Miller v. Mines et al, No. 7:2012cv00382 - Document 12 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 10/18/2012. (tvt)

Download PDF
ct ' oFFt U G DI COUM e- s ce :% A Ms L V T vl A ki, Fl I T U T DS AT SDS RCTCOUR N HE NIE T E IT I T FO R TH E W ESTE RN DI STRI T O F V I G I A C R M R O AN O K E DI I O N V SI R O BER T E.M I LLER , Pl nt f , ai i f j JJ t . U tLA sv: j r C E W cE p C i lA c i N o.7: c 00 vi ton 12- v- 382 M EM OR ANDVM OPI ON NI By: P.M I E S,etal, N . D e endant . f s H on.Jackson L .K i ser Se or U ni e St e Di t i tJudge ni t d at s s r c i l i ht om a nt Robe tE. il r a f r i a e pr e i pr > ,fl d a c vi r g s c pl i r M le , ede al nm t oc ed ng o t ie . . pur ua t Bi nsv.Si Unknow n N a e A ge sofFe r lBur a ofN a eotc ,403 U . 388 s nt o ve x m d nt de a eu r is S. ( 97 ) wi j rs i o v se i 28U. C. 1 31 Plitf dd n ts b t a me t fte$ 5 1 1 , t u id di n e td n h S. j 3 . an if i o u mi p y n o h 3 0 flngfewihhi compli .Se 28U. C. 1 4() Pli ifha a l s t e non- bea ii e t s ant e S. j 91 a . antf d t ea t hre ha s c vi a tonsor a i l ci ppea s pr vi l di m i s d a fi ous a m alci ,orf f ii t s a e a l e ous y s s e s r vol , s i ous or a lng o t t c am u l i pon whi h r i m a be g a e Seç e. , ilrv. td Stt , 1 1 c elef y r nt d. , g.M le Unie aes No. 0- 5437( 1h 1t . Ci. b. 2011 ( aldimis dasfi ousandentr l wihoutmeil M ilrv.Unie r Fe 9, ) appe s se rvol iey t rt; le td Stts No.1:0-vae , 1 c 02996( D.Ga.Oc.29,201 ( s se asalgaly fi ousa tonl N. t 0) dimis d e l rvol ci ; M ilrv S h d , .11 - v 01 2 ( D. . e t 2 , 01 )( imis dwihp eu ief r l . c mit No :0 c - 1 8 N. Ga S p . 3 2 0 ds se t rj dc o e lc o s b e t te j rs ito v ateih rn p we of h c u tos re fioo sa to s; a k f u j c matr u idcin i h r ee t o r t e o r t ce n rv lu cin l l M ilrv.Mil , 109-v- 700( D. J y2, 0)(rntngaFe R.Ci P.1 b) le lerNo. : c 01 N. Ga. ul 201 ga i d. v. 2( motont dimiswih prj c a fndngt a tond oi a i eandl ki i mei a t i o s s t eudie nd i i he ci s mplusbl s ac ng n rt s o esa iht c eelckofaf r c r s '.Se as Neizkev. ilams 490U. tbls he omplt a edeal ontovery') e lo t W li , S. 31 ,3 ( 989 (trvol 'i l scai ba e upona i s abl meil sl lt oy, 9 27 1 ) s i ous'ncude l ms s d f n ndiput y rtes ega he r cl i sofi r nge e ofa l gali e e tw hi h c ea l doesnote s , orc am swhe e t f c ua am nf i m nt e nt r s c l ry xi t li r he a t l c e to aecla l bas esl Ros v.Baon,No.1 1 201 U. App.LEXI 1 95 ontnins r e ry el s; s r 2- 272, 2 S. S 7 7, 2 2W L 3 9 91 ( t Ci. g. 2 2 2 (e o nzn ac u ta k s be tmatr u idcin 01 5 0 4 4h r Au 2 , 01 ) r c g ii g o r lc s u j c te j rs ito ove a obvi l fi ousc ant; ueCr s& Bl Shil ofAl v.Sa r,1 F.d rn ousy rvol ompli ) Bl os ue ed a. nde s 38 3 1 1 -2 ( 1h Ci.1 )(xpli ngt taf dea q sin cai ma bedimis df 347, 3515 1 t r 998 e ani ha e rl ueto l m y s se or lc o s b e tmatr u idito i t ecam i whol i u sa ta a fi lu ) l a k f u j c te j rs cin f h li s l ns b tn il nd rvoo s. n y ac or ncewiht t eesrke pr vii of28U. C.j1 ( ) 1prvi l a s dpli if c da t he hr -ti s o son S. 915 g , e ousy dvie antf t the ne ded t s ha e o ubmi t $350. tlng f oresa ih a i i ntt ea ofs rousphysc t he 00 ii ee tbls n mm ne hr t e i ial har t pr ee w ih a c vi s t M il ry. h, 7: 1c 00290, l op. t5n. ( . Va m o oc d t i l ui. le Zyc No. 1 -vsi p a 1 W D. . - J 27, 1. une 201 ) A f e r vi w i pl i if ss i s onsi t i ci la ton, ti cl a t tpl i i fdoesnot t r e e ng a ntf ubm s i n h s vi c i i s e r ha a ntf al gea f t i c i t hei cure l unde a i i ntt ea ofa s rousphysc l le ny ac s ndiatng hat s r nty r ny mm ne hr t ny e i ia ij r wi nteme nngo 2 U. C. 1 5g . Ac o dn l , ds s t a t nwi u n uy t h a i f 8 S. j 91 ()l c r ig y 1 imis he ci t t hi o ho p eudief pli ifsf l et payt flngf a t tmeoftlngt c anta dimis rj c or antf aiur o he ii ee t he i ii he ompli nd s s a1pe ngmotonsasmoot Se e. , e v.Pame,284F. 1 1 ( 1hCi. 1 ndi i . es g.Dupre l r 3d 234, 237 1 t r 2002) (e o ngt tt flngf i dueupo flng acvi a ton whe i f ras ni ha he ii ee s n ii i l ci n n onnapa rspr sons upei ovii do nota y t pl i ifa t t c ti notr quiedt pe m i pl ntf a opporu t t pa ppl o antf nd hat he our s e r o r t ai if n t niy o y t flngf ea trr ognii pli ifi i lgi et pr ee j fr paupei) he ii e fe ec zng antf s nei bl o oc d . oma q rs. lPl ntf fld t Compl n whenhew a i r e ae i l a , whi negaesi i dange a tfc s ai if ie he ait s nca c r td n ndina ch t mm nent r bou a t des i d i t Compl n f prs n condii i Vigi a. Se e. ,AbdulAkbarv.M c vi,239F. 307,31 crbe n he ait or io tons n r ni e. a. Kel e 3d 4 ( d Ci. 0 1 (e o n zngt a tmmi n d n e 'r lt st t etmewh nt ep io e flst ea to , o a o ta J r 2 0 ) r c g i i h t t ne t a g r' eae o h i i e h rs n r ie h c in n t b u p s d n e) Si lry panifsmoinfratmp rr r sri n od rdic se hsc n to so c ni e n at a g r. mi l, litf a to o e oay etanig re su ss i o di n f o tn me t i i l a a doe no s f intyr at t t c lng prs c tonsi Vigi a.SeeOm ec W ordTr ve n ndina nd s t ufk e l el e o he hale ed ion ondii n r ni a l a l v. A,1 1F.d1 ,1 (t Ci.1 9 )(tt mo a t tetbiharlto s i bewe nteijr came i TW l 3 4 6 4h r 9 7 sai ng v n mus sa ls eain hp t e h nu y li d n temoinf rpei n r ij n tv rle a tec n u tgvigrs t ac mplit.S eas l r Mir sR h to o rl ay nu cie eif nd h o d c i n ie o o an) e lo n e co o mi Ani u t t , 3 F.d51 , 2 (t Ci. 0 3 (ttn ta wi u t sn x ,h c u tho l n t o sd rte tt s Lii 3 3 3 7 5 6 4h r2 0 ) saig h t t thi e uste o r s ud o c n ie h r a. ho fco sfrpei n r ij n t erle a tr o rl ay nu ci eig. mi v The Cl r i die t d t s nd co e oft sM e a ek s rce o e pis hi mor ndum Opi on andt ac ompa ng ni he c nyi Or rt pl i if de o a ntf . ENTER:T il w hs dyo Ocoe,02 a f tbr2 1. 1 Se rU nied St t sD i ti tJ ni t a e sr c udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.