McLean v. Ratliff et al, No. 7:2012cv00227 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 05/29/2012. (kab)

Download PDF
# . ra msoFFl u, Dl rnlr n oe s. sx l A a FN DEv T c Io ,A j EK L MAï 2 2 1 92 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R T H E W ESTERN D I STR I T O F V I I I C RG N A R O AN O K E D I I O N V SI QUENTI M CLEAN, N Pl ntf ai if, V. M S.R ATLI e t , FF, t #. D efendant . s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) . , ' JUL C. A EY, GLEM BY t DE CL ERK Ci lA cton N o.7: vi i 12cv00227 M EM O M N D U M O PI I N N O By: Sam ue G .W is l lon Unied St e Di t i tJudge t at s s r c Pli if Que i M c n,a Vigi a prs r pr e di pr s brngs t s a ton antf ntn Lea r ni ione oc e ng o e, i hi ci purua t 42 U. C.j 1 s nt o S. 983. Howeve,a las t e ofM cLe n' prvi c ant ha r t e t hre a s e ous ompli s ve be n dimis d wih prj ce fr f l e t sae a cam puruan t 28 U. C. e s se t eudi o aiur o tt li s t o S. v an 1 5()2)B)i)' Theeor ,M cle may no pr e wih t saci unl she et rpa 91 e( ( (i. rf e t oc ed t hi ton es ihe ys te$ 5 .0fl g feo s o t a h i ( n e i n n d n e o s ro p ysc ln uy. 2 h 3 00 ii e r h ws h t e s s d r mmie t a g r f eius h ia ij r ' 8 n u ' U. C.j1 5( . S. 9l g) A s M c w n has neihe pr pai t flng f e nor de ons r t d t t he i ' lea t r e d he ii e m ta e ha s ' r unde i n n d n e o s ro p ysc lij r ,2hec u t imissh sc mplitwi o t rj dc mmie t a g r f eius h ia nu y' t o r d s se i o an t u p eu ie ' h a de eshi motont pr e i or nd ni s i o oc ed nf mapau i purua t 28U. C.j 1 5() pers s nt o S. 91 g . 1 See M c n v. F ut No.2:9 v 2 ( D.Va J n 2,1 9 )(imisd wi p eu ie frfi r t sae a Lea a s, 9 c 6 5 E. . u e 9 9 ds se t rj dc o al e o tt h u cam) afd 1 9 WL 1 5 7 (t Ci. c 2 ,1 9 ) Mc a v Bol , .79 v 41( . Va J l 2 , li , f - 9 9 25 7 3 4h r De . 7 9 9 . Len . li No :9c 3 W D. . uy 6 , nc 1 9 )( s se wi p eu c frfi r t sae a cam) afd s n m. Mc a v.Ang ln ,1 9 WL 9 9 dimis d t rj die o al e o tt li , f' ub o , Le n h u eo e 9 9 1 6 0 (t Ci. v 2 ,1 9 ) Mc aa v UntdSae , 2:6 v 47( D.Va S p .1 ,2 0 )( imisd 0 5 33 4h r No . 4 9 9 * le n . ie tts No. 0 c 4 E. . e t 2 0 6 ds se , wi p eu ief rfiuet saeacam) afd5 6F.d3 (t Ci.2 0 ) Th c u t tst a i Mc -n v t rj dc o alr o tt li , f 6 3 9l 4h r 0 9 . e o r noe h t n Le . h a . Uni dSae,5 6F.d3 l(t Ci. 0 )teUnidSae Co ro Ap e lfrteForhCicisae ta t tts 6 3 9 4h r20 9,h t tts ut f g as o h ut rutttd ht e e McLe wasno at e srke . Howe r a trt co tatr d t dit tco tsdimis ofM clea sca e an t hr e ti r ve , fe he ur fime he snc ur' s sal a n' s frfi r t saeacam, le nrc ie hi tidsrk .Asn tdb tedse ti ta c s,d pv nta te o al e o tt li Mcaa e ev d s hr tie u oe y h isn n h t a e tg ie h t h l mao i a re t tMc a h sa la twope iu srk s Mc a s o l hee fe b d e datresrke . jrt g e sha Le n a t e s t rvo s tie , Len h ud ratr e e me h e -ti r . y ' S eas , Len v S hln .e a.No. 86 7 (t Ci.S p .l2 0 )t u tak o e e ta Mcaa ' e lo Mc a . c il c. t I i , 0 -4 9 4h r e t 0 9 co r c n wldg d h t te n wa atresrk ra drvo di omapa pei sau) s he -tie n e ke nf r u rs tts. . . 2 M c ae algest tt def nda shaves r dhi A nt naed f li r t iton f rc l an le ha he e nt e ve m l ami t ood' n ealai o omplit t theha co an s ha s fl agai tsaf. M cLe doe notalge how hi f i c a nae orwhen he wass r d t s alge y ied ns t f an s le s ood s ontmi td e ve hi le dl c a natd f ontmi e ood. M cLe as doe notalege whehe he ae t alege y c a naed f orwheherhe an lo s l t r t he l dl ontmi t ood t s fee a yij r a ars t etn a c na n tdf d.Mc a sae t th d fnd nsaep yi g ad u frd n nuy s eulof aig ny o tmiae oo Len tts ha te ee at r a ng u rs $10 0 0 t s r e hi c n a nae f o b c u e çh y wa tt ha e g i k l d' As r l f Mc a s e s ,0 .0 o e v m o t mi td o d e a s ç e n o v hm) i e . t l ' ei , Le n e k e ij n tv rl ft t rv n ilg l a n 'a dc na n to o hsf d Upo rve o hsc mplittec ut nu cie ei o ç e e t l a g mig' n o tmiain f i oo . n e iw f i o an,h o r e p e fndst tM c a n' alega i a e f r t s ultve vague and conc us y t r s t t l ofa consiu i l i ha lea s l tons r a oo pec a i , , l or o ie o he evel tt tona vi a i A s s h,t c tfnds t t M cLe n has f l d t de onsr t t t he i u r i mi nt da ol ton. uc he our i ha a aie o m t a e ha s nde m ne nger of s r ousphys c lha ei i a nu. The Clr i die t d t s ac rii c py oft sM e or ndum Opi on a t e k s r c e o end e tfed o hi m a ni nd he a c panyi Or rt t pl i if c om ng de o he a ntf . ) a. ' z, z# ' ENTER: hszV%uyoMa,02 Ti f y2 1. K 'e Stt sDititJ d a e src udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.