Hart v. Commonwealth of Tazewell County, Virginia, No. 7:2012cv00277 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 07/20/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
oaFRK' OFFt U. Dl COURT S CE S. sm AT ROANOKE, VA Fifb s. q I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W EST ERN DI STRI O F V I G I I CT R N A RO AN O K E D I ISIO N V JEFFER Y A LLEN H A R T, J 22 1 UL 2 JULI A BK Y, CLERK ' D J'YCL RK I E ' C A SE N O .7: 2C V 00277 1 Pet toner, ii M EM O R AN D U M O PI NION V. CO M M ON W E ALTH O F TA ZEW ELL C O U NTY ,V I G I I , R N A By: G l n E.C onr e ad Chi fUni e St t s Di t c Judge e t d a e s ri t R espondent. J f r Ale Ha t a Vi gi a i a e pr e ng pr K ,tl a pl a ng he syl a ef e y l n r , r ni nm t oce di o i ed e di t ed s ( OTI TO VA CA TE A $ Ol A B l I O 'CON V I O N AN D SEN TEN CE û M ON V D N TI CTI P UANT TO VA. URS CODE j8014 8' Hat o o jcst t c u tsc n tu to o hs . - 2 . r n w be t o he o r' o sr cin f i ' moi a apeii f awrtofha asc ton s tton or i be opus purua t 28U. C.j225 Ast sae1w , s nt o S. 4. he tt a pr son on whih Ha tr i doe nota ho i et sf de a c t o r viw t va i t ofhi ovii c r eles s ut rz hi e r l our t e e he ldiy s camsta h i wr n f l c n ie u e asaec u t rmia j d me tt ec u t imis s li h t e s o g ul o fn d nd r tt o r ci n l u g n ,h o r ds se y Hatsp t o wi u p eu ie r' ei n t t rj d c . t ho H a tfl d hi C O TI TO VA CA TE A G OI AB l I O 'C ON V I ON AN D r ie s E M ON V D N TI CTI SENTENCE PURSUANT TO VA.CODE j8. - 'onJ 22,201 Bec us Ha ts 01428' une 2. a e r' pla n c alng dtev ldt o hsc n i me tu d rac i n l u g n e tr da an t e dig h le e h aiiy f i o fne n n e rmia j d me t n ee g is hi byt Ta we lCount Cicui Cour by or re e e J 28,2012,t c t i r ly m he ze l y r t q de nt r d une he our lbe a l c tu a c tonal tl Ha tsa ton asape ii f awrtofha a c pus purua onsr ed nd ondii ly ied r' c i tton or i be s or , s nt t 28U. C.j2254.Se Catov. tdStts 5 U. 375,381( o S. e sr Unie ae , 40 S. 2003)(t derlc rs t Fe a ou t som etm esw ili e t l i l gnor he egall t a pr y lt ga atachest a m oton and r abel hat o x ii nt t o i echar erze ad i . t motoni or t plc iwihi adifr tl alc tgor ' Thec tsor ri onne he i n der o a e t t n feen eg ae y.) ' our' de nf d Ha t ha heha notpad t r st $5. flng f ef t a to i o me Ha t ha a a rt t d i he equiie 00 ii e or he c i n; nf r d r t t s J j225 peii hi pla nga r t beuntmeyfldunde 28U. C.j2244( ( ) a 4 tton, s e di ppeaed o i l ie r S. d)1; nd g a e hi a oppo t t t pr vi a a tona evi nce r r ng t tm e i s ofhi r nt d m n r uniy o o de ny ddii l de ega di he i lne s s j2254petton. ii Ha'h sn w s b te wha t ec u t o sr e a hso j ci nt t ec u tsp ir l a o u mitd t h o r c n tu s s i be to o h o r' ro t c tu tonofhi moin a aj2254peii onsr ci s to s tton.Hatsae t thedoe notwa hi pla ng r tts ha s nt s e di a ese asaj2254ha speii be aus a s h,imaywelbedimis da uni l ddr s d bea tton, c e s uc t l s s e s tmey tldu d rj22 4( .Th c u t l s sant i o jcin.Ha tnssst t h c u t d rs ie n e 4 * e o r wil u t i h s be to r i it ha t e o r a d e s hi pl a ng i t a a a t oton t Vac t a V oi A b l to Convi ton a Se e e ' s e di ns e d s d i o M ae d nii c i nd nt nc ' unde r Vigi aCodej8. - Thi saesauedoesnota horzet sfdealco tt rviw t r ni 01428. s tt ttt ut i hi e r ur o e e he vai i o Ha4 sc nfn me tu d rasaec u t rmi lu me tlTh r f r ,h c u t l ldt f l' o i e n n e tt o r c i na j dg n . e eo e t e o r wil y tnni t t j2254c ea wildimisHa tsmoton/ ttonwihoutprj ce An e nae he as nd l s s r' i peii t eudi . a opra eor rwilis t sda ppr it de l s ue hi y. The Cl r i di e t d t s nd c e oft sm e or ndum opi on and a om panyi e k s r c e o e opi s hi m a ni cc ng or rt pettone . de o ii r ENTER:Thi Q O da ofJ y, 2012. s y ul Chi fU nie St esD i t i tJ e t d at sr c udge 1 Har al i or st courtt the fld a sm iarm oton i t Supr t so nf m he ha ie i l i n he eme CourtofVigi a, but r ni hasr nty r fie t moton i t Taze lCount Cicui Cour,whih appea t be t appr it ece l e l d he i n he wel y r t t c rs o he opra e f um f Ha ' curentcl m s. SeeECF No.3. or or rts r ai