Hannah v. Mardavich et al, No. 7:2012cv00320 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 07/19/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
r FRKS OFFI U. DI COUA d CE S. SX AT ROANOKE, VA FI. rD ! I TH E U N I N TED STA TE S D I STR I T C O U R T C FO R TH E W E STER N DI STR I T O F V I G I I C R N A R O A N O K E D IV ISIO N D ER W IN K E N DA LL H A N N A H , JUL !8 2 1 . 22 J A C., - CLERK ULt ' . BY; op' t E r kvc C i lA ct on N o.7: vi i 12cv00320 Pl ntff ai i , M EM O M N DU M O PI I N N O FR A N K E.M A R D A V ICH et al, . D efendants. By:Sam uelG .W ison l Uni St esD i t ctJudge ted at s ri Pl i ifD e wi H a h, V i gi a i a e pr ee ngpr s ha tl t sa ton a ntf r n nna a r ni nm t oc di o e, s i ed hi c i purua t 42U. C.j1 agans sxdee t, 1ofwhom a art bee oye soft s nto S. 983 i t i fndans a1 ppe o mpl e he D a le A dul De e i C e e ,c ai i i t r i t c tt i lvi a i a s e ng nvil t t nton nt r l m ng nde e m na e ons iutona ol tons nd e ki d ma e a dij n tv r le .Be a eHa n h h sn tpe fcsi s p r o hi cams t e a g s n n u cie eif c us n a a o ld a t n u po t f s li ,h c u t ldimisHa na sc mpan wih u p eu iet r fln o r wil s s n h' o lit t o t rj d c o eiig. A c pl i m us a l ge t nough f t t s a e a cl i t r le t ti pl us bl on is om a nt t le d e ac s o t t a m o e i f ha s a i e t f e. Gi rtnov.J hns 521F. 298,302(t Ci. )( i BelAt.Cop.v. ac ' araa ' o on, 3d 4h r 2008 quotng l l Twombl 550U. 5 570( v, S. 44, 2007).Howe r t fmii r e ofpla ngaeg e ty ) ve,he a lar uls e di r r al r l xe f pr s pl i i f ,a lt g t w ih m ert i cl i s s ul notbe s ym i d by e a d oï o e a nt f s nd ii an s t ior ous a m ho d t e t hnialrquieme s Se Bea tv.CiyofHa on,775F. 1 1 ec c e r nt. e udet t mpt 2d 274, 277-78( h Ci. 4t r 1 5) Stl,t r lxai oft nzesi notwihoutlmis A cour mus,a mi mum, a e 98 . il he ea ton he l s t i t. t t t ni be bl t dice n f om t c pl ntt pa tesbei s d a t a l ged c o s r r he om ai he ri ng ue nd he le onduc on w hi h ea h c a m t c c li r t . Though r a es s el xed,t s a r s ilde a g ne a cohe e e, i doe notr qui e he t nda d tl m nds e r l r nc and t s e r c u t toc n u eu q e to n ve s u rl p e e tdt t e ' I a 1 8 Ditit o rs o rs s o j r p u sins e r q aey r s ne o h m. d. t 27 . src c u t t ' a e r quied t r vi w pr s r c pl i s f com pla e w ih t ba i r esofpl a ng, nd i r e r o e e i one om a nt or i nc t he s c ul e di a n doi s t c t us eihert de i y c za e c a m s ordi m i s t c pl i ... ft ng o, he our m t t d ntf ogni bl l i i s s he om a nt i he co ant...al t sat acam uponwhihr i ma beg a e ' 28U. C.j1 5A( . mpli fis o t e li c elef y r ntd. ' S. 91 b) Hee, nna hastldac aitdi de i ot e cli (1 t ta uns cfe r Ha h ie ompl n vi d nt hre ams: ) ha n pe iid dee ntt hi pe s lpr t ( t theS e ei dac r f ar orwhihwass d fnda ook s rona opery,2) ha ç c ve hage or az r c ol o t fc n e n, n ta c ul (lfc ( ilrla ed t, a d ()t a a u p cfe d fn a t u o a te a d h t o d a fe t hs ee s ae' n 3 h t n ns e iid ee d n ' haase hi c usnghi me a a s a e ina sr s ( r s d m, a i m ntl nguih nd moto l tes. Compl2,ECF No.1)The . . co pli tdoesnotelbor t a t how orwhe a ha as mentocc r t cr um sa s m an a ae s o n ny r s ured, he ic t nce s r ur oundi hi di c plna y c ge, ha pr ry t de e nt t a underw ha f c ua ng s s i i r har w t ope t he f nda s ook nd t at l cic sa est t i,whi de e nt pa tcpa e i whi h c s ofc r um tnc hey ook t ch f nda s ri i t d n c our es onduc ,o wha t r t s cii rgh st def nda sha vi aed. Theco ti t r f eunabl t r ibl dic r a pe fc i t he e nt ve ol t ur s he e or e o ela y s e n ny pa tc a cons iutonalvi a i fom t com pl ntort d e m i w he he a vi bl cl i s ri ul r tt i ol ton r he ai o et r ne t r ny a e a m lea i tany i vi lde e nt .W hiet pl di r l sdo noti i gans ndi dua f nda s l he ea ng u e mpos a e c i e n xa tng s a r on H n h,a w hie t c ti i f c s i t ofhi c a m s a w illbe a l t nda d nna nd l he our s n a t olcious s l i nd l i r ly c t u a pl a ng t he tl i t f ur ,he m us of e s m e f hol on whi h t ons r e ny e di hat i es n he ut e t fr o oot d c he de enda t c n ba e a ans e o on whi h t c tc ba e a de i i 1 A c or ngl , t f ns a s n w r r c he our an s c s on. c di y he c u t ldimisHn na sc mpan wi u p eu iep ru n t 2 U. C.j1 5 e( )B) o r wil s s n h' o lit t t rj d c u s a t o 8 S. ho 91 ()2 ( f f l et sa eacli . or aiur o t t am EN TER :Jul 19,201 y 2. / / f s ' . ux e e . * z'T . ,' . v j,-e , , . .+ UN I TED STATES D I STRI J D GE CT U 'Ha nnahhasfld as tlte i whih hesaest thehasuns es uly r que t t de e nt f l ie hor etr n c tt ha ucc sf l e sed he f nda s' ul namesfo t die t oft D a leA dul Deen i Cen e .Thec ti notdim isngHanna sc pli f r m he r cor he nvil t t ton t r our s s si h' om ant or f ii t pr de t de e t 'f lna es a lng o ovi he f ndan s ul m .