McKinney v. Commonwealth Of Virginia, No. 7:2012cv00166 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 04/20/2012. (kab) (Main Document 2 replaced on 4/20/2012) (kab).

Download PDF
O >R> OFFI U 8 YI CŠr CE ST, A-1C ?-,1;,l f?''t .. h. - > .7 . j ' : h k il 'LEI ' . : I I TH E U NI N TED ST ATES DI RI T C O U RT ST C FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STRI T O F V I G I A C R NI R O AN O K E DIVISIO N D O N W . CK I N EY , M N APq 22 2 1 22 JULf A BY: ' D ,L CL RK C A SE N O .7: 2CV 001 1 66 Pl ntf ai if, M EM O M ND U M O PI I N N O VS. By: Jam es C .T urk Seni U nied St es D i ri Judge or t at st ct C O M M O N W EAL TH O F V I I I , RG N A D ef endant . D on W .M c i y,pr edi pr >q fl d a c pl i s e ng m one a y da age f K nne oce ng o , ie om a nt e ki t r m s or - i a s i a ce a i 'l Li r ly consr ng M c nne ss ison asale ng vi ai ofhi $ le nc r r ton. f ' be a l tui Ki y' ubm s i l gi oltons s c tt tona r g s t cour f l d hi c pl i asa ci lrght ac i pur ua t 42 U . C. ons iu i l i ht , he t ie s om a nt vi i s ton s nt o S. j1 983.Be a eM cKi y di notpr pa t $350. flngfe,heco tas consnzshi c us nne d e y he 00 ii e t ur lo t e s s b s ina s e i gt p o e di o mapa pe i, ndwilga th m t ssaus Afe rv e u miso s e k n o r c e nf r u rs a l r n i hi tt . tr e iw o t rc r h we r t c u t u rl d s se tea to wi o tp eu ie p ru n t f he e o d, o ve,he o r s mma i imis s h cin t u rj dc , u s a t o y h 28U. C.j 1 5()2) f fiur t saeacai S. 91 e( ,or al e o tt l m. l M cKi y a lgest f l ng s r ef t a nne le he olowi pa s acs bouthi ca e.l Oc obe 1 s s n t r 993, ut ii s a horte a r s e M c im e on a c i i c r a a pr ton vi a i cha ge a de a ned hi untl re td K l y rm nal ha ge nd oba i ol ton r nd t i m i Fe ua y 1 br r 994. M c i K nney pl ded no guit i t W i e Count Cic tCo tt bo h c r s ea t ly n he s y r ui ur o t ha ge . J tda l t ,M cK im e sa t ne a s hi t pl a notg ly by r s ofi a t a us ys a er r y' tor y dvi ed m o e d uit ea on ns niy, nd t j d ea c p e t t la he u g c e td ha p e . M c mwy as e t t tt Co tc d ha obt ne r or t twoul ha pe s de Ki s rs ha he ur oul ve ai d ec ds ha d ve r ua d aj r t tn h m n tg i yo b t c ag s b c u ete ewa ç oe d nc . Mc n yas u y o i d i o ul n oh h r e , e a s h r s l vie e' Kine lo t n ' co e t tbe a e t Cour a t d i i f ih, M c nne s f r d t a s i a ce a i 'i nt nds ha c us he t ce n d bad a t ' Ki y uf e e t l e nc r r ton' n ' f 1 M cK i y i no l nne s ongerde ai . t ned t W ie Count J i i 1993- 994 a i t D e r m e ofM en a Re a da i n and Subsanc he s y al n 1 nd n he pa t nt t l t r to t e Abus Se v c s H e s s t Com m onw e 1h ofV i gi a f t1 t 1 m ilo dola s' e r ie . ue he at r ni or 1 8 o 9 li n l r . ' 1 1 Un e 2 U. C. 1 5 e , ihg v r si o mapa pe i p o e d n s t ec u t a a d r 8 S. j 91 () wh c o en nf r u rs r c e i g ,h o r h s ma t ydut t s r ni ta flngs ErlneCo.v.J on, F. 6 656- ( hCi. ndaor y o cee niil ii . ii ohns 440 3d 48, 57 4t r 2006) Spe iialy,ç diti c tmus dimisa a i t tt cour fndst befi ousor . cfc l $ srct our t s s n cton ha he t i o rvol a maii ort tf l t saeacli ' M iha v.Chal t Count 43 F.d725, ( h lcous ha ais o tt am.' c u reson v, 4 3 728 4t Ci. r 2006)(ii 28U. C.j 1 5()2)B).Tosaea a tonabl cam,t fcua ctng S. 91 e( ( ) tt n ci e li he a t l a lga i i t c pl ntm us c an û et n lbel a c l i ns'a k us be le tons n he om ai t ont i ' mor ha a s nd oncuso ' nd l t m e nough t r s arghtt r lefa o aie i o e i bove as ultve lve .'Be lAt.Cor v. pec a i e l' l l p. Twombl 550U . v, S. 544,555( 2007) . The onl def ntt tM c i y enda ha K nney na esi t s l w s ti t Co m o e t of m n hi a ui s he m nw alh Vigi a I i wels tldt tasaec nnotbes dunde j1 r ni. t s l ete ha tt a ue r 983.W ilv. ihi nDe tof l M c ca p' S aeP lc , 1U. 58 71( 9 9 ( l li raSaen risof ca sa tn i tero fca tt o ie 49 S. , 1 8 ) û et s he tt o t t il ci g n h i fiil i c pacte ae'es ' rj 1 ' .l a ton,t El nt Ame a iis r p ronsunde 983.5 n ddii he eve h ) ndme bar s t diecl nt s uis r ty a i tt s a e, ega dl s oft na ur ofr lefs ga ns he t t r r e s he t e e i ought Se i e Tr be ofFl r da v. orda, . m nol i oi Fl i 51 U. 44,58( 996) Thus M c nne c nnotpr e wihhi lws ta i tt 7 S. 1 . , Ki y a oce d t s a ui gans he Commonweat a alcl msagans t sdee ntmus bedimis dunde j 1 5()2)b) 1h, nd 1 ai i t hi fnda t s se r 91 e( ( . M or ove , cK i y' com pl ntf l t aleg s f c e f t t s a e a ac i bl e rM nne s ai ais o l e ufi i nt ac s o t t ny tona e cli unde j 1 agans a am r 983 i t nyone.Theco antc it ofacole tonofco l or mpli onsss lci ncus y as e tons a opi ons a doesnotf e s f c son w hi h M c i y co d pr a s ri nd ni nd or ca t a t c K nne ul ove n actonabl cl m t he suf er a vi aton ofhi cons iutonalr ght r at t hi pr r al i e ai hat f ed ol i s tt i i s el ed o s eti de e i orhi de e i afe hi pl a ofno guit by r a on ofi a t Tw om bl 55 U . t nton s t nton t r s e t ly es ns niy. v, 0 S. a 5 5 Na i v W ad n M d Ho s o Co rcin 6 F.d95 , 5 ( t Ci.1 9 )(i dn t 5 ; sm . r e , . u e f re to , 4 3 1 9 3 4h r 9 5 fn ig t a j 1 1 p nnt dsrc c u t t id p n e tya s s t eme iso i o mapa pe i h t 9 5 e is itit o rs o n e e d n l s e s h rt f nf r u rs c ant, ûoexcudes t t tha noagua ebassi lw orf f'. ompli s and ç t l uis ha ve r bl i n a ac ) I II Fo t er a o ssae ,h c u t imis sM c n e sc mpan wih u prj d c , r h e s n ttd te o r ds se Kin y' o lit to t eu ie purua t j 1 5()2)b) f rf itr t saeacai TheClr i diecedt s ndco e of s nt o 91 e( ( , o alte o tt l m. ek s r t o e pis t sm e o a hi m r ndum opi on and a om panyi or rt pl i if ni cc ng de o a ntf . ENTER:Ths 20 a o Ap i, 01 i y f rl2 2. +. J Se ùrUnie St t DititJ nl t d aes src udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.