McKinney v. Commonwealth Of Virginia, No. 7:2012cv00166 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 04/20/2012. (kab) (Main Document 2 replaced on 4/20/2012) (kab).
Download PDF
O >R> OFFI U 8 YI CŠr CE ST, A-1C ?-,1;,l f?''t .. h. - > .7 . j ' : h k il 'LEI ' . : I I TH E U NI N TED ST ATES DI RI T C O U RT ST C FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STRI T O F V I G I A C R NI R O AN O K E DIVISIO N D O N W . CK I N EY , M N APq 22 2 1 22 JULf A BY: ' D ,L CL RK C A SE N O .7: 2CV 001 1 66 Pl ntf ai if, M EM O M ND U M O PI I N N O VS. By: Jam es C .T urk Seni U nied St es D i ri Judge or t at st ct C O M M O N W EAL TH O F V I I I , RG N A D ef endant . D on W .M c i y,pr edi pr >q fl d a c pl i s e ng m one a y da age f K nne oce ng o , ie om a nt e ki t r m s or - i a s i a ce a i 'l Li r ly consr ng M c nne ss ison asale ng vi ai ofhi $ le nc r r ton. f ' be a l tui Ki y' ubm s i l gi oltons s c tt tona r g s t cour f l d hi c pl i asa ci lrght ac i pur ua t 42 U . C. ons iu i l i ht , he t ie s om a nt vi i s ton s nt o S. j1 983.Be a eM cKi y di notpr pa t $350. flngfe,heco tas consnzshi c us nne d e y he 00 ii e t ur lo t e s s b s ina s e i gt p o e di o mapa pe i, ndwilga th m t ssaus Afe rv e u miso s e k n o r c e nf r u rs a l r n i hi tt . tr e iw o t rc r h we r t c u t u rl d s se tea to wi o tp eu ie p ru n t f he e o d, o ve,he o r s mma i imis s h cin t u rj dc , u s a t o y h 28U. C.j 1 5()2) f fiur t saeacai S. 91 e( ,or al e o tt l m. l M cKi y a lgest f l ng s r ef t a nne le he olowi pa s acs bouthi ca e.l Oc obe 1 s s n t r 993, ut ii s a horte a r s e M c im e on a c i i c r a a pr ton vi a i cha ge a de a ned hi untl re td K l y rm nal ha ge nd oba i ol ton r nd t i m i Fe ua y 1 br r 994. M c i K nney pl ded no guit i t W i e Count Cic tCo tt bo h c r s ea t ly n he s y r ui ur o t ha ge . J tda l t ,M cK im e sa t ne a s hi t pl a notg ly by r s ofi a t a us ys a er r y' tor y dvi ed m o e d uit ea on ns niy, nd t j d ea c p e t t la he u g c e td ha p e . M c mwy as e t t tt Co tc d ha obt ne r or t twoul ha pe s de Ki s rs ha he ur oul ve ai d ec ds ha d ve r ua d aj r t tn h m n tg i yo b t c ag s b c u ete ewa ç oe d nc . Mc n yas u y o i d i o ul n oh h r e , e a s h r s l vie e' Kine lo t n ' co e t tbe a e t Cour a t d i i f ih, M c nne s f r d t a s i a ce a i 'i nt nds ha c us he t ce n d bad a t ' Ki y uf e e t l e nc r r ton' n ' f 1 M cK i y i no l nne s ongerde ai . t ned t W ie Count J i i 1993- 994 a i t D e r m e ofM en a Re a da i n and Subsanc he s y al n 1 nd n he pa t nt t l t r to t e Abus Se v c s H e s s t Com m onw e 1h ofV i gi a f t1 t 1 m ilo dola s' e r ie . ue he at r ni or 1 8 o 9 li n l r . ' 1 1 Un e 2 U. C. 1 5 e , ihg v r si o mapa pe i p o e d n s t ec u t a a d r 8 S. j 91 () wh c o en nf r u rs r c e i g ,h o r h s ma t ydut t s r ni ta flngs ErlneCo.v.J on, F. 6 656- ( hCi. ndaor y o cee niil ii . ii ohns 440 3d 48, 57 4t r 2006) Spe iialy,ç diti c tmus dimisa a i t tt cour fndst befi ousor . cfc l $ srct our t s s n cton ha he t i o rvol a maii ort tf l t saeacli ' M iha v.Chal t Count 43 F.d725, ( h lcous ha ais o tt am.' c u reson v, 4 3 728 4t Ci. r 2006)(ii 28U. C.j 1 5()2)B).Tosaea a tonabl cam,t fcua ctng S. 91 e( ( ) tt n ci e li he a t l a lga i i t c pl ntm us c an û et n lbel a c l i ns'a k us be le tons n he om ai t ont i ' mor ha a s nd oncuso ' nd l t m e nough t r s arghtt r lefa o aie i o e i bove as ultve lve .'Be lAt.Cor v. pec a i e l' l l p. Twombl 550U . v, S. 544,555( 2007) . The onl def ntt tM c i y enda ha K nney na esi t s l w s ti t Co m o e t of m n hi a ui s he m nw alh Vigi a I i wels tldt tasaec nnotbes dunde j1 r ni. t s l ete ha tt a ue r 983.W ilv. ihi nDe tof l M c ca p' S aeP lc , 1U. 58 71( 9 9 ( l li raSaen risof ca sa tn i tero fca tt o ie 49 S. , 1 8 ) û et s he tt o t t il ci g n h i fiil i c pacte ae'es ' rj 1 ' .l a ton,t El nt Ame a iis r p ronsunde 983.5 n ddii he eve h ) ndme bar s t diecl nt s uis r ty a i tt s a e, ega dl s oft na ur ofr lefs ga ns he t t r r e s he t e e i ought Se i e Tr be ofFl r da v. orda, . m nol i oi Fl i 51 U. 44,58( 996) Thus M c nne c nnotpr e wihhi lws ta i tt 7 S. 1 . , Ki y a oce d t s a ui gans he Commonweat a alcl msagans t sdee ntmus bedimis dunde j 1 5()2)b) 1h, nd 1 ai i t hi fnda t s se r 91 e( ( . M or ove , cK i y' com pl ntf l t aleg s f c e f t t s a e a ac i bl e rM nne s ai ais o l e ufi i nt ac s o t t ny tona e cli unde j 1 agans a am r 983 i t nyone.Theco antc it ofacole tonofco l or mpli onsss lci ncus y as e tons a opi ons a doesnotf e s f c son w hi h M c i y co d pr a s ri nd ni nd or ca t a t c K nne ul ove n actonabl cl m t he suf er a vi aton ofhi cons iutonalr ght r at t hi pr r al i e ai hat f ed ol i s tt i i s el ed o s eti de e i orhi de e i afe hi pl a ofno guit by r a on ofi a t Tw om bl 55 U . t nton s t nton t r s e t ly es ns niy. v, 0 S. a 5 5 Na i v W ad n M d Ho s o Co rcin 6 F.d95 , 5 ( t Ci.1 9 )(i dn t 5 ; sm . r e , . u e f re to , 4 3 1 9 3 4h r 9 5 fn ig t a j 1 1 p nnt dsrc c u t t id p n e tya s s t eme iso i o mapa pe i h t 9 5 e is itit o rs o n e e d n l s e s h rt f nf r u rs c ant, ûoexcudes t t tha noagua ebassi lw orf f'. ompli s and ç t l uis ha ve r bl i n a ac ) I II Fo t er a o ssae ,h c u t imis sM c n e sc mpan wih u prj d c , r h e s n ttd te o r ds se Kin y' o lit to t eu ie purua t j 1 5()2)b) f rf itr t saeacai TheClr i diecedt s ndco e of s nt o 91 e( ( , o alte o tt l m. ek s r t o e pis t sm e o a hi m r ndum opi on and a om panyi or rt pl i if ni cc ng de o a ntf . ENTER:Ths 20 a o Ap i, 01 i y f rl2 2. +. J Se ùrUnie St t DititJ nl t d aes src udge