Sanchez v. F.B.O.P., No. 7:2012cv00371 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 11/8/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
CL ERK' OFFI U. Dia . S CE 3. t' COURA r AT M NVI E, LL VA FI D r Gr N0V -8 2 1 02 I TH E UN I N TED STA TES DI RI C O U RT ST CT FO R TH E W ESTE RN DISTR ICT O F V IR G I IA N R O A N O K E D I ISI N V O FER N AN D O SA NC H E Z, Pet toner, ii F. O . , B. P. R espondent . ) ) ) ) ) ) ) JUL C Du Ex CtEl I i - kK BY; DE c( . C i lA cton N o.7: c 00371 vi i 12- vM EM O M N D UM O PI IO N N By: H on.Jackson L.K i ser Seni Unied St esD i ri Judge or t at st ct Fe na r ndo Sa he a f r i a e pr e di nr K ,tl d a pe ii f r a wr tof nc z, ede al nm t oc e ng o ie tton o i ha ascor , s t 28U. C.j2241 Peii raleg t ttt f'a t Unie Stt be pus puruant o S. . ttone l es ha s af t he td aes s Pe tntayi Le Count Vigi a(t Lee', lge l a unehi ly sntpeiine t nie ir n e y, r ni t USP ' negi nty nd t cal e tto r o ) t Spe alM a ge ntUni (û 'pr r a t tsaf a t Bur uofPrs '($ ' he ci na me td SMU' ogam nd ha t f t he ea ) ions EBOP' ) Ce r lO f i ha no ans e ed pe ii r s g i va . Pe ii rf t ralege t tt nt a fce ve t w r ttone ' r e nce ttone ur he l s ha he Dici i He rngOfier($ ' a t SMu-rnse he rngwasbis d a i thi a s plne ai fc ; DHO') t he ta fr ai a e gans m nd U SP Le saf c pied t cove up t D H O ' er or .1 Pettone e ude t tt e e r s e t f ons r o r he s r s ii r ond s ha hes ror a omisonsvi a e duepr e sa e nd si olt d oc s nd qualpr eci n g r nt e by t Fit Ame ot to ua a e d he fh ndme t nt o s t s or or elm nary revi , purs ew t Unies St es Cons iuton. Thi m ateri bef e m e f pr i i he t at tt i 2 uantt o Ruls1b)and4oft Rul Goveni j2254Ca e .Afe rviwi peii rs e ( he es r ng s s tr e e ng ttone ' s b sin , ds s t p tto wi u p eu ieb c u ep tto e ' camsd n ts u di u miso s l imis he eiin t t rj d c e a s eiin rs li o o o n n ho ha sr le . bea e i f Pe ii r sha as c a m s i l ng t thi as i entt t SM U vi a ed a rghtt ttone ' be l i , nc udi ha s s gnm o he ol t i o d p o e s fi a amatro lw.Se to 2 41' o f r h b a j idcint h a t e ue r c s, al s te f a cin 2 ' n e s a e s urs ito o e r h c 1Peii ras m e i t tU SP Leeû tf 'teashi unf ry, de e hi physc pr eci a t mper wih ttone lo ntons ha t a f r t m ail nis m s ial ot ton, nd a s t hi m ai,al i rt la i f runs ciidr as ns s l l n e aiton o pe fe e o . 2Alhou pl ntf as i t gh ai if lo nvoke 5 U.S. j5 2ag ()Th Prv c Ac o 1 7 , edo sn td srbea ycam s C. 5 ()3 , e ia y t f 9 4 h e o eci n li a boutac s t publcr cor . Pettone as i ce s o i e ds ii r lo nvokes28C.F. j5 .2, chdoesnote s. R. 411 whi xit pe ii n ofaf de a prs rwho i c l ng nott valdiy butt e c i ofhi tto e r l ione s halengi he i t he xe uton s s ntnc ' W oodalv.Fed.BurauofPrs ,432F.d235,241( Ci. c e e. ' l e ions 3 3d r 2005) SeeI r . ne J ,226F. 328,333- ( hCi. ones 3d 34 4t r 2000)( i exc ptonpurua t 28U. C.j2255h). notng e i s nt o S. () Thec t tkocus)ont ne dt e ur t t... ione sus onl ha a c pus... our mus t l he e o ns e ha prs r e y be s or f r m e eswhe t y s ek t i lda et du ai oft i c i m e - - t rdie ty t ough e di n he e o nva i t he r ton her onfne nt -eihe r c l hr a ij n to c mp li s e irrla eo i drcl tr ug aj iil tr n to ta n nu cin o el pe d e ee s r n ie ty h o h udca deemiain h t ng nec s arl i i st unl ul soft ... t y. W iki on v. s 5 U. 7 81 e s iy mple he awf nes he cusod ' l ns ' Doton, 44 S. 4, ( 2005) Se e. ,Pr ie v.Rodrq z,411U. 475,499- ( 973) Noneofpeiine ' . e. g. esr iue S. 500 1 . tto rs cli sa f c t lngt ofhi s nt nc Eve i pettone ' SM U cli wass ce sul f am fe t he e h s e e e. n f ii r s am uc s f , or e pl ,r l s ng pe ii r f o t SM U t t ge r popul ton w o d nota t rt f tor xam e e ea i ttone r m he o he ne al ai ul le he ac dur ton ofpe ii ne ' c i m e .Ac di y,pe ii rf ist e t bls a en ilme t ai tto rs onfne nt cor ngl ttone a l o sa ih n tte nt o ha e srle vi j2 41 a dId s s t ep tto wih u p eu ie3 b a eif a 2 , n imis h eiin t o t rj d c . The Cl r i diec e t s nd a c oft sM e o a e k s r td o e opy hi m r ndum Opi on a t a co pa i ni nd he c m ny ng Or rt pettone . de o ii r EN TER : s = Thi da ofN ove be ,201 y m r 2. Se i U nied St esD i r c Judge or t at sti t 3Ide i t consr peii rscli asa ii u rt Prvac Ac of197 orBi nsv. Si UnknownNamed clne o tue ttone ' ams rsng nde he i y t 4 ve x Fe al nt ofFe alBur u ofNa c is 403 U. . 3 8( 9 l, e a s p tin rddn t a ap o e der Aae s der ea r otc , S 8 1 7 )b cu e eio e i o n me r p r t defnda a c e nt nd annotr l on lbesandconcl inst saeacl m u n whi r le ma begr ntd. SeeBelAt. ey a l uso o tt ai po ch eif y a e l l Co p v Two l 5 0U.. 4 , 5 (0 7 ( odigta apanifsb ssf rrl f e uie mo eta lb l a d r . . mby, 5 S 5 4 5 5 2 0 ) h l n h t litf' ai o ei rq rs r h n a es n e c n lso s; C v Me e, 0U. 47148 8 (9 4 (eu i t fn aBie srme ya an t fd rl o cu in lFDI . y- 51 S. , 4-6 1 9 ) rfsng o id v n e d g is a e ea r a e c ) 28C. R. 1 . 7(it imaer c r sa e e t db t eBOP fo t ePrv c Ac) Se as Go d n g n y ; F. j 6 9 l i n t e o d s x mp e y h s ng r m h ia y t. e lo r o v. e k , 7 F. l 4 ,1 51( t Ci.1 7 )(e o n zn t a ad src c u ti no e pe t dt a s met er eo L e e 5 4 2d 1 7 1 4 h r 9 8 r c g i ig h t itit o r s t x ce o su h ol f advoc t frapr j plitf) ae o o . an it. q - .