei h s nd s r m nt mplcat he ght Ame me t.Ev n i Ha rsc ul s w t tt a lsme c lsa fha a tdne ie ty wihr g r t nd n) e f ri o d ho ha hej i' dia tf s ce glg n l t e a d o hi teat e ,of i al neglgentactonsdo notgi rs t any consiutonalcl m ac i s r m nt fci s' i i ve ie o tt i ai tonabl unde e r j 1 3.Esel, up a. 98 t le s r 3