Karavias v. Commonwealth Of Virginia et al, No. 7:2012cv00326 - Document 13 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 10/11/12. (tvt)

Download PDF
ctenx' orFl u s Dl cour s cE sm , , A D N l iy T l vt s k . IN TH E UN ITED STA TES D ISTR ICT C O UR T FO R TH E W ESTE RN D I STRI O F V I G I I CT R N A RO AN O K E D IVISIO N JA SO N S.I M VIA S,I G I, Pl ntf ai if, COM M ONW EALTH OF V IR G I IA,etal, N . Defendant s. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) soo. > kc 0CT 1 1 2 1 22 dUL C. DL CL RK D EX -, DEPUW CL 4. Ci lA cton No.7: cvvi i 12- 00326 M EM O R AN D UM O PI IO N N By: H on.Jacks L.K i on ser Se or Uni e St t s Di t i Judge ni t d a e sr d J on S. a a a ,1 ,a V i g ni i a e pr ee ng pr K ,f l a c vi r ght Com pl i t as K r vi s I r i a nm t oc di o ied i l i s an a r que t l ave t pr ee w iho pr pa e oft t lng f e,pur ua t 28 U . C . nd e s ed e o oc d t ut e ym nt he i i e s nt o S. j1915()2) ByOr re eedonAugus 2, 2,heco tdiecedpl ntf t fl c rii a( . de ntr t 201 t ur r t ai if o ie e tfed i t tus ac ountr cor f t sx- ont pe i be or J y 201 wihi ffee da . mna e r t c e ds or he i m h r od f e ul 2 t n i t n ys Pl i ifs e nty fl d aM oton t Compe a Or rfom t Cour,as ng t co tt antf ubs que l ie i o l n de r he t ki he ur o or runknow n pr s of i i l a t Re Oni St t Pr s n,W a l nsRi St t Prs n, nd de i on fc a s t he d on a e i o le dge a e i o a Powha a Coreci lCe e t tl pli ifsfna i ldaaon hi be fbe us pl itf f t t n r tona nt r o ie antf i nc a t s hal ca e an if el t pr e sw ast s r s f and bur ns e. The M agi ta e J he oc s oo t e s ul de om s r t udge lbe a l c t u d t i r ly ons r e he r ques a an e e i oftm et compl wih t Augus 2,201 Or rand gr nt d pli tf e t s xt nson i o y t he t 2, de a e a n if t ry a tonalda Pli ifç ppea s' h M a sr t J hit ddii ys. a ntf t a l't e gita e udge' Or rf m et r viw . s de or o e e A Ditit ud ema ûe o sd ra p era matrgeer dt ama itaej d e src J g y ' c n ie ny r til te rfre o r gsrt u g l wh r ih sb e s o t a t . .L gsr t j d es o d ri ce rye r n o so c nrr t ee t a e n h wn h t he . ma itae u g ') r e s lal ro e u r o tay o lw. 28U. C.5636( ( )A) Pli ifa g t tma nghi pr det fna ildaa a ' ' S. b)1( . antf r ues ha ki m ovi he i nca t e us l ue s r s ' a he r a onst tt co ti r s a es l und t es ,' nd es ha he ur s e pons bl f rr c rng t da a f om i e o e ove i he t r t s a ount ofic r be us i i t e c t notpl i tf , ho w a st i or a i . Pl i if nl t cc s t e s ca e t s h our , a n if w nt he nf m ton a ntf a s be ivesi i unf i f t c t o c gehi $350 f a cvi aci a t n m a hi lo le t s a r or he our t har m or i l ton nd he ke m pa f c esa posa t r ove a fl t fna i lda a.Pl ntf f t fl d as c md y or opi nd tge o ec r nd ie he i nc a t ai if urher ie e c M oton t Com pe a O r rf om t Cou tt r cove t fna a da a f om s a e of i i l f i o l n de r he r o e r he i nci l t r t t fc a s or t s er he am easonsnot i t Sappeal' ed n he t .' Pl i iff l t e t bls t tt M ag s r t J a ntf ais o s a i h ha he i t a e udge' or rw a c e r y e r ous or s de s l a l r one c r r t l w . The M agit a e J ont a y o a s r t udge' or rm er l gr nt d pl i i ft ry a tona d t s de e y a e a ntf hi t ddii l ays o rc e overt r qui ie fna a do e s Furhe m or t s a ut a l w i pl ntf t he e s t i nci l cum nt . t r e, he t t e lo ng ai if he prvie ofpr edi wihoutprpa ngt $350fer uiesai ioner...gojs ta i lge oce ng t e yi he e eq r t s pr t ubmi c r ii c oft tus f a ountsa e e ... ort prs rf t 6- ont pe i e tfed opy he r t und cc t t m nt f he i one or he m h r od i me ael pr e ng t tlngoft c pli ornotc ofa al obt i d fo t m di t y e edi he ii he om ant i e ppe , ane r m he a opra e ofi i ofea h pr s a w hi h t pr s r i o wasconfned.' 28 U . C. ppr i t t c al c i on t c he i one s r i ' S. j1 5 a ( (mpha i a ) 91 A()2) e ss dded .Thus i i pli ifsoblgai t tl t ne sa yfna il ,t s antf' i ton o ie he ce sr i nca doc nt , t c t a pl i ifm a pa t e ie $350 flng f e whe flng aco ant ume s not he our, nd antf y y he ntr ii e n ii mpli i he tnds i t s r s ulor b de om e t r c r tna i ld um e sf om pr s n ofi i l . f i t oo tes f ur ns o e ove i nc a oc nt r i o tc a s A c di y,pl ntf ' û ppe ' a M o i t Com pel whi h r ie a e t a gum e t no e i cor ngl ai if s t al' nd tons o a , c e t r t he r ns td n t dappeal' ar deni he d ,' e ed. M o et 45 da ha elps d,a pli ifha notr q sedm or tm eorc r han ys ve a e nd antf s e ue t ei omple id w ih t Augus 2,201 O r r w hi wa ne t ta f l e t c pl w oul r s ti di m i s l t he t 2, de , ch r d ha aiur o om y d e ul n s s a o ti a t nwih u p eu c . Ac o di l , 1 imist ea to wi o tp eu iea d srke f h s ci t o t rj die1 c r ng y d s s h ci n t u rj d c n ti o h t c e f om t a i doc oft c t Pl i ifm a r ie t c ai si a s pa a e a ton he as r he ctve ket he our . a ntf y efl he l m n e r t c i oncepli ifi pr pa e t pa t $350 flng f eortl t ne s a y doc e st pr ee a ntf s e r d o y he ii e ie he ce s r um nt o oc d w ihoutpr t epayi t flng f ng he ii ee. 1Pl ntf tld unc tfe c esofi aetus ac untsatm e sfom M a c ,A prl M a J ai if se eriid opi nm t r t co t e nt r rh i, y, une,J y, ul and A ugus 201 t 2. The Cl r i die t d t s nd a co oft sM e or ndum Opi on a a om pan ng ek s rce o e py hi m a ni nd cc yi Or ert pl ntf . d o ai i f E E T i l'# dyo- tb r2 1. NT R: hs l x a foco e, 02 ' # F e r Unied St t sD i t i tJ ni t a e s rc udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.