Wolters v. Commonwealth Of Virginia et al, No. 7:2012cv00269 - Document 8 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 7/3/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
4k 4opy. :j xmwtiw . . r r #*,;. , j e I THE UNI STATESDI CT COURT N TED STRI FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRICT OF VI RGI A NI t- V. R2 % ROANOK E DI SI VI ON AN DR EW W O LTER S, Pl nt f , ai i f c> C i lA c i N o.7: c 00 vi ton 12- v- 269 V. . . M EM O R AN D UM O PI NIO N CO M M ONW EALTH OF VI NI # 1 , RGI A, By: H on.Jackson L .K i ser Seni U ni ed St esD i t ctJudge or t at s ri D ef endant s. A ndr w W ole s a f de a i na e pr ee ng pr K ,f l a c vi r ght co pl i t e t r , e r l m t oc di o ied i l i s m a n . pur ua t Bi nsv. x Unknown Na s nt o ve Si med Ace sofFe r Bur u ofNa cot's 403U . 388 nt de al ea r i , c S. ( 9 )wihj rs ito v se i 2 U. C. 1 1 Plitf ddn ts b tp y n o te$ 5 1 71, t u idcin e td n 8 S. j 33 . an if i o u mi a me t f h 3 0 fl f ea d a k t p o e dj f r pa p rs S e2 U. C. j 1 4 a , 91 . ii e n s s o r c e - o ma u e i. e 8 S. j 91 () 1 5 ng q The c tfndst tpl i ifha a l as t e no ha s c vi com pl nt ora a s our i ha a ntf d t e t hr e n- bea i l ai s ppe l pr vi l dimi s a fi ous a malci ,o f rf ii t sat ac am upon whih r le e ousy s s ed s rvol , s i ous r o a lng o t e l i c e if ma begrntd.W olesv.Fç r Bur uofPrs , 1 3071 si op. t12( hCi. a y a e tr dqal ea ions No. 0- 7, lp a - 5t r J n. l1 2011 (ppe dimis d a fi ous; oler v. de a Bur uofPrs , 08-v, ) a al s se s rvol ) W t s Fe r l ea ions No. c 0S37, si o a 1( . La J l 5 201 )(cind s se wihp eudc a fi lu a df rfiig l p. t W D. . uy , 0 a to imis d t rj ie s rvoo s n o aln p t saeacli uponwhihr i ma begrntdl W olq sv. e,No.1: c 02290,si o o tt am c elef y a e ; tr Huntr 07-vlp p. a 4( Coo. a . , 0 9 ( ci nds se wihp eu ief rf iigt saeacam up n t D. l M r 2 2 0 ) a to imisd t rj d c o aln o tt li o whih rle ma beg a e .Se He lev. le , 116707,si op.a 1 ( h Ci.J 5, c eif y r ntd) e nse Kelr No. lp t 0 4t r une 201 ( ohi tngadititco tdimis lt bec i r at r s<kewhiet dimis li 2) pr bii src ur s s a o onsdeed hid ti l he s s a s benga ald) I a or nc wiht t e srke pr sonof28U. C.j l 5() t Cou t i ppe e . n cc da e t he hre-ti s ovii S. 91 g ,he r ofAppea sf t Fit Cic tpr vi usy a vie pl i ift thene de t s i t $350 00 l or he fh r ui e o l d s d antf ha e d o ubm t he . ftng f ores a i h a i m i ntt ea ofs < o phys oa ha m t pr ee w ih a v vi s to ii ee t bls n m ne hr t e i us i l r o oc d t i l ui nee h a c muae tr etti s'p ru n t 2 U. C. 1 1 ( ) W o tr v, dea Bu e uo e c u lts h e d rke , u s a t o 8 S. j 9 5 g . le s Fe rl r a f s ' Pr s ,N o.1 3071 s i op. 2. i ons 07, lp at Pl i ifnamesasde e nt t t sa i t Comm onwe 1h ofVigi a a Bobby antf f nda s o hi cton he at r ni nd Rusel,Su rne ntoft W ese Vigi aRe o J i (6ai') Plitf c ansa s l peitnde he tm r ni ginal al & l'. anif ompli bout J t di gnos s a t e t ent pr de by t J i' m e ca saf t t e tpl ntf sbl s a he a e nd r a m s ovi d he a l s di l t f o r a ai if ood ug r l ve s Pl i tf al o a l est tJ i s a fr t la ed a ns hi ba e on va i co tonsof e l . a n if s leg ha a l t f e a i t gai t m s d rous ndii c i m e a hi i e a to wih J i sa f onfne nt nd s ntr c i ns t al t f. Afe r e ng pl ntf sc tr eviwi ai if ompli ti t sa ton,i i c e rt tpli ifdoe no a n n hi c i t s l a ha a ntf s t e tbihta h i c re t un e a i n n t ra o a y sro sp y ia ij r wihnt e sa ls h t e s u r nl d r ny mmie t h e t f n e iu h sc l nu y ti h y mea ngof28U. C.j1 g) Se e. ,Ma tnv.Shet 319F. 10 1 (t Ci. ni S. 915( . e, M. ri lon, 3d 48, 050 8h r 2003)(e rngpr ofa ong ngs rousphysc lijlyorapat nofmic rquii oof n oi ei ia ntr ter s onduc t e i n i t el eioo o i n n s ro sp y ia ij r l As lyv Diwo t,1 F.d71 , vde cng h i l d f mmi e t ei u h sc l nu y ; he . l rh 47 3 5 k h 71 (t Ci.1998)(t lgai t tt prs rhasfce i ne da ri t pa ta e 7 8h r û e tons ha he ione Al a d mmi nt nge n he s r i ufi i t ti rt e e e i t j 1 5( .....Furhemo e pli ifwa hous da a ns tcent o rgge hll xc pton o 91 g) ) t r r , antf s e t f r pe t nta y i Pe yl a whe hei tt e t saci a t , ai ifcoul not ede al nie ir n nns vani n nsiut d hi ton, nd hus pl ntf d havebe n i i mi ntda rofs ro physca har i Pe yl ni a tt c tons e n m ne nge e i us i l m n nns va a bou he ondii pr ousye re e a t J li Vigi a.Ac or ngl 1dimist aci wiho prj ce evi l xpeinc d t he ai n r ni c di y, s s he ton t ut eudi f pl ntf sf iur t pa t flng f a t tme oftlng t c or ai if a l e o y he ii ee t he i ii he ompl n . Se e. .Dupr v. aitl e, a, . ee Pame , 4F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci. l r 28 3d 234, 237 1 t r 2002)(e o ngt tt flngf i dueupo flnga ras ni ha he ii ee s n ii cvi a to whe L f apa rsm o sonsdono a yt pli ifa t tt e ti no i l cin n q oml upei vii t ppl o antf nd ha he our s t r quied t pe m i pl ntf a opporuniy t pa t f lng f i pl i i fi i i bl t pr e e r o r t ai if n t t o y he ii ee f a nt f s nelgi e o oce d t f mapa rs. q or upei) . 1Co e nty, pl ntf m o i t m e gedoc e sfom prorca e i o t sa to i de e a m oo . ns que l ai ips ton o r um nt r i s s nt hi c in s nid s t 2 The Clr i die e t s nd c esoft sM e or ndum Opi on a t a ompanyi e k s r ctd o e opi hi m a ni nd he cc ng Or rt pl i if de o a ntf . EN TER : Thi J d oJy0. a fl21 y u, 2 r % . Se rU nie St t n' t d ae 3 . # i ti tJ sr c udge