Moore et al v. Corell Electrical Contractors, Inc., No. 7:2012cv00262 - Document 21 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 10/30/2012. (eot)
Download PDF
. - r, couq. xov r CLERK' OFFf U..DIT COUR7 S CE S S . AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED 02T 32 2 1 22 I TH E U N I N TED STA TE S D I RICT C O U R T ST FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI O F VI CT RGI A NI R O AN O K E D I SI N VI O M I AEL M O ORE etal, CH . J ULI C. B; Y DEP , LERK CL E Ci lActon No.7: v00262 vi i 12: Pl ntff ai i s, M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N N O C O R E LL EL EC TR IC A L C O N TR A C TO R S,l C . N , By:Sam uelG .W ison l U nied St esD i ri Judge t at st ct D ef endant . Thi i a a ton by M ihae M oo e J hn Ar sr ng, vi W ilams a St ve s s n ci c l r, o m to Da d li , nd e Ra a al c r nta f m e e pl esofCo el El c r c lCo r c o s l . plr ua t t gl nd, l ur e nd or r m oye r l e t i a nt a t r , nc , z s nt o he FarLa StndadsAc,29U. C. 20le s q.(t i bor a r t S. j te û FLSA',al i t tCorl wiluly ' legng ha el lf l ) vi a e t pl i i f 'r ght t r e ve m i m u wag a o ri e pa The pl i if s e t ol t d he a ntf s i s o ec i ni m e nd ve tm y. a ntf s e k o r pr s ntal smia l st t d e oye who ha wor d a Co elsf iiy i Salm, e e e l i lry iua e mpl es ve ke t r l' aclt n e V i g ni ,s nc J y of2009,a t y hav fl a m oto t t tef e t Co e lha r ponde by r i a i e ul nd he e ied i n o ha f c . r l s es d flngaRul 1 b)6)motont ds s t c mpli ba e o i ufiintpla ngt rBel ii e 2( ( i o imis he o ant s d n ns fce e di mde l Ata tcCo . Twombl 5 U. 544( )a As r tv.gbal556U. 662( lni p v. v, 50 S. 2007 nd hcof l , S. 2009) . Viwi t c e ng he ompl i i t lg m os f vor bl t t pl n if,t c tfndsi ne ry ant n he i ht t a a e o he aitf s he our i t a l de d off t a lga i a t r f ei ufk i n l pl unde Twombl a I ba . voi acual le tons nd he e or ns t e ty ed r y nd q l Ac o dn l ,h c u t l g a t rl' moint ds s wih u p eu ie c r ig y t e o r wi r n Co els to o imis t o t rj dc . l 1. Thepl nif (ndt me r oft pr edcas)aec r ntorf me Co el aitfs a he mbe s he opos l s r ure or r r l e pl esw ho ha pr de ç e rca s r c 'on Cor l ' beha f The pl i if ale t t m oye ve ovi d t cti l e vi es' el e ls l. a ntf s l ge ha çso o tePlitfsa dme r o t prpo e ca sweep i b t j bo ts .Th y i l me f h anif n mbes f he o sd ls r ad y he o r a k e g L... '. . v . we eno pa d o - nd- ha ftm e t ti houry r t ofpa f a lhour s twor ngove r t i ne a one- l i s h r l aes y or 1 s pen ki r 40 i a w or w e k,norw e e t y pa d f rco pe a e tm e s ntt a lng w hie wor ng f n k e r he i o m ns bl i pe r ve i l ki or a f t be ftofCo el' Ac or ngt t pli tfs Co el f iedt ke p a qua ewa nd or he ne i r l.' c di o he a n if , r l a l o e de t ge r c ds i tt e at s ba e pay s t m t tr ule i t pl i if e r ngl s t n e or , nsiut d a k- s d yse ha es t d n he antfs a ni e s ha mi mum wa a enga i a 1oft aleg co ni ge, nd ged n 1 he l ed nduc i wilulvi ai oft FLSA. t n lf ol ton he ll. Fe r lRul ofCi lPr ce lel b)6)pemist c tt dimisac antf r de a e vi o dtr 2( ( r t he our o s s ompli o Callet saeacli uponwhihr ifca begrnt ' Fed. Ci P.1 b)6 .Tos i k itr o tt am f c ele n a ed. ' R. v. 2( () unrve amoton und t sr e, heco pl ntmus c an ' nough f c st sa eacli t r le t t i er hi ul t m ai t ont i û e a t o tt am o e if ha i plusbl o isfc ' Twombl 55 U. a 570(iai omit .Thepli if mus al e s a i e n t a e. ' v, 0 S. t ctton ted) antfs t leg f c st tC a s arghtt r le a a t ha t ie i o e if bovet s c ai lve . l a 5 d-hepl usbiiy r he pe ultve e l' d. t 55. ç- a i lt ' l sanda d i no a n t a ç oba lt r quie e t'buti a ksf mor t n a s rpos i lt t r s t ki o pr biiy e r m n , t s or e ha hee sbiiy t ta d e nthasac ed unl uly.' I l l 5 U . a 678.W hie t co tm us a e t ha ef nda t awf l ' cba , 56 S. t l he ur t cc pt he cai nt 'f c ua alega i a tue t st ne i tna plc bl t lga c usons Thr dba e l ma s a t l l tons s r , hi e t s ç p ia e o e l oncl i . ea r i r iasoft elme sofaca eofa ton,s ect l he e nt us ci uppore by me ec us y sae e s dono td r oncl or tt m nt, t s fce' L. ufi .' ds u He e t compl ntno e t tCo elpai t pl ntf sl st t m i mum hou l r , he ai t s ha r l d he ai if es han he ni ry w a an l s t n t ge d e s ha s a one ha ftm e t ei hotry r t ' f rove tm e, aie t one- nd- - l i s h r zl a es' o ri f l d o c ompe a ee oye f rcompe a e ta ,s r isdu y t ke p a cur t wager c ds ns t mpl es o ns bl r vel hiked t t o e c ae e or , a di ea h oft et ngswiluly.Thes a e' oncus y ale tons'andt y a ee tte nd d c hes hi lf l e r t l or lga i ,' c he r n ild t no we gh f t pur e o e l tng t s fc e y oft oo pli .Theonl o i t or he pos s f vaua i he uf i nc he m a nt y di c r bl f c u s s e ni e a t al uppor f t s c l i nsi t pl ntf s m e t o ofa t s ba e t or he e onc us o s he ai i f ' n i n a k- s d pa m e s t m a isr e i de i ng t pl i i f ofa qua e pa l ea r r ia sof y nt ys e nd t ol n pr vi he a ntf s de t y. t Thr dba e ec t l t e e nt ofa c us ofaci n,s he l me s a e to uppore bym e ec l or sa e nt ,' l no s t n a td r oncus y t t me s'wil t usai e ls ton o s s . c ai t r le 1I A c or ngl t c t a sCor l ' m o i t dim i s l m o e i f ;s c di y, he our gr nt - 11 1. Fo ter a o ssae ,h c u t r ns wih u p eu ie Co elsmoint ds s te r h e s n tt d t e o r ga t, t o t rj dc , rl' to o imis h c pl nt om ai . EN TER :Oct r 30, 2. obe 201 .w, ., -' ' .' e zr ' ' Z e .e .. a r . UN I TED STA TES D I STRI J GE CT UD 3 . >