Pagan v. United States District, No. 7:2012cv00170 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 04/19/2012. (kab)

Download PDF
r FRKS OFFI U, DI K UA a CE B. SX AT ROANUKE, VA Fl FD lE AP 1S 2 1 2 22 I T H E U N I D STA T ES D I N TE STR I T C O U R T C FO R TH E W E STER N DI STR I T O F V I G I I C R N A ROANO KE DI VISIO N A LBER T O PA G A N , J A t. i.' .ICLERK ULI ) $:* -/ BY; DE U CLERK C i lA ct on N o.7:12cv00170 vi i Pet t one i i r, M EM O M ND U M O PIN IO N V. UNI TED ST A TE S D I STR I T , C By:Sam uelG .W ison l Uni St ted atesD i t ctJudge s ri R es pondent . Thi i a pe ii by V igi a i a e A l ro Pag n, oc edi ss tton r ni nm t be t a pr e ngpr s ,pur ua t 28 o e s nt o U. C.j2241, le ngadeane se ngfom Pag spr bai vi ai i t S. chalngi ti r tmmi r an' o ton olton n he S uh r Ditito Ne Yo k.Be a ed tiesb s do p o ainvilto aen ts b e t o te n src f w r c us ean r a e n r b to oains r o u j c t t l esaeAg e me onDeane sAc (1ADA',1 U. C.a 2( ) t c tfnds o he ntrtt r e nt ti r t ' I ' 8 S. pp. 2006 ,he our i ) t tj2241pr vi snor i a de esPa n' peiin. ha o de elef nd ni ga s tto 1 . The V i g ni D e rm e ofCor e tons i ar e a e Paga i 2005 f l i hi s a e r i a pa t nt r c i nc c r t d nn olow ng s t t c nvi to f rr bbe y. A ferPaga si a ce a i n, he U nie St t s D i ti tCour f rt o ci n o o r t n' nc r r to t t d a e src t o he Sout r D i t i ofN e Yor i s a a r tw a r tc r ng Pa n w ih a vi a i oft he n sr d w k s ued n r es r an ha gi ga t ol ton he t nnsofhi pr ton,a t w a r ntw asl ed asa de ai rw ih t V igi a D e rm e of e s oba i nd he r a odg t ne t he r ni pa t nt Cor e tons Pa n now cl i st de ai ri ca i hi c r ntpr s t de hi c r a n r c i . ga a m he t ne s us ng s ur e i on o ny m e t i pr vieg ,1and he as t c tt dim i st pr ton vi a i orot r ie di pos oft i l es ks he our o s s he oba i ol ton he w s s e he de ai r t ne . lSpe iialy,Pa ale st prs i de ng hi a es t educ in,pa tci in i wor r e s ato c fc l gan lge he ion s nyi m cc s o ri pato n k-ela e pr a s f ro ogr m s u lughs ta f st l lvels c iyi tt i ,a pa tcpai i i herprs aci tesa ,r nser o ow-e e urt nsiutons nd rii ton n ç ot ion tvii nd r biia i pr r m s' eha lt ton og a . ' I I. The I D A i a com pac a ong f t ei sa e ,t Di t i tofCol bi ,Pue t Ri o, A s tm or y- ght t t s he s rc um a ro c t Vigi I lnds a t Unied St t sofAme ia. Ari 11oft I he r n sa , nd he t ae rc tde 1 he ADA esa ihesa t bls pr e zebywhihaprs ri aceae i onesae (hetsndi sae' ma dema t oc dlr c ione nc r rtd n tt2 t ûe ng tt') y nd he s e diposton ofd ny unti d i cm e ,nf r ton orc pe dy s ii l a re ndi t nt i o mai ompli 't ti t bassofa ant' ha s he i deane l dagans hi byanot rsae(heCec i ngsae'.l t prs rmake s ha ti r odge i t m he tt t t evi tt') f he ione r s uc de a t I D A r r st a hortesi t r ce vi s a e t brng hi t t i lw ihi 1 m nd, he A equi e he ut ii n he e i ng t t o i m o r a t n 80 days ort c t us di m i st i c m e ,i or a i orc pl nt a t de ai rw il , he our m t s s he ndi t nt nf m ton, om ai , nd he t ne l ce e t be ofa f ce oref e t H o eve , he I D A doesnota y t a de ai rbas o a as o ny or fc. w rt A ppl o t ne ed n pr to vi ai Ca c nv. s 473U. 71 726( 98 . obain olton. r hma Na h, S. 6, 1 5) He e,Paga doesno c le t de a ne ' l lbas s R a he ,he as t tt r n t ha l nge he t i r s ega i. t r ks ha he de ai rt s i fed by a s nt nc ofi prs e orbe di m i s d a t ts h s nt nc t ne d ats i be e e e m i onm nt s s e nd ha uc e e e c dr nc oul u oncure l t hi t nt ( ye r s ntnce' be al c tued,Pa n' petton rnty o s we y 20) as e e .'Li r ly onsr ga s ii pr desbuto gr ovi ne ound on w hi h t c t i gr ntt tr ques :nonco pla e w ih t c he our m ght a ha e t m i nc t he I ADA. Howe ,be us t I ver ca e he ADA doesnota y t de ane sba e on pr bai vi a i , ppl o t i r s d o ton oltons t c ti co tane t de Pa n' peii Seejta 734( di t tt I he our s nsri d o ny ga s tton. ., t t . hol ng ha he ADA doe not s a y t de a ner ba e on pr t o vi a i nsa r ver i t l e c ts gr ntofa habe s ppl o t i s s d oba i n ol t o nd e s ng he ow r our ' a a peii . tton) 2A Sus d i t I DA, çsat'm ea i St eoft Unie Stt ;heU nied Stt ofAm e ia;a e n he A it e' ns ç at he t d aes t a t aes rc tri r o p seso o teUntdSae 'h Ditito Coumbi'o )h Co nwe l o P roRio. l ert y r o ssin f h ie tts te src f l a (r te mmo at f uet c ' 8 o , , h ' U. C. p . j2 S. a p 2 . 2 11 1. Fort ras satd,hec twilde Pa n' j2241peii TheCl ki die td he e ons t e t our l ny ga s tton. er s rce t s a c oft sm e or ndum opi on a t ac om pa ng o de t Pa a o end opy hi m a ni nd he c nyi r r o nx EN TER :Thi 1 t da ofApr l 201 s 9h y i, 2. UN I TED STA TES D I STRI J DG E CT U 3

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.