DePaola v. Ray et al, No. 7:2012cv00139 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 06/15/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
pdFRK S OFFI U, . ST. CE S DI COURT AT Rt;N1 iF bA -tO ( 1 , ' i i; : : è ) JUN 15 2 1 22 TH E UN I TED STA TES D I STR I CO UR T CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI O F V I I I CT RG N A R O AN O K E D IVISION ERIC J.DEPA O LA , JUL/ t 'k '$ r CL I' ' . 7 ' ERK . ) l BK D CLERK C i lA cton N o.7: cv-00139 vi i 12- Pl nt f , ai i f M EM O M N D U M O PI I N N O V. TR AC Y R AY,e aI t . By:Sam uelG .W ison l Unied St es D i ri Judge t at st ct D ef endant s. ErcDe ol ama mum-ec iyi t a Re Oni Stt Prs (( i pa a, xi s urt nmae t d on ae ion 1ROSP',ha tl ' s ied ) ac antpurua t 42U. C.j 1 a t RelgiusLandUs a l tt i lz ompli s nt o S. 983 nd he i o e nd nsiutonaied Pes Ac ($ PA' , U. C.j2000cc na ngt re ndefnda sa alegi rons t t RLU1 ' 42 S. ) , mi hite e nt nd l ng vi a i nsofRLU I and t Fis ,Fo t Ei ht a Fo t en h A m e ol to PA he r t ur h, g h, nd ur e t ndm en s H e s ks t. ee ij n t r le t so srps a c e , o r c alg dyu lwf l rs nc ndto s fr ete n u ci eif o tp ti e r h s c re t l e l na u p io o iin , o c h ve e V igi a De rm e ofCor e tonst pe f m ps hol c le l tons on i a es r e e r ni pa t nt rci o r or yc ogi a va ua i nm t , el as hi f om s gr ga i t a f rhi f om RO SP, ovi c os c ptone l l m i vi os o m r e e ton, r ns e m r pr de l ed- a i d s a c de n pr s t l vi i ,c di t w ih t c y c r t e ur s t rw a ttm esf pr s r i on e e s ons oor na e t he ount ou t o ns e hor e i i or i one he rngs a alow s gr at prs r t s m e prvieg a no s e t d i a e . I a i , nd l e eg ed i one s he a i l es s n- egr ga e nm t s n a ton,hes e at t of$326, i da a sfo va i def ndan s The c tgr nt ddii e ks o al 000 n m ge r m rous e t . our a s Depaol i f r a pa r s sat a w ildi m i st cl i s a ns J m e W ad s s e a n om upe i t us nd l s s he a m gai t n s e ua pont purua tt 28U. C.j1 ( ( ( .Thematrwilpr e d o De ol srmai ngcams s n o S. 915e)2)B) te l oc e n pa a' e ni li . 1. I Count1 D epaol com pl nsaboutpri condii - partcul l t e r a ed t hi n , a ai son tons i ary hos el t o s pl c m e i a s rs gr ton pod- t ta l gedl vi at d hi Four h,Ei h, nd Foure t a e nt n upe e ega i ha le y ol e s t ght a ten h Am e e r gh s I Countl ,D e ol c ai s vi a i ofRLU I a hi fee e r i e ndm nt i t . n l pa a l m ol tons PA nd s r xe c s rg sbec us hewasale dl t bl t me ngf l wa c ' heFrda J i ht a e l ge y t una e o ani uly t h't i y umu'h s r i e a e vc br dca tf t t o a one- l m ont he w asi a s r s r ga i pod. l Count1 1 oa s or he w nd ha f hs n upe - eg e ton n 1, De ol brngscai unde j1 3a RLUI be a eofc tonshealge ye e pa a i l ms r 98 nd PA c us ondii le dl ndurd whie t ng a t i t t W i e Count c t l aki rp o he s y our hous e. Amongt ot camsi Count11 De ol algest thedi notrceveaj cebox he her li n 1, pa a le ha d e i ui i hi ba d l h,a hes ekst hol ROSP' f s vie diecor J m esW ade la e f n s gge unc nd e o d S ood-er c r t , a , i bl or t to r i tptr ua t t Ei ht A m e ha ve s gh ls nt o he g h ndm e pr bii on c t la unus puni hm e . nt ohi ton rz nd e ual s nt Ev na s mi gW a eweedie tyr s nsbl f rfiigt p taj c - o i De oasln h e su n d r rcl e po i e o aln o u uie b x n pa l' u c , t cam i wholyfi ous Omitngaj c - fom aba he li s l rvol . ti uiebox r ggedl h doe note nrmotl unc s ve e ey r s m bl a Ei h A m e e e e n ght ndm e vi a i a t c t ildi m i s W a a a def nda nt ol ton, nd he our w l s s de s e nt purua t 28U. C.j1 5()2)B) s nt o S. 91 e( ( . 111. Fort reasons s at t courtwildi m i t com pl ntagai tW ade w ihout he t ed, he l s ss he ai ns t p eu ieu d r28U. C. 1 5e ( )B)a fioo s Th smatrwil r c e wi r s c t rj dc n e S. j 91 ()2 ( s rv lu . i te l p o e d t epe to h t r a nd oft de enda s The c e k i diec e t s a c he em i er he f nt . l r s r t d o end opy oft sm e or ndum hi m a opi o a t ac ompa ng or rt t pli if ni n nd he c nyi de o he antf. + * x. . e ' z a e x M ENT ER :June 15,2012. w zA . A a y' A ' a z ' ' z UN I TED STA TES DI STRI J G E CT UD