Marshall v. Holloway, No. 7:2012cv00123 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 3/23/2012. (tvt)

Download PDF
' .n sOFIEusDs ou Bi r FC E lmc v A R A JK ,A T O N iv gl kso I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I CO U R T CT FO R TH E W E STER N DI STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R O A N O K E D I ISION V AU G U STU S M A R SH A LL, MA2 26 2 1 02 2ULA l - . 'l ' v . f . C ASE N O .7: 2CV 001 1 23 Pe ii r, t tone M EM O M N D UM O PI I N N O VS. H O LLO W A Y , By: G l n E.C onr e ad C hi U nied St es D i ri Judge ef t at st ct R es pondent . A ugus us M ar ha l a i a e pr e ng pr K ,f l d t s pe ii f a wr tofha as t s l, n nm t oe edi o ie hi tton or i be cor ,ptruan t 28 U. C.j2254,alegng t the s ul be rla e fom confne nt pus zs t o S. l i ha ho d ee s d r i me b c us t e S ae o W ic n i i whih he wa c n itd l tjzid cin o rh m a tr e a e h tt f s o sn, n c s o v ce , os l s ito ve i fe r t a f ni hi t a V igi a pr s n. Upon r vi w oft r c d, he c tdi m i s t pe ii r ns e ng m o r ni i o e e he e or t our s s es he tton a wihoutm e i. s t rt I M a s l s a e t the w a c r ha l t t s ha s onvi t d ofuns cii c r si J 1 0 i t Cic t ce pe fed ha ge n une 98 n he r ui Cour f r M iw a e Count W i c i a s nt e t prs Ats m e poi durng s v c to l uke y, s ons n, nd e enc d o i on. o nt i er i e ofhi prs n s t nc W iconsn prs a hortese e ed i o a c r tt ta f rM a s l t s i o en e e, s i ion ut ii nt r nt ontac o r ns e r hal o W al nsRi St t Prs i V igi a,whe ehei c r ntyconfned. M a s l a s t t tby le dge ae ion n r ni r s ur e l i rhal s ers ha ta fri hi a r s saebo d r, ic n i a t o iisv ln aiyr ln u s e jlidcin rnserng m co s tt r es W so sn u h rte ou trl ei q ih d t s ito r o rM a s l. Be a e M a s l i no c cedofcomm itng a c i i Vigi a, a s l ve rhal c us rhal s t onvit ti ny rme n r ni M r ha l a srsta Vign ah sn J rs ito t i ac rt hm.Sn en saeh s u idcino e se t h t r ii a o ' idcin o nc re ae i ic o tt a j rs ito v r u hi ,M a s las e t t thei c i a W a lnsRi i vi aton oft Unie Stt m r hal s rs ha s onfned t le dge n ol i he t d a es Cons iuto a m us be r l s d f om c t y. tt i n nd t e ea e r us od RK 11 M a s lwoul ha t cla ml e ouspr e a hur e be or t sc tc d g a r hal d ve o e r m r oc dur l dl s f e hi our oul r nt hi t r le he r que t r e e f om c i m e . M a s l a is t the w asnotc m he e i f e s s: el as ' r onf ne nt r ha l dm t ha onvi t d ce wihnt etnio il u idcino t sc u t n t a heddn t r s n h sc re tcamst a y t i h e tra j rs ito f hi o r a d h t i o p e e t i u rn li o n sa ec t or flng t sf de alpe ii t t our bef e ii hi e r tton.M a s lalo ofe sno e de e c rhal s f r vi nc once ni t r ng he daeofhi ta f t Vigi a, ciia fc i dee mi ngt tmei s ofhi j2254peii t s rnser o r ni a rtc l a t n tr ni he i lne s s tton. The c t ncudes ho ve ,t tr ar es ofispr ed aldef t , a s l' pe ii mus our co l , we r ha eg dl s t oc m ec s M r ha ls tton t be s l m a iy di m i s d asw ihou m e i. lm rl s s e t t rt M a s alsa s ri nt a n saeh s u idcino e hi lc me i.S e eR, rsv. rh l' se t h t o tt a j rs ito v r m a ks rt e , ..Kal o Hu s n 1 2F.d 9 2 1 9 W L 31 40 *1( 0hCi. 9 9 (ee tn a gz n ta n sae do , 8 3 3 , 9 9 46 , 1 t r 1 9 ) rj cig r l t h t o tt me ha j idito o rW iconsni t ta fre f i aceai i Oklhoma. W iconsn d urs cin ve s i nmae rnserd or nc r rton n a ) s i l w e es l a horze ta f r ofW i c i i a est pr s ope at d by o he s a es l see a xpr s y ut i s r ns e s s ons n nm t o ions r e t r tt . W i. a.Annj30121 1 () Se on301. ( m)a)6)oft tsaut r quiest tany s Stt . ( m)a . di 21 1 ( ( ha tt e e r ha c r c r ga di s h i e sa eta f r mus i l apr son r t ni W ic i s onta t e r ng uc nt rt t r nse s t ncude ovii e ai ng s onsn' j rs cino e t imae rh lo fr n e ie c s g si t a t eitrtt c nr c u idito v r he n t.Ma s al fe s o vd n e ug etng h t h ne sae o ta t unde whi h W ico i a ho ii sta f redhi t W a lnsRi di noti l apr son r c s nsn ut rte r ns e r m o le dge d ncude ovii rti n W ic nsn s u idcino e hi eanig s o i ' j rs ito v r m. 1 W iconsi ssat eaut i ng i ert t tanser hasbeen uphel agai tnumer s n' t ut horzi nt sa e r f s d ns ous c n tuin l h l n e .S e eg, ayv W ic n i, 5F. yx5 7 2 0 W L21 5 6 6 * (t o si to a c al g s e , ..He l . so sn 6 Ap ' 6 , 0 3 t e 0 4 4 , 1 7h Ci. 03)( iigPic kev. tc e ,l F.d49 50 01( t Cl.1 )( hol n c nsi i aiy r 20 ctn s h Lis h r 78 3 7, 0- 7h r 999 up dig o tt on lt ut o W i. a . n j3 l212 ,a t rzngta f rofW ic nsnp io r t p ia ey r nprs si f s Stt An 0 . ( m) uho ii rnse s o i rs ne s o rv t l u ion n ohe sae ) t r tt s. 2 Onamor ba i lve,M as l' peii f rl s unde j225 lcksmei bec us e sc e l rhals tton or eea e r 4a rt a e he f l t de ais o monsr t t thi c i m e i aVigi aprs i t d ofa W ico i prs ta e ha s ontne nt n r ni ion nsea s nsn ion vi aesa fde al pr e tdrgh .j2254()( uhorzi c togrntha a rle t sae olt ny e r ly otce i t a a t i ng our t a be s eif o tt i a e s i t the i i c t i vi a i oft Co tt i orl w s o t e tesoft nm t how ng ha s n us ody n ol ton he ns iuton a r rai he Unie Stts.$( ni esaeprs ta fr...doe no de i a i t ofanylbet td ae ) tA) ntrtt ion rnse s t prve n nmae i ry i e es pr e e byt DuePr es Cl e i a ofis l ' Olm v.W a ne ntr t otctd he oc s aus n nd te f ' i ki kona,461U. S. 238,248( 983) Mor r i tsha nof rlco tt i rghtt i aceai i any 1 . eove ,nmae ve edea nsiutonal i o nc r rton n patculrprs n.M ea hum v. no,427U. 215, 27( 976) ri a io c Fa S. 226- 1 . Fo t r s sa e t co ts m a iy di m i s M a s l' pe ii a wihout r he ea ons t t d, he ur um r l s s es r ha ls tton s t me i.2 TheClr i die t t s nd c esoft sme or ndtm o ni and a ompanyi rt e k s r c ed o e opi hi m a l pi on cc ng or rt pe ii . de o ttoner ENTER:Thi 13 d yo Mac , 2012. s a f rh Chi fU nie St t s D it i tJ e t d a e s rc udge 2 P ru n t Rue4o teRue Go enn j2 5 Cae,h c u t ys mmai ds s a u sa to l f h ls v r ig 2 4 sste o rma u rl imis y j 25 p ttonwh r ttpli y a pe r fo t p ttona d a a tc d e blst a peilne i no 2 4 eii e e ç anl p a s r m he eii n ny ta he xhi t h t tto r s t i entted t r i i t dititcoul ' il o elef n he src t'

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.