Bryant v. Hinnant et al, No. 7:2012cv00335 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 8/9/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
cL - I T H E U NI N TED STATES D I STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W E STERN D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R O A N O K E D W ISIO N R ON N I L.BRY A N T, E Pl nt f , ai i f N . .H INN A N T,etal, A . D ef endant s. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) s OFFI u. Dl . CE s. sT COURT AT M NVI E, LL VA FI L A JU BK -! . D DE sy c Ci lA cton N o.7: c 00335 vi i 12- v- M EM O R AN DU M O PI I N N O By: H on.Jacks L.K i on ser Se or Uni e St e Di t i tJudge ni t d at s s r c Ro eL.Br nt aVigi ai epr e ngpr K ,tl aci lrght compl i nni ya , r ni nmat oce di o ied vi i s ant purua t 42U. C.j1983wihj iditonve tdi 28U. C.j 1 s nt o S. t urs ci se n S. 343.Pl ntf na a ai if més s dee d n sN. Hin n, Ca ti a teCo fe o Co rcin l ntr(CCC' ; J fn a t A. n a ta p an t h fe wo d re to a Ce e ç 1 ' B. . ) Se te,aCCC Li ut na ;J Doe?aCCC Se ge nt a J a J ne Doe CCC Core tona tl e e nt ohn r a ; nd ohn nd a , rci l Ofi e s Pl ntf ge r l alege t tde e n sf ie t pr e thi fom a he i t s fc r . ai if ne aly l s ha f nda t al d o ot c m r not r nma e' a s ul.Thi matri bef emef s r ni purua t 28U. C.j 1 5A.Afe rvi ng s a t s te s or or cee ng, s nt o S. 91 tr e ewi plitf' s b sins 1dimistec mplitwih u p eu ief rf iigt saeacam u o an ifs u miso , s s h o an t o t rj dc o aln o tt li p n w hi h r le m a be gr nt d. c e if y a e Pli ifmeey algest te c dee ntwasdei rtl i fee i figng)t antf r l le ha a h fnda lbeaey ndif rntE ali o by e c s r s bl a or na y c r 't pr t d pl ntf fo physca ha m , conducta xer ie ea ona e nd di r a e' o o e ai if r m i l r n a dequa e i tga i ort ke r as bl m e s e t pr ve tt a t k. 1m us dim i s a y t nves i ton, a e ona e a ur s o e n he tac t s s n aci orcai fl by a i ae i 1de e mi t tt a ton orc am i fi ousorf ist ton l m ied n nm t f t r ne ha he c i l i s rvol al o s a e a c ai on w hi h r i fm a be g a e Se 28 U .SC.j 1 5e ( ) 1 5 b () 4 tt l m c ele y r nt d. e . j 91 ()2 , 91 A( )1; 2 U. C.j1 e() Thefrtsa di ude cai basdupon ç n i s a ymeils S. 997 c . is tndar ncl s l ms e i ndiputbl rte s a l galt r ' C a m sofi rngem e ofa l li t r s w hi h c e r y doesnote s ,' orc a m s e heo yy û i ' cl nf i nt ega n e e t c l a l xi t ' l i w he e t t a t lcont t ons m' cl a l bas l s .' Ne tkev. ila s 490 U. 31 327 r he t c ua f en i e e r y e e s ' iz W lim , S. 9, ( 989) Thes ondsa r i t fmiirsa r f amoint dimisunde Fe rlRul 1 . ec tndad s he a la tndad or to o s s r dea e RK ofCi lPr e e1 b)6) a ce i apli ifsfdua al tonsa tu A compli ne vi oc dur 2( ( , c ptng antf' a l legai s r e. ant eds ta s r a pl i s a e en oft c a m s w i t tt pl a r i e il d t r le 'a û ho t nd a n t t m t he l i ho ng ha he e de s ntte o e i f nd s fce Gljct al tons...t r s arg t r i a ufiint dfa ual legai o aie iht o elef bovet s cul i l l ... Bel he pe atve eve. ' l ' A t.Cor v.Tw om bl 55 U. 5 555( l p. y, 0 S. 44, 2007)(ntr quot i ma ksomitd) A i enal aton r te . - pli ifsba i f r le t e r smor t n lbe sand c l i ....'1 The e or a a ntf' s s or ei f t quie r e ha a l oncusons ' d. r f e, plitf mus û legef t s fcintt saealt ee nt of(he)cam.'Bas v. l anif t l l acs ufi e o tt 1he lme s t li ' s E.. a DupontdeNe s& Co.324F. 761 765( hCi. 03 . mour , 3d , 4t r 20 ) Dee m i ng whehe a c tr ni t r ompli sa e aplusbl cli f r i fi tac e -pe ii ant t t s a i e am or ele s t ont xts c fc ts ta rq rsterviwig c u tod a o is udca e pein ea d c mmo sns . a k h t e uie h e e n o r t rw n t j iil x re c n o n e e' ' As r tv.gbal556U. 662, 79( 09 .Thus ac 'sr e ngac antunde Rul hcof l , S. 678- 20 ) , out c e ni t ompli r e 1 b)6)ca i niypl di t taenote ttedt a asumpton o tut be a et y 2( ( n de tf ea ngs ha r nil o n s i f r h c us he co itofnomor t nlbesa c l i .J sAlhoug 1lbealyconsr epr K nss e ha a l nd oncusons - t h i r l / tu o c ant, ne v. r r 404U. 51 520- ( 972) 1donotac ast i e' ompli s Hai s Kene, S. 9, 21 1 , t he nmat s a dvoca e,s s nt devel pi s a ut r a c tt i lc a m st i a e f ie t cl r y t ua po e o ng t t o y nd ons iutona l i he nm t a l d o ea l rieont fceoft c ant Se Br k v.Car l 1 F. 241 243 ( h Ci.1 as he a he ompli . e oc rol, 07 3d , 4t r 997) ( tg,J,c ni ;Be udetv. t QfHa on,775F. 1 4,1 ( h Ci.1 .Se Luti . oncu ng) a t Ciy mpt 2d 27 278 4t r 985) e as Gor v.Le 574F. 11 1151( hCi.1 (e lo don eke, 2d 47, 4t r 978) rcogni ngt tadititc ts zi ha src our i note xpec ed t as um e t r e ofa t o s he ol dvoc t f a pr K pli ig. a e or o antf . Tosaeacl m unde j 1 apli ifmus algeihevi ai ofarghtsc edby tt ai r 983, antf t le 4 olton t i e ur t Cons iu i n a l w s oft U nie St t , nd m us s w t tt a l ge de i ton w as he tt t o nd a he t d a es a t ho ha he le d prva i co tedb ape s aci unde c o o saelm ' W e tv.At ns 487U. 42, ( 988) mmit y ron tng r olr f tt a ' s ki , S. 48 1 . Pl ntf sa l ton t ta de e ntac e ne i nty i nots f c e t s a e a ac i nabl ai i f lega i ha f nda t d glge l s uf i i nt o t t n to e j1 cam.Se W hilvv. bes 475U. 31 31 (98 Cçoq a y a wa ol s 983 li ç te Al r, S. 2, 9 1 6) t bdurc nd nt mes, n t n d e tn e. . haa trz t ec n u t r hiie b ( Eiht Ame d n ) . .) o i a v re c . c rce ie h o d c p o btd y t g h he n me t. .' . ' Pl i if s m er r ia i oft el m ent ofa Ei h A m endm e cl i a r i nc o l be s a ntf e ec t ton he e s n ght nt a m nd ela e n a l a co l i ,whi a e notenttedt a a s nd ncusons ch r il o n s umpton oftut a e no s tce t sa ea i r h, r t ufi int o tt c am upo whi h r i fm a be g a ed. Twombl 550U . a 555. Ac di y,1dim is li n c ele y r nt y, S. t cor ngl s s pl nifsco antwiho prj ce aitf' mpli t ut eudi . The Clr i diecedt s nd c esoft sM e or ndum Opi o a t a ompa ng e k s r t o e opi hi m a ni n nd he cc nyi Or rt pl ntf. de o ai if EN TER :Thi da ofA ug t 201 y us , 2. * . Se rUnie Stt iti tJ e n t d a es src udg