Springer v. Adams et al, No. 7:2012cv00336 - Document 105 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 9/10/2013. (tvt)

Download PDF
# nlFRK' OFFI u,s. sm cour S CE Dl AT ROANOKE, VA FI ED L sEP 12 2 1 23 I TH E U N I ED STA TE S D I N T STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A RO ANOK E DI SI VI ON J AC ULI BY; Lc LEM D LE V ISPR I G ER , N Ci lAc i No.7: CVvi ton 12- 336 Pl ntf ai if, V. M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI J. GI T. LBERT,e al, t . By: Sam ue G . is l W lon Unie St esDit i Judge t d at s rct Defendant s. OnFe u r 25,201 pl ntf Le Sprnge (lprnge ' a i t a Re Oni Stt br a y 3, ai if vi i r çs i r), n nmae t d on ae Prs fldaM otont Compe Dic r ( ion, ie i o l sove y Docke le No.70)i t cvirg sa tonhe t tm n he i l iht ci br oughtt r42U. C.j 1 mde S. 983.Si et ttme,t pa tesha fld,a t c t nc ha i he ri ve ie nd he our has a d e s d oh rmoi n i cu i gmoi n t d s s a df rs mmayj d me t Th d r se , t e to s n ld n to s o imis n o u r u g n . e r m ani de enda si ude JT.Gibe t Sgt Coli ,C/ M uli ,a C/ Brnkly. e i ng f nt ncl . l r, . lns 0 lns nd O i e S rng rsrmanngcamsicu ewh t rted fn a t 1 alwe a a s uta dfie t p i e ' e ii li n ld ehe h ee d n s ) lo d n sa l n ald o p o e tS ig ri Ma 2 2( am Th e )a d2 un o siuinal c n iu dt ea pl ain r tc prn e n y 01 Cli r e n ) c n ttto l o tn e h p i to y c offvepoi rsr i son Sprnge be l ngSe e r1 201 ( ai Fotr.Sprnge i i - nt e tant i r gimi ptmbe 8, 2 Cl m tl i r s s eki t pr ton ofr co di t tpur t y c ptlet ei i nt a a i i nt e ng he oduc i e r ngs ha poredl a tr hos ncde s nd n ncde f om J m e 23, 2011. r t # Th d f n a t s p o tdtermoi n frs mmayj g n b p o u igah nd l e e e d n s u p re h i to s o u r ud me t y r d cn a hed vie ( d o DVD)fo S p e e 1 , 01 S rn e n w se t f lo n a dto a ds o ey: r m e tmb r 8 2 2. p ig r o e ks he olwi g d iin l ic v r 1 S pi EyeM ove nt'c mear or ngsfom J 23, 1durngSprnge ' )ç d Ra me ' a r ec di r une 201 i i rs a s ul i t o sder r a i a ea; s a t n he ut i ec e ton r *The de endant have notfl an opposton t SprngersM oton t Com peland t deadlnef f s ied ii o i ' i o he i or r s o ngun rW . Va Ci R.l () 1 ha e pie l a c r nc wi W . Va. v. 1 ( a e p ndi de D. . v. lc ( ) s x rd. n c o da e t D. Ci R. 1b) nd h Fe R. v. 78b) t c r wild tr net mo in wih ta o a he rng d. Ci P. ( ,he ou t l ee mi he to t ou n r l a i . 2) ha l vi or or ngsofSprnge ' asa ti t outi rceain ae onJ ndhed de ec di i rs s ul n he sde e r to ra une 23,201 1; 3 ha d edvie r c r i o e ie c o S rn e ' a s uti t rc e to ae o ) n h l d o e o dng f vd n e f p ig rs sa l n he e r ai n ra n M a 1 20 1 ' y 0, 2, 4) vi orco di fom Se e r1 201 bewe a oxi t y7: 9: am. de e r ngs r ptmbe 9, 2 t en ppr mael 30- 30 . w he t de enda sr m ove t fve- ntr t a nt ;a n he f nt e d he i poi esr i s nd 5 vie rc r ig fo S p e e 1 , 01 a p o i tl 1 - 7h u sa tr h ) d o e o dn s r m e tmb r 9 2 2 p r xmaey 5 1 o r fe t e def nda spl c Sprnge i fve poi tr tai sbe wee 1 00- 00 a. . e nt a ed i r n i - n esr nt t n 2: 2: m Fe R.Ci P. b)1 pe t dic r r z nga no i lge matrt ti d. v. 26( () nnis s ove y egadi ny nprvie d te ha s r l va t a pa t sc am orde e e. ç l va i onnaton nee notbea s i ea t e e nt o ny ry' l i f ns k e nt nf Re i d dmisbl t he ti li t dic r a a sr s na y cac a e t l a t t dico r ofa isbl ra f he s ove y ppe r ea o bl lult d o e d o he s ve y dm s i e e d n e' Fe R. v. 2 ( ( ) Th c u ti dsta rc r ig o t ei cd n so M a a d vie c . d. Ci P. 6b)1. e o r tn h t e o dn s f h n ie t f y n ' Se e ber201 a e r e ntt Spr nge ' c a m sa t t de e e a w ilgr nthi m oto a pt m 2 r el va o i r s l i nd o he f ns nd l a s in s t t er quess Thec ltwilde Sprnge ' m o i ast r c di fom Jme 23,2011 o hos e t . otr l ny i r s ton o e or ngs r t . Sprng ' cai r r ng J 23,2011ha be n dim is d a dic y a t t tcli i i ers l m ega di une s e s s e nd s over s o ha am s no r l va no r a ona y c l ul t t l d t t dic y ofa isbl e de e a t t t e e nt r e s bl a c aed o ea o he s over dm s i e vi nc s o he r m a ni c a m s e i ng l i . Fort f e ng r as ,t c twilgr nti pa ta de i pa tSprng r sM oton he or goi e ons he our l a n r nd ny n r i e ' i t Compel The c twilor rt de e nt t pr uc a r c di ofSprnge fo M a o . our l de he f nda s o od e ny e or ngs i r rm y 10,2012 a Se e be 19,201 w ihi 1 da . nd pt m r 2 t n 4 ys E T R: spmbr *% 21. NE et e/ 03 e Ikt io TATES DI TRI J ; - ! f S CT uocE

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.