Verdi v. Commonwealth Of Virginia, No. 7:2012cv00343 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 08/20/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
CLERK: OFFI U, DI COUG CE S. ST. AT ROANOKE, VA F1. D tE I T H E UN I N TED STATES DI STR I C O U R T CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI CT RGI A NI R O A NO K E DIVISIO N JO SEPH M .VER D I, Ad 2 2 2 1 C 22 J A C,%J FY C.ERK ULL -tDL , L ' BK PUW CL ERK C A SE NO .7: 12CV 00343 Pet toner, ii M EM O M ND U M O PI O N NI VS. C O M M O NW EA LTH O F V I GI I , R N A By: Jam e C.Tur s k Se or Uni e St esD i t i tJudge ni t d at src R es pondent . J e M . e di a V igi a i a e pr e i pr y f l d t s pe ii n f ra wrtof os ph V r , r ni nm t oc ed ng o q, ie hi tto o i - h b a c r us p ru n t 2 U. C. 2 4 c aln igteAp i 2 2j g n o t a e s o p , u s a t o 8 S. j 25 , h l gn h rl 01 ud me t f he e Pityl i Count Cic tCot tu rwhi h he s a co c e ofa s ul a ba t r a a ts van a y r ui u' nde c t nds nvi t d s a t nd te y nd pr pe t of e e and s n e e t 36 m on hs Upon r vi w oft r c d, he c tc l o ry f ns e t nc d o t . e e he e or t our onc udes ta tepeiinmu t s mma i d s se wi o tp eu ief rf izet e ha s saec u t h t h tto s be u rl imis d t u rj d c o alr o x u t tt o r y h t r m e es e di . Unde 28U. C.j225 1 afdea co tc nnotgrntaha a peii unl st r S. 449, e rl ur a a be s tton es he pe ii rha e us e t r m e e a ia e i t c t oft s a e i w hi h he was ttone s xha t d he e di s va l bl n he our s he t t n c c ce Thee onvi td. xhausi r quie nti s ts id by s e ngr viw oft cai s t oughout ton e r me s a ife e ki e e he l m ,hr tesaec u t yse t tehih s saec u t t j rs ito t c n ie t ecams S e h tt o r s tm,o h g et tt o r wi u id ci n o o sd r h li . e h O' lva v. r ke,526U. 8 ,845( 999 .I Vigi a a t hi c ci i t til Suli n Boe c l S. 38 1 ) n r ni, fer s onviton n he ra c qt de e ntca tl adie ta pe lt t Cour ofAppe l ofVigi a, t a our he f nda n ie r c p a o he t as r ni wih s bs uen a alt t Supr m e Cour ofVi gi a. A st c a m s t tge r ly c nnotbe u eq t ppe o he e t r ni o l i ha ne a l a a es e on a pe , s h a cl i s o i f e tve as it nc oft i c ddr s d p al uc s a m f ne f c i s s a e ral ouns l 1t e de e nts e , h f nda ' s a e cou tr m edi i Vi gi a i l tlng a s a e ha spe ii w ih t Cic tCo t tt r e es n r ni nc ude ii t t bea tton t he r ui ur ' Se Lenzv. Co e mmon aI , 4 S. 2d2 ,3 4 ( 2001 ( l msr ii ie fci we t 54 E. 99 0 Va. ) cai asng n fe tve h as ît ssanceofcouns i aVigi a crm i cas m us beas ered i a habeascor pr eedi and ar el n r ni i nal e t s t n pus oc ng e n tc nia eondie ta pe l. o og z bl rc p a) whe ehewasco c e wih a a a ofa a r ede ii n t t Supr m eCour ofVigi a, r nvit d, t n ppe l n dve s c so o he e t r ni Va. CodeAz j8. - a () j 1 1411 ori t atr tve flngasaeha a peii m. 01654()1 ; 7.- , n he lenai , ii tt be s tton die tywiht SuprmeCour ofVigni 8. - a () Whihe rr ehef lwsi r cl t he e t r i a.j 01654() 1. c ve out olo n e us i s a e c t em e es a def nda m us uli a e y pr e hi c a m st t Su e e xha tng t t our r di , e nt t tm t l es nt s l i o he pr m Cour ofVigi abe or af er ld src c tc n co i rt me isofhi cli sunder t r ni f e ed a itit our a nsde he rt s am j2254. I t sj2254peiin,Vedialgest thi tilc elpr de i c aea ce n hi tto r le ha s ra ouns ovi d nac urt dvi a o t h s ne eVed wo l rc iei e h n ef rhsg lyplaa dta tetilu g b u t e e tnc r i u d e ev n xc a g o i ui e n h th ra j d e t a e hi s e ng dic ei n. Ve disaeson t f ceofhi peii t thedi notpur uea bus d s entnci s r to r tt he a s tton ha d s diec a r t ppea i sa e co tand t theha notfl d a ot rpos c l n t t ur ha s ie ny he t onvi t on pe ii orm oton ci tton i c n eni t i j dg n o c n ito i a y saec u t Saec u t e or sa albeo ln o c r ng h s u me t f o vcin n n tt o r. tt o r rc d v ia l ni e a s i c t t tVer hasnotpur ue a a pe lorot rpos con c i r m e i a sa e lo ndi a e ha di s d ny p a he t viton e dy n ny tt cour . t l i cea fom t pe ii a t o i r co dst tVe dihasa ia e sae c ur t s l r r he tton nd he nlne e r ha r val bl t t o t r medist thehasnotye pur ue Alhough Ve disopporuniy t pur uea die a alha e e ha t s d. t r ' t t o s r ct ppe s e r d, e dic n pr enthi cl i si a pe ii f r a wrtofha s c pus i t Pityl ni xpi e V r a es s am n tton o i bea or n he ts va a Cou y Cic tCour, t as e nta nt r ui twih ubs que ppea a lbl i t Supr m e Cou tofVigi a.l l vaia e n he e r r ni n t ale na i V e dic pr s nthi cl i s i a ha asc pus pe ii t l die ty i t he t r tve, r an e e s am n be or tton i ed r c l n he Supr m e Cour ofV igi a.2 e t r ni Be us V e di sc ca e r ' uaentpe ii i ca e t the hasa ia e s a e c t e e esa tton ndi t s ha va l bl t t our r m di t t i tme ti c u t t imish sj2 4p tt nwi o t rj dc . Se S a t nv S t, hs i ,h s o r mus d s s i 25 eio t u p eu ie e lvo . mih i h 404U. 53,5 ( 971 (i ngt tj2254ha a peii mus bedimis dwiho p eudie S. 4 1 ) fndi ha be s tton t s se t ut rj c 2 Thi cour' fndi t Ver hasavaiabl sat cour r e esdoesnotconsiut a tndi s ts i ng hat di l e te t em di tt e i ng t tt alegai i hi curentpetton sa eany habeascor cl m on w hi he i e il t r i . ha he l tons n s r ii t t pus ai ch s ntted o elef i peiine ha no prs ntdhi camst t a o it saec tandc dsildos .An f tto r s t e e e s li o he pprprae tt our oul tl o) a opra e or rw ili s t s da ppr i t de l s ue hi y. The Cl r i die t d t s c esoft sm e o a e k s r c e o end opi hi m r ndum opi on a ac om pa ng ni nd c nyi or rt pe ii r de o ttone . ENTER:Thi (/, ,o y ofAug t 201 tm . s t da us, 2. , , y, u . . y Se or nie St t D it i J nl t d a es s r c udge