Martin v. Blue Ridge Regional Jail Authority- Lynchburg, No. 7:2012cv00391 - Document 13 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 10/05/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
I TH E U NI N TED STATE S DI STR I CO U R T CT FO R TH E W ESTER N DI STR I T O F V I G I I C R N A R OA N O K E DIVISIO N R O G ER LEE M A R TIN,JR . , nlForsA ce t.s. sT. - 1 oFF# J Dl enlr T ROANOKE, 3, , / % FIFD L CASE N O .7: 12CV 00391 Pl ntf , ai i f OCT 25 2 1 22 JULA C, I DUDC CL G ERK BK W Y CL ERK M EM O M N DU M O PI O N NI YS. BLU E W D G E R EG IO N A L JAIL A U TH O Y TY -LY N CH B UR G , By: Jam e C.Turk s Seni U ni ed StatesD i t ctJudge or t s ri D ef endant . Roge Le M a tn,J . a V igi a i a e pr e di pr K , ied t sc vi r g sac i r e ri r, r ni nm t oc e ng o f l hi i l i ht ton purua t 42U. C.j1 3,algi t her evedi de t medi lte t ntatt Bl s nto S. 98 le ng hat ec i na quae ca r ame he ue Rig Re in l al(t ej i',nvilto o hsc n ttto a rg t.Up nr ve o t e d e go a J i lh al) i oain f i o si in l ih s o e iw f h t ' u r or t c tfndst tt a ton m us be s m a iy dim i s ec d, he our i ha he c i t um r l s s ed. I M atnalege t f l ngfcsr e ntt hi j 1 aci ( No.1, 8.Whie ri l s he olowi a t elva o s 983 ton. ECF 4, ) l deane a t ai,M a tnrcevedçhewrngme cai ' Hi mo hs l a hu ts s ti d thej l ri e i t t o di ton. s ut weled nd r, pot ' de l d on hi body,a he c d bar l t k.M a tn c d no t ke a f ve ope s nd oul e y al r i oul t a ny ood,s t m ed c l o he ia s af pl c d hi on a lqui di tf ra w ee He a s s ntt t t e da i bed. M a tn s t f ae m i d e o k. l o pe wo o hr e ys n ri ues o l t e als e i mo eayd ma e . ny h j i, e kng n tr n g s 11 Tosaeaca eofaci underj 1 3, pli ifmus etbls t thehasbe n tt us ton 98 a antf t sa ih ha e de i ofr gh s gua a e by t Cons iuton orl w soft U nie St t a t tt s prved i t r nt ed he tt i a he t d a es nd ha hi deprvaton r t f om conductcom m it by a per actng undercol ofs at l . W est i i esuled r ted son i or t e aw v. ki , U. 42( 988) Theco ti r rdt dimisa a ton orcam fldbya At ns 487 S. 1 . ur s equie o s s ny ci li ie prs ne a i ta gove nm e ale iy orof i li t c t t nui t tt a ton o cli io r gans r nt ntt ic a f he our de e nes ha he c i r am i fi ous m alc o , f l t saea ca m onwhih r ifm a be g a e 28 U. C. s rvol , ii us or ais o t t li c ele y r nt d. S. j1 5A( ( ) 91 b)1. tloc lgo r ngbodis... a bes ddiecl und rj 1 f moneay,de lrt y, su a veni e c n ue r ty e 983 or tr caaor o ij n tv r l f e e. .hea to ta i alg dt b l o siu in li lme t o r nu cie ei wh r . t cin h t s le e o e mc n t to a mp e n s r e t e c e a polcy s a em en ,or na ,r gul ton,orde i i n of i i ly adopt and xe ut s i tt t di nce e a i c so fc al ed pr m ul t d by t tbody' ofi e s' M one l N e Yor Ciy D e t of Soc a Se v ce , o ga e ha s tc r . ' l v. w k t p i l r i s 436 U. 6 8 6 0(97 ) p o eta ag v r me tle tt s c a alc l al i l bl fr S. 5 , 9 1 8 .To r v h t o e n n a ni u h s o a j i,s i e o y, a c tt i lvi a i c mit d by ise oye s pli ifmus s t tt en iy' polc onsiutona oltons om te t mpl e , antf t how ha he tt s iy w asç he m ovi f ce oft c tt i lvi a i ' Pol Co y v.D ods n, 4 U . 31 t t ng or he ons iutona ol ton. ' k unt o 45 S. 2, 3 6( 9 ) Ma t f ist ll aj i p l yt a yo t alg dc n ttto a voain 2 1 81. ri al o ik al oi o n fhe le e o siuin l ilt s n r c o r r ng hi m e c lt ea m e . A c or ng y, a tn ha no l galorf c ua ba i f hi c a m ega di s di a r t nt c di l M r i s e a t l s s or s l i a an ttej i, a dtec u t ld s s tec mpan wih u p eu ie p ru n t g is h al1 n h o r wil imis h o lit t o t rj dc , u s a t o j1 5A( () a lgal fi ous Ana o it o de wilis t sda 91 b)1 , s e ly rvol . pprprae r r l sue hi y. The Cl r i di e t t s nd c esoft sm e or ndum opi on a ac om pa ng e k s r c ed o e opi hi m a ni nd c nyi o de t pli if r r o antf . E r a:T i fd- y o- t r 2 1. xy hs zda tocobe 02 ' , 4 J Se orUnie Stt DititJ dg ni t d a es src e 1M a tn' alg to as f it saea y a ton bl j1 :3cam a ans a yj iofiil The ri s le a ins lo alo tt n ci a e 9 li g i t n al fca. j i' me ia sa fp o de M a t wi te t nta h sa s rinst ta pe t o t a te t ntwe e als dc l tf r vi d ri t rame , nd i se to ha s cs f h t r ame r n h i ppr i e,ort tt medi ton w asGwr na oprat ha he ca i ç onp'ar nots fcintt s ' e ufi e o uppor afndi t tanyone t i ng ha knowi y punihed M artn by gi ng hi mediaton orteat ngl s i vi m c i r mentt har hi . SeeEsele v. hat med m t l Ga l,4 U. 97 1 2 ( 97 (idi t tt saeEihh Ame n cl m,imaemu ts w mbe 29 S. , 0 1 6) fn ng ha o tt g t ndme t ai n t s ho p io o fca ' d lbeaei fee et i t' sro me ca n e ; rg tv. lns 7 6F. rs n fiils ei rt ndifr nc o nmae s eius di l e dl W ih Coli , 6 2d 8 ,8 ( t Ci.1 5 (i n t ti t sdia r e n wihme c lp ron l e a di dign i 41 49 4 h r 98 ) fndig ha nmae' s g e me t t dia e s ne r g r ng a oss a c ureofte t ntd sn ti iaet eEihhAme me ) nd o s r ame oe o mplc t h g t nd nt.