Osbourne v. Clarke et al, No. 7:2012cv00301 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 7/12/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
eke- ' Q'Re' u : >I eŠr : R A MN I i V T vI ,A L F I TH E UN I N TED STA TES DI STR I T C O U R T C FO R TH E W E STER N DI STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R O A N O K E D I ISIO N V D ER W I O SB O U RN E, N Pl nt f ai if, J D 1 1 J ULW E% BK , EP ct - Ci lA ct on N o.7: c 00301 vi i 12- v- M EM O R AN DU M O PI IO N N HAROLD CLARKE, 1 , ë D efendant s. By: H on.Jac on L.K i er ks s Seni U nied St es D i ri Judge or t at st ct i or e i na y D e wi O s u a V igi a i a e pr ee ng pr y ,f l d a m oton f a pr lm i r r n bot me, r ni nm t oc di o t ie . ij to whih1co tuea alobengacvirg sc antpurua t 42U. C.j 1 3 n uncin, c nsr s s i i l iht ompli s nt o S. 98 wihj rs ito v se i 2 U. C. 1 43 Plitf n me a d fn a t Hao dClr e t u idcin e td n 8 S. j 3 . anif a s s ee d ns r l ak , Die t oft Vigi aDe rme ofCor tons(t rcor he r ni pa t nt reci t VDOC' ; be t cDo l,Govenorof ' Ro r M nnel ) r Vigi a;R. ahe W adenoft Re Oni St ePrs (C r ni M t na, r he d on at ion $ ROSP' ; Kie ,heROSP ' J. sr t ) A s it ntW a de , . ibour a RO SP U ni M a ge 'a La a K .J c ,a A s it nt ssa r n' K l ne, A t na r nd r , a obs n s s a Ator y Ge r lofV igi a. Thi m a t i be or m e f s r eni pur ua t 28 U . C. t ne ne a r ni s ter s f e or c e ng, s nt o S. j 1 5A.Afe rviwi pli ifss si ,1de t motonf pr i na yij tve 91 tr e e ng antf' ubmisons ny he i or elmi r nunci rle a dd s s t ec mpli t t o tp eu iea fi oo s eif n imis h o an wih u rj dc s rv lu . Pl i if a l ge t f l ng i or a i n. Pl i ifnotfed de e nt t the i ka rs a ntf le s he olowi nf m to a ntf i i f nda s ha s tt i k ofs i ij y o ham,' dee erous nur r r 'but fndant ha nota tdonpl ntf' be f Pl ntf i a s ve ce ai ifs hal. ai if s thos a 'a t R O SP a a r ul ofa uns ii t olus on' i t Fa r ax G e r D it i t t t ge' t he s es t n pec fed t l i ' n he i f c ne al s rc t f s ove e ha a ntf he t l i n ' nd t f hr a e c Cour . RO SP s a fdi c r d t tpl i ifnow knows oft t olus o ,' a s a ft e t n t' pl i ifa sea , antf nd t l dmnage ordesr pl ntf' pr ry. Cons que l pli if si r e a i , toy ai ifs ope t e nty, a ntf nca c r ton 1Pl ntf beleve t hi sae c ai if i s hat s tt o r c n ci n volt sVigni Co ej 1 2 2 , n h ctsta s rp so asae u t o vito i ae r i a d 9.- 41 a d e ie r n c it f tt c u t rc e igwh r aGe ea Ditit u g e pli h d e n t a j rs cina u s mehngrltdt a o r po e dn ee n r l src J d e x ans e o s o h ve u idito bo t o ti eae o ga dj r S cinj1 8 i temenst vndc t fd rl iirg t, o t a d esvolt n o saelw. rn uy. e to 9 3 s h a o i iae e ea cvl ihs n to d rs i ai s f tt a o Pl ntf ar y uns e f l pe ii d vi 28U .S. j2254 t va t t co c i e er i J 1 byt ai if lead ucc ssuly ttone a C. o cae he nvitons nt ed n une 994 he Cic tCour ofFara Count f ,i erai,frtde eem u de andm ai ouswoundi . Os nev. ohnson, rui t if x y or nt la is- gr r r lci ng bour J - - No 2:5c - 6 ( D. . b.l , 0 6 .Totee tn p tto rwa t t a anc aln et s c n ito s h . 0 -v001 0 E. Va Fe 4 2 0 ) h xe t ei ne n s o g i h l g hee o vcin , e i e ma a kt eFo rh Cic i Co r o Ap asf r r s in t tl as c e sv j2 4pei o y s h u t r u t u t f pe l o pemiso o 5e u c s i e 25 t i n. t RK c us sS es dal ,'a hee ince he dac ,c tpans numbnes,a c tnt a e t s iylq' nd xpere s a hes hes i , dur s nd onsa t hought ofr venge. û o m e ca t e t e o c r i be ng pr de i a m a m e f rt s e $ N di l r a m nt r a e s i ovi d n ny r r o he i er lorexena pr e ( ai if hagl' nt na tr l oblms pl ntfj s.' Pl i ifcom pl i t the i i s gr ton,i e c t a ound R O SP wih a K - dog,a a ntf a ns ha s n e ega i s s ored r t 9 nd c nnotbuy f a ood. RO SP of i i l w ilnotus t i ow n g i vanc s t m t t ll a of i i l fc a s l e he r re e ys e o el oc l fc a s a boutpl i ifs s t ton a do notgi pl i iff e pos a s a ps Pl ntf co ude ,E n a ntf iua i nd ve a ntf r e t l t m . ai if ncl s ( m 1 no f c t f gh of m y oppr s s t putan e t t r ci tm it ea m e b usng m y lce e w or ed o i t f es or o nd o he a s s r t nt y i i ns t dee g s l a a c t' Pli ifse e tbl r ift c o fnd mylef t ny os. antf e ks quia e ele o ompe dee nt'C evie . ' l fnda s s r c s' s ' 1m us di m i sany a ton orc ai f l d by a i a e i 1de e m i t tt ac i n or t s s ci l m ie n nm t f t r ne ha he to cl i i f i o or f ist s a e a c ai on w hi h r le m a be gr nt d. Se 28 U . C. a m s rvol us a l o t t l m c ei f y a e e S. jj1 1 e ( ,1 5A( ( ) 42U. C.j1 () 9 5()2) 91 b) 1; S. 997ec .Thefrtsa r i ude camsbas upon is tnda d ncl s li ed ( n i s abl m ertes l ga t or ' i a m sofi rnge e ofa l ga i e es w hi h cl a l C ndi put y a il s e l he y, ç i ' cl nf i m nt e l nt r t c e r y doe notexi t' orc ai sw he e t k a t c en i a e c ea l ba e e s ' N eizke v. s s, ' lm r he i c ual ont tons r l ry s l s . f ' t W ila ,490U. 31 327( 98 .Alhoug 1lbeal c tu pr . c ai s Hanesv. lims S. 9, 1 9) t h i rly onsr e oK ompl nt, i Kene,404U. 51 520- ( r r S. 9, 21 1972) 1donota ta t i t sa ae s s ede l ng , c s he nmae' dvoc t, ua pont veopi sat o y a c tt i t ut r nd ons iutonalcl i s t i a e f ie t c e ry r i e on t f c o t c pl i . a m he nm t a l d o l a l a s he a e f he om a nt SeeBr kv. rol,1 F. 241 243( hCi.1 ( tg, , onc rng ;Bea tv.Ciy oc Car l 07 3d , 4t r 997) Luti J.c uri ) udet t ofHa on,775F. 1 4,1 ( hCi.1 .Se as Gor v. e ,574F. 11 mpt 2d 27 278 4t r 985) e lo don Le ke 2d 47, 1l (t Ci.1 (e nii t tadititc tsnote t t asumet r eof 51 4h r 978) r cog zng ha src our i xpeced o s he ol advocat f a pr >qpli ig. e or o antf - The f c s a a t boutbe ng e c t by a K - dog, i i s ega i no bei a e t buy i s ored 9 be ng n egr t on, t ng bl o f f om a c m i s r a notr e vi f e pos a sam ps do noti plca e a Ei ht or ood r om s a y, nd ec i ng r e t l t m i t n g h Four e nt A m e en vi a i n. Se e. ,Sa n v.Co r 51 U . 472, 48 8 ( 995) te h ndm t ol t o e, c. ndi nne , 5 S. 6- 7 1 . , Be e ai . t ,1 0F.d 5 0, 0 (t Ci.1 9 ) To a v. mo to t 9 F.d 1 7 ,1 8 v rt v Smih 2 3 0 5 2 4h r 9 7 ; k r Ar n r u , 7 3 0 8 0 3 ( t Ci.1 ;Twv n v.Crs 58 F. 352,359( 0t Ci.1 .Veba haasme a 8h r 996) ma ip, 4 2d 1 h r 978) r l r s nt nd i e t e t t a i a e e n t a e e t ti c us a i a e f a ore o i dl hr a s o n nm t , ve o n xt nt ha t a es n nm t e r m tonala e y, nxi t ca co tt eavibl j 1 cai SeeEmmonsv.Mcla hln,87 F. 351,35 ( hCi. nnot nsiut a e 983 l m. auz i 4 2d 4 6t r 198 (ttngve ba t easca i f rf pl nifslf aenotani rnge 9) sai r l hr t usng ea or aitf ie r nfi mentofa co tt i lrght;M atnv.Sa g nt 780F. 1 1 ( h Ci.1 )( li a i t a nsiutona i ) ri re , 2d 334, 338 8t r 985 calng n nmae n obse na di notvi aec tt i rghtl La rv.Stel,698F. 1 (t Ci. c ne me d olt onsiutonal i s ; ma ee 2d 286 5h r 1 3)(i- e t al aenotenough.A g 1 cai onl a cr swhe t t e t or 98 Elhras one r j) 983 l m y c ue n he hr as t eae ngc hr tni onduc r uli aconsiutona de i to ' Ke v.Civ ofAl ny,594F. t es t n tt i l prvain. l; ves t ba Supp.11 ( D. Y.l 4)Cû-l us ofvieanda i lnguage(ncudi rcile t tl 47 N. N. 98 gfhe e l busve a i l ng a a pihes, nomatrhow a rntorrpr he i e c tf m t bassf aj 1 cli ' .Thelw i te bhore e e nsbl, anno or he i or 983 am.' ) a s ce r h tme eCh e tnigln u g a dg su e o (jp n lo fc rd n t e e i tu , la t a r t rae n a g a e n e tr s f a e a fie o o , v n f r e t consiut co tt i vi ai .'Fihe v. o on,373F.Su 970,973( D. 1 . tt e nsiutonal oltons' s r W ods pp. E. Va. 973) A le tonst tpr s of i a s i e i ly orne i nty de i d a i a e of l ga i ha i on fci l nt ntona l glge l prve n nm t pr r y whie a tng out i t s ope ofof i i lpolc or c t do no s a e a e tt i l ope t l ci s de he c fc a iy us om t t t ny ons iutona a ngf t de i ton e dy or he os s va l bl z on cl i i a m e ni ulpos - pr va i r m e f t l si a ia e. H uds v. Pa m e ,468 am f l r U. 51 533( S. 7, 1984) Part v.Ta or 451U. 5 ( 981 , rul L irlva pa4ky ; rat vl , S. 27 1 ) ove r ed q ree nt l Danil v. ila ,474U. 327,330- ( 986) Plitf hasapos- prvai rme unde es W lims S. 31 1 . anif tde i ton e dy r Vigni lw,t Vigi aTor Cli Ac.Se VA. r i a a he r ni t ams t e CODEj8. - 95. ûseci 1 was 01 1 3. f ton 983 i e d t pr e onl f r rg sg r nt e by f er llw,a no t tcli sf rwhih nt nde o ot d y ede al i ht ua a e d ed a a nd t or am o c t r ar a hee e dequaerme e unde saelw.'W rg v.Coli ,766F. 8 8 ( h Ci. t e dis r tt a ' iht lns 2d 41, 49 4t r 1 .Theef e, antf c l prvaionaj l cai agans VDOC ofi il ba e o t 985) r or pli if amot e l 983 l m i t tcas s d n he 2N ohi i cae t tan ofi a polc orc t c us adeprvai ofpr ry. t ng ndi ts ha fcil iy usom a ed i ton ope t aleg pr pe t l s Se Ari v. a No. - 6,1 U. App.LEXI 71 a #1 1 l ed o ry os . e ts M pp, 91 601 991 S. S 22, t , 991 W L 61 a *1( h Ci. . 1 )( rc im)(fimi wiht modiiai t ta 299, t 4t r Apr 24, 991 pe ura atr ng t he fc ton ha n i t s c pl i a utt s a e' de i to ofhi pr ry i f i ousbe us oft mna e' om a nt bo he t t s prva i n s ope t s rvol ca e he a ia lt ofapos- prvain rmedy) valbiiy tde i to e . Pli ifdoesnote anhow adee nti rlt t hi ge r al ai t tdg o antf xpli fnda s eaed o s neal leg ton ha inl m edi t eat entorcar i bei pr ded.' A com pl ntneeds 4a s cal r m e s ng ovi ' ai t hortand pl n s at entof ai t em t ecam s o n t a t pe d ri e tt dt rle ' n s fce tSta ta alg to . .o h li h wi g h t he la e s nil o eif a d ufiin û l cu l l ains . t e l e r s a rghtt relefabove t specul i l ....' Bel At .Corp.v.Tw om bl 550 U . 544, ai e i o i he atve evel ' l l y, S. 555( )(ntr lquotton maksomitd) Pli ifwholy f l t a es t eeme sofa 2007 i e na ai r te . antf l ais o ddr s he l nt n Ei ht Am e g h ndm e m e c lc a m ,a lde i t c t c s h a c a m f hi . Pl ntf nt di a l i nd clne o onsnz t uc l i or m ai i f i t d r le o t m e e c us o t the i no r c vi m e c c e ofhi # mi mi ns ea e i s n he r oncl i n ha s t e ei ng di al ar s . ni s < . : ondii 'ofange ,c s pai ,numbnes ,a he c .None oft de e nt a em e c t c tons' r he t ns s nd ada hes he f nda s r dial s af , a ntf doesno des i a r l tons p be w e n a de e nta t pur t d l c of t f pl i if t crbe ny e a i hi t e f nda nd he por e a k me ca cae, nds r s y labiiyunde j1983ma notbeprdiae o t t or of di l r a upevior i lt r y e c td n he he y r ponde ts ror Se Monelv.De tofSoc Se v .436U. 658,663n. ( 978) es a upei . e l p' . r s, S. 71 . Pl ntf doe nots t i nty a l ge a de e nt s s ik ac orom i s on f m e t ai i f s ufk e l le ny f nda ' pec t t s i or o i e avibl j 1 cl m.Plitf fist esa ihanylkelhoodofs c sont meisof nfr a e 983 ai anif al o tbls i i uc es he rt t a ton; ha hei lkel t s f ir pa a ehar ; ha t balnceofe testpsi hi fvo ; he c i t t s i y o ufer re r bl m t t he a quii i n s a r a t ta ij ton i i t publcitr t W i e v. t r Res De .Co i,I .555U. nd ha n nunci s n he i nees. ntr Naual . f uncl nc, S. 7( ) Acc di y, denypli ifsmoton f pr i na yij ver i a meil sa 2008 . or ngl l antf' i or elmi r nundi elef s rtes nd dimist co antwihoutprj c a fi ous purua t 28U. C.j 1 5A( ( ) s s he mpli t eudie s rvol , s nt o S. 91 b)1 . t'eClr i diecedt sndc e oft sM e apdum Opi o a t a o nyi h ek s r t o e opis hi mpr nin nd he cc mpa ng Or rt pl ntf . de o ai if ENTER:Thi @ s - day ofJ y,2012. ul Seni U nie St t D i t i tJ t d a es s rc udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
