Talley v. Abingdon Police Department et al, No. 7:2012cv00176 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 05/08/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
e PRK' OFFI t. .Dl 'COtRT d : CE JS s7. J AT ROANOKE, VA FJ LED MAt û 8 2 1 22 I TH E UN I N TED STATES DI STR I C O U RT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A R O A NO K E DIVISIO N A UD I W A Y NE TA LLEY , E JULA C. I DUDLE lCL - ER: N B; Y DE / .6. ' 3c . . CA SE NO .7: 12CV 001 76 Pl ntf , ai if M EM O R AN DU M O PINIO N 5' S. A BI G D O N PO LICE D EPA RT M ENT , N O FFI CER W O LFE , By: Jam e C.Tur s k Seni U ni ed St or t ates Di t ctJudge s ri Dee fndants. l) A udi W a e yne Ta l y, a V igi a i a e pr e di pr K , fl t s c vi rgh s a ton le r ni nm t oc e ng o ied hi i l i t c i purua t 42 U. C.j 1 s nt o S. 983. Taly alge t tt tt dee ntpolceofke i o l le le s ha ha he fnda i t r mprpery f ied t s r apr e tve or ron Tal y,a t n wr uly a r t Tale t e tm e f al o e ve otc i de le nd he ongf l resed ly hr e i s or vi a i t t pr e tve o de , c us ng Tale s wr ul de a nm e . Upon r vi w o t ol tng ha ot c i r r a i l y' ongf t i nt e e f he r or t c tfnds t t t c m pl ntm us be c nsr d as a pe ii f a wrt of ha a ec d, he our i ha he o ai t o tue tton or i be s 1 copus purua t 28U. C.j2254,a s r , s nt o S. nd ummaiyds sedwihoutprj ce. rl imis t eudi I Tale alege t f l i s que ofe nt fom whi h hi cl i s a i e. O f i e l y l s he olow ng e nce ve s r c s am rs fc r W ole oft A bi f he ngdon, i gi a Polc D e r m e , r es e Taley on Febr r 1 201 on a V r ni i e pa t nt a r t d l ua y 5, 2 c r ofbe ng dr i publc. The nex da i or rt s c e hi r l a e Ta l y ha t pos ha ge i unk n i t y, n de o e ur s e e s , le d o t bond on ape ng c get thehad vi a e apr e tve o de t twasne rs r d on hi . ndi har ha olt d otc i r r ha ve e ve m Ta l y' bai bonds a c le hi hom e a s le s l m n a ld s nd poke t La W o l y,Ta l y' gilr e t s i o na r e le s rf i nd, o ee f Ta l y c d co e hom e W o l y s d t the c d,s Ta l y r t e hom e. Tha ni , le oul m . r e ai ha oul o le e unz d t ght Febr y 16,2012,an of i ar es ed Taley f vi atng a pr ectve or uar fcer r t l or ol i ot i der. Taley s at t l t es hat t pr ectve or had been ser on W orey,noton hi . O n Febr y 17,2012,Taley he ot i der ved l m uar l 1 RUe4ofteRue Go r i j225 c s sa t rz st i c r t s l h ts ve nng 4 a e uho ie hs ou t o ummaiy d s s a rl imis ha beascor acton i i i clarfom t f oft pl ngt pettoneri notentted t r i . pus i f t s e r he ace he eadi hat ii s il o elef c le W o l y' da e ,Am a Ande s a s a ld re s ughtr nda r on nd poket W ore o ly.The ea tr a horte r fe , ut iis char Taley wih vi atng t pr ectve or f t t r tm e. Taley s Of i W ole ged l t ol i he ot i der or he hid i l ues f cer f f r f ii t p ope l s r t pr t c i or ron Ta l y. A sr i i t s a i Ta l y o a lng o r ry e ve he o e tve de le elef n hi d on, le de andst tt c i i c e pe ng a i thi be di m i s d ort the be s nt nc t tm e m ha he rm nal as ndi ga ns m s se ha e e ed o i s r d. e ve 11 A di ti tco ti notcons r i d by a ltga t s syl ofpl di orr ue tf r le a s r c ur s t a ne ii n ' t e ea ng eq s or e i f nd ma lbeal c tu acvirg sc ai asaha aspeii purua t j2254.Ha i y i rly onsr e i l iht ompl nt be tton, s nt o mln v. arn, F. 29( hCi.1 ) Gor onv. e 574F. 11 ( hCi.1 ) W re 664 2d 4t r 981; d Le ke, 2d 47 4t r 978. deemi whehe a aci i prpel c i rdacvirghsc antunde j1 ora tr ne t r n ton s o ry onsdee i l i t ompli r 983 ha a c puspeii r rnge usi ofsaecou trmedispurua t j2254( , c r be s or tton equii xha ton tt r e e s nt o b)a ou t m us c i rwhe he t tc e 'oft ltga ' cl i conc r t f to dur to oft t ons de t r he t or ' he ii nt s a m e ns he ac r a i n he ltga ' c i me .Pr s rv.Rodrgue 41 U. 475( 973) Toddv.Baker le 71 ii nts onfne nt eie i z, 1 S, 1 . , s vil, 2 F.d7 (t Ci. 98 ) l t ec r o t ec mplitc nc r st ef d o ln t o c nfn me t 2 0 4h r 1 3 . f h o e f h o an o en h a r e gh f o i e n , t n t pr e ng i i ha s he he oce di s n bea . Tale sprm a y gre ncei t sco pli i t thewaswr uly d ai d f ly' i r i va n hi m ant s ha ongf l et ne or va i pe i oftm e be us ofO fi e W ole' a l ge f iur t pr r y s r e t rous r ods i ca e fc r f s le d a l e o ope l e v he pr ec i or ron hi . Be us t sc pl i co e t t f c a t l ngt ofTa l s ot tve de m ca e hi om a nt nt s s he a t nd he e h ley' co i me i t Vigi aprs s tm,hi camsaeno c z bl unde j 1 3.Prie, nfne nt n he r ni ion yse s li r t ognia e r 98 esr s a.The ef e t c tc l upr r or , he our oncudest tTale scai a ea o it l co tue a a ha ly' l ms r ppr pra ey nsr d s peii f rawrtofha sc pusu r28U. C.j225 tton o i bea or nde S. 4. Pr de t tane yc tue j2254peii me t t t es drquie nt f ovi d ha wl onsr d tton es he hr hol e r me s or ha asac i nsunde t s s c i t c tc n add e st pe ii s c ai son t m e is be to r hi e ton, he our a r s he tton' l m he rt . Hane v. r r 404 U. 51 ( 72) Unde 28U. C.j225 b) howe r afde a c t i s Kene , S. 9 19 . r S. 4( , ve, e r l our c l o gr ntaha aspe ii n unl s t pe ii rhase us e t r m e e a l bl i t am t a be tt o e s he ttone xha t d he e di s vaia e n he co t oft s a e i w hi h pe ii ur s he t t n c ttonerw asc c e O ' lva v. onvi t d. Suli n Boer kel 526 U . 838, c , S. 8 (1 99) I t peii rha fie t e 42 9 . f he ttone s ald o xhaus saec t e dis t f r c tmus t tt our r me e ,he edeal our t ds s tej2 5 peiinwih u p eu iet alw hm t rt r t saec u t Sa tnv. imis h 2 4 tt o t o t rj dc o l i o eu n o tt o r. lvo o Smih,404U. 53( 971 . t S. 1 ) Ta l y' co pl ntr l t t the ha no e us e s a e c t e e es H e s a e t t le s m ai efec s ha s t xha t d t t our r m di . t t s ha t c i i lc s pe ng a ns hi wilc e be o et t i lc ton M a 1 201 l t s he rm na a e ndi gai t m l om f r he ra our y 4, 2. n he e pe ng s a e c tpr e ngs Ta l y m ay s e a sa e co t ulng on hi ar e t tt ndi t t our oc edi , le e k t t ur r i s gum nt ha he pr e tve or rw a ne rpr ry s r d on hi . I hi a g e f l ,a he i c c e he ot c i de s ve ope l e ve m f s r um nt ais nd s onvi t d, m a a s pur ue ot r s a e c tr m e es s h a a die ta y lo s he t t our e di , uc s r c ppea ofhi co c i t hi r l s nvi ton o ghe sa e c t . Be us Tale c e ry hasnote us e a ia e s a e c t e edi s a t stm e, t t our s ca e l y l a l xha t d va l bl t t our r m e t hi i t s c r m a notg a r le on hi c ai s ofwr ulc c i a c i e a m us hi ou t y r nt e i f s lm ongf onvi ton nd onfnem nt nd t s mmai d s s t p tto wih u p eudc t alw Talyt p ru hi eamsfrti u rl imis he ei n t o t rj ie o l y i o le o u s e s li is n sa e c t Sl yt s pr A n a opr a e or rw ile e t s da t t our . a on, u a. ppr i t de l nt r hi y. The Cl r i diec ed t s nd c esoft sm e or ndum opi on a a c pa ng e k s r t o e opi hi m a ni nd c om nyi or rt pl i if de o a ntf ENTER:Ths àvsd yo Ma 2 2 i pa f y, 01 . Se orUnied St t D i ti tJ e ni t a es sr c u 3