Miller v. Mines et al, No. 7:2012cv00382 - Document 12 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 10/18/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
ct ' oFFt U G DI COUM e- s ce :% A Ms L V T vl A ki, Fl I T U T DS AT SDS RCTCOUR N HE NIE T E IT I T FO R TH E W ESTE RN DI STRI T O F V I G I A C R M R O AN O K E DI I O N V SI R O BER T E.M I LLER , Pl nt f , ai i f j JJ t . U tLA sv: j r C E W cE p C i lA c i N o.7: c 00 vi ton 12- v- 382 M EM OR ANDVM OPI ON NI By: P.M I E S,etal, N . D e endant . f s H on.Jackson L .K i ser Se or U ni e St e Di t i tJudge ni t d at s s r c i l i ht om a nt Robe tE. il r a f r i a e pr e i pr > ,fl d a c vi r g s c pl i r M le , ede al nm t oc ed ng o t ie . . pur ua t Bi nsv.Si Unknow n N a e A ge sofFe r lBur a ofN a eotc ,403 U . 388 s nt o ve x m d nt de a eu r is S. ( 97 ) wi j rs i o v se i 28U. C. 1 31 Plitf dd n ts b t a me t fte$ 5 1 1 , t u id di n e td n h S. j 3 . an if i o u mi p y n o h 3 0 flngfewihhi compli .Se 28U. C. 1 4() Pli ifha a l s t e non- bea ii e t s ant e S. j 91 a . antf d t ea t hre ha s c vi a tonsor a i l ci ppea s pr vi l di m i s d a fi ous a m alci ,orf f ii t s a e a l e ous y s s e s r vol , s i ous or a lng o t t c am u l i pon whi h r i m a be g a e Seç e. , ilrv. td Stt , 1 1 c elef y r nt d. , g.M le Unie aes No. 0- 5437( 1h 1t . Ci. b. 2011 ( aldimis dasfi ousandentr l wihoutmeil M ilrv.Unie r Fe 9, ) appe s se rvol iey t rt; le td Stts No.1:0-vae , 1 c 02996( D.Ga.Oc.29,201 ( s se asalgaly fi ousa tonl N. t 0) dimis d e l rvol ci ; M ilrv S h d , .11 - v 01 2 ( D. . e t 2 , 01 )( imis dwihp eu ief r l . c mit No :0 c - 1 8 N. Ga S p . 3 2 0 ds se t rj dc o e lc o s b e t te j rs ito v ateih rn p we of h c u tos re fioo sa to s; a k f u j c matr u idcin i h r ee t o r t e o r t ce n rv lu cin l l M ilrv.Mil , 109-v- 700( D. J y2, 0)(rntngaFe R.Ci P.1 b) le lerNo. : c 01 N. Ga. ul 201 ga i d. v. 2( motont dimiswih prj c a fndngt a tond oi a i eandl ki i mei a t i o s s t eudie nd i i he ci s mplusbl s ac ng n rt s o esa iht c eelckofaf r c r s '.Se as Neizkev. ilams 490U. tbls he omplt a edeal ontovery') e lo t W li , S. 31 ,3 ( 989 (trvol 'i l scai ba e upona i s abl meil sl lt oy, 9 27 1 ) s i ous'ncude l ms s d f n ndiput y rtes ega he r cl i sofi r nge e ofa l gali e e tw hi h c ea l doesnote s , orc am swhe e t f c ua am nf i m nt e nt r s c l ry xi t li r he a t l c e to aecla l bas esl Ros v.Baon,No.1 1 201 U. App.LEXI 1 95 ontnins r e ry el s; s r 2- 272, 2 S. S 7 7, 2 2W L 3 9 91 ( t Ci. g. 2 2 2 (e o nzn ac u ta k s be tmatr u idcin 01 5 0 4 4h r Au 2 , 01 ) r c g ii g o r lc s u j c te j rs ito ove a obvi l fi ousc ant; ueCr s& Bl Shil ofAl v.Sa r,1 F.d rn ousy rvol ompli ) Bl os ue ed a. nde s 38 3 1 1 -2 ( 1h Ci.1 )(xpli ngt taf dea q sin cai ma bedimis df 347, 3515 1 t r 998 e ani ha e rl ueto l m y s se or lc o s b e tmatr u idito i t ecam i whol i u sa ta a fi lu ) l a k f u j c te j rs cin f h li s l ns b tn il nd rvoo s. n y ac or ncewiht t eesrke pr vii of28U. C.j1 ( ) 1prvi l a s dpli if c da t he hr -ti s o son S. 915 g , e ousy dvie antf t the ne ded t s ha e o ubmi t $350. tlng f oresa ih a i i ntt ea ofs rousphysc t he 00 ii ee tbls n mm ne hr t e i ial har t pr ee w ih a c vi s t M il ry. h, 7: 1c 00290, l op. t5n. ( . Va m o oc d t i l ui. le Zyc No. 1 -vsi p a 1 W D. . - J 27, 1. une 201 ) A f e r vi w i pl i if ss i s onsi t i ci la ton, ti cl a t tpl i i fdoesnot t r e e ng a ntf ubm s i n h s vi c i i s e r ha a ntf al gea f t i c i t hei cure l unde a i i ntt ea ofa s rousphysc l le ny ac s ndiatng hat s r nty r ny mm ne hr t ny e i ia ij r wi nteme nngo 2 U. C. 1 5g . Ac o dn l , ds s t a t nwi u n uy t h a i f 8 S. j 91 ()l c r ig y 1 imis he ci t t hi o ho p eudief pli ifsf l et payt flngf a t tmeoftlngt c anta dimis rj c or antf aiur o he ii ee t he i ii he ompli nd s s a1pe ngmotonsasmoot Se e. , e v.Pame,284F. 1 1 ( 1hCi. 1 ndi i . es g.Dupre l r 3d 234, 237 1 t r 2002) (e o ngt tt flngf i dueupo flng acvi a ton whe i f ras ni ha he ii ee s n ii i l ci n n onnapa rspr sons upei ovii do nota y t pl i ifa t t c ti notr quiedt pe m i pl ntf a opporu t t pa ppl o antf nd hat he our s e r o r t ai if n t niy o y t flngf ea trr ognii pli ifi i lgi et pr ee j fr paupei) he ii e fe ec zng antf s nei bl o oc d . oma q rs. lPl ntf fld t Compl n whenhew a i r e ae i l a , whi negaesi i dange a tfc s ai if ie he ait s nca c r td n ndina ch t mm nent r bou a t des i d i t Compl n f prs n condii i Vigi a. Se e. ,AbdulAkbarv.M c vi,239F. 307,31 crbe n he ait or io tons n r ni e. a. Kel e 3d 4 ( d Ci. 0 1 (e o n zngt a tmmi n d n e 'r lt st t etmewh nt ep io e flst ea to , o a o ta J r 2 0 ) r c g i i h t t ne t a g r' eae o h i i e h rs n r ie h c in n t b u p s d n e) Si lry panifsmoinfratmp rr r sri n od rdic se hsc n to so c ni e n at a g r. mi l, litf a to o e oay etanig re su ss i o di n f o tn me t i i l a a doe no s f intyr at t t c lng prs c tonsi Vigi a.SeeOm ec W ordTr ve n ndina nd s t ufk e l el e o he hale ed ion ondii n r ni a l a l v. A,1 1F.d1 ,1 (t Ci.1 9 )(tt mo a t tetbiharlto s i bewe nteijr came i TW l 3 4 6 4h r 9 7 sai ng v n mus sa ls eain hp t e h nu y li d n temoinf rpei n r ij n tv rle a tec n u tgvigrs t ac mplit.S eas l r Mir sR h to o rl ay nu cie eif nd h o d c i n ie o o an) e lo n e co o mi Ani u t t , 3 F.d51 , 2 (t Ci. 0 3 (ttn ta wi u t sn x ,h c u tho l n t o sd rte tt s Lii 3 3 3 7 5 6 4h r2 0 ) saig h t t thi e uste o r s ud o c n ie h r a. ho fco sfrpei n r ij n t erle a tr o rl ay nu ci eig. mi v The Cl r i die t d t s nd co e oft sM e a ek s rce o e pis hi mor ndum Opi on andt ac ompa ng ni he c nyi Or rt pl i if de o a ntf . ENTER:T il w hs dyo Ocoe,02 a f tbr2 1. 1 Se rU nied St t sD i ti tJ ni t a e sr c udge