Sanchez v. F.B.O.P., No. 7:2012cv00371 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 11/8/2012. (tvt)

Download PDF
CL ERK' OFFI U. Dia . S CE 3. t' COURA r AT M NVI E, LL VA FI D r Gr N0V -8 2 1 02 I TH E UN I N TED STA TES DI RI C O U RT ST CT FO R TH E W ESTE RN DISTR ICT O F V IR G I IA N R O A N O K E D I ISI N V O FER N AN D O SA NC H E Z, Pet toner, ii F. O . , B. P. R espondent . ) ) ) ) ) ) ) JUL C Du Ex CtEl I i - kK BY; DE c( . C i lA cton N o.7: c 00371 vi i 12- vM EM O M N D UM O PI IO N N By: H on.Jackson L.K i ser Seni Unied St esD i ri Judge or t at st ct Fe na r ndo Sa he a f r i a e pr e di nr K ,tl d a pe ii f r a wr tof nc z, ede al nm t oc e ng o ie tton o i ha ascor , s t 28U. C.j2241 Peii raleg t ttt f'a t Unie Stt be pus puruant o S. . ttone l es ha s af t he td aes s Pe tntayi Le Count Vigi a(t Lee', lge l a unehi ly sntpeiine t nie ir n e y, r ni t USP ' negi nty nd t cal e tto r o ) t Spe alM a ge ntUni (û 'pr r a t tsaf a t Bur uofPrs '($ ' he ci na me td SMU' ogam nd ha t f t he ea ) ions EBOP' ) Ce r lO f i ha no ans e ed pe ii r s g i va . Pe ii rf t ralege t tt nt a fce ve t w r ttone ' r e nce ttone ur he l s ha he Dici i He rngOfier($ ' a t SMu-rnse he rngwasbis d a i thi a s plne ai fc ; DHO') t he ta fr ai a e gans m nd U SP Le saf c pied t cove up t D H O ' er or .1 Pettone e ude t tt e e r s e t f ons r o r he s r s ii r ond s ha hes ror a omisonsvi a e duepr e sa e nd si olt d oc s nd qualpr eci n g r nt e by t Fit Ame ot to ua a e d he fh ndme t nt o s t s or or elm nary revi , purs ew t Unies St es Cons iuton. Thi m ateri bef e m e f pr i i he t at tt i 2 uantt o Ruls1b)and4oft Rul Goveni j2254Ca e .Afe rviwi peii rs e ( he es r ng s s tr e e ng ttone ' s b sin , ds s t p tto wi u p eu ieb c u ep tto e ' camsd n ts u di u miso s l imis he eiin t t rj d c e a s eiin rs li o o o n n ho ha sr le . bea e i f Pe ii r sha as c a m s i l ng t thi as i entt t SM U vi a ed a rghtt ttone ' be l i , nc udi ha s s gnm o he ol t i o d p o e s fi a amatro lw.Se to 2 41' o f r h b a j idcint h a t e ue r c s, al s te f a cin 2 ' n e s a e s urs ito o e r h c 1Peii ras m e i t tU SP Leeû tf 'teashi unf ry, de e hi physc pr eci a t mper wih ttone lo ntons ha t a f r t m ail nis m s ial ot ton, nd a s t hi m ai,al i rt la i f runs ciidr as ns s l l n e aiton o pe fe e o . 2Alhou pl ntf as i t gh ai if lo nvoke 5 U.S. j5 2ag ()Th Prv c Ac o 1 7 , edo sn td srbea ycam s C. 5 ()3 , e ia y t f 9 4 h e o eci n li a boutac s t publcr cor . Pettone as i ce s o i e ds ii r lo nvokes28C.F. j5 .2, chdoesnote s. R. 411 whi xit pe ii n ofaf de a prs rwho i c l ng nott valdiy butt e c i ofhi tto e r l ione s halengi he i t he xe uton s s ntnc ' W oodalv.Fed.BurauofPrs ,432F.d235,241( Ci. c e e. ' l e ions 3 3d r 2005) SeeI r . ne J ,226F. 328,333- ( hCi. ones 3d 34 4t r 2000)( i exc ptonpurua t 28U. C.j2255h). notng e i s nt o S. () Thec t tkocus)ont ne dt e ur t t... ione sus onl ha a c pus... our mus t l he e o ns e ha prs r e y be s or f r m e eswhe t y s ek t i lda et du ai oft i c i m e - - t rdie ty t ough e di n he e o nva i t he r ton her onfne nt -eihe r c l hr a ij n to c mp li s e irrla eo i drcl tr ug aj iil tr n to ta n nu cin o el pe d e ee s r n ie ty h o h udca deemiain h t ng nec s arl i i st unl ul soft ... t y. W iki on v. s 5 U. 7 81 e s iy mple he awf nes he cusod ' l ns ' Doton, 44 S. 4, ( 2005) Se e. ,Pr ie v.Rodrq z,411U. 475,499- ( 973) Noneofpeiine ' . e. g. esr iue S. 500 1 . tto rs cli sa f c t lngt ofhi s nt nc Eve i pettone ' SM U cli wass ce sul f am fe t he e h s e e e. n f ii r s am uc s f , or e pl ,r l s ng pe ii r f o t SM U t t ge r popul ton w o d nota t rt f tor xam e e ea i ttone r m he o he ne al ai ul le he ac dur ton ofpe ii ne ' c i m e .Ac di y,pe ii rf ist e t bls a en ilme t ai tto rs onfne nt cor ngl ttone a l o sa ih n tte nt o ha e srle vi j2 41 a dId s s t ep tto wih u p eu ie3 b a eif a 2 , n imis h eiin t o t rj d c . The Cl r i diec e t s nd a c oft sM e o a e k s r td o e opy hi m r ndum Opi on a t a co pa i ni nd he c m ny ng Or rt pettone . de o ii r EN TER : s = Thi da ofN ove be ,201 y m r 2. Se i U nied St esD i r c Judge or t at sti t 3Ide i t consr peii rscli asa ii u rt Prvac Ac of197 orBi nsv. Si UnknownNamed clne o tue ttone ' ams rsng nde he i y t 4 ve x Fe al nt ofFe alBur u ofNa c is 403 U. . 3 8( 9 l, e a s p tin rddn t a ap o e der Aae s der ea r otc , S 8 1 7 )b cu e eio e i o n me r p r t defnda a c e nt nd annotr l on lbesandconcl inst saeacl m u n whi r le ma begr ntd. SeeBelAt. ey a l uso o tt ai po ch eif y a e l l Co p v Two l 5 0U.. 4 , 5 (0 7 ( odigta apanifsb ssf rrl f e uie mo eta lb l a d r . . mby, 5 S 5 4 5 5 2 0 ) h l n h t litf' ai o ei rq rs r h n a es n e c n lso s; C v Me e, 0U. 47148 8 (9 4 (eu i t fn aBie srme ya an t fd rl o cu in lFDI . y- 51 S. , 4-6 1 9 ) rfsng o id v n e d g is a e ea r a e c ) 28C. R. 1 . 7(it imaer c r sa e e t db t eBOP fo t ePrv c Ac) Se as Go d n g n y ; F. j 6 9 l i n t e o d s x mp e y h s ng r m h ia y t. e lo r o v. e k , 7 F. l 4 ,1 51( t Ci.1 7 )(e o n zn t a ad src c u ti no e pe t dt a s met er eo L e e 5 4 2d 1 7 1 4 h r 9 8 r c g i ig h t itit o r s t x ce o su h ol f advoc t frapr j plitf) ae o o . an it. q - .

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.