Anderson v. Director of the Department of Corr., No. 7:2012cv00323 - Document 11 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 8/8/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
CLERK' Oil1 U, .DI COURT S : CE S ST. 2 AT ROANOKE, VA I TH E U NI N TED STA TES DI STRI T C O U RT C FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A R O AN O K E D I I O N V SI W I A M LEE A N DE RSO N ,l , LLI l Pet toner, ii V. D IREC TO R ,V DO C, R e ponde . s nt Ci lA c i N o.7: 2- vvi t on 1 : 00323 ) ) ) ) ) ) ) FI LED AL 28 2 1 ' 22 JuuA c. l sY: , RK c 0- . CL M EM O M N DU M O PI IO N N By:Sam uelG .W ison l U ni e St t sD i t c Judge t d a e s ri t Pe ii r W ila Lee Ande s l , a V i g ni i a e pr e ng pr J fl t s ttone li m r on, l r i a nm t oc edi o e, ied hi peiin frwrtofha c puspurua t 28U. C.j2254,c lngi hi 2009co ci tto o i beas or s nt o S. hale ng s nviton a s nt nc i t W as ngt Count Cic tCour. The c ttndst tAnde s spe ii nd e e e n he hi on y r ui t our i ha r on' tton i un i e y tl a t the has notde ons r t d a gr s tm l i ed nd ha m t a e ny ounds f r equia e t lng. The ef r , o t bl oli r oe t c tdi m i s hi pe ii n. he our s s es s tt o On De e r1 ,2 0 ,t eW a higo Co ny Cic i Co r e trdj g n a an t c mbe 8 0 9 h s n t n u t r ut u t ne e ud me t g is An es n c n itng hm o ba k r b ey a d o tu t n o j sie An es n dd n ta p a. d ro , o vci i f n o b r n bsr ci f u tc . d ro i o p e l o Ande s fld a ha spe ii i t W as ng on Co t Cic tCour on M a 2,2011 whih r on ie bea tton n he hi t un y r ui t y , c t c tde ed on O c obe 2O,20ll A nde s a a e t t Supr m e C o tof Vi gi a, he our ni t r . r on ppe l d o he e ur r ni whi h di m i s d hi appe on M ar h 5,201 A nde s tl hi f r ha as pe ii on c s se s al c 2. r on i ed s ede al be tton M a 30,201 The cour c y 2. t ondii ly f l d hi pe ii advi e hi t tt pe ii a a e tona l ie s tton, s d m ha he tton ppe r d t be untme y,a ga hi a opporuniy t r pond t t c tr r ng t tm ei s of o i l nd ve m n t t o es o he our ega di he i lne s hi pe ii s tton. I I. A one yea s a u e of lm ia i a i s whe a pe s i c t - r ttt i t tons pple n r on n us ody pur ua t t s nt o he j mentofa sae cour tls a fdea peiin f a wrtofha as c udg tt t ie e rl tto or i be omus 28 U. C.j . S. 2244( . 1 t s case, t saut of lmiai beg t nm on J nua y 1 201 ,whe * 1 n hi he tt e i ttons an o a r 8, 0 n 1Unde 28U .SC. 2 4 d , sa n db teAni roim a dEfe tv De t Pe at Ac (AEDP ' o Api r . j 2 4() a me de y h terrs n fcie ah n ly t K t E A' n rl ) 24,1 996,a fdealpeii f wrt of ha s cor m us be br e r tton or i bea pus t ought wihi one yea fom t l es oft tn r r he at t he f l i olow ng: Ande s sc cton be a e tna . Anderon di notm e tt sJ nua y 1 2011 de dlne;i r on' onvi i cm i l s d e hi a r 8, a i n f c ,by t tda e,Ande s ha ye t tl hi sae habe pe ii 2 A c r ngl , Ande s s at ha t r on d t o ie s t t as tton. co di y r on' peii i ba r d unl she demonsr t s gr ndsf e t bl t lng oft one y rsaut of tton s re es ta e ou or quia e oli he - ea t t e lm ia i ns3 i t to . Des t beng gi n t opporu t t ame hi petton,Ande s makesno a gume pie i ve he tniy o nd s ii r on r nt t s o uppor e t bl t lng of t saut of lm ia i t quia e oli he t t e i ttons. Ac or ngl t c tfnds t t c di y, he our i ha A nde s n ha not de ons r t d a gr ro s m t a e ny ounds f e t bl t lng a t , hi pe ii i or quia e oli nd hus s tton s di m i s d asuntm e y f l d. s se i l ie 1 11. Fort r s sa e t c tdimis sAnde s spe ii asuntmel he ea ons t t d, he our s s e r on' tton i y. - î ;' 7' J. ! ', ENTER:Thi & s da ofAug t201 y us, 2. y Uni Stt Diti tJ id a es src udge ( A) ted t o whc tej d me tb c me f a b tec n lso o dr c r ve o te h ae n ih h u g n ea i l y h o cuin f ie t e iw r h n e r tonoft tm ef s eki s h r ew; xpiai he i or e ng uc evi ( B) te d t o whc te i dme tt fln a a pl ain ce td b Stt a t n i h ae n ih h mpe i n o i g n p i to rae y ae ci n i c o vi ai oft Consiuton orlwsoft Unied Stt i r olton he tt i a he t aes s emove i t a ia was d, f he pplc nt pr ve edfom flngby s h Stt a i e nt r ii uc ae cton; t dae on whi t consiuto l rght as e td was i taly r ni d by t he t ch he tt ina i s re nii l ecog ze he Su eme Cour,i t rghthasbe ne y r ognied by t Supr Cour and ma pr t f he i en wl ec z he eme t de r toaci y a i bl t ca esoncolaerlrviw ;or er tvel pplca e o s lt a e e ( D) ted t o whc tefcu l rdc t o tecam o camspe e tdc udh v b e h ae n ih h a ta p e iae f h li r li rsne o l a e e n dic r t ought exe cs ofduedii nc s oveed hr he r ie lge e. 2 U.. j2 4 ( )1( -D) Hee An es nh salg dn tigt s p o ttea l aino j2 4 ()l( 8 SC. 2 4 d()A . r, d ro a l e ohn o u p r h ppi to f 2 4d( )B e c D) Un e j2 4 d()A)And ro sc n ito be a f l nOco rl , 0 wh nhi t t fl adrc . d r 2 4()1( , es n' o vcin c me i o tbe 8 201 , e s i o ie iet na me a lex r d. ppea pie 2Ande s s one- r coc had ale nm by t tm e he fld hi sae ha s peii t r f r , hi sat r on' yea l k r ady he i ie s tt bea tton; he e o e s t e ? tinafre An esnn tln u drj2 4 ()2. eio f dd dro o ol g n e 2 4d() t o i A p tt n rmu tde n taeete tet l eso hi p tinp ru n t j22 4d o ta tepicpeof eii e s mo srt i r h i i s f s eio u s a t o o h me n t 4 4) r h t h rn il e utbetlig a pisi hsc s . Se Hi v. a tn 2 7F.d7 (t Ci. 0 ) Harsv. thn o 2 9 q ia l ol p le n i ae e l Brxo , 7 3 01 4h r 20 2 ; ri Huc isn, 0 n l F.d 3 5 ( t Ci. 0 0 . Ot e wie a u tmey p tto mu tb d s se b a fdea d src c u t 28U. C. 3 2 4h r 2 0 ) h r s , n n i l e i n s e imis d y e r l itit o r. i S. j2 4 ()1( -D) 2 4 d()A)( .