Patterson v. Middle River Regional Jail, No. 7:2012cv00299 - Document 9 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 09/04/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
nlFRKS OFFI U. DI .COURT CE S ST .. A a * ,A rx v FI LED I THE UNI STATESDI CT COURT N TED STRI s p gj 2 1 22 FO R TH E W E STERN D I STRI T O F V I G I I C R N A R O AN O K E DI SI VI ON %2 %U BK FR EDE RI H . TTER SO N , CK PA ' Rg c E > K C A SE N O .7: 2CV 00299 1 Pl ntf , ai if M EM O M N D UM O PI O N NI VS. M I DLE R I D VER R EG I NA L JA I O L, By: G l n E .Conr e ad C hi fU ni e St t D i t i tJudge e t d a es s r c D ef endant. Fr de i k H. te s aVigni i aepr e di pr K , ie t scvi rg sa ton e rc Pa tr on, r i a nm t oc e ng o fld hi i l i ht c i puruan t 42 U. C.j1 algi t thehasi quaea ce st me a heat te me a s to S. 983, le ng ha nade t c s o ntl lh rat nt t tej i wh r h i c ni e .Up nrv e o terc r ,h c u t idst t h a t nmu tb h al e e e s o tn d o e iw f h e o d te o r fn ha t e ci o s e s m a iy di m i s um r l s s ed. Pat r o saeshi cli a f l : te s n t t s am s olows 1nee t s e a ps hi t itf r m y m e a di or r . The do t c e onc a do e yc a r s o nt l s de s c or om s e m ont b lha ye t s e hi be us t ls i t l ng. lha be he e f r 7 h ut ve t o e m ca e he it s oo o ve en r o m ont now a nee ps hi ti ca e f m y de us o lbipol rs hi hs nd d yc a r c r or l i na - a e zophr ni e c ds r e .1f e ta myme ia n e sa en tb i me b t j i. . io d r e lh t dc l e d r o eng t y he al . . Com pl2. The onl de e ntPate s na e i t M i e Ri rRe o lJ l A sr le , y f nda tr on m s s he ddl ve gi na ai. ei f Patro se ta frt aVigi aDe t ntofCor to ( tes n e ks r nse o r ni parme recins VDOC)prs f iiy t ot t ion aclt û ha s g )ca rc vepr rps hiti cae'Compl 4. he n e ei ope yc arc r.' . Tosaeaca eofa tonunde j1 apli ifmus esa iht thehasbee tt us ci r 983, antf t tbls ha n de i ofrgh sgua a e d by t Consiuton o lwso t Unie St t sandt tt s prved i t r nt e he tt i r a f he td a e ha hi d prva i r ule f om co uc c m it d by a pe s a tng unde col ofs a e l w . W es e i ton es t d r nd t om te r on c i r or t t a t v. ki , U. 42( 988) Thec ti r rdt dimisan a tonorcam fl bya At ns 487 S. 1 . our s equie o s s y ci li ied pr s r a i ta gove m e t e iy orofi i li t c t t r i s t tt a ton orcl i i one ga ns m n al ntt tc a f he our de e m ne ha he c i am i fi o , ai ous orf ist sae acai on whih r le m a be g a e 28U . C. s rvol us m lci , al o t t l m c e if y r nt d. S. j 1 5 b)1 . 91 A( ( ) C algoveni bodi ... a bes die tyunde j1 f mo tr de lrt y, toc r ng es c n ued rcl r 983 or nea y, caaor o ij nci er le whee. .h a to ta i alg dt b u c n tt t n lmplme t o r n u tv eif r . t e cin h t s le e o e n o siui a i e n s r o e cu esa polc sa e e , di nc r ul ton,o de i i of i i l ado e and xe t i y t t m nt or na e, eg a i r c son f c aly pt d pr m ul a e by t tbody' ofier . M one lv.Ne Yor CiyDe ofSoca Se vce ,436 o g t d ha s fc s' ' l w k t pt il r i s U. 6 8 6 0( 9 8 .Top o et a ag v r me tl n i , u ha al c l ali la l f r S. 5 , 9 1 7 ) r v h t o e n na e tt s c s o a j i, s ib e o y c tt i nalvi a i c m m it by is e pl yee , a ntf m us s ons iuto ol tons o ted t m o s pl i if t how t tt e iy' po i y ha he ntt s lc w asS he m o ng f c o t c tt i na vi a i n. Pol Co y v.Dods 45 U . 31 l t vi or e f he ons iuto l ol to ' ' k unt on, 4 S. 2, 3 6( 9 ) P t ro f ist l kaj ip lc t a yo t alg dd prv to sa d a s c 2 1 81. at s n al o i al o iy o n f he le e e iain n s u h, e n n hi a ui fist saea a to a ecam a ans t ej i,whih i t onl def ndanti t sl ws t al o tt n cin bl li g i t h all c s he y e . Th r f r,h c u t l ds s tec mpan wi o t rj dc .An a prpraeo d rwil ee o e te o r wil imis h o lit t u p eu ie h p o it r e l i s t sda s ue hi y. The Clr i die t t s nd c esoft sm e a um o ni n a a ompan ng e k s r ced o e opi hi mor nd pi o nd cc yi or rt pl i if de o antf ENTER:Ths &- d yo Yu i 1# a f v ' w - , oj a a. Chi fU nie St t s Di t i tJ e t d a e s rc udge 1Patro salgainsas fit saea yato bl jl 3cam a i ta jiof a. tesn' l to lo alo tt n cina e 98 li gans ny al fkil e Fis,Pa t s f l t alege f t i catngt hi curentment healh condii pr ent as i rt ter on ais o l acs ndi i hat s r al t ton es s erous me c nedf i dit te t nto difrn ac dial e ormme ae rame r fee t c ommod tont tl ha rc i da t alo ta ai ha z s eeve theji, r h t e of i al have ac ed wih delber t i fer fci s t t i a e ndif ence t hi needs. SeeEselev.Ga bl 429 U . 97,102 o s tl m e, S. ( 9 )(i i t tt saeEiht Ame me cam,i t mus s w p io ofiilsdei rt 1 76 fndng ha o tt g h nd nt li nmae t ho rs n fca ' l ae be i fee et imae ss rou me c l e ) W rg tv. lns 76 F.d 8 , 49( t Ci.1 5 ndif rnc o n t ' e i s dia ne d ; ih Coli , 6 2 41 8 4h r 98 ) (idi t a imae' ds gre nt t me c l ro ne r g r ngdig ossa c reo te t n fn ng h t n t s ia e me wih dia pe s n l e a di a n i nd ou s f r ame t do sno i iaet eEih hAme me ) Patro do sno alg t a h ha no i e t j i' e t mplc t h g t nd nt. te s n e t le e h t e s tt d he als i m edi saf ofany pari arment healh s pt orexpl ned i hi com pl ntwhatteat cal t f tcul al t ym oms ai n s ai r menthe beive hene d .Se ond Pa tronh snoc nsiu in rg t b c nfne i a y pa t ulrj i o le s e s c , tes a o ttto al ihto e o i d n n ri a al r c p io fclt Se Olm v. a ne on , U. 23 ,2 ( 98 ) rs n a iiy. e i W ki k a 46l S. 8 45 1 3 . 2