Wolters v. Commonwealth Of Virginia et al, No. 7:2012cv00269 - Document 8 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 7/3/2012. (tvt)

Download PDF
4k 4opy. :j xmwtiw . . r r #*,;. , j e I THE UNI STATESDI CT COURT N TED STRI FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRICT OF VI RGI A NI t- V. R2 % ROANOK E DI SI VI ON AN DR EW W O LTER S, Pl nt f , ai i f c> C i lA c i N o.7: c 00 vi ton 12- v- 269 V. . . M EM O R AN D UM O PI NIO N CO M M ONW EALTH OF VI NI # 1 , RGI A, By: H on.Jackson L .K i ser Seni U ni ed St esD i t ctJudge or t at s ri D ef endant s. A ndr w W ole s a f de a i na e pr ee ng pr K ,f l a c vi r ght co pl i t e t r , e r l m t oc di o ied i l i s m a n . pur ua t Bi nsv. x Unknown Na s nt o ve Si med Ace sofFe r Bur u ofNa cot's 403U . 388 nt de al ea r i , c S. ( 9 )wihj rs ito v se i 2 U. C. 1 1 Plitf ddn ts b tp y n o te$ 5 1 71, t u idcin e td n 8 S. j 33 . an if i o u mi a me t f h 3 0 fl f ea d a k t p o e dj f r pa p rs S e2 U. C. j 1 4 a , 91 . ii e n s s o r c e - o ma u e i. e 8 S. j 91 () 1 5 ng q The c tfndst tpl i ifha a l as t e no ha s c vi com pl nt ora a s our i ha a ntf d t e t hr e n- bea i l ai s ppe l pr vi l dimi s a fi ous a malci ,o f rf ii t sat ac am upon whih r le e ousy s s ed s rvol , s i ous r o a lng o t e l i c e if ma begrntd.W olesv.Fç r Bur uofPrs , 1 3071 si op. t12( hCi. a y a e tr dqal ea ions No. 0- 7, lp a - 5t r J n. l1 2011 (ppe dimis d a fi ous; oler v. de a Bur uofPrs , 08-v, ) a al s se s rvol ) W t s Fe r l ea ions No. c 0S37, si o a 1( . La J l 5 201 )(cind s se wihp eudc a fi lu a df rfiig l p. t W D. . uy , 0 a to imis d t rj ie s rvoo s n o aln p t saeacli uponwhihr i ma begrntdl W olq sv. e,No.1: c 02290,si o o tt am c elef y a e ; tr Huntr 07-vlp p. a 4( Coo. a . , 0 9 ( ci nds se wihp eu ief rf iigt saeacam up n t D. l M r 2 2 0 ) a to imisd t rj d c o aln o tt li o whih rle ma beg a e .Se He lev. le , 116707,si op.a 1 ( h Ci.J 5, c eif y r ntd) e nse Kelr No. lp t 0 4t r une 201 ( ohi tngadititco tdimis lt bec i r at r s<kewhiet dimis li 2) pr bii src ur s s a o onsdeed hid ti l he s s a s benga ald) I a or nc wiht t e srke pr sonof28U. C.j l 5() t Cou t i ppe e . n cc da e t he hre-ti s ovii S. 91 g ,he r ofAppea sf t Fit Cic tpr vi usy a vie pl i ift thene de t s i t $350 00 l or he fh r ui e o l d s d antf ha e d o ubm t he . ftng f ores a i h a i m i ntt ea ofs < o phys oa ha m t pr ee w ih a v vi s to ii ee t bls n m ne hr t e i us i l r o oc d t i l ui nee h a c muae tr etti s'p ru n t 2 U. C. 1 1 ( ) W o tr v, dea Bu e uo e c u lts h e d rke , u s a t o 8 S. j 9 5 g . le s Fe rl r a f s ' Pr s ,N o.1 3071 s i op. 2. i ons 07, lp at Pl i ifnamesasde e nt t t sa i t Comm onwe 1h ofVigi a a Bobby antf f nda s o hi cton he at r ni nd Rusel,Su rne ntoft W ese Vigi aRe o J i (6ai') Plitf c ansa s l peitnde he tm r ni ginal al & l'. anif ompli bout J t di gnos s a t e t ent pr de by t J i' m e ca saf t t e tpl ntf sbl s a he a e nd r a m s ovi d he a l s di l t f o r a ai if ood ug r l ve s Pl i tf al o a l est tJ i s a fr t la ed a ns hi ba e on va i co tonsof e l . a n if s leg ha a l t f e a i t gai t m s d rous ndii c i m e a hi i e a to wih J i sa f onfne nt nd s ntr c i ns t al t f. Afe r e ng pl ntf sc tr eviwi ai if ompli ti t sa ton,i i c e rt tpli ifdoe no a n n hi c i t s l a ha a ntf s t e tbihta h i c re t un e a i n n t ra o a y sro sp y ia ij r wihnt e sa ls h t e s u r nl d r ny mmie t h e t f n e iu h sc l nu y ti h y mea ngof28U. C.j1 g) Se e. ,Ma tnv.Shet 319F. 10 1 (t Ci. ni S. 915( . e, M. ri lon, 3d 48, 050 8h r 2003)(e rngpr ofa ong ngs rousphysc lijlyorapat nofmic rquii oof n oi ei ia ntr ter s onduc t e i n i t el eioo o i n n s ro sp y ia ij r l As lyv Diwo t,1 F.d71 , vde cng h i l d f mmi e t ei u h sc l nu y ; he . l rh 47 3 5 k h 71 (t Ci.1998)(t lgai t tt prs rhasfce i ne da ri t pa ta e 7 8h r û e tons ha he ione Al a d mmi nt nge n he s r i ufi i t ti rt e e e i t j 1 5( .....Furhemo e pli ifwa hous da a ns tcent o rgge hll xc pton o 91 g) ) t r r , antf s e t f r pe t nta y i Pe yl a whe hei tt e t saci a t , ai ifcoul not ede al nie ir n nns vani n nsiut d hi ton, nd hus pl ntf d havebe n i i mi ntda rofs ro physca har i Pe yl ni a tt c tons e n m ne nge e i us i l m n nns va a bou he ondii pr ousye re e a t J li Vigi a.Ac or ngl 1dimist aci wiho prj ce evi l xpeinc d t he ai n r ni c di y, s s he ton t ut eudi f pl ntf sf iur t pa t flng f a t tme oftlng t c or ai if a l e o y he ii ee t he i ii he ompl n . Se e. .Dupr v. aitl e, a, . ee Pame , 4F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci. l r 28 3d 234, 237 1 t r 2002)(e o ngt tt flngf i dueupo flnga ras ni ha he ii ee s n ii cvi a to whe L f apa rsm o sonsdono a yt pli ifa t tt e ti no i l cin n q oml upei vii t ppl o antf nd ha he our s t r quied t pe m i pl ntf a opporuniy t pa t f lng f i pl i i fi i i bl t pr e e r o r t ai if n t t o y he ii ee f a nt f s nelgi e o oce d t f mapa rs. q or upei) . 1Co e nty, pl ntf m o i t m e gedoc e sfom prorca e i o t sa to i de e a m oo . ns que l ai ips ton o r um nt r i s s nt hi c in s nid s t 2 The Clr i die e t s nd c esoft sM e or ndum Opi on a t a ompanyi e k s r ctd o e opi hi m a ni nd he cc ng Or rt pl i if de o a ntf . EN TER : Thi J d oJy0. a fl21 y u, 2 r % . Se rU nie St t n' t d ae 3 . # i ti tJ sr c udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.