Gardner v. Oslin et al, No. 7:2012cv00108 - Document 9 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 05/29/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
' rlm cE '-- ts oFFl v.s. sm Dl AT RoA:oK; vA Fl t! p l n - I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT FO R THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A R O A NO K E D I I O N V SI JEFFR EY J SO N G A R DN ER , A MAt 2 2 1 22 JULA #Y; I C, . ' . DEp 1 CL M E cu/:< CA SE N O .7: 2CV 001 1 08 Pl ntf , ai i f M EM O M ND U M O PI O N NI VS. By: Jam e C.Tur s k Seni U ni St esD i ri Judge or ted at st ct M I OS N, AL. KE LI c , , Dee fndants. t) J f r y J s n Ga dne ,a V i gi a i a e pr e ng pr K ,f l d t s c vi rght a to e fe a o r r r ni nm t oce di o ie hi i l i s c i n p ru n t 42 U. C.j 1 8 algn t a p io o fcas d ne hi a p io j b a a f o us a t o S. 9 3 l ig h t rs n fiil e id m rs n o s o d e s r i w or r i vi a i o hi c tt tona rght . Afe r vi w oft r or t co t e v ce ke , n ol ton f s ons iu i l i s tr e e he ec d, he ur sz m a iy di m i s s t a ton. lm r l s s e he c i 1 G a d ra l est f l i s que e ofe nt r e ntt hi cl i s Ga d r a r ne leg he olow ng e nc ve s el va o s a m . r ne , n imaea Ke nM o n anCor cina Ce tr( CC) wa t a o i t ekth n.Hesae n t t e u ti re to l n e KM , n s j b n h ic e tts t t ic e j bso frt h g e t a a dteln eth u so a o a KM CC, l ha kth n o fe he ih s p y n h o g s o r f nyj b t whi e p o ii gimae wihs il ta c udh l t e g ta o i t ef o s r ieid sr a tr r v dn n ts t k l h t o l ep h m e j b n h o d evc n u ty fe s r ease. el G a d ra t c st hi c pl i ta m e or ndum c tng a l pl m e a i n M e o f r ne ta he o s om a n m a ii n m e nt t o m or Vigi aDe rme ofCor cins( r ni pa t nt re to VDOC)Opeai Pr ed e( 8 . whihpr vies r tng oc ur OP) 412, c o d ta ( fe d r wi n t ec n iee f rasnstv j b i wi ntepat1 y a st yha e h t ' fn e s l o b o sd rd o e iie o ,f t h s 0 e r he v o l hi ha gl homii ofe e sxualofe e ki ppi a ton,asa t esa ,e di d any cde fns, e fns , dna ng, bduci s ul, c pe va ng, eudeorpatr off iur t a pe r' Co . tc ( No.13,p.4) OP 8 2lsss l ten al e o p a . mplAta h.ECF ' . 41. it ome j desg tdassnstve, a horz p io a nitao st de m ohe j a sgn n s obs inae e ii but ut ies rs n dmi srtr o e t r ob si me t .' * a s nstvean t t evie on aposton- y- ii ba i ,hec ie i a r src i f s e ii d o t s, r ii b poston ss t rt ra nd e titons or s ii postons a ne ded.' G a dne ad is t the w asc enstve ii s e ' r r m t ha onvi t ofd e c i es' n t c ed l x r m ' i he s W a hi on Count Cic tCour, a g st thei now ei bl unde OP 8 . t hol a s ngt y r ui tbut r ue ha s lgi e r 412 o d snst ej bb c u eh so fn e o c re mo eta tny asa o b t e M ac 1 1 9 a d e ii o e a s i fe s s c u r d r h n e e r g , ewe n rh , 9 9 n v A u t29, gus 2000. 1 OnAu us 2 , 01 , r n rflda a p iainfrakth nj b.W h no h rimae g t 9 2 0 Gad e ie n p lc to o ic e o e t e n ts a ke Mi Osi t f s r iediecor t hieGadne,Osi t dt m,tl q hewrts s d ke ln,he ood e vc r t ,o r r r ln ol he tN' r o ie m or gr e nc t n a e i va es ha nyone ' Com pl 2- Ga dne a s f l d r ques sw ih s ve alo he .' . 3. r r l o ie e t t e r t r of i i l f r a l dm i s r tve J b A s i nm e t . .i o no a l' Co pl 3. G a dne sa e fc a s o n t A ni t a i o sg n , . s t vai. ' m . r r tt s t ti at s wih c ha nm e t onvi tons f hom i i ,s xu of e es a abduc i w or i t kic n c i or c de e al f ns , nd ton k n he t he a t the pos s l s ofa t e tt n t y do. nd ha e es hr a ha he l Augus 2011, r rfl an i or a co ant c am i t tOsi ha de e hi n t Ga dne ied nf m l mpli , l i ng ha ln d nid m aj b i tekth nb c u eo hi g iv n e .Osi swrte r s o eo t ec mplitsae o n h ic e e a s f s re a c s l n' i n e p ns n h o an ttd: t ( O BS I FO OD SERV I ARE A SSI ED I STRI A CCO RD AN CE W I O P 8 2. C J N CE GN N CT TH 41. ' ' ECF N o. p. I hi r gul rgr e nce Ga d r sa e t tO s i s de i i a ns gi ng 2, 3. n s e a i va , r ne t t d ha ln' c s on gai t vi Gad raj vi ae hi duepr e sa e lpr eci rg s 1 a 4.Osi itr iwe rne ob oltd s oc s nd qua ot ton iht. d. t ln ne ve d G a dne a r r bouthi g i va e on Se e be 2,2011 a t d G a dne he di notlke Ga dne ' s r e nc pt m r , nd ol r r d i r rs c r a S ii gre nc sdoe n' ge a nea f s' Co pl 3. I t Leve I ha ges nd k tng i va e wr s t t nyo ny avor . m . n he ' l rs ns W ade Brxt r l Ga d rsgre nc t beu ounde Quoi pa t ofOP e po e, r n a on ued r ne' iva e o nf d. tng rs 841 2 a utofi a s abiiy t r vi e c ie i f s ns tvepostons,t w a de s a e t t , bo tci l ' lt o e s rt ra or e ii ii he r n t t d ha C CC dei st FoodSe vc a as nstveae ,(nlwhih youar i lgi ef C KM fne he r ie s e ii ra i c e nei bl or 1 Cour r dsa l eon Ine f t W as ngt Count Cic tCour i ca et ti t ecor vaiabl i or he hi on y r ui t ndi t ha n Augus 2002,J fey Jas Gar t efr on dnerwasconvi ed ofaggr ed se lba tr and m uli e c sof ct avat xua te y tpl ount se xualpe taton and f ci e s ner i or bl odomy. e o ntduet yourc i i lhit y.'I mpl yme o rm na sor ' d.On a pe l t r gi ldie t u l t p a , he e ona r c or phed he w a de st ndi r n' i ng. Ga dne s Osi t wa de t r ona die t , nd VDOC Die t rHa ol Clr r r ues ln,he r n, he egi l r cor a r c o r d a ke. He a s r st tt de e nt 'a tons de i hi ofduepr e s vi a ed e lpr t to s e t ha he f nda s c i prved m oc s , ol t qua o ec i n p icpls a dc nsiu e rtlain.Asr l f Gad e se sap io j bwi l n h u sa d rn i e , n o t td eaito t ei , r n r e k rs n o t o g o r n e h hi pa a m onea y da a sf de a o e oyme . gh y nd tr m ge or nil f mpl nt 11 The c ti r quied t dim i sa a ton orc a m f l d by a pr s ne ag ns a our s e r o s s ny c i l i ie i o r ai t gove n e alen iy o of i eri t c tde e m i t ac i n o c ai i f i ous m a i i , r m nt tt r fc f he our t r nes he t o r l m s r vol , lc ous orf l t saeacl m onwhi r le ma begr td.28U. C.j1 5A( ( ) l or t ais o tt ai ch eif y ane S. 91 b)1. n der o saeacam i a yfd r l ii a to ,h p an ifsita t a alg to smu t ee o g t tt li n n e e a cv l cin te litf tl cu l le ain s b n u h o l r i e a r g t r le a a s i ht o e i f bove t s c a i l ve , t one t ti l a i e on isf c ' r t he pe ul tve e l' o ' ha s ç us bl pl t a e, a her ' ta meeyt o c i a l . Bel l Co p v. mby, 5 U. 5 4, 7 ( 0 ) h n rl s n ev b e' lAt. r . Two l 5 0 S. 4 5 0 2 07 . c ' A . D ue Pr s oces Ga dne cai t tunde sa el w, ion a hortesa er quiedt pr de i t s r r l ms ha r tt a prs ut ii r e r o ovi nma e wihj bo p ru iis a d fn a t'fi r t p o iehm t ej bf rwhc h i ei il a d t o p o tnte , nd ee d ns al e o r v d i h o o ih e s lgbe n u s t d vi a esdue pr s . Ga d r i m i t ke uie ol t oce s r ne s s a n. W hie t V igi a s a ut G a dne c t s r quie pr s of a st pr de w or l he r ni t t es r r ie e r i on ûci l o ovi k a sgnm en s a o he r ha lt ton pr r m s f i a es t e s a ut s a s gr ntof i i l va t si t nd t r e biia i og a or nm t , hes t t e l o a fc a s s di c e i i m a gi pr s r s c a i cl s i y ng i a esf pa tc pa i i s s r ton n na ng i on e our es nd n a s f i nm t or r i i ton n uch aci tes Se Va.Cod Ann.jj53.- 5 132.,53.- Ofi il mus casiya imae tvii . e e 132, 3.- 1 141. tcas t l sf n n t f w o k a s g ent S c di t ba kg ound,a iude, duca i a r s a ... eds' or r s i nm s t or ng o c r ac ptt e ton, nd i k nd ne , ' w hie al cons derng t he avaiabiiy ofr our and s f ci pr am as gnm ent ' l so i i ç t l lt es ces ufi ent ogr si s,' 3 j53.- 1A)a ( ;a ofii smus prvi i tswihwor o t tesonl tot 132.4 nd B) nd fcal t o de nmae t k pporunii y t he t e entfasbl,'j53.- 1A) Thus c r yt Gadnersa s ri ,hes saut donot xt e i e' 14 ( . , ontar o r ' s e tons t e tt es ce t a ye tte n u e sae1w f rhm t ha a yp riua p io j bo a yj b a al rae n n ilme t nd r tt a o i o ve n a t lr rs n o r n o t l. c W he e i a e c a s fc tons a w o k as i e s a e û a t r ofpr s n r nm t s' l s i i a i nd r s gnm nt r t te s m io a i s r to wihi t di c e i n oft prs n a m i sr t s ' i a esal o ha no dm nit a i n, t n he s r t o he i o d ni ta or ,' nm t s ve c n t uin l p o e tdrg t oj bo p ru iiso t a yp riua j bwhl ic reae . o si t al r tce ih t o p o tnte r o n a t lr o i n ac rtd t o y c e Bul rv.UniedStt Bur a ofPrs ,65F. 48,( hCi. 1 )(i ngnolbet or ge t aes e u ions 3d 5t r 995 fndi i ry p o ryitr s i ha i p io j b (i n S n i v. n e , 1 U. 4 2 4 4( 9 5 . rpet n eet n vng rs n o ) ct g a d n Co n r 5 5 S. 7 , 8 1 9 ) i , M oo v. cae' 429U. 78,88n.9(976); tz rv. deik,569F. 81 81 ( h Ci. dv Da t, t S. 1 ) Alie Pa rc 2d 2, 3 4t r 1 7 ) Co s q e l p io ofiil ma g n r l tnniaea i t fo hij b o r f s 9 8 . n e u nt rs n fcas y e eal e n t n mnae r m s o , r e u e y, y t grnthi apa tc a j f a ras wihoutofe ngf rld pr es prnci es o a m riulr ob, or ny e on t fndi edea ue oc s i pl . Bul r 65 F. a 5 Unde t s prncpl ,Ga d r sf de a duepr es c am sha no ge , 3d t 0. r he e i i es r ne ' e r l oc s l i ve mei a mus bes rt nd t umma iydimisd, s n t j1 5A( () a l alyfi ous rl s se purua t o 91 b) 1, s eg l rvol . B. EqualPr ecton ot i Ga d a s as e t a S l s - - ' eq pr e ton cl i ,a gui t to f c al deni d r ner l o s r s t a s of one ' ual ot c i c a m r ng ha f i i s e hm akth nj bb c u eo h ss xo fn e , ve to g oh rs xo f n eswo ki t e i ic e o e a s f i e fe s s e n h u h t e e fe d r r n h kic n.Tosaeaca sofonecam,Gadne mus ale fcsdemonsrtngt t1 hewas the tt ls - - li r r t lge a t tai ha ) itn in lyte t ddfee tyfo ohessmi ryst tda 2 i o fcasa pl ddfee t ne to al rae ifrn l r m t r i l l i e nd ) f fiil p i ifrn a ua e sa r f kic nj asi nti hi c e,her wasnortonalba i f t difrnc i tndads or the ob sgnme n s as t e ai ss or he fee e n te t nt Se Vil ofW il ookv.Olc 528U. 562,564( rame . e lace lowbr e h, S. 2000)(e r ngsa d rgadi tndar f l ls - - ' li ;M os v.Clr 886F. 686,69 91( h Ci.1 (i ngprs r or ' a sofone'caml c s ak, 2d 0- 4t r 989) fndi ione e qual o e ton cl i r qui e s i t tpl i tf i s m ia l st t a uneq lte t e pr t c i a m e r s how ng ha a n if s i l ry iua ed nd ua r a m nt i notrtonal rlt t algii t govemne a pur e . s ai ly eaed o e tmae r ntl pos ) 4 Gar rdoe notalegef ct sai an e alpr e i cli unde t s prnc pls dne s l a s t tng qu otcton am r he e i i e . Fi s,G a dne hasnots n t the i sm ia l st t d t t ot r i a esw or ng i t rt r r how ha s i l ry iua e o he he nm t ki n he kic n. Ga dne doe no a l ge t ta o t s wor r ha be n co c e oft s m e t he r r s t le ha ny f he e ke s s e nvi t d he a o f ns s a Gar ne ort tt y ha sm ia s nt nc s orc i i lhi t i . Se nd, i on f e e s d r ha he ve i l r e e e rm na s ores co pr s o fcasce ryha elgtmaes c rt itrs i r srcigk the j b t i mae c nvce fiil lal v e ii t e u i n ee tn e tit ic n o s o n ts o itd y n ofl ss ve e c i esor s nt nce ,gi n t f c t ts h i a e w o k i c os pr m iy t es e r rm e e s ve he a t ha uc nm t s r n l e oxi t o ot ri a e a s a f a ha a ce st f ie st be s r d t o he i a e a s a f he nm t s nd t f nd ve c s o ood t m o e ve o t r nm t s nd t f . Th c u t imis sGad e ' e u l r tcincam wih u p eudc , u s a to jl 1 A,o e o r d s se r n rs q a p oe to li t o t rj ie p ru n t 9 5 f r f l et sae acain. aiur o t t l r C. R e a i ton t la i TOs c donaj 1 cli t tprs n ofi asrtlae agans hi ani t mus uc ee 983 am ha io fcil eaitd i t m, nmae t ale f c ss lge a t howi t thi e r ieofac tt i lrg wa as t nta f corm o i tng ng ha s xe cs onsiutona i ht s ubsa i l a t tva i t rtlaor a ton.Se Ada v. c 40F. 7 75( hCi.1 *Ameia Ci l he eait y ci e ms Rie, 3d 2, 4t r 994) , rc n vi Li risUnin v.W i c Cot v,999F. 78 785( hCi.1 ( tngM tHe t Civ be te o comio mt 2d 0, 4t r 993) cii . alhv t Sc DititBoa dofEduc tonv. l,429U. 274,287( 977) Hemus p e e tmor hool src r ai Doye S. 1 . t rsn e t c l or a l gato ofr t la i n. A da s 40 F. a 74. han onc us y le i ns e a i to m , 3d t G a d rf ist s a e f t on whi h he c d pr r t la i n. I i cl a t tpr s z ne a l o t t ac s c oul ove e a i to t s e r ha i on o tcasd n e hm akth nj bb c us h sc n it n f rsx o fn e we ei o e ls fi il e id i ic e o e a e i o v ci s o e fe s s r mp sd e s o t ntny a sa o Th tfc ao eds u l isGad e f rc ranj ba sg n sa KMCC. ha e e r g . a a t ln iq ai e r n r o e ti o s imne t t f M o e r Ga d rwa note r ii a c tt ina rghtm e ey by flng gre r ove , r ne s xe c sng onsiuto l i rl ii ivanc s be a e e , c us i a esha no cons iutonalrghtt a prs g i va e pr dur A da s 40 F. a 75. nm t ve tt i i o i on r e nc oce e. m , 3d t Gadne saesnof t s si t tofi asfie t gi hi akic nj bec us Ga dne r r tt acs uggetng ha fcil ald o ve m the ob a e r r co pl i d t of i a s a m a ne o fci l bouta pa tc a i s i a gre nc The c tdi m i s G a d ' ny ri ul r s ue n i va e. our s s es r ner s rtlain cam wiho prj c purua t j1 5 frfiur t saeacai eaito li t ut eudie, s nt o 91 A, o al e o tt l m. l1 I Fo t ra o sae t c u t imissGad e ' c mplit t o t rj dc , r he e s ns ttd,he o r d s se r n rs o an wih u p eu ie ptrua tt j1915 b)1,f f l et saeacai . ls n o A( ( ) or aiur o tt l m The Cl r i diec ed t s nd c esoft sm e or ndum o ni and a c pa ng e k s r t o e opi hi m a pi on c om nyi or rt pl i if de o antf. ENTER:Ths .% Fd yo M a , 01 . i 1 . a f y2 2 <' / % . . ! . x . / ... y . t l j j j s Se orUnie Stt DititJ e ni t d a es src u
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
