Coleman v. Southwest Virginia Regional Jail Authority-Haysi, No. 7:2012cv00387 - Document 6 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 8/21/2012. (Attachments: # 1 28 U.S.C. §2241 Forms, # 2 28 U.S.C. §2254 Forms)(tvt)
Download PDF
cl xsoF l us nlmcoue- ' FcE sn s A R A bx v T ox k A yl Eo u I T H E U N IT ED STA T ES D ISTR IC T C O U R T N FO R T H E W ESTE RN D I STR I O F V I G IN I CT R A R O A N O K E D IV ISIO N R O SS M .C O L EM A N , At 2 1 2 1 l o 92 JULI C. A BY) D LERK CL C i lA cti N o.7: vi on 12cv00387 Pl nt f ai i f, M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N N O V. SO U TH W EST V I G I I R E G I N A L R N A O JA IL A U TH O R ITY , By:Sam uelG .W is l on U nied St es D i ri Judge t at st ct D efendant . Thi i a a tonptrua t 42U. C.j1 bypl nifRos M . e s s n ci zs nt o S. 983 aitf s Colman,aVigi a r ni i a e pr ee ngpr s ars ng f o de enda t Sout e tV igi a Regi nm t oc di o e, i i r m f n hw s r ni onalJ i Aut iy' a l hort s (S A' l kofhepf nes wihColma speii f awrtofha sc pus Colma t SVRJ ' ac ) l ul s t e n' tton or i bea or . e n s e sijmcier le l ot en x ma wo t v a yp o lmswi lg l r ' Fo te e k nt tv eif i h e t n n'ha e n r b e s t e a wo k. r h h ' ra o ssae heen,h c u t imis sCoe n' c mp an wih u prj ie e s n ttd ri t e o r ds se lma s o lit t o t eudc . 1 . Colma cli hetsntarque tt ( e n ams çe e s o SVRJ saf onJ y 1 201 a as f am i A t f ul 6, 2) nd ked or t o H a sCor . SV RJ s a fr ponded t tCol m a w oul ne t t f bea pus' ' A t f es ha e n d ed o l a f m iy cont d a l g c uslt ydon' gvet m.'Afe flngsve a uns ce su gre nce ,Colma brug be a e he t i he ' tr ii e r l uc sf l iva s e n o ht t sj1 a ton. hi 983 ci II. tf e Consiuton doe no gua a e a i aeade t l ga a ssa a a s' -h tt i s t r nte n nm t qua e e l s it nce nd n ade ua e 1 w lbr y;r t r i gua a e s a r g t r as bl a es t t co t . H a de v. q t a i ar a he , t r nt e i ht o e ona e cc s o he urs ' r n ' Bodior 442F.App' 893,896( h Ci. 1 (ii Le sv. s y,518U. 343,351 f d, x 4t r 201 ) ctng wi Ca e S. (1 ; 996) Boundsv.Smih,430U. 81 838( 977:.ç-herg ofac es t t coursi t t S. 7, 1 d- iht c s o he t s he l di t brng t co t g i va e t tt i a e w i he t pr en y and vi a i oft tr g rght o i o ur a r e nc ha he nm t s d o es t ' ol tons ha i ht occ ro ywhe a i t i ç ndeed (njhi eforst ptrueal lcai ''Pl e v. u nl n n nmae s hi r i s f t o ls ega l m.' ylr M oor 1 F. 365,373( h Ci.1 .Core i fciii mus pr det et sSha e, 00 3d 4t r 996) rctonal a ltes t ovi hos ool l t t t i a esne i or t a t c t i s nt nc ,di e ty o c l t r ly,a i or rt he nm t ed n der o t a k he r e e es r c l r ola e a l nd n de o c le t c tonsoft i c i e .' Le i , U . a 355. t m pa r e ofa ha l nge he ondii he r ontnem nt' w s 518 S. t é l i m nt ny ot rltgai c pact i smpl oneoft i de a tndpere tyconsiuto l he ii tng a iy s i y he nci ntl a fcl tt ina) c e nce ofconvi i n a i r r ton.' I l or rt e t bls a cl m ofde a of ons que s cto nd nca ce a i ' d. n de o s a i h ai ni l a e st t c t,a i t mus algea acualijur (uc ast de e nt ca i a cc s o he ours n nmae t le n t n y s h he f nda s usng n a tona ecam t bel torpr ntngt pli iffom flngacai rs tngfom t ci bl li o os eve i he antf r ii l m) e uli r he de a.Le s 518U. a 348;Coc a v. oni,73F.d 1 0,1 7( h Ci.1 (n nil wi, S. t hrn M s 3 31 31 4t r 996) e ba ) nc. Hee t o l tn u y' s enbl fo Coe n' c mp an i h sia lt t o ti a r ,he ny t j r 'dic r i e r m lma s o lit s i n bii o b an i y pr prnt f m f t lng a ha s pe ii Col m a ha no a l ged t tSV RJ s a fhi r e i ed or or i i bea tton. e n s t le ha A t f nde ed hi a lt t fl a ha spe ii ort thei ot r s una e t fl ape ii l f c , t n s biiy o ie bea tton, ha s he wie bl o ie tton. n a t wihi w e ks ofhi f r tr ques t SJ A r ga di ha a ,Col m a ha s es f ly i tt t d t s e s is e t o RV e r ng be s e n d ucc s u l ns iu e hi j1 a ton.Nohi i Colma sc anti c tst tSVRJ woul i efr wihhi 983 ci t ng n e n' ompli ndiae ha A d ntre e t s a lt t do t s m e w ih a habe petton. The c tt e or fndst tCol m a s biiy o he a t as ii our her f e i ha e n' a l to a e i ufi i ntt sat a c a m f rdeni lo ac es t t co t lega i ns r ns fc e o t e l i o a f c s o he ur s. 111. Fo t er a o ssae ,hec u t ld s s Co e n' c mpan wih u p eu ie r h e s n ttd t o r wil imis lma s o lit t o t rj dc plrua t 28U. C.j 1 5()2)B)f fiur t saeacam.Theceki die tdt s nda zs nt o S. 91 e( ( or al e o tt li lr s rce o e 2 c oft sm e or ndum opi on and t a c pa ng or rt t pl i i f1 opy hi m a ni he c om nyi de o he a ntf . -. o ' e v.' ,-. -' ENTER :A ugust2 1,2012. ,# 'z -. e z # . , ,' / M UNI TED STA TES D I STR I J D GE CT U 'l Col f emanw ihest s ekr le unde 28U .S. j2 41o 2 5 , ema u et a p o raeatc e s o e eif r C. 2 r 2 4 h y s he p r p it ta h d f m. or