Egan v. Roanoke City Circuit Court et al, No. 7:2012cv00129 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 04/26/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
CL B OFFj U,S. ST. ERK' CE DS COURA ATROANOKE,VA FI LED AF 25 2 1 R 22 I TH E U N I N TED STA TES DI STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DI RI O F VI G I I ST CT R N A R O AN O K E D I I O N V SI ED W A RD JA M ES EG A N , J UUA C. J LLX CL Dt ' ERK s,op ty v ff 2 EJ y CA SE N O .7: 2CV 001 1 29 Pl ntf ai if, M EM OM NDUM O PI ON NI VS. RO AN O K E C I C I CU I C OU R T, TY R T W K , By Ja sC. k : me Tur Se or Unied St esD i t i tJudge ni t at src De e f ndants. t) Edwa dJ m esEg aVigi ai aepr ee ng pr K ,fl d t sac i whih he r n an, r ni nm t oc di o ie hi ton, c 1 3 syl d ast' e ge y'Fe r Com pl i . Bec us Ega co pl nst ts a e c tof i i l a e t e tEm r nc de al a nt a e n m ai ha t t our f c a s r vi a i hi c tt i lr ght i a pe ng c i i lca e t cour co t ue a f l d Ega s ol tng s ons iutona i s n ndi rm na s , he t nsr d nd ie n' s si asacvi rg sa tonpurua tt 42U. C.j1 ubmison i l iht ci s n o S. 983.Upo rvi oft rcod,t n e ew he e r he c ts m a iy di m i s t a ton. our um r l s s es he c i I hi orgi lpe ii Ega as t co tt tnt r ne'i a i n s i na tton, n ks he ur o s e ve ' n n i i ongoi 'sa ec t ng' t t our c i i lpr e ng a or rt sa ec t o a ntco e f Ega Ther e ntf c sa e rm na oce di nd de he tt our t ppoi uns l or n. elva a t r t s asgl ne fom Ega ss r epl di a o i r cor sa ec tr or . I he e, ea d r n' pa s ea ngs nd nlne e ds tt our ec dsl n Se t mbe 2011 Ega fl ape ii n i t Roa pe r , n ied tto n he nokeCount Cic tCour, a mi t t y r ui tcli ng ha svea ci na j d me t e tr da an t m ae' od' n s o l bev c td. e rl rmi l u g n s ne e g i s hi r t i'a d h ud a ae v ( 00 - 40. TheCommonwe lhofVigi ars CR03 0735 7 ) at r ni e ponde wihamotont dimis d t i o s s Eg n' p t inf rlc o j rs ito Eg nfldmo in i teCic i Co r a kngf r a s ei o o a k f u idcin. a ie to s n h rut u t s i o t 1 Recor fom t Roanoke Count Cicui Cour a eaccessbl onlneat ds r he y r t tr ie i ht /www.o t.tt va. . A fd r lc ur ma tk j iiln tc off cu i o mai lc tdi tp: / c urssae. us e e a o t y a e udca o ie a t alnf r ton o ae n pos i on gover tngs nment websiesi t Unied SGt . See l ReKati Ca Br al t n he t es n rna nal eachesCons . ol Lii , 33F. pp. d 61 ,6 - 3& n 1 - 5( D. . 008 ( olc i c s si iai ta fdea tz.5 Su 2 5 313 n. 4 1 E. La 2 ) c le tng a e ndc tng h t e r l c rsma tkej ca noieofg e n na we sts icudngc u t e o ds; ila v. nc 5 ou t y a udiil tc ov r me tl b i ,n l i o r r c r l W lims Lo , 25 e F. pp, d 6 9, - 8& n. ( M d. 08 ( o lcigc s si c tngt tpo tn o g venme t Su 2 7 686 8 4 D. 20 ) c le tn a e ndiai ha sigs n o r n we ie aeihe e l a t e i ors l-ut ntc tn . bsts r n r nty u h ntc efa he iaig) . :, appoit n mentofc ouns li t sma tr butt Cour di notg a t emotons St t c t e n hi te , he t d r nt hes i . ae our r c dsonlne i ca e t tt Cic tCo tdi m i s Ega spe ii n t voi t c i i l e or i ndi t ha he r ui ur s s ed n' tt o o d he r m na j d me t b o d re trdM ac 2 2 2. u g n s y r e ne e rh 9, 01 A fe t Ci c tCo tdi m i s hi ca e Ega fl d a a e t r he r ui ur s s ed s s , n ie n m ndm e t hi f de al nt o s e r com pl nt as e tng t tt di m i s lw a e r ous Eg a guest tt s c t a i s a ai , s ri ha he s s a s r one . an r ha hi our m y s ue wrtunde t é lW rtsAc,'28U. C.j 1 ,oitr e i t saeci na pr ee ng i r he < Al i' t' S. 651 t ne v ne n he tt rmi l oc di andor rt Cic tCour t r i tt Eg n' pe ii n t voi hi c c i a t a l hi de he r ui t o ensa e a s tto o d s onvitons nd o low m t t s iy,r e ve c ta nt d co e ,a pr s tw ines e t s o e tf ec i our - ppoi e uns l nd e en t s s o how t thi c c i ha s onvi tons w e e il ly obt i r lega l a ned. Thecour sunm a iy dimi s sEga si ta f der lpe ii a m oo .Theca ef tt rl s s e n' niil e a tton s t s or whih Ega s hta or rdie i t Cic tCour t a n co elf hi ha now be n c n oug n de r ctng he r ui t o ppoi t uns or m s e dimis The e or ,t co tc nno gr ntt r le Ega r ue t i hi co pli ,a t s s ed. r f e he ur a t a he ei f n eq ss n s m a nt nd he co pl i i m oot A f r lc t no a ho iy t r nde de i i o m ootq tons m a nt s . ede a our has ut r t o e r c s ons n ues i . Ch rho Sce t l v o Ca. UntdStts 5 6U. 9, 2( 9 2 .E A)c s i mo t e u c f inoog f lv. ie ae , 0 S. 1 1 9 ) E a e s o wh n g t is pr e e aenol e çi .... Powelv. c he sues esntd r ong r lve' ' ' l M conna k,395U. 48 496( 969 . c S. 6, 1 ). M or ve ,Egan i note ild t t r le hes e .I i we le t ihedt tf de a eo r s ntte o he e if e ks t s l sabls ha e r l c u t ma n ta r ij n tv r le t a wo l af c p ndngsaeci n l r c e ig o rs y o wad nu cie eif h t ud fe t e i tt rmia p o e dn s a e e r or na y c r um s a esnotpr e he e. Se Y ounae v. a r s 401U . 37, bs nt xt a di r i c t nc es nt r e r H ri , S. 45 ( 9 ) Hu f nv Pu s e Lt .4 0U, 5 2 6 8(9 5 (id n t a saec u t rmi a 1 71; fma . ru . d, 2 S. 9 , 0 1 7 ) fn i g h t tt o r ci n l pr c e i sa ec nsd r dp n i gu t saej dca rme ish v b e e h u td . o e dng r o ie e e d n ni tt u iil e de a e e n x a se ) l Th e or t c ts m a iy di m i s Ega spe ii s eki a or r diec i t s a e er f e, he our um r l s s es n' tton e ng n de r tng he t t courtt appoi couns f hi . o nt el or m Eg n' a e a s m nded pe ii n,s ki a or rfom t c tdie tng t sa ec t o tto ee ng n de r he our r c i he t t our t r nsaeEga speii f voi j me ,seq lywihoutmei.Thi cour hasno ei tt n' tton or d udg nti ual t rt s t J iditon t r viw orove t n t Cicui Cour' de ii t dimi sEgan' peii z ' s ci o e e ur rur he r t ts c son o s s s tton. Fo ter a o ssae ,h c u t imis sEg n sc mpan wih u p eu ie p ru n r h e s n ttd t e o r ds se a ' o lit t o t rj dc , u s a t t j 1 5 b)1,asl lyfi ous3 TheClr i die tdt sndc pisoft smemorndum o 91 A( ( ) egal rvol . ek s rce o e o e hi a o ni a ac om pa ng o de t pl ntf . pi on nd c nyi r r o ai i f ENTER:Thi %( d yo Ap i 2 2 s a f rl 01 . , Seni Unie St t Di i tJ t d aes s c udge 2 Lowe fd rlc u tdono ha uidci t rviw dietytej g nsofsaec rs r e ea o rs t vej rsiton o e e rcl h ud me t tt out. Pl e v. o e 1 F. 7 731( t Ci.1 97 .J rs cinf ra pelt rviw ofsaec ur vlr M or, 29 3d 28, 4h r 9 ) u idito o p lae e e tt o t j gme t le e cusvey wihs rorsaec u t a d, tmaey wiht Unie S aesS r me ud n s is x l i l t upei tt o rs n uli tl, t he td tt up e Cour. l Onl aft a de endanti sat cour c i i pr t d. y er f n te t rm nal oceedi hase ngs xhaused hi sat cour t ste t r emedi ,can hepur uehabeascor r i i f alcour. 1 at732.Becaus Egan cl l hasnot es s pus elef n eder t d. e eary ye exhaused avaiabl s a ecour r edi r di t cl m sr s i hi Cic tCour petton,he i t t l e tt t em es egar ng he ai aied n s r ui t ii s notentted t habe cor r i . Ther or t cour w ilnotconsruehi cur e s isonsasa il o as pus elef ef e. he t l t s r nt ubm s i peiin frawrtofh be sc r sun e 28U. C.j225 tto o i a a o pu d r S. 4. 3 A com pl ntfl by an i a e c l ng t conductofa çofi orempl ai ied nm t halengi he n i lcer oyee ofa g e n ntle tt ' ybed s s e u e j 1 5 b ( )it ec mpliti <rvoou , lci so ov r me a niy'ma imis d nd r 91 A( ) 1 f h o an s G i l s ma i ou r f f l t sa e acl m upon whi r ifmay be gr nt ' ais o tt ai ch ele a ed. ' 3