Hamlor v. Clarke, No. 7:2012cv00397 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 11/2/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STRI CO UR T CT FO R TH E W ESTE RN D I STRI T O F V I G I I C R N A R O AN O K E DI I O N V SI M ONTY E. AM LOR, H r FRK: OFFI t. DI cotR' d CE Is. ST. l r ATROANOKE, VA FI LED CASE NO.7: 2CV00 1 397 d0V 22 2 1 92 JUL BY: D DL 'L-7K C% FR 2 ' P Ol . FRR Pettoner. ii M EM O M ND U M O PI O N NI VS. H AR O LD W .CLA R K E,D I REC TO R , By: Jam e C.Tur s k Se or U ni e St e D i t i tJudge ni t d at s s r c R espondent . M on y E. m l ,aVigi ai t pr ce di pr K ,tl t saci asapeii f a t Ha or r ni nma e o e ng o sed hi ton tton or wrto ha a c pusunde 28U. C.j2254,algi t tVigni paol sautsaevoi f i f be s or r S. le ng ha r i a r e tt e r d or vag uene s i vi a i ofhi r g t due pr es ,b a e t y do notde i t c iera a s , n ol ton s i ht o oc s ec us he f ne he rt i n imaemus s tsyt beSounds t e'orpaol und rVa.CodeAnn.j53.- 3 Upon n t t aif o t f uiabl'f r e e 1 1 6. r vi w oft r co d,t c ttndst tt a i mus be s e e he e r he our i ha he cton t umm a iy dimis d be us rl s s e ca e Ha o ' al ai fi t saea cai f rle un rj225 1 mlrs leg tons al o tt ny l m or eif de 4. I H a l alege t f l i f c sr e ntt hi cl m . H a l pl ade guit i 1 m or l s he olow ng a t el va o s ai m or e d ly n 984 i t N or ol Cic tCour t c r ofbur a y,m alci w oundi a r l t d of e e , n he f k r ui t o ha ges gl r i ous ng, nd e a e f ns s a s ntnc d t lf i prs Ha o ha bee i a ce aedi t Vigi a De rme of nd e e e o ie n ion. ml r s n nc r r t n he r ni pa t nt Core tons(C rci tVDOC' ont ss tncefrmo et n28ye r ' hi ene o r ha ) as.TheVigi aPaol BoadCs r ni r e r t he Boad' hasrviwe Ha orf posi edicei r paol r e e1 tme .TheBoad r' ) e e d ml or sbl s rtonay r e elas 6 i s r c onduc e H a l ' m os r e par e r vi w o Oc ob r 1 2011 a on O c obe 27, 1 t d m or s t ec nt ol e e n t e 9, , nd t r 201 , 1 Unde Rul 4( o t Rue Gov r n j225 Ca e , t cour m a s a l dim isa r e b) f he ls enig 4 s s he t y umm riy s s j22 4peiin t ifipli y a a sfom tep tto a a ya tc de hiist t h p tton ri no 5 tto ç l t anl ppe r r h eiin nd n ta he x bt ha t e eii e s t g entted t r i i t dit i cour . il o elef n he srct t' ' Ha orr eve notcet tt Boa d di notfnd hi s t bl f rpa ol r l s . Ha l ha ml ec i d i ha he r d i m uia e o r e eea e m or s no prorf l ny co c i i eo nvi tons Ha l t l d a sa e habe c pus a ton i t N o f k Cic tCour on J 3 2011 m or i e tt as or c i n he r ol r ui t une 0, , No. 1 - 1 a r nty r i i t s mecli t ther i e i hi f der lpe ii The L- 1 51 2, ppa e l a sng he a a ms ha a s s n s e a tton. cr ui c tdim is d Ha orson Nove r1 2011 The Supr m eCour ofVigi a ic t our s s e ml ' mbe 7, . e t r ni dimis Ha orss eq nta lonM ac 1 201 unde Va.Sup.Ct Rul 5:7() s sed ml ' ubs ue ppea rh 9, 2, r . e 1 d, u n t Co ts fndi t tH a l f ie t pr de tm e y paym e a r qui e t pr ry po he ur ' i ng ha m or a l d o ovi i l nt s e r d o ope l pe fc hi a l Pe.Ex.ECFNo.12,p.2.. re t s ppea. t ( ) l hi j225 peii Ha orsae ashi s ecam:C n s 4 tton, ml tts s ol li C PROCESSVI DUE OLATI ON UNDER THE 5 HAND I T AM ENDM ENTg j s ee co e Pei o S ae n wih T 4H S . e n ls d tt n ttme t t i Me a mor ndum ofLa ' Pet 6. The C m ' . G STATEM ENT OF PETI ON'doesnots f t a TI ' et orh numbe e ls ofc am st tHa o s e t purue Li r ly c tung Hn o ' a lga ins r d it l i ha ml r e ks o s . be a l onsr i ml rs le to , how e r hi pe ii n a ar t a l ge t f l i g o ve , s tto ppe s o le he olow ng r unds f r le : or e i f Va Co eAl j5 .- 3 ()i v i f rv g e e sb c u ei d e n t . d m. 3 1 1 6 2 s od o a u n s e a s t o s o i i ih ntdeciiu dstal'f j rl,eut g n ri r n df etetn do nbyi be'rr aoersln i abtaya d eons t e' dons ut Boao n ns f i r nc se he d. 2. TheBoar r le on isown d i t d dic e i 'r t rt n de opi d e is t t mie s r ton,' a he ha vel ng unl a usng SGe a Rul 'i c nd i ç ner l es' n onduci hea i t detr i i tng rngs o e m ne f pe ii r i S uia e ' o pa o e ttone s ç t bl ' f r r l . s Ha l hasbee una et obt n ac oft E ne a Ruls' i ng m or n bl o ai opy he s Ge r l e 'defni t c ie i on w hi h t Boa d r le t de er i s t biiy f pa ol he r t r a c he r e i s o t m ne uia lt or r e. Hmnlrsae t a çh )d e no c aln et j d l e to hi c re tsn e c ( r t e o tts h td e o s t h le g he u g mln f s ur n e tn e o l h l d cso o t ep r l b a dt d n hm p r l.gljc aln e s t p o e u e whc h v e iin f h ao e o r o e y i a oe le h le g g) he r c d r s ih a e 1dt be vi t ti nota c da wih saea fdeallw.'Pe.St .2( No.1 1 p. e o ha or ha s c or nt t tt nd e r a ' t mt ECF -, 2 A san exa pI ofi it ol si , m e nconssentpar edeci ons Haml r f st VDOC I a eLan' Hayni or e er o nm t y e, a s cond tm eofender se enc i t 1 e i f , nt ed n he 980st t eelf se encespl 44year f m uli e ofense o hr ie nt us s or tpl f s, who wasr eas on dicr tona y par e i M a ch orAprl201 aferse vi onl 24 year ofhi el ed s ei r ol n r i 2, t r ng y s s s ences. ent 2 2..Asr l f Ha o s e d caao ya dij n tv rle dr ci gt a h r c i $ ) ei , mlr e ks e lrt r n nu cie eif ie tn h t e e eve $ e a r he i donei a co da e wih a i a e saut r lw . Pe .1 e arng n c r nc t pplc bl t t o y a ' t 5.Ha oras movesf ' ml lo or c rii to ofquesi of1 t t Sup e Cour ofVigi a,r ga di t sa e' pa ol e ttca in tons aw o he r me t r ni e r ng he tt s r e sautsa pr e es ( No. ) tt e nd oc dur . ECF 2. 11 Thi f r ldit i tco t% ha le e t i a a i a i f a w rtofha sco pus s ede a s r c ur t l nt r a n n pplc ton or s i bea r g d r2 U. C.j2 5 ) i b hafo ap ro i c so yp ru n t t ej dg n o aSae un e 8 S. 2 4 n e l f e s n n u t d u s a t o h u me t f tt c tonl on t g o t thei i cusod i vi a in oft Consiuto o lwsorteai s our v he r und ha s n t y n olto he tt i n r a r te oft Unie Stts' j225 a)(mpha i a d) Thedheese eofha ascor i a he td ae .' 4( e ss dde . û s nc t be pus s n a t k by a pe s n i c t upo t l lt oft tc t ' e s rv.Rodrcue 41 U . tac r o n us ody n he ega iy ha usody.'Pr i e i z, 1 S. 475, 4( 973) Cusodyc lnge i l a 48 1 . t hale s ncude, mongot r ,camst tt saut ofc viton he s li ha he tt e on ci i unc tt i l t tpe ii rw a de i d ofc tt i s ons iutona , ha ttone s prve ons iutonalpr t c i a ti l t t o e tons t r a , ha pe ii r spa ol w asunl w f l r voked,o t tpe ii nerw asil ly de i d o ea ne ttone ' r e a uly e r ha tto lega l prve f r d g c ood onduc c e t w hi h r s t d i a l rt r ofc i m ent I a 485- Any c a m t r di , c e ule n onge e m onfne . d. t 86. li co e ni t f c orlngt ofpeii r spr s ntorf ur co i m e f lse l i l i t nc r ng he a t e h ttone ' e e ut e nfne nt al xcusvey n he ha sar na.I a 487.Chale bea e d. t lngest pa ol pr e di , t o he ha whi h s e o r e oc e ngs on he t r nd, c e k i pl m e t ton ofne pa ol pr ed es butw hi h w o d notne s a iy r s ti t m e nai w r e oc ur , c ul ce s rl e ul n he peii rss e e r e efo c i me , notSi 1a Ghec eofha a c pus'' ttone' pe dir elas r m onfne ntdo deg t t or l be s or ,' W iki onv.Doton,5 U. 74,82( )( tngPr ie , 1U. a 48 .Se as l ns s 44 S. 2005 quoi es r 41 S. t 9) e lo Ski rv.Swiz rl3lS. .1 1 ( 1 (d- be si t e l i rmedy...f t nne te , Ct 289, 293 201 ) s l a s he xcusve e la or he prs ne whos e çmmedit ors e e r las fom c i me t' ( tngW iki on, io r e ks i ae pe dir ee e' r onfne n .) quoi ' l ns 5 U. a 82) 44 S. t . 3 Ha l ' cai sdo notas e t ha t f c o t s he ed d ai n ofhi c i me i m ors l m s r t t he a t r he c dul ur to s onfne nt s unl w f i a r s c . Ra he ,Ha l ' c ai s c e n t pr dur t Boa d utlze i a ul n ny e pe t t r m or s l m onc r he oce es he r ii s n c onduci par e ei biiy pr e ngsa s e c ng t t e pr edur so t t m a r tng ol lgi lt oce di nd e k ha es o hos oc e r o he nne i whihteBo r a p ise sigp o e u e .Th p o e u a fn i g o a j t nsHa o n c h a d p le xitn r c d r s e r c d r l id n s r dusme t mlr de ie wilnotne e s rl r s ti hi i pee e r e efom c i m e 'orde sr s l c s a iy e ul n s ç dir elas r s onfne nt' monsr t a ta e ny c tt i li im iy i hi c i i lcon c i n ors nt nc Be us H a l ' cl i s d not ons iutona nfr t n s rm na vi to e e e. ca e m or s a m o c aln etelg l yofhsc so yu d rasaec u tu me t sr q rdt a t o ierle h le g h e ai t i u td n e tt o rj dg n a e uie o uh rz eif u de j2 4 t ec u t u rl ds se hi j2 5 peiinwih ut rj ie3 n r 25 , h o r s mmaiy imis s s 2 4 t o t o p eudc . t a opraeor rwile e t sda Upo t dimis loft unde l ng peii Ha ors ppr i t de l ntr hi y. n he s s a he ryi tton, ml ' m o i t ce tf que tonsofs a e l w t t Supr m e Cour ofVi gi a i m oota m us be ton o riy si t t a o he e t r ni s nd t d s i s asw e l i m s ed l. TheClr i diec e t s nd c e oft sm e r ndum opi on a a c e k s r t d o e opi s hi mo a ni nd c ompa ng nyi or rt pe ii r de o ttone . ENTER:Th sf4 i da o y f , 1 20 2. Se orUnie St t D it i t nl t d a es s r c ç 3 Ham l ' cl m smay i t becogni bl i a ci lrght a i under42 U .S. j1 3 or s ai nsead za e n vi i s cton C. 98 , s e ngij nci a / rd caaor r l f Se W i ns n, 44U. a 82.Tobrn alws tun r e ki n u tve nd o e lrt y ei . e l o 5 e ki S. t ig a ui de j 1 83 ho v r Ha o mus alg tep ron liv v me to t ed f n n o dee da sa dmu t 9 , we e , mlr t le e h e s a n ole n f h e e da t r f n nt n s a r et p y t e $3 00 sa u o y fln f ef rb i i g a c v la to i f de al o t S e 2 U. C. g e o a h 50. t t t r ii g e o rng n i i c i n n e r c ur. e 8 S. j l 4() l t saci Ha orha p i onl t $ 0 flngfef afde a ha e sa to j ,a d 91 a . n hi ton, ml s ad y he 5.0 ii e or e r l b a cin,#. n hasna ed ast onl r pondentt die oroft VDOC,who hasno per onali ve enti par e m he y es he r ct he s nvol m n ol d cson .Thee o e t c r de lne t c nsr eHa o ' c re s misona a j1 8 c mplit e ii s r f r ,he ou t c i s o o tu ml rs u rnt ub s i s 9 3 o an. 4