McLean v. Ratliff et al, No. 7:2012cv00227 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 05/29/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
# . ra msoFFl u, Dl rnlr n oe s. sx l A a FN DEv T c Io ,A j EK L MAï 2 2 1 92 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R T H E W ESTERN D I STR I T O F V I I I C RG N A R O AN O K E D I I O N V SI QUENTI M CLEAN, N Pl ntf ai if, V. M S.R ATLI e t , FF, t #. D efendant . s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) . , ' JUL C. A EY, GLEM BY t DE CL ERK Ci lA cton N o.7: vi i 12cv00227 M EM O M N D U M O PI I N N O By: Sam ue G .W is l lon Unied St e Di t i tJudge t at s s r c Pli if Que i M c n,a Vigi a prs r pr e di pr s brngs t s a ton antf ntn Lea r ni ione oc e ng o e, i hi ci purua t 42 U. C.j 1 s nt o S. 983. Howeve,a las t e ofM cLe n' prvi c ant ha r t e t hre a s e ous ompli s ve be n dimis d wih prj ce fr f l e t sae a cam puruan t 28 U. C. e s se t eudi o aiur o tt li s t o S. v an 1 5()2)B)i)' Theeor ,M cle may no pr e wih t saci unl she et rpa 91 e( ( (i. rf e t oc ed t hi ton es ihe ys te$ 5 .0fl g feo s o t a h i ( n e i n n d n e o s ro p ysc ln uy. 2 h 3 00 ii e r h ws h t e s s d r mmie t a g r f eius h ia ij r ' 8 n u ' U. C.j1 5( . S. 9l g) A s M c w n has neihe pr pai t flng f e nor de ons r t d t t he i ' lea t r e d he ii e m ta e ha s ' r unde i n n d n e o s ro p ysc lij r ,2hec u t imissh sc mplitwi o t rj dc mmie t a g r f eius h ia nu y' t o r d s se i o an t u p eu ie ' h a de eshi motont pr e i or nd ni s i o oc ed nf mapau i purua t 28U. C.j 1 5() pers s nt o S. 91 g . 1 See M c n v. F ut No.2:9 v 2 ( D.Va J n 2,1 9 )(imisd wi p eu ie frfi r t sae a Lea a s, 9 c 6 5 E. . u e 9 9 ds se t rj dc o al e o tt h u cam) afd 1 9 WL 1 5 7 (t Ci. c 2 ,1 9 ) Mc a v Bol , .79 v 41( . Va J l 2 , li , f - 9 9 25 7 3 4h r De . 7 9 9 . Len . li No :9c 3 W D. . uy 6 , nc 1 9 )( s se wi p eu c frfi r t sae a cam) afd s n m. Mc a v.Ang ln ,1 9 WL 9 9 dimis d t rj die o al e o tt li , f' ub o , Le n h u eo e 9 9 1 6 0 (t Ci. v 2 ,1 9 ) Mc aa v UntdSae , 2:6 v 47( D.Va S p .1 ,2 0 )( imisd 0 5 33 4h r No . 4 9 9 * le n . ie tts No. 0 c 4 E. . e t 2 0 6 ds se , wi p eu ief rfiuet saeacam) afd5 6F.d3 (t Ci.2 0 ) Th c u t tst a i Mc -n v t rj dc o alr o tt li , f 6 3 9l 4h r 0 9 . e o r noe h t n Le . h a . Uni dSae,5 6F.d3 l(t Ci. 0 )teUnidSae Co ro Ap e lfrteForhCicisae ta t tts 6 3 9 4h r20 9,h t tts ut f g as o h ut rutttd ht e e McLe wasno at e srke . Howe r a trt co tatr d t dit tco tsdimis ofM clea sca e an t hr e ti r ve , fe he ur fime he snc ur' s sal a n' s frfi r t saeacam, le nrc ie hi tidsrk .Asn tdb tedse ti ta c s,d pv nta te o al e o tt li Mcaa e ev d s hr tie u oe y h isn n h t a e tg ie h t h l mao i a re t tMc a h sa la twope iu srk s Mc a s o l hee fe b d e datresrke . jrt g e sha Le n a t e s t rvo s tie , Len h ud ratr e e me h e -ti r . y ' S eas , Len v S hln .e a.No. 86 7 (t Ci.S p .l2 0 )t u tak o e e ta Mcaa ' e lo Mc a . c il c. t I i , 0 -4 9 4h r e t 0 9 co r c n wldg d h t te n wa atresrk ra drvo di omapa pei sau) s he -tie n e ke nf r u rs tts. . . 2 M c ae algest tt def nda shaves r dhi A nt naed f li r t iton f rc l an le ha he e nt e ve m l ami t ood' n ealai o omplit t theha co an s ha s fl agai tsaf. M cLe doe notalge how hi f i c a nae orwhen he wass r d t s alge y ied ns t f an s le s ood s ontmi td e ve hi le dl c a natd f ontmi e ood. M cLe as doe notalege whehe he ae t alege y c a naed f orwheherhe an lo s l t r t he l dl ontmi t ood t s fee a yij r a ars t etn a c na n tdf d.Mc a sae t th d fnd nsaep yi g ad u frd n nuy s eulof aig ny o tmiae oo Len tts ha te ee at r a ng u rs $10 0 0 t s r e hi c n a nae f o b c u e çh y wa tt ha e g i k l d' As r l f Mc a s e s ,0 .0 o e v m o t mi td o d e a s ç e n o v hm) i e . t l ' ei , Le n e k e ij n tv rl ft t rv n ilg l a n 'a dc na n to o hsf d Upo rve o hsc mplittec ut nu cie ei o ç e e t l a g mig' n o tmiain f i oo . n e iw f i o an,h o r e p e fndst tM c a n' alega i a e f r t s ultve vague and conc us y t r s t t l ofa consiu i l i ha lea s l tons r a oo pec a i , , l or o ie o he evel tt tona vi a i A s s h,t c tfnds t t M cLe n has f l d t de onsr t t t he i u r i mi nt da ol ton. uc he our i ha a aie o m t a e ha s nde m ne nger of s r ousphys c lha ei i a nu. The Clr i die t d t s ac rii c py oft sM e or ndum Opi on a t e k s r c e o end e tfed o hi m a ni nd he a c panyi Or rt t pl i if c om ng de o he a ntf . ) a. ' z, z# ' ENTER: hszV%uyoMa,02 Ti f y2 1. K 'e Stt sDititJ d a e src udge