Venable v. Ziglar, No. 7:2012cv00130 - Document 30 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 10/11/12. (tvt)
Download PDF
CL :OFFI U.S. ST. ERK' CE DI COURT ATD L K V ANVIL A Ft o<lr lE . I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I CO UR T CT FO R TH E W EST ER N DI STW C T O F V I G I I R N A R O A NO K E DI I O N V SI 0CT 11 2 1 02 ' JUL sv. . AE DPO LR CL EM CLERK C i lActon N o.7: ev-00130 vi i 12- JO H N NY LA M O N T V EN A BLE ,111, Petii toner, M EM O R AND U M O PIN IO N By: JO A N ZIG LA R , R es pondent . H on.Jacks L.K i e on sr Seni U nied St es D itri Judge or t at s ct ied tto o J ohnny La ontVe e,11 aVigi ai aepr ee ng pm K ,fl ape ii n f ra m nabl 1, r ni nm t oc di . wrtofha sc pus purua t 28U. C.j2254,a amotont a ndt peii i bea or , s nt o S. nd i o me he tton. Res ponde fl d am oton t dim is a pe ii ne r po d,m a ngt m at rrpe f nt ie i o s s , nd tto r es nde ki he te i or di pos ton. A fe r vi w i t r c d,1di m i st pe ii n a tm e ba r d. g ii t r e e ng he e or s s he tt o s i re 1. The Cicui Courtoft Ciy ofM ari vil sent r t he t tns le enced pettoneron June 2,2010,t an ii o a tve s nt nc oft o yea s a sx m ont a t pe ii rpl ade guit t t o c ci e e e w r nd i hs fer ttone e d ly o w ount of s di ti i coc i . Pe ii r di notf l a a a t t Cour ofA ppea sofV igi a s rbutng a ne ttone d ie n ppe l o he t l r ni . On A pr l24,20l1, ttonerfl d a pe ii n f a w rtofha asco pusw ih t Cic t i pe ii ie tto or i be r t he r ui Cour oft Ciy ofM ari vil ,w hi h de e t pe ii n on t m e is o Se e be 7,20l1 t he t tns le c ni d he tto he rt n pt m r . Pe ii ra a e t t Supr m e Cour ofV igi a whi h di m i s d t a ttone ppe l d o he e t r ni , c s s e he ppea on M a c 9, l rh 201 bec us pe ii 2, a e ttonerf l t a s gn e r t t l w e cour ' r i ,pur ua t V i g ni aied o s i r or o he o r ts ulngs s nt o r i a SuprmeCour Rul 5:7() 1() Peii tl t i tntf r ha speii o M ac e t e 1 c ()i. ttoneried he nsa edeal bea tton n rh 1 201 Se R.Gov.j2254Ca es3( ( ci ngt prs mal r e . 4, 2. e s d) desrbi he ion- ibox ul) Il . Ha aspeii fl unde j225 a es j c t ao ye rpeid oflmiain.28 be ttons ied r 4 r ub e t o ne- a ro i tto U.. j2 4 ( )1. Ge e a1,hi p ro b gnst rn fo ted t o whc t ej d me SC. 2 4 d ( )1 n r1y t s e id e i o u r m h ae n ih h u g nt ofc ci bec sfna. 28U .. .j2244( ()A) A c ci be onviton ome i l2 SC d)1( . onviton come fna onc t s i l e he a ia lt ofdiec r e i exha t valbiiy r t eviw s used.Unie Sttsv.Cly,537U. 522,52 ( td ae a S. 4 2003) The . one ye flngpe i i t ld whie ac ctst ope l fl a ia i f rSt t - ar ii rod s ole l onvi ' û pr ry ied pplc ton o a e pos-onvito oroherc ltr rviw'i û ndi ' 28U. C.j2244( ( .Se W alv. tc cin t olaeal e e 's t ng.' pe S. d)2) e l Khol, i U. S. ,1 S.Ct 1 ,1 - ( 1 ( s us i pr e ngst tqualf as 31 . 278 28889 201 ) dic sng oce di ha iy colatr rviw) l eal e e . Peii rsj2254petton i untmel unde j2244( ( )A) Peii rsc ci ttone ' ii s i y r d)1( . ttone ' onviton bec m e tna on J y 2, 0,w he t tm e e r d f pe ii rt no e a a a i l ul 201 n he i xpi e or ttone o t n ppea f om t l r he Cic tCour oft Ciy ofM a tns let t Cour ofAppe l ofV igi a Se Va.Sup.Ct R. r ui t he t ri vil o he t as r ni . e . 5A: a)(ttnga a alfom t tilc tt t Cour ofAppeasi alowe onl i t 6( sai n ppe r he ra our o he t l s l d y f he a eln flsan tc o a pe l ti t it d y o t etna j g n ) Pei o e fldhs pp la t ie o ie f p a wih n hry a s f h i lud me t. tt n r ie i i s a e ha s pe ii on A prl24,2011 296 da a tr hi c c i be am e tna . t t bea tton i , ys fe s onvi ton c i l 1The one ye rp ro o l tto f rfl g ah be speiin u d rj2 4 b gnst r n o t lt s o f u d ts a e id f i ai n o ii mi n a a t o n e 25 e i o u n he ae t f o r ae : t ( ted t o whihtej d me tb cmefn l ytec n lso o drc rve o tee prto o te A)h ae n c h u g n e a ia b h o cu in f ie te iw r h x iain fh tme f s eki s h r vi w ' i or e ng uc e e , ( ted t o whc tei di n t Gl ga a piaince tdb Saeato i voaino te B) h ae n ih h mpe me to i n p lcto rae y tt cin n ilto fh n Consi i orl oft Unied Stt i r tt on aws he t m aes s emoved,i t a i ntwaspr entd fom flngbys h f he pplca ev e r ii uc St t a ton; ae c i ( ted t o whc t c nsiuin l ih a sre wa iial rc g ie b teS p e Coutit C) h ae n ih he o ttto a rg t se td s nt l e o nz d y h u rme r,fhe i y rghtha be n newl r cogniedby t Supr m eCour a m adertoa i ya i bl t ca eson i s e y e z he e t nd er ctvel pplca e o s cola e alr e ;or lt r evi w ( t ed t o whc t ef cua p e ia eof h cam o c amsp e e t dc u dh v b e d s o e e D) h a e n ih h a t l r d c t t e li r li r s n e o l a e e n ic v r d t ought exe cieofduedii nc hr he r s lge e. 28U. C.j2 4 d ( )A)( . S. 24 ( ) 1( -D) 2P tin rddn tag etmeie su d rsbscin ( tru h( eio e i o ru i l s n e u eto s B) ho g D) t n . Thesaut oflm iai wast ld f 1 da be we n Aprl24 a Oc obe 7,2011 t t e i t tons ole or 66 ys t e i nd t r . Pe ii rpr r y fl d t s a e ha aspe ii n on A prl24,2011 a t Cic tCour oft ttone ope l ie he t t be tto i , nd he r ui t he Ciy ofM a tns le di m i s d i on Se e be 7, 1. Pe ii ne ha u i Oct r 7, 1 t t r i vil s s e t pt m r 201 tto r d ntl obe 201 , o p o el tl a a p a t t Su r meCo r o Vign a3 Se V a S p. . 5: ()(tt g r p ry ie n p e l o he p e u t f r ii. e u Ct R. 9 a sai n . a la ha t r y da t fl a notc ofa alf om a t i lc tt t Supr m e Cour of ppe l nt s hi t ys o ie ie ppe r ra our o he e t Vigi a) Anohe 15 dayspa s dbewee Ocobe 7, 1 a M ach 1 201 whe r ni . t r 9 s e t n t r 201 , nd r 4, 2, n pe ii rfl d t i t ntpetton. Eve t lng t e 1 da w hie pe ii r spr r y fl d ttone ie he ns a ii n oli h 66 ys l ttone ' ope l ie a i ai f c l t r lr vi w wa pe ng,pe ii rtld t i t ntha aspe ii mor pplc ton or ola e a e e s ndi ttone ie he nsa be tton e t n 460 da a t hi convi i n be a e fna . ha ys fer s cto c m i l Equiabl t lng i ava lbl onl i Shos r r i tnc swhe e - duet cr m sa es t e oli s ia e y n û e a e nsa e t r o icu t nc e e nalt t pa t s own c xt r o he r y' onduc - i woul be unc c ona e t e o c t lm ia i pe i t t d ons i bl o nf r e he i t ton rod a ans tep rya d g o sij tc wo l r s l. Ro s v. e 3 9F.d23 , 4 (t Ci. g i t h a t n r s nusie ud e ut' u e Le , 3 3 8 2 6 4h r ' 20 )(n ba )(ntr lquottonmaksomitd)( tng Harsv.Huthi on,209F. 325, 03 e nc i e na ai r te cii ri c ns 3d 330(t Ci. :.Thus apeii mus ha û e purui hi rght diienty,and... 4h r 2000 , ttoner t ve û n s ng s i s lg l be s e e r or nar c r um s a s ood i hi w a ' o pr ve tm e y tlng. H ola v.Fl r da om xt a di y i c t nce t n s y' t e nt i l i i l nd oi , U. S. ,1 S.Ct 2549,2560( 0) 30 . 201 . 3A lhoughpeii rnot an a a t t Supr m eCour ofVigi a hedi notpe f tt a albe us h di t ttone ed ppe l o he e t r ni, d rec he ppe ca e e d n tasg errt telwe c utsr ln , us a t oVigii S p e Co r Rue5:7c()i.Th rfr,h o sin ro o h o r o r' uig p ru n t r na u rme u t l l ()1() eeo e te a p a wa n ttrpel fld'op nnitligtet tea p a wa p n i b fr t S p e Co r o j e l s o I o ry ie 't e toln h i h p e l s e dng eo e he u rme u t f p me Vlgna S eAru v Be n t 5 1U.. , ( 0 0 (g na piaini ûrpel fld' e isdeieya d rii. e tz . n e, 3 S 4 8 2 0 ) 6A1 p lcto s po ry ie wh n t l r n ( v a cpa c aei c mpl nc wihtea pia elwsa dr lsg v r n tl gs' ( tra ctto so t d. c e tn e r n o i e t h p lcbl a n ue o enig ii .) i en l i in mit ) a n ' n a e Stt lw gove'swhet rapl di fld i saec 'wasç ope l fl ' Se Pa v.Di il o,5 U . ae a l n he ea ng ie n tt oul t t pr ry ied. e ce ' Guilem 44 S. 4 8( 0)(o kn t saelw t dtr n whe aplaigh sbe (rpel fld'o pyoe o afdrl 0 20 5 lo ij o tt a o eemie n edn a en t o ry ie'fr u ss f eea p t l i .Vig n aS p e Co r t k l 5 1 ( )r q ie t a ap tto f ra p a icu a1 to t s cfc i i t r i l u r me u tû u e :7 c e u rs h t eii n o p e l n lde 1 fhe pe ii me m ) l s e r s i t r i bel , r or n he ulng ow upon w hi h t appela i e t r l u ra s pa at he ng e il d,< s i c he l nt nt nds o e y, nde e r e adi ntte A sgnment s o Ero . Va Su Ct R. 1 ( ) W i o ts c als a d h a ig,h p tto d e no me tt er q r df r o f r r' . p. . 5:7 c . t u u h it n e dn t e eiin o s t e h e uie o m f h tep tto fra p a. Chit nv. s ril, 3 F. u pz 6 5 6 7( D. . 0 ) h ei n o p e l' rsi Bakev l 2 2 S p .d 0 , 0 E. Va 2 01. i ' a e 3 Pe ii r s l c ofkno l dge a tl lpr s ort s a ut y dea i f f r l ttone ' a k w e bou ega oce s he t t or dlne or ede a ha asr i f doe no s be ele s t uppor g a i s , e r or na y r i . H a r s 209 F. a 330. t r ntng uc xt a di r elef h ri, 3d t Fur he m or ,ldo notf nd a e r di r cic s a esi t sr or t tpr nt d t r e i ny xtaor na y r um t nc n hi ec d ha eve e peiinerfo flngatmeypeiin.Se .e. ,UniedSttsv.Sos 364F. 507,51 ( h tto rm ii i l tto e g. t ae a, 3d 2 4t Ci. 0 4 ( r y sau a d in rn eo telw d e n t u tf e u tbl t lig ; r e v. r 2 0 ) p o . tt s n g o a c f h a o s o j siy q ia e oln ) Tun r . q J hns 1 F. 390,39 (t Ci.1 ( tngt tunfmiirt wiht 1w duet o on, 77 3d 2 5h r 999) noi ha a laiy t he a o ilt acy orpr K sat doe nott l i tto pe i .Acc di y, ii rtl hi lier o t us s ollmiains rod) or ngl pettone ied s . f de alha aspe ii n be e r be tt o yond t one- rs a ut oflm ia i ,pe ii ri no e il t he yea t t e i t tons ttone s t ntted o e t bl t lng, a t petton m us be di m i s d. quia e oli nd he ii t s se 4 11 1. Fort f e ng r s ns Ide pe ii ne ' m oton t a e asf ie,gr nt he or goi ea o , ny tto r s i o m nd utl a r ponde ' m oton t dimi s a dim ist pe ii n f awrtofha asc pus Ba ed u n es nts i o s s , nd s s he tto or i be or . s po m y fndi t tpe ii rha notm a t r qui ie s t nta s i ng ha ttone s de he e st ubs a i l howi ofa deni lofa ng a c tt i lrghtasr r by28U. C.j2253() ac riiaeofa albiiyi denid. onsiutona i equied S. c , e tfc t ppe a lt s e TheClr i die t d t s nd aco oft sM e a um Opi on a t ac ompa ng ek s rce o e py hi mor nd ni nd he c nyi Or rt pe ii ra c de o ttone nd ouns ofr cor f rr pon el e d o es dent . E T T i tR dyo O tbr2 1. N ER: hs ' a f coe,02 l 'x ' p j Se rU nie St t s Di t i tJ e n' t d a e s rc udg 4Ide pettone ' motont am e asf iebec us t a e entdoesnotafe tt dee m i to t t ny ii rs i o nd utl a e he m ndm f c he tr nain ha peiine un i el fld t f r lhabea petton, Se Fo anv. Da i, lU. .1 8 1 2 ( 9 2 ( o ig ta a tto r tm y ie he ede a s ii e m v s 37 S 7 , 8 1 6 ) n t h t n c u t h l n tg a t f i a n me t. o r s oud o r n a m l me d n ) e 4